Divorce Africa from the World Bank and IMF: Reflections on an
Abusive Relationship
The African Executive | Divorce Africa from the World Bank and IMF
About the Author
James Shikwati is the Founder and Director of the Inter Region Economic Network and
CEO of The African Executive magazine
The African Executive | Free Africa's Ultimate Capital. He was named
among top 100 most influential Kenyans by The Standard Group in 2007 and also named
among the 245 Young Global Leaders of 2008 by the Forum of Young Global Leaders,
an affiliate of the World Economic Forum.
Introduction
It is not America that buys champagne from France. It is always an individual
American who buys it from an individual Frenchman. Ludwig Von Misses
Introduction
Attempts to push Africa to adopt a market economic policy framework by Western
countries through the World Bank, IMF and their allied international agencies goes
against the spirit of free choice enshrined in free market systems. To fully enjoy the
benefits of a market economic system, Africa must divorce herself from the forced
marriage to the World Bank and IMF a legacy of colonialism. African countries must
proactively seek to build their own market systems based on freedom of choice and
exploitation of existing natural resources for the benefit of her people.
Defining Market Economics
The market economic system or free market and capitalism operates on the basis of
voluntary exchange as opposed to planning or control by a central authority. In the
market economy, decisions and the pricing of goods and services are guided solely by the
aggregate interactions of a countrys citizens and businesses with minimal government
intervention.
Interrogating Market Economics in Africa
Markets are not new in Africa. In Africa, the means of production were privately owned.
The profit motive was present in most market transactions. Free enterprise and free trade
were the rule in indigenous Africa. Each region in Africa has a history of pre-colonial
trade routes. Small or large, centralized or decentralized, no African society was an island
to itself.
Debate on why Africans failed to leverage and develop their indigenous market systems
have over the years been pegged on colonialism and its benefactor market economics.
The market economy and recently neo-liberalism are perceived to have fed colonialism
and continue to sustain neocolonialism in Africa.
Whereas the market economic system operates on the basis of voluntary exchange, in
Africa, it doesnt. Africa is poor, ultimately, because its economy and society have been
ravaged by international capital and local elites who are often propped up by foreign
powers. Wealthy nations force poor countries to adopt market economic policies in total
disregard of the tenets of free will and choice.
Protectionism and its Impact on Africa
Protectionism has never been good for Africa. The continent is already groaning under
wealthy nations protectionist measures supervised by the World Bank/IMF and their
allies that range from skewed international trade policies, trade distorting subsidies, debt
and aid.
According to the Tony Blair Commission for Africa, the trading relationship between
developed and developing worlds is dominated by a web of rules, taxes, tariffs and quotas
which tilt international trade in favor of the rich. The G8 and EU countries for example,
subsidize their agricultural sector to the tune of $350 billion a year, 16 times the amount
of aid they give to Africa, but expect free market competition with farmers in Africa.
African countries are faced with other types of protectionism such as inefficient
producers in wealthy nations being guaranteed a market in poorer countries by virtue of
aid driven-relations or colonial legacy; health and safety standards to bar products from
Africa; and the emerging green protectionism barrier that use carbon tariffs to bar
products.
A dispute between Tanzania and Kenya on the pace that regional integration should take
best illustrates Africas predicament on protectionism. Whereas on the surface, it would
appear that Tanzanias main fear is Kenyas bigger economy; the truth however is, they
fear the power of outsiders who run Kenyas economy, for after all, the Kenyan or
African economy is largely not driven by indigenes but by companies from wealthy
nations.
The African Policy Makers Dilemma
Should Africans protect their own industries or those of their aid doling allies operating
on their soil? The ongoing financial crisis has helped expose the hypocrisy of westernengineered
market economic system that has for long been forced down the throats of
Africans.
According to the Report of the Commission for Africa, three contradictory dynamics
dominate Africas relationship with rich nations: trade, debt, and aid. In the last few
decades Africa has seen its share of world trade fall from six per cent in 1980 to less than
2 per cent in 2002. African countries were forced to open their markets and get integrated
in the global economy and compete on equal footing with those who champion market
economy and yet practice the complete opposite of what they prescribe as seen in Gordon
Browns push for British jobs for British workers and Americas Buy American.
