11 Political and Economic Experts present strong case for 2-government Union

[Ng'wamapalala]

A TEAM of dons led by the Chief Executive Officer of the Eastern and Southern African Universities Research Project (ESAURP), Prof Teddy Malyamkono, handed over a book titled ‘100 Academics in Search of Katiba Bora Tanzania,’ which emphasises on retaining the current structure or a switch to a one-government union.

The book, which was handed over to the Vice-Chairperson of the Constituent Assembly (CA), Ms Samia Suluhu Hassan, is a work of 11 experts who researched on various matters related to the Union of Tanganyika and Zanzibar.

Prof Malyamkono was accompanied by the Dean of the School of Law in the University of Dar es Salaam, Prof Bonaventura Rutinwa and an economist from the same university, Prof Nehemiah Osoro.

Prof Rutinwa said that the book looked at issues related to citizenship and rights of the people and found it necessary that the union remain as it is or a possible switch to a ‘’one-government one considered.’’

“The constitution of Zanzibar has since 2003 stated that it is a country while the current one just repeated the former; this should not be a matter of concern,” he observed.

He added that a three-government union will not give equal rights to the people, pointing out that the Constitution of Zanzibar has already given exclusive rights to its people on some areas, while hindering the same to people on the Mainland.

On his part, Prof Osoro focused on the economic implications as discussed in the book, saying that a three-tier union, as proposed by the Constitution Review Commission (CRC) in the Second Draft of the Constitution, ‘’will weaken the union government and make it poorer.’’

He reiterated President Jakaya Kikwete’s statement that such a situation could force the army to overthrow the government in case the two governments refuse to give monies to the Union government.

He pointed out that research conducted by the team of experts shows that though the CRC proposes the reduction of Union matters from 22 to 7, the cost of running such a government will go down slightly because the matters removed were not costly ones. “Those who are proposing the three-tier union basing on economic argument are not genuine, because such argument does not hold water here; we can only reduce costs by 6 per cent,” he said.

Prof Malyamkono pointed out that ESAURP, which is an umbrella for various public universities from 12 African countries, embarked on the research and found out that 50 years of the Union were enough to warrant a move to a one-government arrangement.

“It is not true that Zanzibar has gone too far in breaking the union, we can still move on with the current structure or switch to one government,” he pointed out.
At least 700 copies of the book have been submitted for distribution to CA members to serve as point of reference in broadening their knowledge.

Ms Samia commended the academics for their work and promised to distribute the books to members.
She said the publications will broaden the members’ knowledge as they deliberate on the draft constitution to enable them come up with the best constitution, which will meet the needs of Tanzanians.

Source: Dailynews.

 

[Communist]

Wanatutia aibu wasomi. Mimi simo kabisa. Tena hili neno eti wasomi wa Tanzania mkome.

 

[Ng'wamapalala]

Wow, this is political war. This is a triggered bomb in a form of book towards UKAWA-ndani na nje!.

Why present a so called ‘100 Academics in Search of Katiba Bora Tanzania,' now?. What is the motive(s) behind?.

I just have this feeling that the constitution-making process might be heading towards a stalemate.

The CA standing Order Number 37(1) is killing the entire hope of New constitution come 2015, not only from one side of a divided Constitution Assembly, but also for the entire nation.

I can't see two-third votes comes from Zanzibar member of Constitution Assembly. You can't change or sway opinion to a CUF pukka member or supporter to embrace two-government system. Never!.

My wish, If we can't have one-government union, ni bora tu kila nchi ikachukua fito zake na kuondoka. Tutakuwa tunakutana kwenye UN, EAC, SADC, OIC. etcetera etcetera

Serikali tatu ni mchakato wa kuvunja Muungano lakini kwa gharama kubwa sana. Kwa nini kuingia gharama zote hizo kwenye taifa ambalo hata ubao wa kufundishia mashuleni ni kifaa cha anasa.

Ni kweli usiopingika kuwa serikali tatu haziwezi kusimama kwenye haya mataifa ambayo yako unbalanced economically and socially.

