Broken Systems/ Broken Lives


It is taking a long time to see positive changes because of the lack of political will from those in positions of power to make effective decisions that can help us move forward.

And the excuse that it takes a long time is unacceptable — it is easy to accept that it will take a long time to develop if you are economically comfortable but the majority of this country cannot afford for economic development and an increase in their standard of living to take a long time to come to fruition.

Those disgruntled individuals are citizens of the United Republic of Tanzania who deserve to have their grievances heard and if you put party loyalty and selfishness aside, why do you think that the opinions of actually the majority of this country do not deserve to be heard, respected, and acted on ? People are not sharing their grievances for fun, they are sharing their pain so that those who have been put in positions of power to protect the overall interests of this nation and its citizens do something about the things they are suffering from.

The award for the most disingenuous statement of the year goes to, “there is nothing wrong with how Tanzania is being run.”

If there is nothing wrong with how Tanzania is being run why are we in the bottom threshold of almost any index you can think of. The ones that we find ourselves ranking highly in are all related to disease and poverty.

Historical problems ??? Every country in the world has historical problems and many have found a way to move forward, including those who started off their independence journeys exactly in the same way we did.

The most frustrating thing about being on Jamii Forums is having to deal with individuals like you, people who have chosen to deny themselves of all reason, human decency, remorse, and empathy for other human beings.

Do you re-read the things that you write ?

You literally wrote that “the political will of Tanzania’s leaders is to maintain the status quo” And of course you do not see any issues with that statement because according to you the country is currently being governed perfectly, 10/10, with no notes necessary.

“Disgruntled minority who lack the flexibility to survive the existing political environment”

You are absolutely right, I am disgruntled, not only disgruntled, but appalled by the lack of care the Government of Tanzania continually shows for its own citizens, with the nadir of their behaviour being what they horrifically did to innocent civilians last year.
 


Thank you for your contribution!

I accept that the ball is in their court, especially since they have proven that they will not hesitate to cause harm to anyone that tries to say otherwise, but they also have to accept that choosing not to change directions and work towards healing the relationship between the the Government of Tanzania and its people will in the long run not only cause problems for us, the ordinary citizens, but also for them.

The protests last year were just a glimpse of how bad things can get if improvements are not made.

And no amount of violent suppression will prevent the total political and economic collapse that will be inevitable if they continue on the road they are currently on.
 
The Good thing about you is that you have the intellectual capacity to comprehend things which is not the case with majority of Tanzanians?In my case the opinions I am expressing here do not reflect my core beliefs however they reflect what I observe.

Now back to the Key issues:

1. Regarding our scores in various index-Can you provide the specific Indices so that I can establish their authenticity?
2.Secondly on the October 29 Events,Can you provide your opinion on how the situation should have been handled and what should be done that we are one year away?
3.On the issue of opinions can you provide clear and specific opinions on the aspects of our governance that you think if changed will greatly improved the welfare of the people.
4.Lets deals with specifics and engage in a constructive discussion as I would rather we keep this going until we reach a point where we are clear on where we want our nation to go and not Vague Ideals about democracy,human rights,corruption and justice which do not have a definitive description
 
I doubt if they know this!.
P
 

1) That is unpaid labour that I will not be doing — the indexes exist — it is obvious we are not doing well politically and economically — there are numbers and there are lived experiences (quantitative data/ qualitative anecdotes) and in our case they say the exact same thing.

2) I am not going to discuss 2 today. What the Government of Tanzania did there was inexcusable and it is obvious it was done to hold on to power. What could have been done differently is they could have chosen not to kill innocent civilians in cold blood.

3) My original post describes with several examples where they are going wrong — and my main emphasis was on how terrible the provision of services to citizens is — if people have to bribe officials for basic things like signatures — it is clear that that government is failing badly.

4) Idealism is where it all begins — you have to be able to imagine the kind of society you want to live in and the kind of government you want to have before you can come up with concrete ways to turn theories into a reality. Because so many other economic and political trajectories can be studied, we have the advantage of seeing what has worked well and what hasn’t in different countries in the region and elsewhere.

Democracy, human rights, corruption , and justice have definitive definitions — they are not fantasy. Saying that those things are vague ideals is an excuse used by those who do not want to do the work of ensuring that they are core pillars of the politics and social organisation of their society.

There is a reason why the UN declaration of human rights is central to everything in international politics — it was supposed to be the measure of the world that was to be created after the horrors of WWII — it was meant to guide the concrete reconstruction of Europe and the evolution of previously colonised territories into independent states. It acts as a benchmark for who we must aim to be even if we fall short.

