Nani aliyemuumba Mungu?

Nani aliyemuumba Mungu?

K

Kisai

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2018
Posts
29,126
Reaction score
29,333
The question: "If God is the creator, then who created the creator?" is illegitimate because by definition, the Creator is uncreated. He is eternal, without beginning, without end and all affairs return back to Him: (وَأَنَّ إِلَىٰ رَبِّكَ ٱلْمُنتَهَىٰ) "And that to your Lord is the return (of all beings and affairs) (and of all perfections in attributes)." (53:42).

Thus to ask who or what created something that is uncreated is the way of:
a) an ignorant person devoid of intellect,
b) a lying deceiver, a sophist.

Note : Maelezo haya mafupi nime "copy" na ku "paste" toka kwenye tovuti iitwayo "www.aboutatheism.net", mnaweza tembelea huko mpate faida.

Tujadili hili, kwa wale wote ambao huuliza swali hilo, waje watuambie kwanini wanauliza swali hilo.

Ahsante.

Jurjani (Zurri)
 
Jurjani said:
The question: "If God is the creator, then who created the creator?" is illegitimate because by definition, the Creator is uncreated. He is eternal, without beginning, without end and all affairs return back to Him: (وَأَنَّ إِلَىٰ رَبِّكَ ٱلْمُنتَهَىٰ) "And that to your Lord is the return (of all beings and affairs) (and of all perfections in attributes)." (53:42).

Thus to ask who or what created something that is uncreated is the way of:
a) an ignorant person devoid of intellect,
b) a lying deceiver, a sophist.

Note : Maelezo haya mafupi nime "copy" na ku "paste" toka kwenye tovuti iitwayo "www.aboutatheism.net", mnaweza tembelea huko mpate faida.

Tujadili hili, kwa wale wote ambao huuliza swali hilo, waje watuambie kwanini wanauliza swali hilo.

Ahsante.

Jurjani (Zurri)
Click to expand...
Nani aliyemtengeneza, (sio aliyemuumba), aliyeteneneza gari?

Sent using Jamii Forums mobile app
 
Jurjani said:
Thus to ask who or what created something that is uncreated is the way of:
a) an ignorant person devoid of intellect,
b) a lying deceiver, a sophist.
Click to expand...


Hiyo ni lugha ya matusi unaposema kila anayehoji; "Mungu kaumbwa na nani" ni; ignorant, unintellectual, a lying deceiver, a sophist.

Huyo aliyeandika hayo ndiye ignorant na sophist, kwani ni nani mwenye "dynamic mind" hata siku moja asikae na kutafakari; Mungu alitokea wapi??!!--- bila shaka hata yeye mwenyewe amepata kuhoji hilo swali ndipo akaja na jibu kwamba Mungu ni eternal na akaweza kunukuu hiyo aya ya Qur'an, bila ya hiyo aya si bado angekuwa katika ujinga wa kutojua jibu la vipi Mungu aliumbwa au hajaumbwa.

Huyo jamaa kaandika nonsensical.
 
Mengine yote uko sahihi ila aya ya Quran hajajibu kitu chochote.
Mokaze said:
Hiyo ni lugha ya matusi unaposema kila anayehoji; "Mungu kaumbwa na nani" ni; ignorant, unintellectual, a lying deceiver, a sophist.

Huyo aliyeandika hayo ndiye ignorant na sophist, kwani ni nani mwenye "dynamic mind" hata siku moja asikae na kutafakari; Mungu alitokea wapi??!!--- bila shaka hata yeye mwenyewe amepata kuhoji hilo swali ndipo akaja na jibu kwamba Mungu ni eternal na akaweza kunukuu hiyo aya ya Qur'an, bila ya hiyo aya si bado angekuwa katika ujinga wa kutojua jibu la vipi Mungu aliumbwa au hajaumbwa.

Huyo jamaa kaandika nonsensical.
Click to expand...
 
Jurjani said:
The question: "If God is the creator, then who created the creator?" is illegitimate because by definition, the Creator is uncreated. He is eternal, without beginning, without end and all affairs return back to Him: (وَأَنَّ إِلَىٰ رَبِّكَ ٱلْمُنتَهَىٰ) "And that to your Lord is the return (of all beings and affairs) (and of all perfections in attributes)." (53:42).

Thus to ask who or what created something that is uncreated is the way of:
a) an ignorant person devoid of intellect,
b) a lying deceiver, a sophist.

Note : Maelezo haya mafupi nime "copy" na ku "paste" toka kwenye tovuti iitwayo "www.aboutatheism.net", mnaweza tembelea huko mpate faida.

Tujadili hili, kwa wale wote ambao huuliza swali hilo, waje watuambie kwanini wanauliza swali hilo.

Ahsante.

Jurjani (Zurri)
Click to expand...
Warumi 11

33 Jinsi utajiri wa Mungu ulivyo mkuu! Hekima yake na maarifa yake hayana mwisho. Njia zake na maamuzi yake hayachunguziki!

34 Kwa maana ni nani amepata kufahamu mawazo ya Mungu au kuwa mshauri wake?

35 Au ni nani amewahi kumpa cho chote ili arudishiwe?

36 Kwa maana vitu vyote vyatoka kwake na vipo kwa ajili yake na vyote vinadumu kwake. Utukufu ni wake milele. Amina.



Sent using Jamii Forums mobile app
 
Jurjani said:
The question: "If God is the creator, then who created the creator?" is illegitimate because by definition, the Creator is uncreated. He is eternal, without beginning, without end and all affairs return back to Him: (وَأَنَّ إِلَىٰ رَبِّكَ ٱلْمُنتَهَىٰ) "And that to your Lord is the return (of all beings and affairs) (and of all perfections in attributes)." (53:42).

Thus to ask who or what created something that is uncreated is the way of:
a) an ignorant person devoid of intellect,
b) a lying deceiver, a sophist.

Note : Maelezo haya mafupi nime "copy" na ku "paste" toka kwenye tovuti iitwayo "www.aboutatheism.net", mnaweza tembelea huko mpate faida.

Tujadili hili, kwa wale wote ambao huuliza swali hilo, waje watuambie kwanini wanauliza swali hilo.

Ahsante.

Jurjani (Zurri)
Click to expand...
Hilo swali achana nalo, ishia hapo hapo.
 
Tajiri Mapesa said:
Akili yako iko sawa kweli, kwa hiyo wewe unafuata dhana za watu au unaelewa mwenyewe?
Click to expand...
Naelewa mistari kisha naichambua kwa akili yangu mwenyewe kupata kitu cha ukweli.

Hata Bible na Qur'an kuna vitu nakubaliana navyo, vingine navikataa.

Pambana na hali yako.

Sent using Jamii Forums mobile app
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Discussions

Our Community

Coming Soon

Regional Communities

Coming Soon
Back
Top Bottom
Menu
Forums
New posts
Log in
Register