Cost comparison SGR Kenya vs SGR Tanzania

Geza Ulole

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
Messages
19,848
Points
2,000

Geza Ulole

JF-Expert Member
Joined Oct 31, 2009
19,848 2,000
Tanzania secures $7.6 billion financing deal from Chinese lender to build new railway

President John Magufuli with China Exim Bank president Liu Liang after holding talks at Chamwino State Lodge in Dodoma this week. PHOTO | COURTESY

In Summary

  • Dar es Salaam is positioning itself as a regional hub, upgrading its port to attract more business from its neighbouring landlocked countries.
  • The EAC railways master plan incorporates the standard gauge railway’s Northern and Central Corridors, which are both commercially viable for landlocked countries in the region as they give them strategic access to the ports of Mombasa and Dar es Salaam.
  • The Northern Corridor Integration Projects championed by Rwanda, Kenya and Uganda spearheaded the establishment of a railway link from Mombasa to Kigali.
  • In June 2013, a Northern Corridor Integration Projects Heads of State Summit held in Kampala put in place mechanisms for fast-tracking the development of the SGR.


Tanzania has secured a $7.6 billion loan from China’s Export-Import Bank (Exim) for the construction of a railway line that will link it with Burundi, Rwanda and Democratic Republic of Congo.

President John Magufuli secured the concessional loan after meeting with the Exim Bank’s president Liu Liang.

President Magufuli, while announcing the funding, alluded to a preferential deal without providing details.

Oil and gas discoveries have turned Tanzania into an exploration hotspot, but the country’s transport infrastructure has suffered from decades of under investment. The country is also positioning itself as a regional hub, upgrading its port to attract more business from its regional landlocked neighbours.

According to Mr Liu, China Exim Bank will offer Tanzania technical support.

READ: China Exim sets terms for financing Uganda’s SGR

ALSO READ: Rwanda looks to Tanzania for rail transport as Uganda falters on SGR

Last year, Tanzania announced that it had awarded rail contracts to a consortium of Chinese firms led by China Railway Materials (CRM), which included the standard gauge rail project.

The Exim Bank is also financing a $1.2 billion, 532km natural gas pipeline in Tanzania.

On Wednesday last week, Finance and Planning Minister Dr Philip Mpango after a meeting with Dr Alberic Kacou, African Development Bank vice-president for human resources and corporate services, announced that Tanzania had secured a further $200 million loan from the AfDB to finance transport infrastructure projects.

“We will use some of this funds towards the construction of the SGR project to transform the country’s infrastructure,” Dr Mpango said.

In an interview with Bloomberg, Gerson Msigwa, a spokesman for Tanzania’s presidency, said the construction will start by July next year. Before then, Tanzania and Exim Bank China will be expected to have finalise technical issues on the contract and sign the financing deal for the 2,190km project.

Tanzania Transport Minister Samuel Sitta said the SGR will have a main line that will connect the port city of Dar es Salaam to Rwanda and Burundi, with additional branch lines running within the country.

“We expect to have two offshoots: One of them to Mwanza, which will open up the lakeside port city and link it with Uganda, while the second one will link to the coal, iron ore and soda ash mining areas in the south. Through this, we expect an increase in cargo on this route,” Mr Sitta said, adding that will be at an additional cost of $6.6 billion.

Already, Tanzania has signed contracts with China Railway No 2 Engineering Group to build a rail link between the southern port of Mtwara, which is rich in coal, iron ore and natural gas. The contract will see China Railway No 2 Engineering Group provide 10 per cent of the funding with the rest provided by the government.

Kenya is also constructing a $3.27 billion 609km new standard gauge railway line between Mombasa and Nairobi to boost the movement of cargo from the port.

However, queries have been raised over the economic viability of SGR, after key landlocked states indicated their intention to connect to the Indian Ocean through Tanzania.


The issue of cost is also bound to arise now that Tanzania’s SGR is four times longer than Kenya’s but only two times as expensive.

In a previous interview with The EastAfrican, Kenya Railways managing director Atanas Maina said that the cost of the Kenyan SGR was high because of the design adopted, which will see the train maintain an average speed of 80 kilometres irrespective of the terrain.

