Ventilation on MCC move is primed on wrong assumptions

[MchunguZI]

Aisee kumbe tuna watu wenye akili sana nchi hii ila hatuwatumii vizuri, angalia mzee alivyochambua na kujenga hoja kwa watu wenye uelewa mzuri watachukua ushauri huu

Usimsifu sana huyo mwandishi. Ndo moja ya watu ambao wametumia vibaya sana PPP kwa kujidai business community.

 

[JERUSALEMU]

By Ali Mufuruki; alimufuruki@infotech.co.tz

I have read some articles by concerned members of the public, government officials and politicians about US government’s recent decision to suspend all relations between our government and the Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC).

Sadly, however, articulate as some of these statements are, they miss the simple point that the world is not as simple and as straightforward as the writers/speakers seem to assume.

They also seem to suggest, unfairly in my opinion, that we Tanzanians bear no responsibility for what has happened and are mere victims of imperialist bullying by the mighty United States, but the truth is much more complex than that.

I have been arguing since this matter came up that, smart diplomacy is the only way to go in today’s complex world. Our diplomatic institutions have been caught napping by this predictable decision by the US. They should swing into action rather than resort to mere complaining and passing blame.

Without pointing an accusing finger at our intelligence and diplomatic institutions, in all fairness, our government should have anticipated the (US) reaction. The Americans more or less telegraphed their reaction with a threat to suspend relations, when the Escrow scandal broke out early last year. This was in connection with an MCC covenant in fighting against corruption in government institutions.

The government knew or should have known how MCC would respond to its handling of the Zanzibar election stalemate and taken necessary pre-emptive steps such as engaging the Americans and other partners immediately after it became clear we were going to have an electoral crisis.

I will not dwell on the disagreement over the cybercrimes law because in my estimation it is a mere red herring.

We should have demonstrated to the Americans and the whole world that the Zanzibar problem, while complicated, is firmly under control and a solution will be found, but it will take time and the world must work with us, not against us.

I have no doubt in my mind that this alone would have gone a long way in reassuring our partners and even various constituencies at home that serious efforts are being made to resolve the problem at hand and we would have secured the much needed political space to deal with this delicate matter internally in an atmosphere of calm without all attendant economic and political pressures that now seem inevitable.

It is a well-known fact that relations between nations are driven by interests not emotions. We should, therefore, not be surprised if the US leverages its considerable financial muscle to achieve its foreign policy objectives, including, but not limited to wanting to be an influential player in a region that is quickly becoming very interesting in the wider global geopolitical context.

Our reaction to this MCC announcement, therefore, should not be one of indignation and surprise, but rather, we should pick up a phone or dispatch our diplomats to Washington, Brussels, Beijing and Tokyo, clarify our position, name the red lines that cannot be crossed, but also ask our partners to be reasonable and supportive of our efforts to resolve our problems.

It is understandable that some people are offended by the hypocrisy and double standards of the US, but we must also understand that the US has never had any problems being called out as a hypocrite. It has never stopped them from doing what they do, be it the unjust 50 yearlong economic embargo of Cuba or the false claim of weapons of mass destruction in Saddam Hussein’s Iraq 15 years ago.

We must be smarter than that and we can learn about how to deal with people you are in disagreement with from none other than the US itself.

A good example is that although President Obama cannot stand his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin, he calls him regularly to discuss important matters of state. He even keeps the infamous red phone in his office desk and on his bedside table in case of that unthinkable eventuality. He calls him even when they are in violent disagreement on ways of resolving ongoing global conflicts such as the one in Syria or Ukraine.

The MCC event is bigger than the money involved. Our failure to comply with the covenants we voluntarily agreed to, is a sign of weakness not strength. It is an admission that we have slipped on the governance scale even by our own standards. It will have consequences beyond the loss of the money being offered under the compact both locally and internationally.

Even if we did not need financial assistance for our development, we would need to maintain good relations with the likes of US, UK, China and EU if we want to avoid unnecessary disruptions to our development plans.

More importantly, however, we must ask ourselves if the decision to reject the MCC funds under these circumstances has the support of the majority of our people and the rights of some of our fellow citizens are not being sacrificed in the name of sovereignty and political expediency.

