English Comment: Manchester United Loss Proves Once Again That Arsenal Fall Short On The Big Occasion
Arsene Wenger's men continue to infuriate in the crunch games
Patrice Evra
Patrice Evra could not help but grin at the final whistle like a gloating child who had just been handed the class prize as he celebrated
Manchester United's 1-0 win over
Arsenal. The full-back is one of the most outspoken characters in football and managed to rile Arsenal supporters last week by claiming the Gunners are simply a "training centre" and slamming their recent record as "a load of rubbish".
Infuriatingly for Arsenal fans worldwide, Arsene Wenger's side then went out and once again proved him right.
Arsenal are not so much academy as they are kindergarten when it comes to the games that really matter against the big boys.
When it was put to Wenger that perhaps Evra was right, the Arsenal manager brushed off the question by claiming he could only make an "objective judgement" on the game.
If the Frenchman wants to draw verdicts on objective analysis based on evidence then someone better tell him that his side have now lost 10 and drawn one of their last 11 games against Manchester United and Chelsea in all competitions, scoring only five goals in those games. Even the solitary draw was against Sir Alex Ferguson's side when they needed just a point to win the title.
'There are no trophies, there is nothing' | Patrice Evra was right about Arsenal
Indeed, their only victory so far this season in a game of note was a 3-0 win at Manchester City in October and that was not a challenging task after Dedryck Boyata was sent off for the hosts just four minutes into the game. Had the Belgian stayed on the pitch, then their record so far this season against their direct competitors would be nigh on embarrassing.
Somehow, Arsenal have managed to hang on in the title race despite failing against their biggest rivals time and again, even including a humiliating 3-2 home defeat by Tottenham after they had taken a two-goal lead.
If Evra does not think the Gunners warrant a second look, it's because he does not see them as challengers to United.
Why should he? Arsenal have not won a single trophy since he arrived in Manchester and have been limited to a role as also-rans behind United and Chelsea. The Londoners may not be in 'crisis' – as Evra provocatively claimed – but they are far too fragile.
In fact, Arsenal have taken just 11 points out of a possible 30 from 10 games against the Premier League's current top 11 and all three of their victories came against 10 men.
The lack of leadership and authority of their side was highlighted by the choice of Tomas Rosicky as captain on Monday night as Cesc Fabregas was not ruled fit enough to start. You can't win the title with kids, and nor can you win it with wimps.
Arsenal players snapped into tackles from the first minute at Old Trafford as if they had a point to prove, and Evra might have reflected that he was more likely to get 'knocked out' by a flying boot than the visitors' attractive football.
But after Park Ji-Sung looped home his clever header it was effectively game over as United slammed the door shut and Arsenal lost their belief save for a brief spell of pressure in the second half.
It was a familiar result for Wenger's side and could have been even worse had Wayne Rooney not blasted his penalty high into the stands. The Arsenal boss seemed to hang his head in resignation towards the end of the game, but no-one realised he was actually blaming the pitch for his side's failure.
The only novelty factor was the presence of Wojciech Szczesny making his Premier League debut in the Arsenal goal. The 20-year-old Pole was solid with his handling but the mere fact that he was thrust into the side on such a big occasion highlights Arsenal's long-held problem between the sticks.
What will hurt Arsenal is that United seem so ready to swat them away, to write them off as nothing more than an irritant that will disappear around the end of March when the heat is cranked up a notch. But you can hardly blame them.
Wenger's team came into the game with best away record in the Premier League but once again failed to beat a big team – a psychological ailment as much as it is a blow.
As usual, they had possession and stroked the ball around in midfield, but they were completely lacking in penetration against a United side that was well organised but below its best.
Evra's only concession to the Gunners had been that they play nice football, but he might even be forced to re-appraise that judgement after such a toothless performance.
It has become too much of a recurring theme to try to excuse Arsenal's regular defeats to United and thrashings at the hands of Chelsea.
Such is the inconsistency of their performances, the Gunners teeter between a potentially excellent side and a collapsing pack of cards from week to week.
It would be no surprise if Arsenal cruise past Stoke on Saturday at the Emirates, but it is equally predictable that they will again surrender against Chelsea on December 27.
Arsenal are so desperate for a trophy that they are even trying in the League Cup this season, a tacit acknowledgement from Wenger that his side need to build some kind of winning mentality. After all, it's already been five years and the club's trophy cabinet has picked up a few layers of dust.
Maybe, one day, Arsenal with have the last laugh.
But for now they are nothing more than an aesthetically pleasing side that don't have the capacity to perform on the big occasion or the mentality to mount a title challenge.
Evra was right.