Bomani Committee hiding the truth?

Kubwajinga

JF-Expert Member
Jan 23, 2008
2,190
1,500
By Correspondent Gadiosa Lamtey
16-05-2008


Reports that the Mining Review Committee is yet to get a chance to present its findings to President Jakaya Mrisho Kikwete are incorrect, a lecturer with the University of Dar es Salaam has said.

It has been reported that the all inclusive committee formed to review mining contracts and recommend corrective measures is yet to submit its report to President Jakaya Kikwete, although the assignment was completed almost two months ago.

State House Communication Director Salva Rweyemamu told The Guardian yesterday the President had not yet received the report from the committee. Also, Committee Chairman Judge Mark Bomani said the report had been completed and was ready for submitting.

``The report is ready. We are only waiting for the President to give us a date when to submit it,`` Bomani said.

However, a Dar es Salaam-based political analyst Dr Laurean Ndumbaru said the appointed committee had not yet completed its task of preparing the final report before submitting it to the President.

``What they are supposed is to tell the truth that they have not yet finalized the report,`` said Dr. Ndumbaro, senior lecturer at the University of Dar es Salaam.

He said the Committee could submit its report to Chief Secretary Philemon Luhanjo who would take it to the President.

He urged the committee to speed up the process by submitting the findings to the responsible authority on time as the public seemed to be tired of unfulfilled promises.

Asked to comment on allegations that his team was dillydallying because it was still finalizing its report, Judge Bomani said that the claims were untrue. ``We have completed our work. We are only waiting for the President to tell us when we can present him the findings.

We cannot present the recommendations to the Chief Secretary, because he is not the one who gave us the assignment. If you want, you can call the Chief Secretary if he is indeed the one who assigned us the task,`` Judge Bomani said and hung up.

The commission, which was formed by President Kikwete at the end of last year, was given until February this year to complete work and submit its recommendations.

It was tasked with reviewing commercial mining contracts and making recommendations that would enable the country to reach a win-win understanding with investors in the mining sector.

The committee was composed of opposition and ruling party legislators, mining experts and other government officials. It was also tasked to review laws governing the industry as well as analyse the taxation system in the mining industry.
Currently, mining companies pay three (3) per cent royalty, an amount seen as peanuts comparing to what they are reaping.

Commenting on the delay, Kahama MP-CCM, James Lembeli said the government decided to form the Mining Contracts Review Committee following the unfolding of the scandal on the Buzwagi mining contract.

``It was because of the on-going allegations on Buzwagi Mine, which is located in my constituency, that the committee was formed. I therefore wonder what has caused a delay in the presentation of the review team`s findings. The people are eager to know the recommendations,`` he said.

Lembeli said further delays could raise suspicion that the team`s report could be tampered with in the meantime. ``Let the document be presented to the President so that people`s faith in their government is preserved,`` the MP said.

Geita legislator-CCM, Ernest Mabina said MPs were eagerly waiting for the mining review team`s report so that they would discuss it. He said any delay in submitting the findings did not do justice to the wananchi.

`However, I understand that the terms of reference given to the committee covered a lot of areas, yet the time span for presenting the report had elapsed, there is a need to make the presidential probe team`s findings public,`` he said.

The MP called upon members of the public to remain patient until the time when the report would be presented.

On his part, Karatu Chadema MP Dr Wilbrod Slaa said lack of seriousness on national resources by the government was the main reason for its delay in making the report public.

Dr Slaa said the committee was supposed to submit its report in February this year although it is now May and nothing had been submitted yet. ``The government is not serious with its natural resources,`` Dr. Slaa said.

The opposition MP said the report should be made public for every Tanzanian to weigh whether they were getting a fair share from the mining industry or not.

The committee was made up of Judge Bomani, Kigoma North MP Zitto Kabwe, (Chadema), Kyela MP Dr Harrison Mwakyembe (CCM), Ezekiel Maige (Msalala, CCM), John Cheyo (Bariadi East, UDP) and Peter Machunde of the Dar es Salaam Stock Exchange.