And while I wish it was not the case, Tanzania doesn’t have sufficient resources to fund all its ambitious development plans using internal sources even if we managed to stop all forms of tax evasion.

And running to the Chinese is not a sustainable solution in the long run. For all I know we will soon reach the ceiling of the debt we can sustainably take from the Chinese if this has not happened already.

The writers of various articles may be right when they claim that our relationship with the US cannot be defined by the MCC alone, but they are terribly mistaken if they think the US will leave us alone simply because we have decided to forgo the MCC money. That’s not how the world works.

We can be as certain as the sun will rise tomorrow that other development partners will soon follow in the footsteps of the US and the implications for us will become significant very quickly.

And let us be honest, Zanzibar is a real problem that requires urgent fixing. These recent elections were a terrible error of judgment. Soon we will see Dr Ali Mohamed Shein struggling to rule by himself in a country, whose Constitution assumes the government will always be made up of the two main political parties.

Now we have no opposition party based on the election results of March 20 and, of course, CCM has the numbers to amend the Constitution to enable it to govern, but such a move would deepen the crisis, not alleviate it.

I wrote a piece last year suggesting that the Zanzibar issue is too complex to be resolved through a one-man-one-vote solution. I also said that Tanzania Mainland could not stay out of the Zanzibar problem because for better or worse, for we are one and the same country.

A negotiated outcome would not have been a perfect solution to the election crisis in Zanzibar, but it would definitely have been better than the sham elections we just had. There was no rush to do this election because Dr Shein was constitutionally in office back then. Now, however, his legitimacy is shaky and he has become part of the problem - not the solution.

My hope is that when JPM takes over as chairman of CCM he will appoint a CCM leader in Zanzibar and on the mainland that can work with CUF and other opposition parties to bring peace and tranquillity back to the Isles.

I also hope that this new leadership will have wise answers to many pertinent questions that are being asked about the Union between Tanganyika and Zanzibar on both sides of the Union.

As for the MCC, we need to engage the Americans and push for the restoration of relations as soon as possible. Americans no doubt have an agenda, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t have our own, because that is how the world works.

Mr Mufuruki is Chairman & CEO, Infotech Investment Group and co-founder and chairman of the CEO Roundtable.
================================================
My take:
serikali kuwakorofisha international partners, na sasa kui-disappoint hata business community (a key source of tax revenue) ndiyo mwanzo wa kutengeneza lile anguko kuu.
i only pray kuwa hatuta-end up kuwa DRC nyingine!

It is my sincere hope that Magufuli will take this first class advice.

 

[chuwaalbert]

Magufuli ana kazi na uozo wa mtangulizi wake!

...Ni kweli.Ila ana nafasi ya Daktari.Kuuondoa uozo KWA KUTUMBUA USAHA katik jipu. Na kazi hii anaifanya vizuri.Nnamshauri ATUMBUE na huu USAHA (suala la Zanzibar).

 

[MikeSpec]

Hiyo ni nzuri ya kusoma

http://s07.jamiiforums.com/mini/uyE8/bg_000000/txt_000000/border_000000/flags_0/

 

[Elungata]

..learn to see justice takes its course, crime remains to be crime with no regard of time, even if it takes 100 years to be revealed!

hilo si tatizo basi,kama tunafuatilia ishu za nyuma si mbaya waanze pia kuanzia miaka ya 1961,wauaji wa mashirika ya umma,mashamba ya vijiji na maduka ya kaya watafutwe na kushughulikiwa,
lakini pia mapungufu ya leo yasiwe justifyed na awamu zilizopita,awamu hii ina uwezo wa kuanza clean,kuliko kujistify mapungufu yanayotokea kwa awamu iliyopita

 

[MchunguZI]

Kikwete tutakukumbuka daima.

Unawezaje kumkumbuka mtu aliyelawiti nchi? Hiyo article inaeleza mwanzo wa yote haya ktk utawala wake, nawe unamsifu. Au hukuelewa lolote?

 

[YEHODAYA]

Ni kweli lakini huwezi kuitenga Zanzibar na Tanzania, kwa sababu hiyo ni sehemu ya JMT, sasa kama sehemu ya nchi imeharibu adhabu ni kwa nchi, sio rahisi kuweka vukwazo kwa Zanzibar, nadhani katiba yetu ndio ina shida.

