Siasa za Nigeria zishaanza kuingia bongo, unahonga wanafunzi wachache wa vyuo vikuu wenye njaa, wanaanza maandamano na vurugu kukuunga mkono. Mwanafunzi wa chuo kikuu anayeunga mkono sera za Kikwete hata elimu yake ya chuo kikuu naitilia mashaka.
TheDoctor,
The fact that Dr. Kitine is tainted by corruption surely diminish his moral standing, but as I pointed out on another post here, replying to a similar argument leveled at Mr. Mateo Qaresi, the fact that these people have issues does not remove the fact that they can still say the truth regardless of their records.
We should concentrate on what is said, is what Dr. Kitine said the truth or not? Once you start engaging in ad hominem attacks (focusing on the person instead of the argument) you will be reduced to no discussion, after all, who among us doesn't fall short in one aspect or another?
Ad Hominem attack
1. Person 1 makes claim A.
2. Person 2 makes an attack on person 1.
3. Therefore 1's claim is false.
Illogical !
I have been guilty of this myself. The pretence that reputation alone can qualify or disqualify a comment is fallacious.Let's stick to the issues, and forget th personalities.
I have said again and again here, one of Africa's largest problems (the whole developing world really) is the fact that we Africans cannot operate on policy, we tend to revolve around personalities and strongmen. This is why you still have people up to today crying for Nyerere while Nyerere left a body of works that can formulate guiding principles for his thinking, but people do not want to understand his philosophy of life, they want to resurrect him and let him lead.
This same focus on personalities -not facts and policies- will blind us into dismissing the Qaresis and Kitines of this world just because they beat their wives and use public funds improperly to take them to Canada for hospitalization.
We should use even mafisadi to end ufisadi, we should not be reduced to the ongoing CCM factions shenanigans, we should float above them pursuing big ideas.