Let's be real. Hivi tunategemea Zanzibar itaweza kulipia gharama za Muungano kwenye serikali tatu kama CUF watachukua madaraka kwa upande wa Zanzibar, halafu CHADEMA wachukue kwa upande wa Tanganyika halafu CCM wawe ndiyo chama kinachoongoza kwenye Serikali ya Muungano. What will happen?.

Serikali mbili ni kero zinazoongezeka kila siku mpaka mwisho wa dunia, lakini kama hizo kero hazitakuwa nzito kuzibeba, basi zinaweza zikaendelea mpaka mwisho wa dunia. Nina amini kadri siku zinavyokwenda, hizo kero za Muungano wa Serikali mbili zitakuwa nzito kubebeka kwa pande zote za Muungano na matokeo yake ni Muungano kuvunjika pia kwa gharama kubwa.

Kauli mbiu ni Serikali moja inawezekana kama haiwezekani, tugawane fito.

Kura ya maoni kufahamu kama Muungano unahitajika au hauhitajiki ndiyo mwarobaini wa kero za Muungano.

 

[Communist]

Warioba: Mwarobaini ni kuundwa serikali tatu Tanzaniaukubwa wa hati ukubwa wa hati kuzisha hati Kichapishi Add new comment Warioba: Mwarobaini ni kuundwa serikali tatu TanzaniaMwenyekiti wa Tume ya Mabadiliko ya Katiba nchini Tanzania Jaji Mstaafu Joseph Sinde Warioba amesema kuwa, muundo wa sasa wa muungano haukidhi matakwa ya Watanzania walio wengi.Jaji Warioba aliyasema hayo jana wakati wa kukabidhi rasimu ya katiba kwa Rais Jakaya Kikwete wa nchi hiyo. Jaji Warioba amesema kuwa, miongoni mwa mambo yaliyopendekezwa kwenye rasimu hiyo ni kwa spika na naibu spika wasitokane na wabunge au kiongozi wa juu wa chama cha siasa, na mbunge kuwajibishwa na wananchi. Tume hiyo imependekeza Msajili wa Vyama vya Siasa iwe taasisi inayojitegemea na si kuwa sehemu ya Tume Huru ya Uchaguzi.Dondoo nyingine kwenye rasimu hiyo ni wabunge kuwa na ukomo, mawaziri kutokuwa wabunge na kupunguzwa madaraka ya rais. Wananchi wa Tanzani kwa miaka kadhaa wameonyesha kuchoshwa na marekebisho yaliyokuwa yakifanywa mara kwa mara katika baadhi ya vipengee vya katiba, jambo lililomsukuma Rais Kikwete aanzishe mchakato wa kupatikana katiba mpya kabla hajamaliza kipindi chake cha uongozi mwaka 2015.

 

[Communist]

Serikali tatu ‘matakwa ya wananchi’, Warioba aliambia Bunge la #Katiba [VIDEO] - Katiba - mwananchi.co.tz muziki

 

[Ng'wamapalala]

Wanatutia aibu wasomi. Mimi simo kabisa. Tena hili neno eti wasomi wa Tanzania mkome.

Wamekutia aibu gani?. Please, naomba ufafanue

 

[Communist]

http://www.habarileo.co.tz/index.ph...fanya-tukapendekeza-serikali-tatu-ni-hayaSoma na hii

 

[Communist]

Tanzania Today - Tanzania, Business , Jobs in Tanzania, News, Business Directory, Real Estate, Finance, Auto hii

 

[Communist]

Wamekutia aibu gani?. Please, naomba ufafanue

Wamepewa ubwabwa wakashiba wakanunulika. Walikuwa wangapi, kati ya wasomi wangapi?

 

[mckenzie]

No comments

 

[Munabusule]

Hivi wasomi wa Tanzania wengi kumbe wamefaulu kwa kukariri????????? Hawakujua kuwa utayarishaji wa katiba ni mchakato unaofuata time frame.walikuwa wapi Wakati warioba anakusanya maoni???? Ukisikia waleta machafu basi ni hawa wasomi 100pages opinions.POle watanzania

 

[Ben Saanane]

Wow, this is political war. This is a triggered bomb in a form of book towars UKAWA-ndani na nje!.

Why present a so called ‘100 Academics in Search of Katiba Bora Tanzania,’ now?. What is the motive(s) behind?.