Africa should build its own Institutions
African policy makers are faced with a big challenge on how to implement market
economic strategies, having simply copy-pasted their institutional framework from
colonial powers. The continent is stuck with organizations as opposed to institutions.
The workings of these organizations partly explain why the existing institutional
framework in Africa is perceived to serve the political elite and foreign interests. For
instance, the violent use of machetes by ethnic groups to address land disputes in Kenya
in 1991, 1997 and 2007 indicates that the masses do not recognize the executive,
judiciary and legislature as just arbiters.
Two parallel systems run concurrently on the continent: the government (organization)
and the community (ignored institutions which are older than existing governments).
Such a predicament complicates the functioning of the market economy.
Governments in Africa must realize that they rule over silent sovereign ethnic
communities whose interests, largely ignored, have slowed down economic development.
Consequently, the inherited government systems must renegotiate with ethnic community
systems to enable the merging of sovereignties that are accepted and respected by all.
Africans must urgently build institutions that will enable them run a market economic
system that unleashes the talents of each one.
African Commodities Exchange Market
Africas old allies, Europe and USA, face stiff competition from re-emerging powers
such as China, Turkey, India and other Asiatic countries in the quest for her natural
resource wealth. Africa must take advantage of the renewed competition to set up
commodity market hubs across the continent that will usher in a one Africa commodity
exchange market. Such a market would not only enhance the continents bargaining
power, but also explore possibilities of exploiting the continents internal market. A
transparent and open trading system backed up by Africas new institutions (not
organizations) would attract financing, say from Central Bank of Africa and save Africa
from resource-related conflicts.
Delink Africa from World Bank/IMF
African countries must delink their economic strategies from the World Bank/IMF driven
goals and initiate their own market-driven relationships amongst themselves and the rest
of the world. The World Bank and IMF force Africans to practice market economics
under constricted freedom.
The World Bank/IMF operates in the arena of development like a one-party dictator,
accountable to no one but themselves. They perpetuate the functions that colonial
governments served; operate according to the dictates of their major shareholders; are not
accountable to the African people and assist in Africas plunder. It is debatable whether
they are accountable to tax payers in countries that finance them. The secrecy that
shrouds their operations casts doubt on their ability to deliver a just and open market
system.
According to WTO, trade among African countries amounted to only 8.9 per cent of total
exports. Within the East African Community (Kenya, Uganda and Tanzania) trade grew
from $778 million in 2004 to $1 billion in 2006. Trade within the Common Market for
Eastern and Southern Africa (COMESA) increased from $4.5 billion in 2002 to $7.8
billion in 2007. The genuine spirit of market economy that ought to have unleashed
Africas entrepreneurial spirit has for a long time been on the leash. The gains of a
genuine open market system for Africa are evident in the expansion of regional markets
for individuals, companies and through technological reach as evident in the cell phone
and internet sectors.
A Gold Standard Approach to Africas Monetary System
Africa must set up its own monetary system by adopting a Gold Standard approach that
may apply to the trading of selected minerals that have international market recognition.
The standard will ensure long-term price stability in Africa; regulate the quantity and
growth of respective countries money supply and guarantee a countrys external value of
its currency.
Africa Should Move Away from Aid Paradigm
Aid (financial and technical assistance from rich nations to poor countries) serves the
interest of the donor more than that of the recipient. For Africa, aid has destroyed the
peoples confidence and abilities to confront their daily challenges. The market economic
system will not work for Africa if it continues to rely on foreign aid to operate. Aid
simply exports the attitudes of the donor to Africa.
Aid has led to an upsurge of NGOs as opposed to enterprises that ought to transform
Africas natural resources to wealth. It begs the question as to whether it is in the longterm
interest of NGOs to find long-lasting solutions to Africas problems.
Conclusion
In the absence of World Bank/IMF and with Africas own governance institutions;
monetary policy and genuine market system, productivity will increase on the continent
and make Africa a major player in the global economy.
Clearly, Africa is not part of the architects of the global economy. Africa must urgently
divorce itself from the planned market system supervised by the World Bank and IMF
and call for a new economic order.