Govt opts for local borrowing after donor cut | JamiiForums | The Home of Great Thinkers

Dismiss Notice
You are browsing this site as a guest. It takes 2 minutes to CREATE AN ACCOUNT and less than 1 minute to LOGIN

Govt opts for local borrowing after donor cut

Discussion in 'Biashara, Uchumi na Ujasiriamali' started by Invisible, May 30, 2010.

  1. Invisible

    Invisible Admin Staff Member

    May 30, 2010
    Joined: Feb 11, 2006
    Messages: 9,090
    Likes Received: 235
    Trophy Points: 160

    Finance Minister Mustafa Mkulo poses with the budget briefcase. Picture: Leonard Magomba

    By Abduel Elinaza
    May 31 2010
    The East African

    Tanzania's Ministry of Finance is in talks with local commercial banks to borrow up to $250 million to cover a deficit left by a recent withdrawal of support by donors.

    The Treasury has initiated the talks with the eight commercial banks, excluding Bank of Tanzania, in a measure aimed at plugging a $3 billion budget deficit without roiling its bank interest, inflation and currency markets.

    Sources who have been part of the negotiations told The East African that the Tanzanian government, stung by donor criticism of the Kikwete government's inability to fight entrenched corruption among the ruling class, is currently facing hard choices - either increase its domestic borrowing through Treasury bills and bonds or raise money from international capital markets through a Eurobond.

    The National Bank of Commerce, a subsidiary of ABSA Group of South Africa, CRDB Bank Plc and Stanbic Bank Tanzania, a subsidiary of Standard Bank of South Africa, are among the banks who have been approached.

    Minister for Finance and Economic Affairs Mustafa Mkulo told The EastAfrican that the negotiations with the eight commercial banks were ongoing but have not reached any conclusion.

    Mr Mkulo said it was premature to disclose the names of the other five banks as talks were at a nascent stage. He defended the borrowing as normal practice for the government that did not require informing the financial custodian and regulator, the country's central bank.

    "After all in the next fiscal year, the bulk of development funds will be borrowed - what matters most is the interest rate charged by the banks," he said.

    Given the size of the loan, it is expected that the Bank of Tanzania would have concerns that it would slow down lending to the private sector as banks prefer lending to the government, increasing interest rates in the economy. This would then slow down consumption by consumers and businesses as debt becomes more expensive.

    A senior lecturer at the Mzumbe University Dar es Salaam Business School, Dr Prosper Ngowi, said that the move will have a crowding-out effect on the private sector, adding, "Commercial bank borrowing increases the debt burden and it's the next generation of taxpayers who will bear the brunt of paying back the debt."

    Hight costs

    Borrowing in international markets is not very attractive at the moment either, because investors who have been stung by the debt crisis facing Greece, Portugal and Spain are wary of sovereign debt from a poor country.

    The interest rates demanded by investors in sovereign debt from frontier economies such as Ghana has been rising.

    The cost of insuring these debts has also been rising dramatically. Tanzania's plans for issuing a Eurobond were scuttled by the global financial crisis.

    As Mr Mkulo prepares to present the new budget on June 10, he faces a tough task balancing the need to instill financial discipline to support Tanzania's economic growth and the tough political realities that his boss President Jakaya Kikwete faces an election he is widely expected to win in October.

    It is not clear how the Treasury by borrowing directly from commercial banks can avoid triggering a rise in local interest rates, but the strategy makes political sense in an election year because commercial banks will not make tough demands.

    With the Tanzanian economy still smarting from a slowdown, President Kikwete, whose political profile on the international stage has been rising, faces major political challenges on the ground with voters who continue to feel the pinch of rising food prices and unemployment.

    In the face of the global financial crisis, he responded with a major stimulus package, which he now wants to expand to increase demand and create jobs.

    The centrepiece of his political reforms has been massive investments in modernising agriculture, education and physical infrastructure. This has been paid through debts, now running to 5.5 per cent of the size of the $15 billion economy.

    Though the deficit has increased as tax collections slow down, the current financing crunch stems mainly from Tanzania's inability to deal with its success in attracting donors and delivering on its pledges to them.

    For instance, as this newspaper reports on page 9 of this edition, the country is now rushing to spend $700 million of unused cheap loans it was awarded in September 2008 by the Millenium Challenge Corporation, an agency of the US Department of State, that it was awarded to spend on energy, water and transport.

    If this money is not spent by 2013, it will lose out on getting a second loan. The country has not used the funds as fast as expected because of the cumbersome procurement guidelines demanded by the US government, which wants to ensure that contracts are not awarded to dubious firms with political connections as is prevalent in Africa.

    Treasury said it could not leave the deficit unattended as it may slow down the country's infrastructure development, especially in the road construction sector.

    Bank of Tanzania Director for Economic Policy, Dr Joseph Massawe said the central bank has not reached its limit on issuing Treasury bonds and that there are a number of issues to be taken into consideration before arriving at a conclusion on borrowung from commercial banks.

    The IMF and World Bank have warned that Tanzania's economy is not out of the woods yet after the global financial crisis, and current spending spree could derail GDP growth, estimated to be 6.2 per cent in 2011.

    In recent years, the government has increased borrowing to bridge the revenue collection gap exacerbated by the global financial crisis.

    In March 2010, revenue collections and grants amounted to $340 million and $21 million respectively, while total expenditure amounted to $475.3 million, implying a deficit of $113.5 million.