I just have this feeling that the constitution-making process might be heading towards a stalemate.

The CA standing Order Number 37(1) is killing the entire hope of New constitution come 2015, not only from one side of a divided Constitution Assembly, but also for the entire nation.

I can't see two-third votes comes from Zanzibar member of Constitution Assembly. You can't change or sway opinion to a CUF pukka member or supporter to embrace two-government system. Never!.

My wish, If we can't have one-government union, ni bora tu kila nchi ikachukua fito zake na kuondoka. Tutakuwa tunakutana kwenye UN, EAC, SADC, OIC. etcetera etcetera

Serikali tatu ni mchakato wa kuvunja Muungano lakini kwa gharama kubwa sana. Kwa nini kuingia gharama zote hizo kwenye taifa ambalo hata ubao wa kufundishia mashuleni ni kifaa cha anasa.

Ni kweli usiopingika kuwa serikali tatu haziwezi kusimama kwenye haya mataifa ambayo yako unbalanced economically and socially.

Let's be real. Hivi tunategemea Zanzibar itaweza kulipia gharama za Muungano kwenye serikali tatu kama CUF watachukua madaraka kwa upande wa Zanzibar, halafu CHADEMA wachukue kwa upande wa Tanganyika halafu CCM wawe ndiyo chama kinachoongoza kwenye Serikali ya Muungano. What will happen?.

Serikali mbili ni kero zinazoongezeka kila siku mpaka mwisho wa dunia, lakini kama hizo kero hazitakuwa nzito kuzibeba, basi zinaweza zikaendelea mpaka mwisho wa dunia. Nina amini kadri siku zinavyokwenda, hizo kero za Muungano wa Serikali mbili zitakuwa nzito kubebeka kwa pande zote za Muungano na matokeo yake ni Muungano kuvunjika pia kwa gharama kubwa.

Kauli mbiu ni Serikali moja inawezekana kama haiwezekani, tugawane fito.

Kura ya maoni kufahamu kama Muungano unahitajika au hauhitajiki ndiyo mwarobaini wa kero za Muungano.

Katiba ya Muungano ndio itakayotoa muongozo hata kama vyama tofauti vimeshinda.Mbona hujiulizi ikiwa CUF watashinda Zanzibar itakuaje ikiwa CCM au CHADEMA wanaongoza serikali ya sasa ya Muungano?

Msimamo wangu ni serikali tatu.Kama haiwezekani basi serikali Moja maana kama serikali tatu ni gharama kwanini iwe serikali 2 na sio moja?

 

[Ben Saanane]

Hivi wasomi wa Tanzania wengi kumbe wamefaulu kwa kukariri????????? Hawakujua kuwa utayarishaji wa katiba ni mchakato unaofuata time frame.walikuwa wapi Wakati warioba anakusanya maoni???? Ukisikia waleta machafu basi ni hawa wasomi 100pages opinions.POle watanzania

Hao ni makuwadi wa watawala.Taaluma zimewekwa mfukoni

 

[Ngoso]

They may have a strong case to argue but the matter is overtaken by event.their points should have been presented to judge Warioba. .The constitutional palierme accepting their books and distribute to the members is ashamed trying to confuse the members.

A TEAM of dons led by the Chief Executive Officer of the Eastern and Southern African Universities Research Project (ESAURP), Prof Teddy Malyamkono, handed over a book titled ‘100 Academics in Search of Katiba Bora Tanzania,’ which emphasises on retaining the current structure or a switch to a one-government union.

The book, which was handed over to the Vice-Chairperson of the Constituent Assembly (CA), Ms Samia Suluhu Hassan, is a work of 11 experts who researched on various matters related to the Union of Tanganyika and Zanzibar.

Prof Malyamkono was accompanied by the Dean of the School of Law in the University of Dar es Salaam, Prof Bonaventura Rutinwa and an economist from the same university, Prof Nehemiah Osoro.

Prof Rutinwa said that the book looked at issues related to citizenship and rights of the people and found it necessary that the union remain as it is or a possible switch to a ‘’one-government one considered.’’