Others were David Tarimo, a tax consultant with PricewaterhouseCoopers, Maria Kejo, director of civil and international law in the Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Affairs, Salome Makange, chief legal officer at the Ministry of Energy and Minerals, Mugisha Kamugisha, commissioner for policy in the Ministry of Finance and Edward Kihundwa, assistant director for human settlements in the Ministry of Lands, Housing and Human Settlements.

SOURCE: Guardian
 

Mtanganyika

JF-Expert Member
Jul 18, 2007
1,606
1,500
The studies faced a lot of challenges. Things like luck of mining contracts analyst, luck of investment banker, luck of smart geologist and corporate tax consultant. Mark Bomani, Mwakyembe, Zitto and others faced many challanges on their analysis because they never exposed on that kind of staff.

For instance, Makampuni yakija hapo Tanzania yanajenge jenga vibarabara mshenzi, vizahanati then they add that cost on outlay cost. Vile vile all this small companies zinazochimba madini Tanzania zinadai haziuzi haya madini zenyewe, so kupanda kwenye price kwenye market hakuna impact kwao, which is a lie lakini kwa sababu hatuna investment bankers we cant find the loophole.

Corporate Finance specialist ni tatizo, kwani hawa jamaa wanacheza na kuzimanipulate earning na serikali inatupia maCPA wake and they can't see anything fishy. Mfano nimesikia Mramba aliwapa hawa jamaa waiver kwenye kodi ya mafuta as long as wapo kwenye hayo madini. That is another loophole, direct access by politican kwa hawa jamaa.

Kwa kifupi tume haikuwa na wataalamu wa kutosha wanajua in and out of coparate structure.
 

Gaijin

JF-Expert Member
Aug 21, 2007
11,817
0
sasa kama hawajamaliza report yao si waseme tu.
hapa mmoja ni muongo, either bomani, au salva.
 

Zitto

Former MP Kigoma Urban
Mar 2, 2007
1,553
2,000
Bomani Committee `hiding the truth`

2008-05-16 09:56:36
By Correspondent Gadiosa Lamtey


Reports that the Mining Review Committee is yet to get a chance to present its findings to President Jakaya Mrisho Kikwete are incorrect, a lecturer with the University of Dar es Salaam has said.

It has been reported that the all inclusive committee formed to review mining contracts and recommend corrective measures is yet to submit its report to President Jakaya Kikwete, although the assignment was completed almost two months ago.

State House Communication Director Salva Rweyemamu told The Guardian yesterday the President had not yet received the report from the committee. Also, Committee Chairman Judge Mark Bomani said the report had been completed and was ready for submitting.

``The report is ready. We are only waiting for the President to give us a date when to submit it,`` Bomani said.

However, a Dar es Salaam-based political analyst Dr Laurean Ndumbaru said the appointed committee had not yet completed its task of preparing the final report before submitting it to the President.

``What they are supposed is to tell the truth that they have not yet finalized the report,`` said Dr. Ndumbaro, senior lecturer at the University of Dar es Salaam.

He said the Committee could submit its report to Chief Secretary Philemon Luhanjo who would take it to the President.

He urged the committee to speed up the process by submitting the findings to the responsible authority on time as the public seemed to be tired of unfulfilled promises.

Asked to comment on allegations that his team was dillydallying because it was still finalizing its report, Judge Bomani said that the claims were untrue. ``We have completed our work. We are only waiting for the President to tell us when we can present him the findings.

We cannot present the recommendations to the Chief Secretary, because he is not the one who gave us the assignment. If you want, you can call the Chief Secretary if he is indeed the one who assigned us the task,`` Judge Bomani said and hung up.

The commission, which was formed by President Kikwete at the end of last year, was given until February this year to complete work and submit its recommendations.

It was tasked with reviewing commercial mining contracts and making recommendations that would enable the country to reach a win-win understanding with investors in the mining sector.

The committee was composed of opposition and ruling party legislators, mining experts and other government officials. It was also tasked to review laws governing the industry as well as analyse the taxation system in the mining industry.
Currently, mining companies pay three (3) per cent royalty, an amount seen as peanuts comparing to what they are reaping.