Mkuu katiba yetu wala haina shida ila wao ndio wenye shida hawataki kuielewa katiba yetu.Uchaguzi ungekuwa wenye matatizo ni wa JMT Tanzania bara na Zanzibar wangekuwa na haki ya kusema wasemavyo.Na ilitakiwa kama ao wanaitambua Jamhuri ya Tanzania tu basi hawa MCC baada ya kumaliza ule uchaguzi ndio wangetoa maoni yao kwani wao unawahusu zaidi ni wa JMT.hUO MWINGINE AMBAO NI WA zANZIBAR ambao sio wa JMT kwao ungekuwa hauna maana sababu ni sawa na kufanya uchaguzi wa monita wa darasa ukavurugika halafu MCC waje waseme tunaondoa misaada sababu uchaguzi wa monita wa darasa haukuwa huru na haki.

Kidiplomasia kama wanatambua JMT tu basi ilitakiwa waishie hata uangalizi wa kimataifa kwenye uchaguzi wa JMT Tu kisha waondoke zao sababu ndio nchi wanayoitambua kimataifa.Chaguzi zingine zote ni kama chaguzi za wenyeviti wa kijiji tu nk haziwahusu.Lakini wanajikoroga huku wanasema wanatambua JMT tu.Huku wanasema Zanzibar tunaijua ni sehemu ya muungano!!!!!! sawa ni ya muungano uchaguzi wa muungano ulishaisha huu uchaguzi mwingine wa kijiji cha Zanzibar kumchagua mwenyekiti wa kijiji mnauingiliaje tena wakati Zanzibar kimataifa haitambuliwi kama nchi?

Nasema ni wahuni tu hao

 

[Easyway]

Ahaa, ndiyo maana Magufuli akasema hayamuhusu?

Nnauhakika lugha imekupiga chenga usingekuja na utumbo kama huu.

Huo ujinga wote wa MCC chanzo chake si uchaguzi wa Zanzibar.

 

[Clemence Baraka]

Mufuruki anaongea kama kibaraka wa MCC.

CUF walishiriki uchaguzi wa marudio na wakapata kura chache.CCM ikashinda.Utaongeaje na mtu aliyeshindwa sanduku la kura?

CUF walishindwa kwenye uchaguzi wa matokeo yaliyotangazwa na tume YA UCHAGUZI.

Amri ya nane ya Mungu yasema usiseme uongo.

 

[Fahari]

Kikwete tutakukumbuka daima.

Kwa kiasi flani alikuwa flexible

 

[bantu.garage]

Sisi watanzania hatuwezi kabisa kuishi bila misaada.Tuanze na mawaziri warudishe magari .

 

[Njilembera]

By Ali Mufuruki; alimufuruki@infotech.co.tz

I have read some articles by concerned members of the public, government officials and politicians about US government’s recent decision to suspend all relations between our government and the Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC).

Sadly, however, articulate as some of these statements are, they miss the simple point that the world is not as simple and as straightforward as the writers/speakers seem to assume.

They also seem to suggest, unfairly in my opinion, that we Tanzanians bear no responsibility for what has happened and are mere victims of imperialist bullying by the mighty United States, but the truth is much more complex than that.

I have been arguing since this matter came up that, smart diplomacy is the only way to go in today’s complex world. Our diplomatic institutions have been caught napping by this predictable decision by the US. They should swing into action rather than resort to mere complaining and passing blame.

Without pointing an accusing finger at our intelligence and diplomatic institutions, in all fairness, our government should have anticipated the (US) reaction. The Americans more or less telegraphed their reaction with a threat to suspend relations, when the Escrow scandal broke out early last year. This was in connection with an MCC covenant in fighting against corruption in government institutions.

The government knew or should have known how MCC would respond to its handling of the Zanzibar election stalemate and taken necessary pre-emptive steps such as engaging the Americans and other partners immediately after it became clear we were going to have an electoral crisis.

I will not dwell on the disagreement over the cybercrimes law because in my estimation it is a mere red herring.