“The constitution of Zanzibar has since 2003 stated that it is a country while the current one just repeated the former; this should not be a matter of concern,” he observed.

He added that a three-government union will not give equal rights to the people, pointing out that the Constitution of Zanzibar has already given exclusive rights to its people on some areas, while hindering the same to people on the Mainland.

On his part, Prof Osoro focused on the economic implications as discussed in the book, saying that a three-tier union, as proposed by the Constitution Review Commission (CRC) in the Second Draft of the Constitution, ‘’will weaken the union government and make it poorer.’’

He reiterated President Jakaya Kikwete’s statement that such a situation could force the army to overthrow the government in case the two governments refuse to give monies to the Union government.

He pointed out that research conducted by the team of experts shows that though the CRC proposes the reduction of Union matters from 22 to 7, the cost of running such a government will go down slightly because the matters removed were not costly ones. “Those who are proposing the three-tier union basing on economic argument are not genuine, because such argument does not hold water here; we can only reduce costs by 6 per cent,” he said.

Prof Malyamkono pointed out that ESAURP, which is an umbrella for various public universities from 12 African countries, embarked on the research and found out that 50 years of the Union were enough to warrant a move to a one-government arrangement.

“It is not true that Zanzibar has gone too far in breaking the union, we can still move on with the current structure or switch to one government,” he pointed out.
At least 700 copies of the book have been submitted for distribution to CA members to serve as point of reference in broadening their knowledge.

Ms Samia commended the academics for their work and promised to distribute the books to members.
She said the publications will broaden the members’ knowledge as they deliberate on the draft constitution to enable them come up with the best constitution, which will meet the needs of Tanzanians.

Source: Dailynews.

 

[Communist]

