Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) alluded this statement ealier before so many others school of thoughts emerged. So He is right in particular context and wrong in another as well.You qouted Kant to support your view, he said the existence of God can be postulated through practical reason. He denied any rational account for the existence of Supreme Being. He went further to elaborate moral imperatives within himself and postulated the existence of God. Therefore, Kant suffers the same critic he offered to rationalists because he has his categories of mind which he said that our mind are fine tuned to understand reality in these categories. If that is the Kant's claim then how does he account for God, which category do we employ while thinking about God. If fact he was brilliant fellow that is why he used the word "postulate" because when you scrutinize his opinion it falls short. In fact even if there are moral laws within us (which I don't believe if we real have those laws) it does mean that we cannot explain some of moral imperative without postulating God's existence. I think, it is because Kant existed before Charles Darwin thats why he said so.
Additionally, if you hold firm that faith is subjective,then you are absolutely correct. In fact you agree with Freud completely that religion is illusion and erroneous to man
Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) alluded this statement ealier before so many others school of thoughts emerged. So He is right in particular context and wrong in another as well.
because with time,so many discoveries came into life. this is how science evolves. His contentions my fit some scenarios in the modern days but may still be grouped as a part of pseudo science.
If youve come across in other disciplined like NEar Death experience(NDE), there's so much to learn there.Which to me i think nullifies the idea of freud. whereby people who are dead come back into life and confirmed that there's is a life in the afterlife. And it has been proven that this is not a function of brain. So there's nothing like illusion there.
Near-Death Experiences and the Afterlife
God is Spiritual so it needs some type of media for us to be connected to him. But the question still comes where is the idea itself originated? i.e. You can not think of Unthinkable!!. freud must know this!! Why all people in the world talk about GOd?
.
Most people who encountered NDE, they said; that world is more real than this world. IS like we are in Fake body with little consciousness.
I think we are very much connected by out true spiritual nature i.e consciousness is independent from body and outlives it. Consciousness is another name of spirit. It appears that we are spiritual beings, having a physical experience. Our spiritual is eternal We may die here, but we may live forever in another world dimension, probably is where God lives.All humans are very much connected into each other consciousness, and may be that's why we all speak about GOD
People who meditate also talk about consciousness and how to get connected to our spiritual world. i hope that another world's dimension is where God lives. And all people of the world Find connected with each other.
may be is the reason all people of the world tend to seek for anything to worship, be it stones, idols, oceans,Rivers, trees, the dead, the sun, the moon, snakes, Animals, jesus, human, etc
They are many anomalies in your comment.
First you said that "Near Death Experience" what is this experience, the word is contrary to death. Near death doesn't mean anything indeed.Have you ever seen someone who died and came back to life.Perhaps that fellow fainted.
i call it spirit because from simple view spirit don't have bodies, when you destroy the body that energy(consciousness) which makes the body alive comes out instantly. That is real you. The term selfish offers ambiguity here. I my self don't want to live forever...cause what's the point..?, but if forever means forever then i want to be at peace, not stuff like hell fire etc.Anyway you talk about consciousness, What do you mean by consciousness? It seems for you consciousness=spirit, (I dont agree with you in this at all). Of course you went further to argue that spirit or consciousness is independent of the body. How consciousness(spirit) and Body work together.This is a deep question which you might not answer.
You talked about immorality, Once Feurbach a Germany Philosopher said that we think about life after death because of our egoistic tendecy. We do not want die but the reality we have to die. So when we face this hard reality our mind always project life after death because we wanna live longer because of our selfishness. Therefore,in order to console ourselves,we project immortality. I totally agree with Feubarch.
What if the bible is crafted by Satan himself to brainwash humankind, as a means to inhibit us from reaching our fullest potential and universial love for eachother. The Bible allows us to be endlessly hypocritical by using it's words against eachother.
Just think about how the poorest and most miserable nations on earth are the most religious ones, while the most prosperous countries are the least religious and most peaceful, happy and equal ones.
Religion is the ultimate deception.