Don't knock what you refer to as idealism — political philosophy especially in regard to democracy and human rights (the fact that they are inalienable) needs to be a central part of any government’s vision for their country.

Our government does not seem to be grounded in political philosophy that is rooted in integrity, equity, and fairness, which is where most of our problems stem from.
 
Aminata,

You wrote very well, speaking for the many voiceless, or even those who have a voice but are slowly accepting "the new normal" which is actually not so new. Every voice counts, every rehashing and retelling counts, there are young people who are at the risk of thinking some bizarre and disgusting abdication of responsibility is just normal.

On corruption, someone was distinguishing our corruption from elsewhere in the world, saying that our corruption, as if it was not bad enough, is also mired in the depth of unpredictability. In other words, corruption, being a sign of inefficiency itself, does not even guarantee things get done. People pay bribes and the system, take the title deed payment systems, is so inefficient and they don't get things accomplished. So our system is so bad even corruption does not work!

But thanks for bringing this up.

We must also go beyond raising awareness. We have been raising awareness for quite some time. The American diplomat and civil servant Samantha Powers (former US Ambassador to UN and former head of USAID) in her book "The Education of an Idealist : A Memoir" talks about how president Obama called her out for "admiring the problem", the act of stating the problem repeatedly, eloquently, without steps towards solving it.

There are steps that can be taken, what you are doing, raising awareness, is part of it, we also need to take ownership. So many people are so discouraged and are just giving up. Increasing transparency and the use of automated technology that bypasses bureaucratic hands that oftentimes need to be greased is another option. This could be buttressed by a public review system where citizens are empowered to air their grievances and rate public institutions, Yelp! style, if possibke with evidence.

There is so much we could do. Admittedly there are so many challenges to new ways of doing things, opposition from some key stakeholders and insiders who benefit from the current inefficiencies is natural, but even with these insiders, there are some allies who are hungry for change. Let us encourage them and work with them.

There is some progress, albeit very slow. There are some parts of government system that are going electronic. For example, the title deed payment system is very broken and corrupt, even with corruption, nothing is certain. Here I want yo caution that technology is not the end all solution, for technology can be sabotaged. But it can help a lot, especially if we take ownership, force transparency and accountability.

I want to encourage you go continue writing, to raise awareness, but also, challenge us to act together.
 

Yes, that is true, many people pay bribes na bado wanazungushwa sana. One is made to pay the bribe to be given the service they should have been given efficiently without the bribe only to still need the service as the corrupt official who accepted the bribe is still refusing to do their job — I think it is safe to say that we are in a very bad place when it comes to the provision of government services.

How to solve our problems ? Well the Government of Tanzania will hopefully re-evaluate themselves and head towards a better direction, one deserving of its people. We really need for some sort of miracle to occur in regards to the souls of our leaders, may their consciences be awakened and may they be able to see how their actions are hurting millions of people and even future generations.

I suppose this is why even in the Bible you are encouraged to pray for your country and its leaders.

If they do not change how they are currently governing then external forces rather than internal ones (the government choosing to re- strategise out of their own free will) could be the driving force whether that be through further protests (though at present this seems to be unlikely — albeit I have been noticing that I think people are beginning to be in silent protest — they know going to the streets is equivalent to death so they have found other ways to express their dissent) or conditions set by the international community.

The path we are on is a dangerous one because Tanzania is one of many poor countries and if we appear to have a rogue government that does not respect international charters on human rights and democracy, yes the international community technically cannot force the Government of Tanzania to change, but they could increasingly over time ice us out. The international community could just end up choosing not to deal with us and our never ending problems.

I do not see change coming from the oppositional politics in front of us. There isn’t a single political party in Tanzania that is trusted by a large enough majority of the population.

Yes, I have noticed that a lot of government systems have been digitised but they still need a lot of work. I also have noticed that what you are saying is true, the technology can be sabotaged — I have experienced it and seen it with my own eyes.

The digitisation of some of these government services is meant to prevent corruption and wasted time but the government officials that monitor the digital platforms absolutely can prevent you from getting the information you are seeking to obtain/ or from filing your own information into their systems. It is frustrating and heartbreaking. The fact that the technology can be sabotaged makes it somewhat redundant.

Thank you 🙏🏾
 
Comrades, I can internalise all grievances you are sharing regarding broken systems in our 'mama Tanzania.' There is a possible solution to clear this mess; and that is through forming new political party that will completely overhaul the prevailing broken systems and build the Tanzania we want. As I write here; there are ongoing initiative to have the party registered in 2028. Karibuni sana, all smart and brave men here at JF. I will keep you posted on the progress and what you can contribute.

MC
 
IPP?
P
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…