“We have built bridges, and raised the track in areas where we would have had corners to achieve the average speed we expect the wagons to travel at. This has increased the costs immensely as compared with the neighbouring Ethiopia and Tanzania SGER designs that haven’t taken this into account,” Mr Maina said.

Recently, a confidential World Bank report cast doubt on the region’s push for the SGR projects, saying they would only be viable with increases in cargo of between 20 tonnes and 55 million tonnes per year.

The report done by the Africa transport unit at the World Bank titled The Economics of Rail Gauge in the East Africa Community showed that the volumes of the forecasts undertaken for the EAC railway master plan and central line in Tanzania, are unattainable over the medium to longer term.

“Based on these assumptions, there is no economic or financial case for standard gauge in the EAC area at this time. A refurbished meter gauge network would appear to be the most appropriate option in economic and financial terms, and could easily accommodate forecast traffic up to 2030, with lower investment requirements,” the report concludes.

The World Bank team highlighted the rehabilitation of the existing railway network as the best alternative, which would allow a phased approach to the regions development, consistent with current and projected demand and the financing envelope available.

The SGR alternative, which the regional governments chose, involves the construction of a standard gauge railway on a new right of way, an option the World Bank team said required additional investment in land acquisition and structures, and new right-of-way construction.

“This alternative predicates axle loads in the order of 25 tons per axles and a maximum operating speed of up to 120 km per hour. Again, based on these assumptions, the estimated maximum carrying capacity of the current network would exceed 60 million tonnes per year. The estimated investment cost per km will be $ 3.25 million,” the report said.

From the estimates provided, the Tanzanian new railway line will cost an average of $3.4 million per kilometre.

MY TAKE

It is time now to look at the cost of the two rails as we know cost of construction is very important for prospect of any infrastructure! i welcome bright minds to contribute and not some propaganda in here!


nomasana, sam999, NairobiWalker, hbuyosh, msemakweli, simplemind, Kimweri, Bulldog, MK254, Kafrican, Ngongo, Ab_Titchaz, mtanganyika mpya, JokaKuu, Ngongo, Askari Kanzu, Dhuks, Yule-Msee, waltham, Mzee, mombasite gabriel, Juakali1980, Boda254, mwaswast, MwendaOmo, Iconoclastes, oneflash, Kambalanick, 1 Africa, saadeque, burukenge, nyangau mkenya, Teen-Upperhill Nairobi, kadoda11
 

ndughuri msuya

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Feb 29, 2012
Messages
793
Points
1,000

ndughuri msuya

JF-Expert Member
Joined Feb 29, 2012
793 1,000
H
In 5years hio mabati shed itakua inakaa rusted kama slums za Mbagala.. hehe. Kumbe difference is price is obvious just by looking at quality of infrastructure. Local mabati sheds vs world class modern stations.
Hiyo sub station isikutie hofu ,wasi wasi wangu Je hiyo treni yenyu a.k.a mtambo wa gongo baada ya miaka mitano itakuwaje?
 

Kosugi

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2019
Messages
1,839
Points
2,000

Kosugi

JF-Expert Member
Joined Sep 2, 2019
1,839 2,000
In 5years hio mabati shed itakua inakaa rusted kama slums za Mbagala.. hehe. Kumbe difference is price is obvious just by looking at quality of infrastructure. Local mabati sheds vs world class modern stations.
Hayo mabati yanaweza badilishwa kijana.
Ishu ninyi migarimoshi yenu.
 

Kosugi

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2019
Messages
1,839
Points
2,000

Kosugi

JF-Expert Member
Joined Sep 2, 2019
1,839 2,000
Unajua kuna vitu ambavyo ni rahisi kuvirekebisha.
Asa hayo mabati???
Ninyi magari moshi yenu ndio itachukua gharama kubadilisha ila sisi mabati ni gharama ndogo sana.
Sijui umenielewa???
Hence what we've been saying all along, cheap now but expensive in the long run
 

Kanya

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2019
Messages
204
Points
250