Commenting on the delay, Kahama MP-CCM, James Lembeli said the government decided to form the Mining Contracts Review Committee following the unfolding of the scandal on the Buzwagi mining contract.

``It was because of the on-going allegations on Buzwagi Mine, which is located in my constituency, that the committee was formed. I therefore wonder what has caused a delay in the presentation of the review team`s findings. The people are eager to know the recommendations,`` he said.

Lembeli said further delays could raise suspicion that the team`s report could be tampered with in the meantime. ``Let the document be presented to the President so that people`s faith in their government is preserved,`` the MP said.

Geita legislator-CCM, Ernest Mabina said MPs were eagerly waiting for the mining review team`s report so that they would discuss it. He said any delay in submitting the findings did not do justice to the wananchi.

`However, I understand that the terms of reference given to the committee covered a lot of areas, yet the time span for presenting the report had elapsed, there is a need to make the presidential probe team`s findings public,`` he said.

The MP called upon members of the public to remain patient until the time when the report would be presented.

On his part, Karatu Chadema MP Dr Wilbrod Slaa said lack of seriousness on national resources by the government was the main reason for its delay in making the report public.

Dr Slaa said the committee was supposed to submit its report in February this year although it is now May and nothing had been submitted yet. ``The government is not serious with its natural resources,`` Dr. Slaa said.

The opposition MP said the report should be made public for every Tanzanian to weigh whether they were getting a fair share from the mining industry or not.

The committee was made up of Judge Bomani, Kigoma North MP Zitto Kabwe, (Chadema), Kyela MP Dr Harrison Mwakyembe (CCM), Ezekiel Maige (Msalala, CCM), John Cheyo (Bariadi East, UDP) and Peter Machunde of the Dar es Salaam Stock Exchange.

Others were David Tarimo, a tax consultant with PricewaterhouseCoopers, Maria Kejo, director of civil and international law in the Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Affairs, Salome Makange, chief legal officer at the Ministry of Energy and Minerals, Mugisha Kamugisha, commissioner for policy in the Ministry of Finance and Edward Kihundwa, assistant director for human settlements in the Ministry of Lands, Housing and Human Settlements.

SOURCE: Guardian

Tumemaliza kazi na tunasubiri tarehe kutoka ikulu. Hakuna ukweli zaidi ya huo.
 

Mtanganyika

JF-Expert Member
Jul 18, 2007
1,606
1,500
Tumemaliza kazi na tunasubiri tarehe kutoka ikulu. Hakuna ukweli zaidi ya huo.

Zitto habari ikija public naomba uje hapa JF utuambie nini ulikuwa ugumu wa study yenu. Maana najua mtakuwa mengubwa na mataizo mengi sana kwenye analyisis zenu.
 

Jamco_Za

JF-Expert Member
Jul 14, 2007
1,330
1,225
Zitto habari ikija public naomba uje hapa JF utuambie nini ulikuwa ugumu wa study yenu. Maana najua mtakuwa mengubwa na mataizo mengi sana kwenye analyisis zenu.

Ikulu hawatawapa tarehe ya karibu kwani hali ya kisiasa sasa hivi ni mbaya sana, halafu na nyinyi mumwage hiyo report ambayo obvious itatolewa public itakuwa ni kuitwisha mzingo mkubwa serikali isijue sehemu ya kuanzia kutatua matatizo yaliyopo.
 

Kubwajinga

JF-Expert Member
Jan 23, 2008
2,190
1,500
Kuna lipi kubwa wasilotaka likawekwa wazi? Hivi wanafikiri itakuwa siri mpaka lini wakati tayari wahusika wako tayari kuongea?




________________________
 

Mwiba

JF-Expert Member
Oct 23, 2007
7,611
1,250
Kuna lipi kubwa wasilotaka likawekwa wazi? Hivi wanafikiri itakuwa siri mpaka lini wakati tayari wahusika wako tayari kuongea?
Naona itatoka hapa mwanzo kabla ya kufikishwa kwa Raisi ,kuna msemo usemao chelewa chelewa utakuta mtoto si wako ,sasa sijui wanachelewa kutia mimba au kutoa mimba kwani miezi miwili imepita ,maana ya msemo ni ipi .
 

mapambano

JF-Expert Member
Mar 14, 2008
535
0
HIZI COMMITTEE NI ULAJI.....nani asiyujua ukishachaguliwa kwenye commitee mambo yako sio mabaya. Unajua ni kiasi gani hii commitee imetumia mpaka sasa? Huwezi kumfanya mwanasheria kuwa daktari wa magonjwa ya moyo. Kila jambo lina ujuzi wake.
 