CCM yatumia wasomi vibaya
JITIHADA za Chama Cha Mapinduzi (CCM) kupigania mfumo wa serikali mbili zimechukua sura mpya baada ya kubainika kwamba sasa kimeamua kuwatumia wasomi 100, wakiwemo maprosesa kutunga kitabu kutetea msimamo wake huo na kupinga mapendekezo ya rasimu ya Katiba ya serikali tatu.
Hatua hiyo ni mwendelezo wa mkakati wa CCM kuwatumia wanazuoni kutetea hoja ya serikali mbili kama alivyofanya msomi anayeheshimika sana nchini, Profesa Issa Shivji, ambaye hivi karibuni aliibuka na kumponda Mwenyekiti wa Tume ya Mabadiliko ya Katiba, Jaji Joseph Warioba na wajumbe wake waliokuja na maoni ya serikali tatu.
Wasomi hao waliomo kwenye Taasisi ya Utafiti ya Vyuo Vikuu vya Nchi za Mashariki na Kusini mwa Afrika (ESAURP), inayoundwa na maprofesa, wametunga kitabu walichokipa jina la ‘Katiba Bora Tanzania' na kukikabidhi kwa Makamu Mwenyekiti wa Bunge Maalumu, Samia Suluhu Hassan.
Wasomi hao ni Profesa Tedi Maliyamkono, ambaye ni Mkurugenzi Mtendaji mwanzilishi wa taasisi hiyo, Mkuu wa Shule ya Sheria katika Chuo Kikuu cha Dar es Salaam, Profesa Boneventure Rutinwa na Mhadhiri wa Chuo Kikuu cha Dar es Salaam, Profesa Nehemiah Osoro.
Kutolewa kwa kitabu hicho chenye mwelekeo wa kutetea msimamo wa CCM wa serikali mbili, kumekuja wiki chache tu baada ya msomi mwingine Profesa Issa Shivji, kuponda mapendekezo ya rasimu ya Katiba yanayopendekeza muundo wa serikali tatu.
Shivji alidai kuwa muundo wa serikali mbili ndio wenye kufaa zaidi hivi sasa, kwa kuwa mfumo uliopendekezwa katika rasimu utawavuruga wananchi.
Serikali tatu ndio mfumo uliopendekezwa na iliyokuwa Tume ya Mabadiliko ya Katiba, chini ya Jaji Joseph Warioba, katika rasimu ya Katiba inayojadiliwa hivi sasa, unaungwa mkono na wajumbe wengi kutoka vyama vya upinzani.
Profesa Maliyamkono alisema ESAURP ilianzishwa ili kuwapa nafasi maprofesa ya kuchambua masuala mbalimbali yaliyoko katika jamii na kuyatafutia ufumbuzi.
Wakabidhi kitabu
Wasomi hao jana walimkabidhi Makamu Mwenyekiti wa Bunge Maalumu la Katiba, Samia Suluhu Hassan, vitabu vyenye mwelekeo wa kuunga mkono na kupinga baadhi ya mapendekezo yaliyomo kwenye rasimu ya Katiba.
Akitoa maelezo wakati wa kukabidhi vitabu hivyo, Profesa Bonaventure Rutinwa, alisema katika rasimu ya Katiba inaonyesha kuwa serikali tatu ni kiini katika kila kipengele ndani ya rasimu hiyo.
Wasomi hao walisema wanavikabidhi vitabu hivyo kwa uongozi wa Bunge Maalumu ili viwe chachu katika mijadala na uamuzi wa upatikanaji wa Katiba mpya itakayokuwa imebeba masilahi ya Watanzania wengi.
Mmoja wa wasomi hao, Profesa Osoro, alisema kuwa wananchi wanahitaji elimu kubwa juu ya madhara ya serikali tatu kabla hawajaukubali mfumo huo katika kura ya maoni itakayofanyika baada ya Bunge kupitisha Katiba iliyopendekezwa.
Alisema kuwa wananchi wamekuwa wakisikia mfumo wa serikali tatu uliotolewa na Tume ya Warioba lakini wengi wao hawajui kwa kina faida na hasara za mfumo huo.
"Waliopendekeza muundo wa serikali tatu, wamepunguza mambo ya muungano kutoka 22 hadi saba. Wao wanasema tukiwa na serikali tatu tutapunguza ghamara za uendeshaji, lakini ukweli ni kwamba, muundo huo gharama zake zinazidi kidogo sana muundo wa serikali mbili tulionao," alisema.
Aliongeza kuwa hawakubaliani na muundo wa serikali tatu kwakuwa zitasababisha wakati mwingine majeshi ya ulinzi na usalama kushindwa kulipwa mishahara, jambo ambalo ni la hatari.
"Kwa hiyo, sisi kama wanataaluma, tunaona muundo unaofaa ni wa serikali mbili tulionao na kama huu hautakiwi, ni boratuwe na serikali moja badala ya hizo tatu," alisema Profesa Osoro.
Hata hivyo, katika kitabu hicho chenye kurasa 372, Profesa Osoro anasema gharama za kuendesha shughuli za muungano na huduma zingine za serikali ni wajibu wa msingi wa Serikali ya Muungano na kwamba Serikali ya Muungano ina uwezo wa kugharamia matumizi ya muungano kwa kuwa ina mapato ya ndani yakisaidiana na fedha za nje.
Kutokana na hali hiyo, anasema Serikali ya Muungano tangu kuanzishwa kwake haijawahi kushindwa kugharamia masuala yake ingawa Tume ya Mabadiliko ya Katiba, imependekeza muundo wa serikali tatu wenye nchi huru mbili kwa maana ya Serikali ya Tanganyika na Serikali ya Mapinduzi Zanzibar na Serikali ya Shirikisho.
"Tanzania Bara ni nchi kubwa na tajiri na ina uwezo wa kugharamia matumizi yake yote na kuchangia sehemu ya mapato yake katika Serikali ya Muungano. Kwa upande mwingine, Zanzibar ni nchi ndogo yenye watu wasiopungua milioni moja na ina rasilimali chache, kwa kifupi ni nchi dhaifu.
"Kutokana na utajiri wa Tanzania, inaweza kubeba gharama za kuendesha muungano kwani tangu mwaka 1968, Serikali ya Zanzibar haijatoa mchango wa Uendeshaji wa Serikali ya Muungano kwani inapata asilimia 4.5 ya misaada yote inayopokewa na Serikali ya Muungano.
"Kwa maana hiyo, kama muundo wa serikali tatu utapitishwa, Zanzibar itabeba gharama zote za serikali yake ambazo zitakuwa kubwa kuliko uwezo wake," alisema Profesa Osoro.
Aliongeza kuwa changamoto kubwa katika serikali tatu ni ya kiuchumi si ya kisiasa kama ilivyofikiriwa kati ya Serikali ya Muungano.
Alikiri kuwa Katiba ya Zanzibar ya mwaka 2010 imevunja sehemu ya Katiba ya Muungano wa serikali mbili lakini jambo hilo linaweza kurekebishwa bila kuanzisha mfumo wa serikali tatu kama ilivyopendekezwa na Tume ya Warioba.
"Duniani kote nchi ikiwa ndogo kiuchumi, eneo au hesabu ya watu itategemea nyingine hasa ikiwa na vyanzo vya uchumi imara…hii ni sababu kubwa ya muungano na ndivyo ilivyo EU na kutokana na hilo Katiba itamke hilo," alisema
Profesa Bonaventure Rutinwa, alisema SAURP kama taasisi ya umma itakuwa inatimiza wajibu wake wa kuhimiza wana taaluma kutoka vyuo vikuu kujihusisha na ufumbuzi wa shida walizonazo wananchi.
Kutolewa kwa kitabu hicho kunazidi kuimarisha mikakati ya CCM, kutaka jamii isizungumzie wala kuukubali mfumo wa serikali tatu uliopendekezwa na Tume ya Warioba ambayo wajumbe wengi wa CCM wanaiponda kwa madai ilifanya kazi kwa masilahi binafsi.
Hata hivyo wiki iliyopita baadhi ya wajumbe wa Umoja wa Katiba ya Wananchi (UKAWA), wakiwemo Tundu Lissu pamoja na Ismail Jussa, walipinga kitendo cha wasomi kuurubuni umma kuhusu ubaya wa serikali tatu.
Lissu na Jussa walikuwa wakimjibu Profesa Shivji, ambaye walisema ameanza kufanya mambo kinyume cha misimamo yake ya huko nyuma na kwamba ameamua kutumiwa na CCM kutetea hoja yao ya serikai mbili.
Viongozi hao walisema kuwa vitabu vingi alivyotunga msomi huyo ameelezea muundo wa serikali tatu ulivyo bora kuliko serikali mbili.

