Fact Check: Anaposema "hata huko yanatokea" anamaanisha mambo gani yanatokea wapi?

[ISO M.CodD]

Tunaambiwa haya mambo yanatokea huko duniani, serikali ya JMT inayaona na haiyasemei kitu.

Are we not comparing apples to oranges?

Kama ni watu kupigwa risasi huko duniani - je, wanapigwa risasi katika mazingira sawa na yaliyotokea Tanzania? Na je, uwajibikaji baada ya matukio hayo unafanana na wa Tanzania?

Tusije tukawa tunaona kilichotokea kwetu ni kitu cha ajabu kumbe ni cha kawaida. Nikaona nimpe chatgpt prompt hii afanye research

List countries that curbed protests using live bullets in the last 20 years, alongside number of deaths and whether the protests were successful in their goal. No ethnic wars, no rebels. Just unarmed citizen killed by govt forces while /after protesting. Global list, large scale incidents only with more than 50 deaths

Matokeo:

---

Uzbekistan – Andijan Massacre (2005)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: ~300+
• Protest Goal: Economic justice; protest unjust trials of local businessmen
• Outcome: Failed (brutally crushed by government)

---

Thailand – “Red Shirts” Uprising (2010)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: 90
• Protest Goal: Dissolve parliament; call new elections
• Outcome: Failed (military crackdown; government later changed)

---

Egypt – January 25 Revolution (2011)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: 302
• Protest Goal: End Hosni Mubarak’s rule; democratic reforms
• Outcome: Succeeded (Mubarak ousted)

---

Egypt – Rabaa Sit-in Massacre (2013)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: 817
• Protest Goal: Reinstate President Morsi (overturn 2013 military coup)
• Outcome: Failed (sit-in violently cleared)

---

Ukraine – Euromaidan (2014)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: ~100+
• Protest Goal: Closer EU integration; oust President Yanukovych
• Outcome: Succeeded (Yanukovych fled)

---

Nicaragua – Anti-Ortega Protests (2018)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: 322
• Protest Goal: Reverse social-security reforms; oust President Ortega
• Outcome: Failed (Ortega remained in power)

---

Sudan – Khartoum Massacre (2019)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: 100+
• Protest Goal: Transition to civilian-led government
• Outcome: Partial (Bashir removed but military still powerful)

---

Iran – “Bloody November” Fuel Protests (2019)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: 304
• Protest Goal: Reverse fuel price hike; broader political/economic reforms
• Outcome: Failed (demand suppressed; prices remained high)

---

Myanmar – Anti-Coup Uprising (2021)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: ~1,500
• Protest Goal: Restore elected civilian government (overturn military coup)
• Outcome: Failed (junta retained power)

---

Kazakhstan – January Unrest (2022)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: dozens
• Protest Goal: Repeal fuel tax hikes; broader economic/political reforms
• Outcome: Failed (brutal crackdown; leadership reshuffled)

---

Iran – Mahsa Amini / Women’s Rights Protests (2022)​

• Estimated Civilian Deaths: 300+
• Protest Goal: Accountability for Amini’s death; end women’s oppression and broader repression
• Outcome: Failed (demands unmet; security forces prevailed)

---

Here is a slightly summarized version in simple Swahili:

---

Uzbekistan – Mauaji ya Andijan (2005)​

• Vifo: Zaidi ya 300
• Lengo: Haki ya kiuchumi na kusimamisha kesi zisizo za haki
• Matokeo: Haikufanikiwa (serikali ilikandamiza kwa nguvu)

---

Thailand – Waandamanaji wa “Red Shirts” (2010)​

• Vifo: 90
• Lengo: Kufuta bunge na kuitisha uchaguzi mpya
• Matokeo: Haikufanikiwa

---

Misri – Mapinduzi ya Januari 25 (2011)​

• Vifo: 300+
• Lengo: Kuondoa utawala wa Hosni Mubarak
• Matokeo: Yalifanikiwa (Mubarak aliondolewa)

---

Misri – Mauaji ya Rabaa (2013)​

• Vifo: 800+
• Lengo: Kumrudisha rais Morsi aliyepinduliwa
• Matokeo: Haikufanikiwa

---

Ukraine – Euromaidan (2014)​

• Vifo: 100+
• Lengo: Umoja wa Ulaya na kuondolewa kwa rais Yanukovych
• Matokeo: Yalifanikiwa (Yanukovych alikimbia)

---

Nicaragua – Maandamano dhidi ya Ortega (2018)​

• Vifo: 300+
• Lengo: Kubatilisha mageuzi ya malipo ya jamii na kuondoa rais Ortega
• Matokeo: Haikufanikiwa

---

Sudan – Mauaji ya Khartoum (2019)​

• Vifo: 100+
• Lengo: Serikali ya kiraia
• Matokeo: Nusu tu (Bashir alianguka, jeshi lilibaki na nguvu)

---

Iran – “Novemba ya Damu” (2019)​

• Vifo: 300+
• Lengo: Kupunguza bei ya mafuta na mageuzi ya kiuchumi
• Matokeo: Haikufanikiwa

---

Myanmar – Maandamano ya Kupinga Mapinduzi (2021)​

• Vifo: 1,500+
• Lengo: Kurudisha serikali iliyochaguliwa
• Matokeo: Haikufanikiwa (jeshi likabaki madarakani)

---

Kazakhstan – Ghasia za Januari (2022)​

• Vifo: Kadhaa (makumi)
• Lengo: Kushusha bei/makato ya mafuta na marekebisho ya kisiasa
• Matokeo: Haikufanikiwa

---

Iran – Maandamano ya Mahsa Amini (2022)​

• Vifo: 300+
• Lengo: Haki za wanawake na uwajibikaji kwa kifo cha Mahsa
• Matokeo: Haikufanikiwa

---

Tunapoambiwa haya mambo yanatokea huko duniani, nchi zilizofanya hivyo ni hizi hapa.

Uzbekistan, Thailand, Misri x2, Ukraine, Nicaragua, Sudan x2, Iran x2, Myanmar na Kazakhstan.

Je, nchi hizi zimetoa tamko lolote kuhusu kilichotokea Tanzania?

 

[Nyani Ngabu]

Samia ana akili ndogo sana!

Hapo hakuna hata nchi moja ya EU.

 

[mjingamimi]

Katika Yale mauaji mwenzenu hana NDUGU mmoja aliyekufa Kwa yeye anaona sawa tu.
Tena moyoni anasema ndo mkome

 

[mjingamimi]

Ndo maana anasema wapo tayari kuua Tena mkiingia barabarani kwamba ameshajitoa sadaka.
Mjipange mchawi kalaba hatanii

 

[Dr am 4 real PhD]

Katika Yale mauaji mwenzenu hana NDUGU mmoja aliyekufa Kwa yeye anaona sawa tu.
Tena moyoni anasema ndo mkome

R.I.P vicent Mshale

 

[Mjusi Sharobalo]

Hii ni mbaya sana.