Rwanda: Economic sanctions from Western Donors

Rwanda: Economic sanctions from Western Donors

What can TZ really do? ... The US temporarily blocks the UNSC from releasing the Experts' group report to save face... Imposes some paltry USD 200K Military aid restriction to Kagame with a lot of media fanfare... JK afanye nini?..

Ukisoma au kuangalia documentary iitwayo Darwin's nightmare utaona kua insecurity in the Great Lakes Region of Africa inasababishwa na availability of small weapons toka Russia, na Mwanza ndio imekua entry port ya silaha hizo (zinakuja na ndege zenye kupeleka samaki aina ya Nile perch). The DRC, Rwanda, and Burundi can only absorb so much weapon before they start overflowing into Kenya and Tanzania. Ukiona mwenzio ananyolewa ... Soma hapa: https://www.jamiiforums.com/habari-...ilishwa-kwa-gunia-la-mahindi.html#post4287872
What the Government should do, as an emergency, ni kuziba tundu hilo linalo ingiza silaha, na kuongeza control over refugees and shephereds from Rwanda and Burundi. wengi wao wanaingia kupitia njia za panya na sometimes wanakuja na silaha.
 
The rebels want to cut the Kivu region (South Kivu, North Kivu and Maniema provinces) and make it into a republic. the region is mineral rich and the idea will be to reward their allies (in this case Rwanda) with mining contracts. In this case the US ans UK will have a share too because the mining companies are likely to be UK and/or US based.
Hii 200,000 ni less than 0,1% of the total UK and US aid to Rwanda (USD 350 M in total). this money is believed to be the driving engine of the entire balkanisation machine.

Correct. That has been planned: Now it's a matter of implentation. The similar plan might have been used for the break up of Sudan. What if the future wars will be fought for water and land, you can guess who is next.
 
The rebels want to cut the Kivu region (South Kivu, North Kivu and Maniema provinces) and make it into a republic. the region is mineral rich and the idea will be to reward their allies (in this case Rwanda) with mining contracts. In this case the US ans UK will have a share too because the mining companies are likely to be UK and/or US based.
Hii 200,000 ni less than 0,1% of the total UK and US aid to Rwanda (USD 350 M in total). this money is believed to be the driving engine of the entire balkanisation machine.

Spot on her Majesty, this is precisely what've been telling the whole world to be warry of HIMA empire Architects - M7 , Kagame mixed grill gonna cost our Region an arm and LEG, the time to contain them is NOW not LATER.
 
Since Kagame came to power he has embarked on many expansionist campaigns in DRC. Along with Museveni, Kagame proves to be another nightmare in the region despite all chest beating that he has transformed Rwanda. Kagame and Museveni goofed believing that their marriage with the US will never come to an end. Saddam Hussein was once the darling of US, even Osama bin Laden was once.
It is sad that even bigger and powerful East African countries such as Tanzania have never reckoned with the danger Kagame poses. If anyone wants to help Rwanda is to make sure that this stinking dictator is deterred by all means possible. We need to see DRC breathing the air of relief and peace after being ruined by maddog Mobutu Seseseko.

I warned my country ages ago, tell you what? -no soul took me seriously!
 
The UK and the Netherlands have joined the US in withholding aid to Rwanda over its alleged backing of rebels in Democratic Republic of Congo. The UK government said it was delaying £16m ($25m) in budget support due this month while it considered whether aid conditions had been met.


Rwanda again rejected allegations in a UN report that it was supporting the M23 movement rebels in DR Congo.
Foreign Minister Louise Mushikiwabo told the BBC it was "one sided". The rebels mutinied from the Congolese army in April and some 200,000 people have fled their homes as a result of fighting.



News of the further aid suspensions came as a senior UN official told the BBC that defecting Congolese rebels have confirmed that they were recruited in Rwanda. On Thursday, the UN reported that its forces helped the Congolese army push the rebels out of two towns north of Goma using helicopter gunships and armoured vehicle.


Eastern DR Congo has been plagued by fighting since 1994, when more than a million ethnic Hutus crossed the border into DR Congo following the Rwandan genocide, in which some 800,000 people - mostly Tutsis - died. Rwanda has twice invaded its much larger neighbour, saying it was trying to take action against Hutu rebels based in DR Congo. Uganda also sent troops into DR Congo during the 1997-2003 conflict.


The brief UK announcement emerged after the Dutch foreign ministry confirmed it would no longer be making payments worth $6.15m (£3.9m) to Rwanda's aid budget until it had received reassurances from Kigali. The Dutch money was being used to improve the country's judicial system - Dutch support for non-governmental organisations will continue. The BBC's Anna Holligan in The Hague says the Dutch government is still awaiting a response from Rwanda and is in the process of talking to other European government about possible further action.