    On cumulative basis, revenue collections in the first nine months of 2009/10 were below budget estimates, with all categories falling short of targets.

    The total domestic revenue collection excluding Local Government Authorities' own sources was 91.3 per cent of budget projection during the period.

    The government had to borrow money from various sources following reduction of development partners' contribution to General Budget Support (GBS) of $220 million for various reasons, including delay in implementation of some reforms.

    The African Development Bank (AfDB) announced a GBS commitment of $534 million for the next financial year, while putting the government on notice to implement "at the required pace, certain required reforms or else lose the funding."

    Recommendations made by the IMF

    Tanzania should look for alternative financing to plug the anticipated deficit in the 2010/2011 budget.

    David Robinson, resident representative of the International Monetary Fund in Tanzania, said that there are a range of possibilities, including public private partnerships, syndicated loans, or Eurobonds, that however need to be handled carefully and in the context of a strategy that comprehensively weighs the risks and returns.

    Mr Robinson said that if there is a need for a fiscal stimulus package in the forthcoming financial year, it should not be to the level of the outgoing financial year 2009/2010.

    "For the next fiscal year, fiscal and monetary policy must be carefully balanced to support the economic recovery, while at the same time gradually scaling back the fiscal stimulus injected in response to the global crisis," he said.

    In the outgoing financial year, the government committed $1.7 billion to stimulate the economy through the injection of funds into key sectors.

    The IMF supplied the government with $336 million in installments to help fight the adverse effects of the global crisis.

    According to Mr Robinson, for the country to have a successful 2010/2011, the government needs to make improvements in revenue collection and minimise recurrent expenditure.

    In May, the donors slashed funding pledges for Tanzania's 2010/2011 budget by nearly a quarter of a billion dollars to $534 million due to concerns about the slow pace of reforms in the country.
  2. Mwana wa Mungu

    Mwana wa Mungu JF-Expert Member

    May 30, 2010
    Joined: Aug 14, 2008
    Messages: 1,007
    Likes Received: 21
    Trophy Points: 135
    Hivi wakubwa, kwa wana uchumi naomba wanisaidie, hivi selikali haiwezi kukopa kwa wananchi kwa njia ya Treasury bonds (yaani hati fungani za selikali) watu tukanunua na wakatulipa kwa miaka kama mitano hata kumi ijayo? Plus interest?...mbona watu wangenunua tu na billions nyingi sana zingepatikana kwasababu watu wanajua kuwa selikali haiwezi kufilisika na bonds ni secured security?

    ...kwanini kujiaibisha kukopakopa kwa mabenki tena yasiyo ya kitz?

    NB; mi si mwanauchumi, nirekebisheni kama sielewi....
  3. Invisible

    Invisible Admin Staff Member

    May 30, 2010
    Joined: Feb 11, 2006
    Messages: 9,090
    Likes Received: 235
    Trophy Points: 160
    Mkuu Mwana wa Mungu,

    Umeuliza nilichotaka kuuliza; ngoja tuone wachumi wanatushauri vipi
  4. k_u_l_i

    k_u_l_i Senior Member

    Jun 4, 2010
    Joined: Jan 26, 2010
    Messages: 122
    Likes Received: 1
    Trophy Points: 0
    Mimi si mwanauchumi lakini siamini kama kuna wateja binafsi wa kutosha kununua T-bonds za $250. T-bonds kawaida zina-mature miaka 20 hadi 30. Hizi huja na political risk kubwa. Mara nyingi serikali ya Tz huuza kwa wananchi T-bills ambazo huwa za muda mfupi hata miezi 6 au mwaka. Hizi zinapatika pale benki kuu.

  5. ngoshwe

    ngoshwe JF-Expert Member

    Jun 4, 2010
    Joined: Mar 31, 2009
    Messages: 4,075
    Likes Received: 33
    Trophy Points: 145
    Ndiko huku ambako Serikali ya Mkwere ingetufikisha kabla jogoo ajawika mara tatu. Hii ni awamu ya kwanza tu ya Uongizi wake. Nchi inaongozwa kwa Sera za majinamizi ya kushitukiza na yasiyo na utafiti, zile pambio za maisha bora kwa kila mtanzania, Mabilioni ya JK, Kilimo Kwanza, nk hatuwezi kuzisikia tena. Sasa tunaletewa ngoma ya nyingine kabisa tusiyoweza kuicheza. Zilidaiwa kupatikana Bilioni 40 za EPA mzee akasema zimepelekwa Sekta ya Kilimo..Matokeo mpaka leo hayaonekani. Tuliambiwa makusanyo ya mwaka kutokana na Kodi na maduhuri ya Serikali yameongezeka mara dufu zaidi mpaka kufikia kiasi cha kuwaongezea mishahara akina "Zakayo" (TRA) sasa ule wimbo u wapi tena!.
  6. BAK

    BAK JF-Expert Member

    Jun 4, 2010
    Joined: Feb 11, 2007
    Messages: 70,496
    Likes Received: 81,820
    Trophy Points: 280
    Watanzania tuna uwezo wa kununua T bonds zenye thamani ya shilingi 300 bilioni? Mimi nafikiri Serikali ingweza kabisa kupunguza matumizi ya kifahari ambayo ni mengi sana ili kufidia pengi hili na pia kuongeza kodi kwa makampuni ya Wawekezaji na mahoteli ambayo mengi hayalipi kodi kabisa.