We should have demonstrated to the Americans and the whole world that the Zanzibar problem, while complicated, is firmly under control and a solution will be found, but it will take time and the world must work with us, not against us.

I have no doubt in my mind that this alone would have gone a long way in reassuring our partners and even various constituencies at home that serious efforts are being made to resolve the problem at hand and we would have secured the much needed political space to deal with this delicate matter internally in an atmosphere of calm without all attendant economic and political pressures that now seem inevitable.

It is a well-known fact that relations between nations are driven by interests not emotions. We should, therefore, not be surprised if the US leverages its considerable financial muscle to achieve its foreign policy objectives, including, but not limited to wanting to be an influential player in a region that is quickly becoming very interesting in the wider global geopolitical context.

Our reaction to this MCC announcement, therefore, should not be one of indignation and surprise, but rather, we should pick up a phone or dispatch our diplomats to Washington, Brussels, Beijing and Tokyo, clarify our position, name the red lines that cannot be crossed, but also ask our partners to be reasonable and supportive of our efforts to resolve our problems.

It is understandable that some people are offended by the hypocrisy and double standards of the US, but we must also understand that the US has never had any problems being called out as a hypocrite. It has never stopped them from doing what they do, be it the unjust 50 yearlong economic embargo of Cuba or the false claim of weapons of mass destruction in Saddam Hussein’s Iraq 15 years ago.

We must be smarter than that and we can learn about how to deal with people you are in disagreement with from none other than the US itself.

A good example is that although President Obama cannot stand his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin, he calls him regularly to discuss important matters of state. He even keeps the infamous red phone in his office desk and on his bedside table in case of that unthinkable eventuality. He calls him even when they are in violent disagreement on ways of resolving ongoing global conflicts such as the one in Syria or Ukraine.

The MCC event is bigger than the money involved. Our failure to comply with the covenants we voluntarily agreed to, is a sign of weakness not strength. It is an admission that we have slipped on the governance scale even by our own standards. It will have consequences beyond the loss of the money being offered under the compact both locally and internationally.

Even if we did not need financial assistance for our development, we would need to maintain good relations with the likes of US, UK, China and EU if we want to avoid unnecessary disruptions to our development plans.

More importantly, however, we must ask ourselves if the decision to reject the MCC funds under these circumstances has the support of the majority of our people and the rights of some of our fellow citizens are not being sacrificed in the name of sovereignty and political expediency.

And while I wish it was not the case, Tanzania doesn’t have sufficient resources to fund all its ambitious development plans using internal sources even if we managed to stop all forms of tax evasion.

And running to the Chinese is not a sustainable solution in the long run. For all I know we will soon reach the ceiling of the debt we can sustainably take from the Chinese if this has not happened already.

The writers of various articles may be right when they claim that our relationship with the US cannot be defined by the MCC alone, but they are terribly mistaken if they think the US will leave us alone simply because we have decided to forgo the MCC money. That’s not how the world works.

We can be as certain as the sun will rise tomorrow that other development partners will soon follow in the footsteps of the US and the implications for us will become significant very quickly.

And let us be honest, Zanzibar is a real problem that requires urgent fixing. These recent elections were a terrible error of judgment. Soon we will see Dr Ali Mohamed Shein struggling to rule by himself in a country, whose Constitution assumes the government will always be made up of the two main political parties.

Now we have no opposition party based on the election results of March 20 and, of course, CCM has the numbers to amend the Constitution to enable it to govern, but such a move would deepen the crisis, not alleviate it.

I wrote a piece last year suggesting that the Zanzibar issue is too complex to be resolved through a one-man-one-vote solution. I also said that Tanzania Mainland could not stay out of the Zanzibar problem because for better or worse, for we are one and the same country.

A negotiated outcome would not have been a perfect solution to the election crisis in Zanzibar, but it would definitely have been better than the sham elections we just had. There was no rush to do this election because Dr Shein was constitutionally in office back then. Now, however, his legitimacy is shaky and he has become part of the problem - not the solution.

My hope is that when JPM takes over as chairman of CCM he will appoint a CCM leader in Zanzibar and on the mainland that can work with CUF and other opposition parties to bring peace and tranquillity back to the Isles.

