Beating the Drum on One Side: Confusing the People on Both Sides


Sasa historia kapotosha nani kama Nyerere anasema jina la TANU lilipendekezwa na kina Sykes ? Hoja ya Mohamed Said ya upotoshaji inaegemea kitu gani ? Kwa mantiki hii hizi simulizi za Mohamed Said zinavuta hisia lakini kimsingi hazina maana yoyote.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Are you saying Nyerere did not allow muslim to build their school? I know one muslin school in dar buld in nyerere time called el haramain in kinondoni. Also i don't think government MOUs was used to build secondary schools.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Alimaanisha Prof Hirji, kiwewe kina mambo!!! mtu kashikwa tembe, inauma bwana!

Tulichowahi kusema ndicho alichosema Prof. Tukaambiwa hatupo Oxford
library
Kwi! Kwi! Kwi! Kwi! Kwi!

Mpira haujavuka mstari wa goli unashangilia.
 
Are you saying Nyerere did not allow muslim to build their school? I know one muslin school in dar buld in nyerere time called el haramain in kinondoni. Also i don't think government MOUs was used to build secondary schools.

What year was it built?
 

Vipi? yameliwa na panya?
 
Which is more appropriate word than What. This mistake makes your question senseless.

I am right, if you have lived in the Americas and using an American English you wouldn't have been surprised, your problem is lack of exposure.
 
Gombe Sugu, kumbe upo ila umebadilisha/umefupisha jina lako! Et tu - Hata wewe kweli huoni hoja za msingi za Profu? Inshallah, urejee kesho tujadili aya kwa aya.

Mkuu Udadisi,

Nimekusoma ndugu yangu na nimejaribu kukufahamu, pia nafarijika mno kukusikia baada ya kitambo.

Ni kweli naliadimika takriban miezi mingi kiasi hapa JF...yaani nimekinzwa mno na majambo ya kibaruani na Family. Tuwiane radhi na tuko pamoja Kaka!

Mie sijasema popote pale yakua ati nimeipinga hiyo critique ya Bwana Hirji, ati yoote!? Hasha, asilan!

Ndoo maana nikachagua tu ile premise kiduchu kwa kuanzia na nakhis bado pana mangine alopotosha amma ni debatable arguments...japo kwasasa tuziache kando, au!? Pia yamo mangine yeye Bwana Hirji amejitahidi mno kunyambua kwa kiasi chake, japo pia penye kufanza hivyo ame-over look baadhi ya facts!?

Mie binafsi na weye, tunamfahamu na kumstahi mno Dr Hirji kwa taaluma yake na uwezo mkubwa alonao...japo hii haimaanishi yakua ati hakosoleki amma kupingwa kwa hoja mwanana...yaani kama mwenyewe alivyokiri hapa jamvini, yakua pamoja na ubobefu wake mkubwa mno lakini hata naye pia ni mwenye madhaifu hata ndani ya hiyo taaluma yake!?

Ningalipenda kuchukua fursa hii pia kumshukuru Dr Hirji, kwa kujongelea hapa jamvini/mnakashani na kuzidi kutufunda amma kutufanzia fafanuzi za kina!...japo ingalikua busara na vyema zaidi kama atakua verified user, yaani kama mwanzie Dr Mohamed Said, au!?

Nitajitahidi mno kurejea hapa na kujazungumza nawe kwa staha na labda kujaribu kufundana kwayo!?...lakini nachelea kuwavunjia isijekawa twawavunjia hishma yao Manguli wetu Dr Hirji na Dr Said...maana wao ndoo Vinara wenye mpambano/mchakato huu!? Au sasa umeamua huu "mnyukano" uwe baina yangu na yako, Kaka!? Duuh! Teeeh! Teeh!

Nakutakia jioni/usiku mwema na mapumziko yenye kheir...na penye majaaliwa tutazungumza zaidi!

Ahsanta sana.
 
OK, tunangoja "full version" ya "Professor" Hirji tuione, maana hii kakiri ina makosa haifai na si yenyewe.

Kama una nia ya kuanzisha mada kuhusu Mungu na Uislam nakushauri ufunguwe nyuzi, hapa kuna ya Professor Hirji.


