When a man claims to have been raped. Can an erection be considered to have been his consent?

[ERoni]

Mbona sisi tukiwabaka tunakutana na uke upo so wet, what does that mean.?

 

[MamaSamia2025]

Nastaaajabu na wale wanaoelekea kumullelewa huyu.
Huyu Mama Samia ni mhuni ambaye anapaswa kufa kifo kibaya.

Kila mtu atakufa ukiwemo wewe.

 

[kina kirefu]

Election kwa maana ya uchaguzi?

nenda kwa mwalimu sanga, muulize tofauti ya erection na election

upate majibu sahihi ,hakikisha mwali huyo wakike.......kenge mkubwa wewe unawaharibia Uzi wabakaji ....

 

[Chamoto]

Scientifically yes. Without your consent a man cannot maintain an erection.

Ever considered a scenario involving a woman secretly adding a substance to a man's drink with the intention of altering his state, specifically to increase his libido?

 

[kina kirefu]

No, an erection cannot be considered as consent.


Erections are physiological responses that can occur due to various reasons, including fear, stress, or even involuntary physical stimulation, regardless of a person’s emotional or mental state. Consent is an active, voluntary, and informed agreement to engage in sexual activity. Just because someone's body reacts in a certain way does not mean they agreed to or wanted what happened.


This is why legal systems and psychological studies recognize that men, like women, can be victims of sexual assault, and their physiological responses do not invalidate their experience.

naswali Moja lenye vipengele viwili

(a) mental state ,you mean akili ya Dola ?

(b)Je, sisi tunaotoka bar na think-tank assistant(k-vant), nakufika nyumbani usiku kuanza kuwambia wakezetu geuka huku nakusokomeza kijinga kwa nguvu ukeni Pao, Je nasi tunakuwa tumebaka wakati ni wakezetu.

 

[Iyerdoy]

Erection is uncontrollable situation in front of kipochi manyoya

Sio sahihi sana haswa ukizingatia zipo pia factors nyingine e.g. asubuhi ukiamka unaweza kujikuta una hio hali wakati hakuna hata pochi hapo.
Unashindwaje kuji-control wakati huku unatakiwa upeleke marejesho, mtoto akafukuzwa shule, wife (kama yupo) kaanzisha timbwili eti anataka vitenge vya Iddi au Pasaka na sasa jua lenyewe ndo hilo tena huko shambani ni sifuri?

 

[Rwebo]

Ever considered a scenario involving woman secretly adding a substance to a man's drink with the intention of altering his state, specifically to increase his libido?

Spiking somebody 's drink is a crime itself.

 

[Last_Joker]

naswali Moja lenye vipengele viwili

(a) mental state ,you mean akili ya Dola ?

(b)Je, sisi tunaotoka bar na think-tank assistant(k-vant), nakufika nyumbani usiku kuanza kuwambia wakezetu geuka huku nakusokomeza kijinga kwa nguvu ukeni Pao, Je nasi tunakuwa tumebaka wakati ni wakezetu.

(a) Mental state siyo akili ya Dola, bali inahusiana na hali ya kisaikolojia ya mtu wakati wa tukio, kama alikuwa na uwezo wa kufanya maamuzi sahihi au la. Katika kesi za ubakaji, inaweza kuzingatiwa kama mhusika alikuwa na hiari au alilazimishwa kwa njia yoyote.


(b) Kuhusu ndoa na ubakaji – Ndio, kama mke hataki na anasema hapana lakini unamlazimisha kwa nguvu, huo bado ni ubakaji hata kama ni mke wako. Ndoa haimaanishi kuwa mwenza hana haki ya kukataa tendo la ndoa. Katika mahusiano, consent (ridhaa) bado ni muhimu, hata kama mko ndani ya ndoa.

 

[Ngurukia]

Then once you erect during raped means you facilitate it!.

Sent from my Infinix X6511B using JamiiForums mobile app

Nope, does your morning wood imply you want to have sex?

Many a times an erection can be involuntary, in an incident of being raped, the body can respond to the most immediate natural response to being stimulated; which is an erection.

 

[kina kirefu]

(a) Mental state siyo akili ya Dola, bali inahusiana na hali ya kisaikolojia ya mtu wakati wa tukio, kama alikuwa na uwezo wa kufanya maamuzi sahihi au la. Katika kesi za ubakaji, inaweza kuzingatiwa kama mhusika alikuwa na hiari au alilazimishwa kwa njia yoyote.