I also hope that this new leadership will have wise answers to many pertinent questions that are being asked about the Union between Tanganyika and Zanzibar on both sides of the Union.

As for the MCC, we need to engage the Americans and push for the restoration of relations as soon as possible. Americans no doubt have an agenda, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t have our own, because that is how the world works.

Mr Mufuruki is Chairman & CEO, Infotech Investment Group and co-founder and chairman of the CEO Roundtable.
================================================
My take:
serikali kuwakorofisha international partners, na sasa kui-disappoint hata business community (a key source of tax revenue) ndiyo mwanzo wa kutengeneza lile anguko kuu.
i only pray kuwa hatuta-end up kuwa DRC nyingine!

Well observed, argued and excellent suggestions. Economic realities are obvious and in a free global trading world, nothing like what happened in Tanzania should have never happened. Big up Mafuruki!

 

[Clemence Baraka]

mufuruki mwenye mwizi na tapeli mkubwa kapata fedha za dili dili tu

Tukiachana na hayo yako anachosisitiza Mafuruki ni kwamba misaada ni kitu kingine hata kama hatuitaki lakini mahusiano ni jambo muhimu sana na nyeti.

 

[Mtanzania]

Asante sana mkuu Mafuruki kwa article hii.

 

[Easyway]

Kenya,Uganda ,DRC,Msumbiji hazipati hiyo misaada ya MCC na wanaishi.

Lazima na sisi tijifunze kuishi bila misaada,na mwanzo wa kujitegemea ndio huu lazima tupitie njia ngumu ndio tutajifunza.

 

[mr gentleman]

Kikwete tutakukumbuka daima.

Magufuli anabeba mzigo wa Kikwete hana mzigo wake ata mmoja.

 

[funaku]

Ni kwa sababu for sure aliyetangulia katangulia tu...

Sasa kuna muda watu wanaamua kukomaa tu...kama mbwai ni mbwai.....

 

[mr gentleman]

uozo upi?
After magufuli alitakiwa aanze na kushukughulika na awamu yake,sio kufuatilia mambo yaliyotokea awamu iliyopita wakati nchi ikiwa chini ya mtu mwingine,
haya ya kukamata watu walikula rushwa miaka mitano kabla hajawa rais yanapaswa kuwa nyongeza tu,
katika awamu yake anatakiwa sasa asile rushwa hata mtu mmoja ,ili baada hata ya miaka miwili bila hata mtu mmoja kula rushwa ndo tutajua kumbe kweli KAZI IPO HUKU

Utaanzaje kupambana na rushwa ikiwa wala rushwa unao ndani? Yani ulitaka asiwaguse wala rushwa alafu apambane na wala rushwa wapya kivipi sijaelewa?

Ebu nipe mfano tukianzia na bandari.

 

[FaizaFoxy]

Usimsifu sana huyo mwandishi. Ndo moja ya watu ambao wametumia vibaya sana PPP kwa kujidai business community.

Sisi watanzania hatuwezi kabisa kuishi bila misaada.Tuanze na mawaziri warudishe magari .

I have a feeling the first one to be sodomized in the contry was you, otherwise you wouldn't have come with such a gayish comment.

I challenge all those who are answering this thread to use the language used in the first post, by doing so we will be enlightened as to those who have really understood Mafuruki's message.

 

[TrueVoter]

hilo si tatizo basi,kama tunafuatilia ishu za nyuma si mbaya waanze pia kuanzia miaka ya 1961,wauaji wa mashirika ya umma,mashamba ya vijiji na maduka ya kaya watafutwe na kushughulikiwa,
lakini pia mapungufu ya leo yasiwe justifyed na awamu zilizopita,awamu hii ina uwezo wa kuanza clean,kuliko kujistify mapungufu yanayotokea kwa awamu iliyopita

Kama ushahidi upo yanapaswa yafuatiliwe, watz tujifunze kufanya mambo yetu kwa uhalali..habari ya ujanja ujanja na bahati NO! una uhalali gani kama kiongozi na msimamizi wa haki kumshughulikia mhalifu wa leo unamuacha mhalifu wa jana ilhali aliyetendewa ubaya ni yule yule..!