Battle: Dar es Salaam vs Nairobi

Kazi ya National Government ni kutransfer pesa to counties, they have no business on how counties will prepare their budgets. Usiwe mjinga.
Tueleze maana ya budget ni nini?
Kwa mujibu wa Financial Management.

Budget ni Revenue and Expenditure

Haya umeulizwa ulete Bajeti ya Kaunti moja. Wewe unaongelea transfer of money.

Jinga kweli hili
 
Unajua maana ya transfer of powers? 😂 😂 😂 Wewe ni fala.
Transfer of power sio kutengeneza wizi Buda.
Tanzania kuna municipalities ziko chini ya mayors na kadhalika na hazihusiani kabisa na central government na mandate yao Iko kwenye own source revenue ya municipality, allocation ya central government Iko based kwa parliament.
Ingekuwa devolution imewasaidia basi kuna county kama mandera, wajir na kadhalika wasingekuwa na shule za miti au kuwa na uhaba wa maji ,
Tanzania pamoja na kuwa hatuna devolution kwa sasa huwez Kuta kuna shule za miti au kusomea chini ya miti, actually most classes kwa sasa Zina tiles kitu ambacho kwenu ni ndoto
 
Tueleze maana ya budget ni nini?
Kwa mujibu wa Financial Management.

Budget ni Revenue and Expenditure

Haya umeulizwa ulete Bajeti ya Kaunti moja. Wewe unaongelea transfer of money.

Jinga kweli hili
Hawaelewi kuwa bajeti inakuwa inclusive na zile za counties ili kuunda bajenti ya nchi.
Kwenye bajeti husika kuna mpaka presentation ya zile institution ambazo ziko 100% owned na government ila walivyo wajinga wanajua kinachosomwa ni allocation tu.🤣🤣🤣
 
Sasa after kujaribu kusupport ujinga wako na ukafail, umeamua kuendelea kua mjinga zaidi instead of admitting you were wrong.
 
Kaka Tanzania tupo na Devolution inayoitwa D by D.

D-by-D stands for Decentralization by Devolution, which is a specific form of devolution.
 
View attachment 3587799
On top of that Nairobi also gets infrastructure developments from the central government.

So tell us how this is the same with Dar

Sasa huoni kama bado uko palepale nilikuambia leta planned budget ambayo inatokana na osr ( own source revenue ya Nairobi) maana hiyo ndo inajitegemea na haiko included kwenye national budget.
Ukiangalia allocation zako 40+ % inatoka central government.🤣🤣🤣🤣
Kukuelimisha tu dar es salaam inatumia 70% ya osr kwenye developemnt expenditure not inclusive zile za Toka central government
 
Also:

D-by-D stands for Decentralisation by Devolution. It is a specific policy framework used to transfer power, responsibilities, and resources from a central government to local government authorities.

The primary benefit of Decentralisation by Devolution (D-by-D) over "only" devolution is the intentional, integrated transfer of three critical pillars—political, administrative, and fiscal power—rather than just shifting political authority alone.

The term is most famously associated with Tanzania, where the government formally adopted the D-by-D policy in 1998 as part of the Local Government Reform Programme (LGRP). It was designed to replace a highly centralised system with a decentralized one to empower local councils.
 
The spending of all those staff working at the facility.. all in Nairobi.
Millions of dollars per week
 
Sasa nini maana ya kuwa na Counties kama employees wa Counties wanalipwa na central government?

In Kenya, county government employees are officially employed and paid by their respective County Governments. However, the funds used for these salaries are primarily disbursed from the National Government (Central Government) as part of the equitable share of revenue, supplemented by local revenue generated by the county.
 
Kazi ya National Government ni kutransfer pesa to counties, they have no business on how counties will prepare their budgets. Usiwe mjinga.
Transfers sawa kwahiyo haijawa included kwenye national budget?
Hizo transfer tukisearch haziko budgeted?
Letsay hakuna popote kwenye national budget pesa iliyobajetiwa kwa ajili ya transfer?
Hivi unajua huwa kuna min budgets ambayo unatengeneza national budget?
County budget ni min budgets haijalishi mtazitumiaje hizo hela au mtapangaje, ndo maana utakuta kwenye national bajeti utakuta bajeti hata ya zile taasisi za serikali ambazo ni owned.
 
Hebu kwanza lete hizi figures za osr za dar municipalities ndo tuendelee na discussion. 2nd Your point was development budgets for counties is included in the central government development budget which is not true. County governments get a guaranteed share of the national government budget( which is approximately 15% of the total budget) , then the national government budgets for the remaining 85% . Lastly counties have more revenue sources compared to your municipalities can't be compareble
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…