Mtanganyika

JF-Expert Member
Jul 18, 2007
1,606
1,500
Jamani huwezi kuileta report kwenye public kabla haijafika kwa muheshimiwa. sio chain of command hiyo.
Kazi kweli ipo
 

Nemesis

JF-Expert Member
Feb 13, 2008
5,013
2,000
Tumemaliza kazi na tunasubiri tarehe kutoka ikulu. Hakuna ukweli zaidi ya huo.

Serikali inaandaa bajeti sasa, ripoti ikiwasilishwa kipindi hiki watashindwa kujibu swali la kwanini mapendekezo ya Kamati ya Bomani hayapo kwenye bajeti? ndiyo sababu ya chelewa chelewa hii.
 

Kuhani

JF-Expert Member
Apr 2, 2008
2,944
1,195
Jamani huwezi kuileta report kwenye public kabla haijafika kwa muheshimiwa. sio chain of command hiyo. Kazi kweli ipo

Kazi ipo enh? Tutaifanya basi. Ngoja nianze na weye!

Baba: Athumani kaniletee Wallet yangu nimpe Mama hela ya mboga.

Mama: Athumani, si ulitumwa Wallet kitambo, nasubiri hela mimi.

Athumani: Walet nimeshaileta, nasubiri huyu Baba aniruhusu nimpe Wallet aliyo nituma!

Kuna complications za Chain of Command hapo au ni smokescreen ya Baba na Athumani kumyeyusha Mama tu? Umetumwa, umekamilisha, kabidhi, tukabidhiwe. Msilete chicanery za chekechea jamani. Tafadhali Kikwete, Bomani na wewe Mtanganyika msiwafanye Watanzania wajinga. Yani mnatufanya watoto wa chekechea kabisa kabisa?

Hatusemi Bomani ndio ailete hiyo ripoti hadharani. Kikwete ndio tunamuuliza hiyo ripoti, na Bomani kwa sababu alitumwa tunamuuliza inakuwaje ukitumwa yabidi usubiri ruhusu kukabidhi ulicho tumwa.

 

Kleptomaniacs

Member
Apr 23, 2008
86
0
Yaleyale, wanaidokta ama inakuwaje, halafu kuna fununu kwamba wale wazungu wa Buhemba wametuachia mashimo yetu na kuondoka kimyakimya usiku!hizi data zina ukweli? ebu mwenye taarifa atumwagie hapa ukumbini basi!
 

Mwanagenzi

JF-Expert Member
Sep 11, 2006
690
1,250
Kimsingi JK anayo hiyo ripoti na anaipitia kusudi ajue cha kusema mara atakapokabidhiwa rasmi. Habari zilizopo ni kwamba baraza la mawaziri litakutana hivi "karibuni" kujadili baadhi ya masuala yaliyomo humo, na huenda baadhi ya mapendekezo yakaingizwa kwenye bajeti inayoandaliwa sasa. Bila shaka kwenye hotuba ya mwisho wa mwezi rais ataizungumzia na kutoa tamko la serikali mintarafu ya ripoti hii.
 

Mr EWA

JF-Expert Member
Mar 15, 2007
332
225
Nafikiri kwasababu hawajapata muda wa kukaa ofisin,si waombe wapelekewe hiyo report mahali popote waliko kwa sasa.
 

Katibu Tarafa

JF-Expert Member
Feb 16, 2007
976
1,225
Nafikiri kwasababu hawajapata muda wa kukaa ofisin,si waombe wapelekewe hiyo report mahali popote waliko kwa sasa.

mbona buzwagi ilisahiniwa hotelini,kwa nini wasinge mfuata raisi alipokuwa mikoani kwenye ziara.lakini sasa nasikia yupo ndani ya jiji
 

Mwafrika wa Kike

JF-Expert Member
Jul 5, 2007
5,192
0

Kazi ipo enh? Tutaifanya basi. Ngoja nianze na weye!