The UK government said its general budget support payment was being delayed while the government reviewed whether the expectations associated with the strict partnership principles surrounding the disbursement of aid are being met.
Total UK aid to Rwanda in the year 2012-13 is projected to be about $118m.

Mrs Mushikiwabo (Rwandan Foreign affair minister) said any decision to suspend aid based on the UN report was "taken on evidence that does not exist" as she had explained to UN experts visiting Rwanda this week.

"More importantly I think it's a wake-up call for Rwanda and other aid recipient countries to actually start fending for ourselves and figure out a way to sustain our development without being subjected to bullying and pressure from donors," she told the BBC's Focus on Africa programme.


The Congolese rebels who took up arms in April named themselves M23 after a failed peace agreement signed with DR Congo's government on 23 March three years ago.The rebellion is led by renegade general Bosco Ntaganda, who is wanted by the International Criminal Court for alleged war crimes. He belongs to the Tutsi ethnic group like the top leadership in Rwanda, which fears the presence of rival Hutu militias in eastern DR Congo.



Speaking off the record, a senior UN peacekeeping official told the BBC about the debriefing of 30 former members of the M23 movement. The defectors said they had been recruited in Rwanda, but were then sent into DR Congo to find themselves fighting with the M23. The UN official said this chimed with the UN's own observations of some rebels who are unlike the other Congolese troops who mutinied. They are armed with weapons not used by the Congolese army, speak English - unlike most Congolese - have unusual uniforms and undertake night attacks - something the Congolese army does not do, the official said. The UN says the M23 has grown in recent weeks - another sign that they are being reinforced.


Following the US cut of $200,000 in military aid, Stephen Rapp, head of the US Office of Global Criminal Justice warned on Wednesday that Rwanda's leadership, including Mr Kagame, could possibly face prosecution at the ICC over the current unrest. "There is a line that one can cross under international law where you can be held responsible for aiding a group in a way that makes possible their commission of atrocities," the US ambassador for war crimes told the UK Guardian newspaper. "I think you would have a situation where individuals who were aiding them from across the border could be held criminally responsible."


Mr Kagame has dismissed the article as irresponsible. He commented on his Twitter account that it was "laughable" and displayed "gross ignorance".
 
Economic sanction/Aid that has been officially withdrawn after the report:
- US$ 200,000 from the US (out of some 150Millions of the 2012 budget)
- US$ 6,1 Million from the Netherland (total amount for the 2012 budget)
- US$ 25 Million from the UK (out of some 118M expected for the 2012 budget)
- US$ 26 Million from Germany (for theperiod between 2012-2015)
- US$ 39 Million from the Scandinavian Board of the African Development Bank (2012 budget)

Legal sanction
:
- Threat from the US government officials to send top Rwandan official including President Kagame to the ICC
 
"It's a wake-up call for Rwanda and other aid recipient countries to figure out a way to sustain our development without being subjected to bullying and pressure from donors"
Louise Mushikiwabo Rwandan foreign minister to BBC (27th july 2012)

"This child-to-parent relationship has to end ... there has to be a minimum respect," Foreign Minister Louise Mushikiwabo said in an address to a Kenyan business club called Mindspeak.


"As long as countries wave cheque books over our heads, we can never be equal."

She added that Africans had to work hard to develop their economies in order to stop relying on Western donors.
 
"This is laughable and displays gross ignorance"
President Kagame on his Twitter on the 27th of July 2012
 
"This is laughable and displays gross ignorance"
President Kagame on his Twitter on the 27th of July 2012

What is he saying about the reasons upon which this decision was based?...:spy:
 
Kagame asipoangalia ataishia the hague..mtu hatari sana yule
 
Nimesoma kutoka BBCSWAHILI kuwa serikali ya Udachi imeamua kusitisha misaada ya ke ya kifedha kwa serikali ya Kagame kwa kuwa imekuwa ikifadhiri vita ndani ya DRC.

Maoni: kagame ajiandae kwa yaliyompata Taylor, naona machozi na machungu ya wanyarwanda wanaoteswa na Kagame yamemfikia Mungu, sasa ni bora kagame angejiondoa madarakani mapema kabla ya anguko la aibu.
 
What is he saying about the reasons upon which this decision was based?...:spy:

He says there is no evidence to backup the report and that the UN experts are against him, they are not happy to see an African country emerging so fast and his Minister says this is an opportunity for them to move to other sources of funding. In short: It wasn't me, and if you want to keep your money, keep it, we can make our own.

Ila sasa out of shame from the role they might have played in the Congo war all these years, US and UK (who transfer a total of 350M per anum to Rwanda) have requested for a counter UN expertise to confirm Rwandan involvement in the M23. This is the first time a UN report is questioned to such an extent. The new team is currently investigating.

On the ground the situation is worse. this report actually came few days before the violent conflict that has made 25,000 internally displaced people. the M23 troops are progressing and there is more evidence of Rwandan logistical and military support, including Rwandan soldiers.