 

[Ngoso]

They may have a strong case to argue but the matter is overtaken by event.their points should have been presented to judge Warioba. .The constitutional palierme accepting their books and distribute to the members is ashamed trying to confuse the members.

A TEAM of dons led by the Chief Executive Officer of the Eastern and Southern African Universities Research Project (ESAURP), Prof Teddy Malyamkono, handed over a book titled ‘100 Academics in Search of Katiba Bora Tanzania,’ which emphasises on retaining the current structure or a switch to a one-government union.

The book, which was handed over to the Vice-Chairperson of the Constituent Assembly (CA), Ms Samia Suluhu Hassan, is a work of 11 experts who researched on various matters related to the Union of Tanganyika and Zanzibar.

Prof Malyamkono was accompanied by the Dean of the School of Law in the University of Dar es Salaam, Prof Bonaventura Rutinwa and an economist from the same university, Prof Nehemiah Osoro.

Prof Rutinwa said that the book looked at issues related to citizenship and rights of the people and found it necessary that the union remain as it is or a possible switch to a ‘’one-government one considered.’’

“The constitution of Zanzibar has since 2003 stated that it is a country while the current one just repeated the former; this should not be a matter of concern,” he observed.

He added that a three-government union will not give equal rights to the people, pointing out that the Constitution of Zanzibar has already given exclusive rights to its people on some areas, while hindering the same to people on the Mainland.

On his part, Prof Osoro focused on the economic implications as discussed in the book, saying that a three-tier union, as proposed by the Constitution Review Commission (CRC) in the Second Draft of the Constitution, ‘’will weaken the union government and make it poorer.’’

He reiterated President Jakaya Kikwete’s statement that such a situation could force the army to overthrow the government in case the two governments refuse to give monies to the Union government.

He pointed out that research conducted by the team of experts shows that though the CRC proposes the reduction of Union matters from 22 to 7, the cost of running such a government will go down slightly because the matters removed were not costly ones. “Those who are proposing the three-tier union basing on economic argument are not genuine, because such argument does not hold water here; we can only reduce costs by 6 per cent,” he said.