Near Death Experience (NDE): Here is his description:A man is dying and, as he reaches the point of greatest physical distress, he hears himself pronounced dead by his doctor. He begins to hear an uncomfortable noise, a loud ringing or buzzing, and at the same time feels himself moving very rapidly through a long dark tunnel. After this, he suddenly finds himself outside of his own physical body, but still in the immediate physical environment, and he sees his own body from a distance, as though he is a spectator. He watches the resuscitation attempt from this unusual vantage point and is in a state of emotional upheaval.After a while, he collects himself and becomes more accustomed to his odd condition. He notices that he still has a 'body,' but one of a very different nature and with very different powers from the physical body he has left behind. Soon other things begin to happen. Others come to meet and to help him. He glimpses the spirits of relatives and friends who have already died, and a loving, warm spirit of a kind he has never encountered before -- a being of light -- appears before him. This being asks him a question, non-verbally, to make him evaluate his life and helps him along by showing him a panoramic, instantaneous playback of the major events of his life. At some point he finds himself approaching some sort of barrier or border, apparently representing the limit between earthly life and the next life. Yet, he finds that he must go back to the earth, that the time for his death has not yet come. At this point he resists, for by now he is taken up with his experiences in the afterlife and does not want to return. He is overwhelmed by intense feelings of joy, love, and peace. Despite his attitude, though, he somehow reunites with his physical body and lives.
Later he tries to tell others, but he has trouble doing so. In the first place, he can find no human words adequate to describe these unearthly episodes. He also finds that others scoff, so he stops telling other people. Still, the experience affects his life profoundly especially his views about death and its relationship to life.
Another thing is Out OF body Experience (OBE):
There is the tunnel traveled through as well as the experiences of seeing one's own body from outside and seeming to have some other kind of body, and the ineffability is familiar. One is tempted to conclude that in death a typical OBE, or astral projection, occurs, and is followed by a transition to another world, with the aid of people who have already made the crossing, and that of higher beings in whose plane one is going to lead the next phase of existence
i call it spirit because from simple view spirit don't have bodies, when you destroy the body that energy(consciousness) which makes the body alive comes out instantly. That is real you. The term selfish offers ambiguity here. I my self don't want to live forever...cause what's the point..?, but if forever means forever then i want to be at peace, not stuff like hell fire etc.
well don't get me wrong here...When i heard people talk about heaven it is where i see there is reason to live. otherwise not.This world sucks man
My experience shows that if you think too much about the almight God, you may under go crazy.
God is unquestionable!!!!!
A poor would fall for anything than a wealth contented person. A Religion inhibits people to pursue some of the goals which may lead believers to become rich. A Religion declares Does and Don'ts to believers, for that it controls their consciousnesses and take it to another level. it may even turns a Human into beast.They tell us abraham is our father, but am black unlike semites and europeans..............I believe Nimrod is our Father.
How do men believe in the unseen?
If god realy loves us why would he allow many religions that lead to massacres in his name?
who has ever seen satan and why is he regarded as evil?
Africa,middle east an some parts of south america have the most religious people,poor people and warring people hence can I say poverty and religion are brothers?
People Who Have NDEs are Convinced It Was the AfterlifeThe elaboration of Near Death Experience is delusion. I call it Fantasy and stark Non-Sense.
The explanation of consciousness seems unsatisfactory because It is important to clarify our terms before starting using them. Would tell me what is consciousness?how do we perceive it? I hold on to that because i think it's a mistake to think that consciousness and spirit can be used interchangeably.
Boy!!when one talks about Body. It implies something physical made up of atoms, limited in space and time. Therefore, I do not understand the new body you are talking about?
Things of Hell or Heaven are typical construction of your own mind. They only exist in your mind. They are not independent themselves.
If you do not wanna live longer then why do you believe in immortality or life after death. The belief in immortality suggests to some extent a desire to live longer.
A poor would fall for anything than a wealth contented person. A Religion inhibits people to pursue some of the goals which may lead believers to become rich. A Religion declares Does and Don'ts to believers, for that it controls their consciousnesses and take it to another level. it may even turns a Human into beast.
Ant Christ movement!!
Masadiki kwa Mungu Baba Mwenyezi.
Muumba wa mbingu na dunia na kwa Yesu Kristo mwnnae wa pekee Bwana wetu
Aliyetungwa kwa Roho Mtakatifu
Akazaliwa na Bikira Maria
Akateswa kwa mamlaka ya Ponsio Pilato
Akafa akazikwa akashukia kuzimu. Siku ya tatu akafufuka katika wafu
Akapaa Mbinguni. Amekaa kuume kwa Mungu Baba Mwenyezi. Toka huko Atakuja
Kuwahukumu wazima na wafu.
NASADIKI kwa Roho Mtakatifu
Kanisa takatifu Katoliki
Ushirika wa watakatifu
Maondoleo ya dhambi
Ufufuko wa miili
Na uzima wa milele AMINA
I have questioned that and never gone crazy,infact am more enlightened and confident to say there is no god.