TANGOLD, Meremeta back in the spotlight:As Bomani team seeks deeper probe into whole affair
THISDAY REPORTER
Dar es Salaam
THE presidential mining sector review committee has called for an official investigation into the supposedly government-owned TANGOLD Limited company, whose controversial list of shareholders includes former Cabinet minister Andrew Chenge and the reportedly deceased ex-governor of the Bank of Tanzania (BoT), Daudi Ballali.
In its report submitted to President Jakaya Kikwete last weekend after more than six months of research, the committee chaired by retired Judge Mark Bomani has raised more questions on a series of payments amounting to more than 158bn/-, made by BoT to both TANGOLD and its apparent forerunner company Meremeta Gold.
As such, included in the report's recommendations is a call for a thorough investigation into both the Meremeta and TANGOLD companies, encompassing their formation and (in Meremeta's case) liquidation, the extent of government ownership interest in them, and ''the legality of the payment of $132m by the BoT to South Africa's Nedbank.''
According to the report, there are several discrepancies in the financial records of both companies behind the Buhemba Gold Mine in Mara Region.
It notes that: ''Based on the (BoT) governor's report, the central bank paid Nedbank a total of $132m, equivalent to 158bn/-, with regards to the Meremeta company. However, other reports suggest that the loan amount to be paid was just $104m.''
''The committee was unable to get detailed explanations on the establishment, ownership and liquidation of the Meremeta company, and the eventual registration of TANGOLD outside the country,'' the report states.
It is understood that the formation of Meremeta Gold company had the strong backing of former president Benjamin Mkapa, whose government (and State House in particular) was seen to aggressively promote the company's gold mining activities in the Tembo area of Buhemba in Mara Region.
On the other hand, it has been established that TANGOLD - which was the beneficiary of a highly-questionable $13.34m (approx. 17bn/-) payment from the BoT - was registered as an offshore company in Port Louis, Mauritius in April 2005, months before the Mkapa administration wound up its tenure.
At least five top government functionaries were listed as TANGOLD company directors at the time of its registration, these included the then BoT governor Ballali, and the then attorney general Chenge.
Others were the then permanent secretary in the Ministry of Finance, Gray Mgonja (who still retains the same position in the current government), the then permanent secretary in the Ministry of Energy and Minerals, Patrick Rutabanzibwa, and the then permanent secretary in the Ministry of Livestock Development, Vincent Mrisho.
Rutabanzibwa and Mrisho are now permanent secretaries in the Ministry of Water and the Prime Minister's Office, respectively, while Chenge later relinquished the AG post, entered politics, won a parliamentary seat and was included in the fourth phase government of President Jakaya Kikwete, first as Minister of East African Cooperation and later as Minister for Infrastructure Development.
He was, however, forced to resign from his ministerial position last month, after being implicated in the 70bn/- military radar scandal. As for Ballali, he was sacked from the central bank governorship by President Kikwete earlier this year, and is now reportedly deceased.
This means that of the five registered company directors, only Mgonja has remained in exactly the same position as at the time of registration in April 2005 (just over three years ago).
The BoT payment to TANGOLD followed another payment amounting to over $118m (approx. 150bn/-), ostensibly to liquidate a loan issued to the Meremeta Gold company as part of its winding-up process.
It is now understood that Meremeta Gold was in fact a joint venture project owned on a 50-50 basis by the Tanzanian government and a private South African firm going by the name of Trinnex (Pty) Limited.
Further mystery surrounds an announcement made in parliament by former energy and minerals minister Nazir Karamagi, to the effect that all assets and liabilities of Meremeta Gold - including the Buhemba Gold Mine � were transferred to TANGOLD Limited as ''a new company wholly-owned by the Tanzanian government.''
However, it has since transpired that the TANGOLD Limited company does not appear on the list of government-owned companies recorded with the Treasury registrar at the Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs.
It has furthermore been established that the official constitution of this supposedly government-owned company has provisions that give its five registered directors - namely Ballali, Chenge, Mgonja, Rutabanzibwa and Mrisho - the right to transfer their shares to family members.
According to a section in the TANGOLD Limited constitution directly pertaining to family transactions:''Any share may be transferred by a shareholder to, or to trustees for, the spouse, father, mother, child, grandchild, son-in-law or daughter-in-law of that shareholder; and any share of a deceased shareholder may be transferred by his executors or administrators to the spouse, father, mother, child, grandchild, son-in-law or daughter-in-law of the deceased shareholder.''
President Kikwete is understood to have ordered the incumbent Minister for Energy and Minerals, William Ngeleja, to study the Bomani committee's report findings and submit his own recommendations to State House for further action.