Prof Malyamkono pointed out that ESAURP, which is an umbrella for various public universities from 12 African countries, embarked on the research and found out that 50 years of the Union were enough to warrant a move to a one-government arrangement.

“It is not true that Zanzibar has gone too far in breaking the union, we can still move on with the current structure or switch to one government,” he pointed out.
At least 700 copies of the book have been submitted for distribution to CA members to serve as point of reference in broadening their knowledge.

Ms Samia commended the academics for their work and promised to distribute the books to members.
She said the publications will broaden the members’ knowledge as they deliberate on the draft constitution to enable them come up with the best constitution, which will meet the needs of Tanzanians.

Source: Dailynews.

 

[Ng'wamapalala]

Katiba ya Muungano ndio itakayotoa muongozo hata kama vyama tofauti vimeshinda.Mbona hujiulizi ikiwa CUF watashinda Zanzibar itakuaje ikiwa CCM au CHADEMA wanaongoza serikali ya sasa ya Muungano?

Msimamo wangu ni serikali tatu.Kama haiwezekani basi serikali Moja maana kama serikali tatu ni gharama kwanini iwe serikali 2 na sio moja?

Kwani hiyo katiba ya Muungano ilikuwa suspended wakati wananchi wa Zanzibar wanafanya mabadiliko ya Katiba 2010 na kuweka katika sehemu ya kwanza ya Katiba, ibara hii,

1. Zanzibar ni Nchi ambayo eneo la mipaka yake ni eneo lotel a Visiwa vya Unguja na Pemba pamoja na Visiwa vidogo vilivyo izunguka na bahari yake ambayo kabla ya Muungano wa Tanganyika na Zanzibar ikiitwa Jamhuri ya Watu wa Zanzibar.

Kushinda kwa CUF au CCM kwa Zanzibar katika serikali mbili hakubadilishi lolote katika Muungano kwa sababu tunaambiwa nje ya gharama zingine, Zanzibar kwa sasa wana miaka zaidi ya kumi hawajatoa mchango wao wa gharama za Muungano. Kwa maana nyingine, Zanzibaris don't give a monkey's!.

Hii ndiyo maana ya Tanganyika kuvaa koti la Muungano. Kuvaa koti ni gharama kubwa. Hili koti kwa sasa kama inavyojidhihirisha ndiyo limeshikilia muungano. Siku Tanganyika ikilivua, basi hata Muungano ndiyo utakuwa mwisho wake kitu ambacho napenda kitokee kama hakuna serikali moja.

 

[Ng'wamapalala]

Hao ni makuwadi wa watawala.Taaluma zimewekwa mfukoni

Siku hizi Watanzania tuna majibu mepesi mepesi hata kwenye maswala yanayohitaji upembuzi wa kina.

Ninaamini hata hujakisoma hicho kitabu lakini tayari umeishapata hitimisho kutoka ndani ya kitabu.

Hii dhana ya kudhani kila mtu ana bei ya kununulika ndiyo chimbuko la kupata majibu mepesi mepesi.

 

[Communist]

Siku hizi Watanzania tuna majibu mepesi mepesi hata kwenye maswala yanayohitaji upembuzi wa kina.

Ninaamini hata hujakisoma hicho kitabu lakini tayari umeishapata hitimisho kutoka ndani ya kitabu.

Hii dhana ya kudhani kila mtu ana bei ya kununulika ndiyo chimbuko la kupata majibu mepesi mepesi.

Hamna kitu ndani ya hiki kitabu, ni ubwabwa tu.

 

[Kichakoro]

awali ya yote nilikua namheshimu sana Prof Osoro lakini kwa hili naona amejipaka majivu. Swali: Kwa nini kama walifamya kama academicians kwa nini hawakuileta kwa academician kwanza tuisome tutoe critiques zetu nio ipelekwe kwa wanasiana? Kwa nini wamekimbilia Dodoma badala ya kuitoa kwenye Vyuo (EAUSAP) kama wanavyofanya kwenye mambo mengine? na hao wasomi 100 ni kina Nani?