(b) Kuhusu ndoa na ubakaji – Ndio, kama mke hataki na anasema hapana lakini unamlazimisha kwa nguvu, huo bado ni ubakaji hata kama ni mke wako. Ndoa haimaanishi kuwa mwenza hana haki ya kukataa tendo la ndoa. Katika mahusiano, consent (ridhaa) bado ni muhimu, hata kama mko ndani ya ndoa.

Asante , kuazia Leo naacha

 

[Daudi1]

We jamaa kuna uzi niliona comments zako ulitema sana madini nikasahau kukupongeza. Sikumbuki vizuri ila nahisi uzi kuhusu wazazi na watoto.... hongera

kumbe kiswahili unakijua kutusumbua tu tuanze kutafuta dikishenari, haya sema kwa kiswahili ulikuwa unasemaje

 

[TZ-1]

Election inawez kuja ata ukiw ucngzn

 

[balibabambonahi]

(a) Mental state siyo akili ya Dola, bali inahusiana na hali ya kisaikolojia ya mtu wakati wa tukio, kama alikuwa na uwezo wa kufanya maamuzi sahihi au la. Katika kesi za ubakaji, inaweza kuzingatiwa kama mhusika alikuwa na hiari au alilazimishwa kwa njia yoyote.


(b) Kuhusu ndoa na ubakaji – Ndio, kama mke hataki na anasema hapana lakini unamlazimisha kwa nguvu, huo bado ni ubakaji hata kama ni mke wako. Ndoa haimaanishi kuwa mwenza hana haki ya kukataa tendo la ndoa. Katika mahusiano, consent (ridhaa) bado ni muhimu, hata kama mko ndani ya ndoa.

She ria za Tanzania hazitambui uwepo wa ubakaji kwenye ndoa.Consent is conceived at marriage once and for all.

 

[Mvinyo mpya]

Legally speaking in our jurisdiction a man cannot be rated.

 

[Last_Joker]

She ria za Tanzania hazitambui uwepo wa ubakaji kwenye ndoa.Consent is conceived at marriage once and for all.

Hili ni suala linaloibua mjadala mkubwa wa kisheria, kijamii, na kimaadili. Ingawa sheria za Tanzania kwa sasa hazitambui ubakaji ndani ya ndoa, mjadala wa haki za ndoa na ridhaa (consent) unaendelea duniani kote.


Katika jamii za kisasa, kuna mtazamo unaosisitiza kuwa ridhaa (consent) inapaswa kutolewa kila mara bila kujali hali ya ndoa. Hii ni kwa sababu ndoa haipaswi kumaanisha kuwa mmoja wa wanandoa hana haki ya kusema hapana.


Hili ni eneo lenye changamoto kisheria na kijamii, lakini linafaa kujadiliwa kwa kuzingatia haki za binadamu, utu, na heshima ya ndoa. Unadhani sheria inapaswa kubadilika ili kuakisi mabadiliko ya kijamii, au inapaswa kubaki ilivyo?

 

[Ajaye]

The definition of rape varies from one jurisdiction to another, for example in Tanzania a male cannot sue for rape because when the court comes to test the elements it will fail to reach a consensus that the man was raped,

so there is no rape for a man in Tanzania. Now let's go back to the basic question I formulated as follows, could an erection be used as a reason for a man to consent? The answer is yes If rape for a man existed according to our jurisprudence in Tanzania, we would say consent is necessary as usual, now if a person does not have consent it means no erection will occur So the presence of an erection shows a willingness to do the act.

 

[Chamoto]

Spiking somebody 's drink is a crime itself.

I was just pointing out that a man can maintain an erection without his consent. As a matter of fact even without being intoxicated a man can be manipulated into have an erection.

 

[Isanga family]

How can I facilitate erection in a sudden event?

Wanakunywesha dawa za erection mazee mbona SA kawaida hiyo na wanakamatwa sana hao wanawake hatari wengine wanasambaza HIV..

 

[nzalendo]

I am not very fluent in Kiswahili that's why I use English to write this thread. Lawyers or any other person with the knowledge about this matter are welcomed to share with us. Being a man is not easy.

Vp ulibakhtisha mshangazi ??

 

[MamaSamia2025]

kumbe kiswahili unakijua kutusumbua tu tuanze kutafuta dikishenari, haya sema kwa kiswahili ulikuwa unasemaje

I know Kiswahili but I am not very fluent.