German minister in plagiarism row stripped of PhD | JamiiForums | The Home of Great Thinkers

Dismiss Notice
You are browsing this site as a guest. It takes 2 minutes to CREATE AN ACCOUNT and less than 1 minute to LOGIN

German minister in plagiarism row stripped of PhD

Discussion in 'International Forum' started by Dingswayo, Feb 24, 2011.

  1. Dingswayo

    Dingswayo JF-Expert Member

    Feb 24, 2011
    Joined: May 26, 2009
    Messages: 4,011
    Likes Received: 86
    Trophy Points: 145
    Watu kama hawa wapo wengi hasa katika ngazi za uongozi. Hawa wa hapa kwetu ao wanahitajiwa wavuliwe hizo shahada.

    German minister in plagiarism row stripped of PhD - The Globe and Mail

    German Chancellor Angela Merkel's Defence Minister was stripped of his doctorate on Wednesday by the German university that awarded the title, after he admitted to flaws in a thesis that is the focus of a plagiarism row.
    Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg apologized "from the bottom of my heart" to parliament earlier on Wednesday for errors he blamed on a busy workload.

    But he said he would not resign over the allegations and rejected accusations of plagiarism, insisting he had not deliberately deceived anyone.

    Mr. Guttenberg, long Germany's most popular politician and sometimes named as a possible successor to Merkel, has been accused of copying parts of his PhD dissertation on constitutional law without correct attribution.
    The scandal, dubbed "Copygate" may damage the centre-right coalition ahead of six regional elections this year because the aristocrat has been a rare bright spots in Merkel's government.

    Mr. Guttenberg has given the coalition a badly needed dash of glamour and topped voter polls for much of the last two years – and a survey taken on Wednesday suggested his popularity was undimmed.

    Mr. Guttenberg gave up his doctorate on Monday, admitting to an unintentional violation of academic standards. He attacked the media for a witch-hunt against him.
    Bayreuth University formally stripped him of his title at a news conference chaired by its chancellor Ruediger Bormann, who had said such a decision was a matter for the institution alone.

    Mr. Bormann, who stopped short of accusing Guttenberg of plagiarism, said any thesis needed to include full references to source material and clearly identify passages taken from other works.
    Mr. Guttenberg "violated these requirements to a significant degree", Bormann said.

    In a heated parliamentary exchange, 39-year-old Mr. Guttenberg earlier answered questions for the first time from deputies.
    "I was so arrogant to think that I could square a circle," he said, referring to a busy work load with the dissertation while being a deputy in parliament and starting a family.

    "I wrote a dissertation that was obviously flawed," he said.
    The telephone survey of 1,000 voters by research institute Dimap for state broadcaster ARD found 73 per cent were satisfied with Guttenberg's performance as a politician, against 68 per cent at the start of February.
    Some 72 per cent said they considered the matter closed following his decision to give up his doctorate, while 24 per cent said Mr. Guttenberg should also resign.

    But analysts warn of dangers to him and Ms. Merkel over the affair because the plagiarism allegations go to the heart of Mr. Guttenberg's image as an honest and upright politician.
    He denied, when asked by an opposition deputy, that he had used a ghostwriter to help him write the dissertation.
    Mr. Guttenberg also faced criticism from within his own party. Norbert Lammert, a leader in Ms. Merkel's Christian Democrats (CDU) and president of parliament, had publicly scolded Guttenberg for not coming clean about "the sloppiness" of his work.

    The opposition Social Democrats renewed their calls for his resignation. Thomas Oppermann, an SPD leader in parliament, said Mr. Guttenberg was a cheat and getting special treatment.
    "It's reprehensible that an academic cheat and liar can remain in the cabinet," Mr. Oppermann told parliament.

    Ms. Merkel has defended Mr. Guttenberg, saying she appointed him to her cabinet because of his political skills and not because she needed an "academic assistant."
  2. movingtarget

    movingtarget Member

    Feb 24, 2011
    Joined: Dec 29, 2010
    Messages: 35
    Likes Received: 0
    Trophy Points: 0
    Wakichunguza PhD za kina nanihii kwenye siasa zetu mbona wengi tu inaonekana hawaku qualify!?
  3. Kiwi

    Kiwi JF-Expert Member

    Feb 24, 2011
    Joined: Sep 30, 2009
    Messages: 1,009
    Likes Received: 197
    Trophy Points: 160
    Habari zaidi ni kwamba pamoja na kunyang'anywa PhD yake feki, anatakiwa ajiuzulu wadhifa wake kama waziri. Hivi vile vihiyo vyetu vyenye 'PhD' za miezi sita USA lini watalijua hilo? Mabomu yanalipuka hawataki kujiuzulu, itakuwa vyeti feki? Kweli tuna safari ndefu. Mungu Ibariki Tanzania!