Kanya

JF-Expert Member
Joined Feb 21, 2019
204 250
Unajua kuna vitu ambavyo ni rahisi kuvirekebisha.
Asa hayo mabati???
Ninyi magari moshi yenu ndio itachukua gharama kubadilisha ila sisi mabati ni gharama ndogo sana.
Sijui umenielewa???
Ata nyinyi with time mtabadilisha hayo ma "bullet train" plus I think ni cheaper kubadilisha a diesel engine kuliko EMUs.
Mnaweka mabati ili mbadishe mara kwa mara? Why not build NOW for the long term to avoid such unnecessary repairs..cheap is expensive
 

kirk git

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2018
Messages
558
Points
1,000

kirk git

JF-Expert Member
Joined Jan 24, 2018
558 1,000
Ata nyinyi with time mtabadilisha hayo ma "bullet train" plus I think ni cheaper kubadilisha a diesel engine kuliko EMUs.
Mnaweka mabati ili mbadishe mara kwa mara? Why not build NOW for the long term to avoid such unnecessary repairs..cheap is expensive
Ile electrification ya kenya sgr ilifika wapi. It was to begin immediately according to masharia!
 

kilam

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
1,786
Points
2,000

kilam

JF-Expert Member
Joined Aug 5, 2011
1,786 2,000
Ata nyinyi with time mtabadilisha hayo ma "bullet train" plus I think ni cheaper kubadilisha a diesel engine kuliko EMUs.
Mnaweka mabati ili mbadishe mara kwa mara? Why not build NOW for the long term to avoid such unnecessary repairs..cheap is expensive
Ndoto zenu za alinacha ziliisha wapi?

 

Geza Ulole

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
Messages
19,848
Points
2,000

Geza Ulole

JF-Expert Member
Joined Oct 31, 2009
19,848 2,000
Unajua kuna vitu ambavyo ni rahisi kuvirekebisha.
Asa hayo mabati???
Ninyi magari moshi yenu ndio itachukua gharama kubadilisha ila sisi mabati ni gharama ndogo sana.
Sijui umenielewa???
Yaani hawa jamaa ni Washamba na malimbukeni sasa, why do we have to put a concrete jungle as a roof for a train platform? SGR in Nairobi interferes with traffic as it crosses roads having no viaduct in the city! Why the he'll should anybody with senses put a concrete roof on a platform n let the SGR criss-crosses roads?
 

Kanya

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2019
Messages
204
Points
250

Kanya

JF-Expert Member
Joined Feb 21, 2019
204 250
Ndoto zenu za alinacha ziliisha wapi?
we plan to upgrade, that's not in question. What we don't have for now is fully RELIABLE, DEPENDABLE, GUARANTEED electric power supply to support the smooth running of the railway.
 

Kanya

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2019
Messages
204
Points
250

Kanya

JF-Expert Member
Joined Feb 21, 2019
204 250
Yaani hawa jamaa ni Washamba na malimbukeni sasa, why do we have to put a concrete jungle as a roof for a train platform? SGR in Nairobi interferes with traffic as it crosses roads having no viaduct in the city! Why the he'll should anybody with senses put a concrete roof on a platform n let the SGR criss-crosses roads?
concrete roofs are durable and low maintenance, only needs painting.Mabati needs periodic replacement..
Hebu tuoneshe ni wapi kwa sgr Kenya kuna level crossing kutoka marshalling yard Mombasa to naivasha.The only place I know kuna level crossing in hapo kwa first mile(port mpaka kwa yard)na hakunanga traffic..
 

Geza Ulole

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
Messages
19,848
Points
2,000

Geza Ulole

JF-Expert Member
Joined Oct 31, 2009
19,848 2,000
concrete roofs are durable and low maintenance, only needs painting.Mabati needs periodic replacement..
Hebu tuoneshe ni wapi kwa sgr Kenya kuna level crossing kutoka marshalling yard Mombasa to naivasha.The only place I know kuna level crossing in hapo kwa first mile(port mpaka kwa yard)na hakunanga traffic..
U don't put up a concrete roof where no floor or heavy load comes on top! Wacha ujinga! Ulaya nzima hawaweki concrete roof on platforms! As a matter of fact not safe incase of an explosion! BTW not all stations in Kenya r concrete roofs!
 

Forum statistics

Threads 1,344,041
Members 515,307
Posts 32,805,699
Top