Maybe what they are fighting for outpasses the 350M per anum they were getting?
 

[TD="class: articleTitle"]Germany latest to suspend Rwanda aid [/TD]

[TD="class: Tmp_hSpace10"]
[/TD]

[TD="class: DetailedSummary"] Rwanda is coming under increasing pressure to halt its alleged support for the rebellion in eastern DR Congo, with Germany becoming the latest donor to suspend planned aid.
Germany's development ministry said on Saturday it suspended $26m in contributions to Rwanda's budget planned from this year through 2015. Britain and the Netherlands already have suspended support and the US cut planned military aid of $200,000. A report by UN experts last month accused Rwanda of helping create, arm and support the M23 rebel movement in violation of UN sanctions. Rwanda denies the charges.
Dirk Niebel, the German development minister, said he expects "unreserved co-operation" by Rwanda with the UN experts. "The accusations must be cleared up completely, and it must be clear that Rwanda does not support any illegal militias in eastern Congo," he said in a statement.
Louise Mushikiwabo, Rwanda's foreign minister, expressed regret on Friday at the "hasty decisions based on flimsy evidence". The Netherlands said it was suspending $6.1m promised to improve Rwanda's judicial sector while Britain, Rwanda's biggest donor, said it was delaying a budget support payment scheduled this month.
London's Financial Times newspaper quoted a Swedish aid official on Thursday saying Scandinavian countries on the board of the African Development Bank also forced the delay of a decision on the disbursal of $38.9m in budget aid to Rwanda from last week until September.

[/TD]
 
President Kabila Kabange:

The ultimate goal is to restore the peace and security that we need to develop that part of the country [refering to part of the Nort and South Kivu where the conflict is]. In order to reach that goal we have four possible options: Military actions, Political action and Diplomacy. the fourth option is a balanced combination of these three and this is the option that we believe will take as very soon to solving the situation. Military operations are currently ongoing, we have lost few battles in the biggining but we know we will win this war. Our diplomatic strategy is unfolding. We are hosting the Sommet Mondial de la Francophonie and this will be an opportunity to reinforce our diplomatic ties with our international allies. After all, the DRC is the largest Francophone country in the world.

He says nothing concerning Rwanda involvement in the conflict.

[PS: the translation is not formal, it is my summary of what he says]



Integral:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's Museveni who put Kagame in to power. They turned out to be our "Mubarak and Assad", the puppets of Anglo-American hegemony. Its 3am and they are feeling kinda lonely now, last call for alcohol and all the skinny girls ar taken, what's left?
 
Juy 28, 2012 | Reuters

Rwanda's foreign minister accused Western governments on Saturday of using aid to treat African states like children, after four countries cut or delayed aid to Kigali because of its policy in neighbouring Democratic Republic of Congo.

The United States last weekend cut military aid for this year while the Netherlands, Germany and Britain followed suit as donors reacted to a United Nations report that accuses Rwanda of backing rebels in the Congo.

The report, contested by Rwanda, said the country was supporting armed groups in neighbouring eastern Congo, including the M23 group, which has seized parts of North Kivu province in fighting that has displaced more than 270,000 people since April.

"This child-to-parent relationship has to end ... there has to be a minimum respect," Foreign Minister Louise Mushikiwabo said in an address to the Kenyan business club Mindspeak.

"As long as countries wave cheque books over our heads, we can never be equal."

She added that Africans had to work hard to develop their economies in order to stop relying on Western donors.

Rwanda, which has been working to rebuild its economy after more than 800,000 ethnic Tutsis and moderate Hutus were killed in a 1994 genocide, relies on donors to fund 50 percent of its annual budget, Mushikiwabo said.

Its ties with its much larger neighbour Congo had been thawing since 2009, following years of conflict in which Rwandan troops crossed the border in pursuit of remnants of the Hutu militias that carried out the genocide.

Mushikiwabo said it was too early to tell what kind of damage the withholding of aid would do to the government's economic development push.

"We have been in much worse situations than dollars being withheld from us," she said.

Germany's Development Minister Dirk Niebel said in a statement his ministry had warned Rwanda four weeks ago it would suspend aid payments due to indications of support for rebels.

"Rwanda did not use this time to rebut these serious allegations... suspending budget aid is a clear sign to the Rwandan government."

CONGO "MESS"
A Reuters reporter said on Saturday that heavily armed rebel forces had moved to Kibumba, around 30 km (20 miles) from the North Kivu capital of Goma, whilst drunk government forces had withdrawn their forces further south towards the city.

Yamina Benguigui, France's minister for relations with French-speaking countries who is in Congo, said Paris had requested a United Nations Security Council meeting for Monday to discuss the crisis.

"A declaration will be negotiated clearly condemning M23 and its support," she said.

