The economics of Hajj: Money and pilgrimage | JamiiForums | The Home of Great Thinkers

Dismiss Notice
You are browsing this site as a guest. It takes 2 minutes to CREATE AN ACCOUNT and less than 1 minute to LOGIN

The economics of Hajj: Money and pilgrimage

Discussion in 'International Forum' started by mtwana, Oct 25, 2012.

  1. mtwana

    mtwana JF-Expert Member

    Oct 25, 2012
    Joined: Oct 13, 2012
    Messages: 399
    Likes Received: 85
    Trophy Points: 45
    Millions of Muslims from all walks of life have converged on Saudi Arabia to perform the pilgrimage known as the Hajj.
    The annual occasion has become a lucrative business in recent years, proving a great financial asset to the economy of the oil-rich kingdom.
    Many pilgrims, however, struggle to reconcile their spiritual needs with their wallets.
    Mohammed Zayan, a 53-year-old pilgrim from Tunisia, has waited a lifetime to perform the religious obligation, which does not come free.
    "I spent up to $6,000 (£3,700) on my Hajj," says Mr Zayan, who wears the traditional white pilgrims' clothes.
    "I thank God that he enabled me to save this amount of money but I'm sad I could not afford taking my wife and son with me."
    The millions who come to Mecca every year bring billions of dollars to the Saudi economy.
    Continue reading the main story [h=2]“Start Quote[/h][​IMG]
    I don't find shop owners opportunists but we help our brothers in Islam to make profit and make ends meet”
    End Quote Ahmed Abdel Rahman Mauritian Hajj pilgrim
    Restaurants, travel agents, airlines and mobile phone companies all earn big bucks during the Hajj, and the government benefits in the form of taxes.
    Last year, the 10-day event generated some $10bn (£6.2bn), according to the Chamber of Commerce in Mecca.
    Worthwhile investment The private sector also maximises its returns during Hajj, with investment in real estate an attractive proposition ahead of the pilgrimage.
    The highest rents in Saudi Arabia are found in the holy city of Mecca, the birthplace of Islam.
    Owners of hotels close to the main mosque ask for $700 a night, blaming the skyrocketing prices of land for the sharp rise in rates.
    "I have been investing in this sector for 35 years. I remember when I first sold a metre of land in Mecca for just 15 rials ($3), now it has reached 80,000 rials ($22,000)," said Mohamed Saed al-Jahni, one of Mecca's real estate tycoons.
    "The demand is higher than supply and that is why many buildings and hotels have been built in recent years to accommodate the increasing number of pilgrims".
    Super-tall buildings are filling the Mecca skyline at an unstoppable pace.
    The ancient city's centuries-old sites are giving way to glitzy luxury hotels, which are not affordable for many pilgrims.
    The government says it is a necessary step, even if the construction comes at the expense of historical mountains dating back to the age of the Prophet of Islam Muhammad and his companions.
    Spiritual relief [​IMG] High-rise luxury hotels have sprung up all over Mecca
    Selling Mecca souvenirs is another very lucrative business during the Hajj.
    There are no official estimates for this profitable trade, but it is believed to bring hundreds of millions of dollars every year.
    Ahmed Abdel Rahman, 43, will leave Mecca laden with presents and souvenirs for loved ones back in Mauritius.
    "These are blessed souvenirs," he says, holding a bead he just bought at almost three times its original price outside the city.
    The price of Mecca souvenirs is often eye-wateringly high and most of the products like prayer mats and beads are not made in the city, but rather in China.
    But Mr Abdel Rahman says he feels a great spiritual relief when he spends his money in Mecca.
    "I don't find shop owners opportunists but we help our brothers in Islam to make profit and make ends meet. This is a highly rewarded act."
    Hajj is one of the five pillars of Islam and an obligation, provided a Muslim is financially and physically able.
    The ritual, which demonstrates the unity of Muslims and their submission to Allah, has been carried out for nearly nearly 1,400 years.
    However much it costs, Muslims will not stop coming to this spiritual and also commercial hub. They simply cannot do Hajj anywhere else.
  2. M

    M-Joka JF-Expert Member

    Oct 25, 2012
    Joined: Dec 13, 2007
    Messages: 308
    Likes Received: 4
    Trophy Points: 0
    Ndugu Mtwana and your reporter,

    Have you ever heard any Muslim complaining about it??? What does that tell you??? Are you that kind to the wealth of the Muslims who go for Hajj, or Muslims in general?

    Are you pretending to be speaking for Muslims and at the same time portraying the message subconsciously that "masikiiiini weee Muslims, they can not speak for themselves" style, isn't it?!. For your information, neither you nor your reporter can speak or represent Muslims in their affairs. No Muslim is struggling to reconcile his/her spiritual needs with the wealth, unless he/she is like you or your reporter, a liar and hypocrite.

    Swallow this for your simple economics lesson:

    People squander a lot of their wealth traveling to Disneyland, to London for Olympics, Las Vegas, Bali, criuising in cruiseliners etc, etc. They pay a lot of money and for many, are the savings of their life times. The worst of all is that all they do while there behind the scenes are worse than animal can do, even their master, "shetani" can not do.And when they come back, they are more dissatisfied than before, more depressed, and more angrier.
    - For what???
    - Whose economy are they helping???
    - What benefit do they get???
    - Is the benefit a value for money they pay???
    - Are they struggling to reconcile with their wallet?

    Compare them and Muslims who come back from Hajj, or relatives of those who do not come back as their appointed times of death reach them while there. If you have measure of value for ones money, go and measure their satisfaction, pleasure to their Lord knowing that their Lord is pleased with them, in addition to the normal experience of that gathering of mankind for one purpose and how their families and their relatives feel about them when they come back.

    Ndugu Mtwana and your reporter, get this into your head and minds: Anything that people embark on doing, whether be it Disneyland or Hajj or Umra in Makka, can be measure by being "value for money". And please do not pretend otherwise, you and your reporter really do not have a slightest idea on the value of performing Hajj in Makka at least once in life time. Contrary to you clueless mind, it is worth more than any wealth that any stupid misguided, greedy, jealous, primary school economics can try to portray.