Baba: Athumani kaniletee Wallet yangu nimpe Mama hela ya mboga.

Mama: Athumani, si ulitumwa Wallet kitambo, nasubiri hela mimi.

Athumani: Walet nimeshaileta, nasubiri huyu Baba aniruhusu nimpe Wallet aliyo nituma!

Kuna complications za Chain of Command hapo au ni smokescreen ya Baba na Athumani kumyeyusha Mama tu? Umetumwa, umekamilisha, kabidhi, tukabidhiwe. Msilete chicanery za chekechea jamani. Tafadhali Kikwete, Bomani na wewe Mtanganyika msiwafanye Watanzania wajinga. Yani mnatufanya watoto wa chekechea kabisa kabisa?

Hatusemi Bomani ndio ailete hiyo ripoti hadharani. Kikwete ndio tunamuuliza hiyo ripoti, na Bomani kwa sababu alitumwa tunamuuliza inakuwaje ukitumwa yabidi usubiri ruhusu kukabidhi ulicho tumwa.


Hii imetulia mkulu!
 

BAK

JF-Expert Member
Feb 11, 2007
114,246
2,000
Tumemaliza kazi na tunasubiri tarehe kutoka ikulu. Hakuna ukweli zaidi ya huo.

Inaonyesha ni jinsi gani ambavyo JK amekuwa hana vipaumbele vyenye maslahi ya Taifa. Kwenye issue ya mafisadi amepwaya mno kiasi ambacho Watanzania tunaona nchi imetekwa nyara na mafisadi, kwenye issue ya mikataba isiyo na maslahi ya dhahabu yetu pia pamoja na kuunda tume ambayo ilimaliza kazi yake miezi miwili iliyopita, Msanii JK bado haoni umuhimu wa kutafuta muda ili akabidhiwe ripoti hiyo na hatimaye aiweke ofisini ili ipigwe na vumbi, maana kishaonyesha ana uwezo finyu kwenye issue zenye maslahi ya Taifa ndiyo maana anaikwepa ripoti hiyo kwa kuwa anajua hataifanyia kazi. Tuna Rais mbabaishaji!
 

Keil

JF-Expert Member
Jul 2, 2007
2,214
1,195
Kwa kifupi ni kwamba report ilishafika kwa Mheshimiwa JK na alishaisoma tayari. Ambacho hakijafanyika ni ile kuipeleka rasmi ili akina Mh. Zitto na wengineo walioshiriki waweze kupiga picha ya pamoja na kutangazwa rasmi kwamba report sasa imefika Ikulu.

Nimesoma ThisDay ya leo walikuwa wanadai kwamba Baraza la Mawaziri litakutana soon kujadili recommendations za kamati ya Mzee Bomani. Inakuwaje wapange kikao cha Baraza la Mawaziri kujadili mapendekezo ya kamati ya Bomani kabla report haijapelekwa Ikulu? Suppose kama kamati ya Bomani haijatoa mapendekezo yoyote? Na kama Kamati imetoa mapendekezo ambayo utekelezaji wake hauhitaji ridhaa ya Baraza la Mawaziri bali ni maamuzi ya JK peke yake?

Nadhani ukweli ni kwamba officially report haijafika Ikulu lakini kwa kupitia mlango wa pembeni tayari JK anayo report na si ajabu alishaanza kuifanyia kazi na ndiyo maana kuna hizo tetesi za kwamba kutakuwa na mabadiliko makubwa kwenye sekta ya madini katika mwaka ujao wa fedha.
 

Toa taarifa ya maudhui yasiyofaa!

Kuna taarifa umeiona humu JamiiForums na haifai kubaki mtandaoni?
Fanya hivi...

Umesahau Password au akaunti yako?

Unapata ugumu kuikumbuka akaunti yako? Unakwama kuanzisha akaunti?
Contact us

Top Bottom