Mushikiwabo accused the international community of using Rwanda as a scapegoat for the chaos in eastern Congo. "Do not draw Rwanda into this mess. It is not our business," she said.

The U.N. report said Kigali had supplied ammunition and communication equipment to the rebels, some of whom are Congolese of Rwandan descent. But Mushikiwabo said the type of ammunition alluded to in the report no longer existed in Rwanda, under regional small arms-reduction programmes.

The radio communications gear cited also was not being used by modern armies like Rwanda, proving they could not have supplied it to the Congolese rebels, she added.

Details of a neutral force to eliminate armed groups from eastern Congo, agreed on by the regional group of Great Lakes states that includes Rwanda and Congo, would be discussed by a meeting of the organisation's ministers of defence and security chiefs in Khartoum over the next three days, Mushikiwabo said.


Source: Reuters

(Additional reporting by Alexandra Hudson in Berlin; Jonny Hogg in Kinshasa; Editing by David Lewis and Michael Roddy)
 
In this case I blame much Rwanda for supporting consipirancies in Congo DRC unless is imperialistic maneuvres being engineered by big powers.
 
By Nicolas Revise (AFP) | July 29, 2012

Washington is loosening its ties to Rwandan President Paul Kagame, long a favorite of the donor community, amid allegations his government is stirring violence in neighboring DR Congo, analysts say.


Last week, in a statement slipped out without fanfare late Sunday, the United States said it was freezing its modest $200,000 in 2012 military aid to Rwanda -- a move experts say represents a major shift in long-held US policy.

"As we have repeatedly said to the government of Rwanda, we have deep concerns about Rwanda's support to the Congolese rebel group that goes by the name M23," State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland said.

The M23 are Tutsi ex-rebels from the Rwanda-backed National Congress for the Defense of the People (CNDP).

They were integrated into the regular army of the Democratic Republic of the Congo in 2009 as part of a peace deal that followed their failed 2008 offensive on the Congo's eastern city of Goma.

But the ex-rebels mutinied in April, demanding better pay and the full implementation of a March 23, 2009 peace deal, and have been engaged in running battles with the Congolese army in the eastern Nord Kivu region.

Kinshasa accuses Kigali of sponsoring the rebellion -- a complaint supported by a UN panel, which said in June that Rwanda was supplying the rebels with arms and soldiers.

Nuland said the United States also has its own evidence of Rwandan involvement in the upheavals, but believed the UN report was "quite comprehensive and quite concerning."

US State Department war crimes investigator Stephen Rapp even told the British daily The Guardian this week that Kagame could one day find himself charged with war crimes. The Netherlands also cut its military aid to Rwanda.

"It is really the first time we have heard strong words spoken against Paul Kagame in Rwanda by the US government. There is a real shift," said Richard Downie, expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

"This is a real change in tone. Rwanda will find itself in a unusual and uncomfortable position right now," he told AFP.

Since Kagame took up the reins of power of his African nation in 1994 ending a bloody genocide which left some 800,000, mainly Tutsis, dead, Rwanda "has been the darling of donors' community for so long," Downie said.

Former British prime minister Tony Blair is a special advisor to Kagame, and has been a steadfast supporter of Rwanda's development through his Africa Governance Initiative.

But the winds began to change in June with the publication of the United Nations report.

Even if the amount of aid was small "there are other signs of unhappiness by the United States," Downie said. "I am told that the head of the Africom postponed a visit to Rwanda and also some people are making some noise that Rwanda wants to get a seat on the UN Security Council."

John Campbell, from the Council on Foreign Relations, said: "The report the UN experts produced provided a clear evidence of Rwandan meddling in Eastern Congo. It is a careful and credible report.

"It has long been US policy to oppose outside intervention in Eastern Congo. In light of the UN report, the Obama administration had to respond."

Rwanda has categorically denied that it is interfering in the DR Congo, accusations which Kagame told CNN were "not true" and "actually ridiculous."

"You see, I hope people can just be fair. It's not even very complicated. I'm really surprised people called experts can make a report this way."

There have long been tensions between Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

Rwanda has been accused on several occasions of aiding Tutsi forces in DR Congo to combat Hutu rebels on its western border. It charges the Hutu rebels with joining the 1994 genocide and says they remain a threat to their country.

Kigali sent troops into the DR Congo from 1996-1997 and then between 1998 to 2002, before moving to act through proxy militias, experts say.

Nuland insisted: "We are continuing to watch this case very carefully and to send public and private messages to the government of Rwanda."

French journalist and expert on the region, Pierre Pean, told AFP the US decision could mark a major shift in regional policy.

It could "perhaps signal the beginning of the end for the soldier Kagame and his license to kill and pillage since 1994 as well as a revision of American policy in the Great Lakes region," he said.
 
Back
Top Bottom