False comparisons of African and Asian nations in the 60's | JamiiForums | The Home of Great Thinkers

Dismiss Notice
You are browsing this site as a guest. It takes 2 minutes to CREATE AN ACCOUNT and less than 1 minute to LOGIN

False comparisons of African and Asian nations in the 60's

Discussion in 'Habari na Hoja mchanganyiko' started by Jasusi, Aug 7, 2012.

  1. J

    Jasusi JF-Expert Member

    Aug 7, 2012
    Joined: May 5, 2006
    Messages: 11,484
    Likes Received: 165
    Trophy Points: 160
    False Comparisons and Why?
    By Marjorie Mbilinyi

    The speech is repeating a position that has been taken by our economists and policy makers many times, sometimes with reference to other countries such as South Korea or Vietnam. It is based on a false assumption, that the GDP is an adequate measure of development. It completely ignores the entirely different political economy/ies within each of the countries referred to; the high level of development of agriculture, manufacturing, and transportation that had been reached eg by India in 1700s-1800s-1900s long before British colonization – hence the British strategy of destroying Indian textile manufacturing in order to open up the Indian market for textile goods from UK.

    True, there was uneven development in each of these countries, including Tanganyika, before colonisation; complex systems of agriculture had emerged in many locations along with basic manufacturing. However, the main commodities that were exported for example in the Indian Ocean Trade Complex were slaves and ivory, and to a lesser extent basic grains to support city states along the coast and on Zanzibar and Pemba.

    We need to ask more questions of our GDP proponents.

    We need to ask questions. For example, what were the major sources of capital accumulation in each country in 1961? What was the structure and composition of trade: domestic trade and export trade? Specifically in the agriculture sector: What proportion of agriculture relied on ox plough cultivation in each of these four countries, including Tanzania, in 1961? Tractor cultivation? Irrigated agriculture? What kind of class formation had developed over time in agrarian society? The entire nation? What was the structure of employment and livelihoods for women and men in rural and urban areas; and what proportion were [self]employed, waged labour, or working as unpaid family labour in household production? Within the category of waged labour, what proportion were employed on a regular permanent basis? Part-time or temporary? Casual labour? …. By exploring these and other questions it will become rapidly clear that the economies of our countries were not similar at all.

    Next, we need to ask what purpose is served by making these false comparisons?

    [TD="align: center"] Reactions/Hisia: [/TD]
    Posted by Chambi Chachage at 5:49 PM
    Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to Facebook
  2. Nyani Ngabu

    Nyani Ngabu Platinum Member

    Aug 7, 2012
    Joined: May 15, 2006
    Messages: 73,656
    Likes Received: 35,418
    Trophy Points: 280
    I agree with her.