Acha kupindisha ukweli amekiri kwenye kipengele cha mau mau kwamba alitaka weka maji maji war...

Hata hivyo bado kuna mengi ya kujibu haimaanishi content yote imekosewa.
 


Ktk uandishi Wa paper makosa ya. kiuchapaji au ya kimsamiati kuwepo ni kawaida Sana na ndio maana uhariri...

Kwa kawaida MTU muelewa angeelewa tu kwenye mau mau palistahili maji maji kwa kufuata mtiririko Wa matini.
 
Ktk uandishi Wa paper makosa ya. kiuchapaji au ya kimsamiati kuwepo ni kawaida Sana na ndio maana uhariri...

Kwa kawaida MTU muelewa angeelewa tu kwenye mau mau palistahili maji maji kwa kufuata mtiririko Wa matini.

Na data za kufikirika kwenye historia? nazo ni kawaida sana?
 
Acha kupindisha ukweli amekiri kwenye kipengele cha mau mau kwamba alitaka weka maji maji war...

Hata hivyo bado kuna mengi ya kujibu haimaanishi content yote imekosewa.

Kakiri kwenye hicho kipengele na kasema kinaga ubaga kuwa "full version" siyo hiyo anayo yeye. Hujaona?

Sasa wewe umeshaisoma "full version" kipi cha maana ulichokiona kilichokosowa historia ya Mohamed Said, mimi sujakiona.

Kilio chake na chako ni sawasawa tu, labda walikuwepo akina Habib Punja hawajawa "heroes" ndiyo analilia nao kwanini Mohamed Said hajawataja?

Unajuwa siwaelewi haswa, kipi cha maana kipya au alichoonesha? au hiki si ukweli, mimi naona yeye ndiyo kaja na data za kufikirika, aka si za kweli na kakiri yeye mwenyewe.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sasa historia kapotosha nani kama Nyerere anasema jina la TANU lilipendekezwa na kina Sykes ? Hoja ya Mohamed Said ya upotoshaji inaegemea kitu gani ? Kwa mantiki hii hizi simulizi za Mohamed Said zinavuta hisia lakini kimsingi hazina maana yoyote.

Hayo unayosema "Nyerere anasema" uliyaona kwenye historia ya Kivukoni? au mradi uchangie tu na upinge tu?

Hivi hizo shule huwa mnaenda kusomea ujinga?
 

Umerudi? ulikimbia humu, sasa huyo kasema nini cha kukufurahisha sana? kajiaibisha kutokujuwa Kiingereza kataka eti kunikosoa kitu ambacho hakielewi, ni kama wewe ulipokuja dai eti unataka kujuwa "sampling" imefanywa wapi? Khaa sampling! kwenye historia?

Hivi hizo shule mlienda kusomea ujinga?
 
Gombe Sugu, kumbe upo ila umebadilisha/umefupisha jina lako! Et tu - Hata wewe kweli huoni hoja za msingi za Profu? Inshallah, urejee kesho tujadili aya kwa aya.

Kama zipi? mimi sijaona na Hirji kabwabwaja na kuhororoja sana lakini cha msingi sijakiona. Unaweza wewe kukionesha?
 

Shukrani GS. Kweli tuwaachie uwanja madakta/maprofu. Sina hakika kama Profu HK ataweza 'mipasho' ya hao vijana wa zamani wa jiji. Heri aandike tu chambuzi na kuzituma zijadiliwe.

Sasa nimerejea jijini na nahitaji kuyapitia yale makabrasha kwenye makavani ya familia yenu. Tafadhali nisaidie kwa hilo. Naandika historia ya 'wateule' (elites) wa jiji wa enzi hizo. Lazima walikuwa ni wengi zaidi ya hawa tuliotajiwa na Profu. MM.
 
Kama zipi? mimi sijaona na Hirji kabwabwaja na kuhororoja sana lakini cha msingi sijakiona. Unaweza wewe kukionesha?

Kama hii hapa chini au wewe unaiona siyo hoja ya msingi?

"By marshalling an array of facts and utilizing key premises, Said draws conclusions of profound implication for our future" - Karim Hirji
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…