Mchemsho wa kwanza wa Zuma......hatujifunzi Waafrika ?
Statement by President Jacob Zuma on the appointment of the new Cabinet
This is Zuma's statement on the formation of his new cab. My critique is below:
10 May 2009
Members of the media,
Good afternoon and thank you for joining us.
We have since the launch of the ANC Manifesto indicated the type of new administration we envisaged in terms of size, shape and political focus.
We wanted a structure that would enable us to achieve visible and tangible socio-economic development within the next five years.
It should be a structure which would enable us to effectively implement our policies.
The structure of Cabinet and national departments has therefore been re-organised to achieve better alignment between the structure, our electoral mandate as per our election Manifesto, and the developmental challenges that need to receive immediate attention from government.
In summary, some of the changes in the structure of government are the following:
Following extensive research on international models on how governments in other parts of the world plan and monitor performance, we have decided to establish a National Planning Commission which will be based in the Presidency.
The NPC will be responsible for strategic planning for the country to ensure one National Plan to which all spheres of government would adhere.
This would enable us to take a more comprehensive view of socio-economic development in the country.
We have also created a monitoring and evaluation competency in the Presidency, to monitor and evaluate the performance of government in all three spheres.
There will therefore be two Ministers in the Presidency, one responsible for the NPC and the other for Monitoring and Evaluation as well as administration in the Presidency.
Other changes are the following:
The Department of Minerals and Energy will be split into two separate departments of Mining and of Energy, each with a Minister.
The Department of Education will be split into separate Ministries, one for Basic Education and the other for Higher Education and Training.
The Department of Housing will be called the Department of Human Settlements to take on a more holistic focus.
There will be a new department of Rural Development and Land Affairs, which are part of our key priorities for the next five years.
The Department of Water affairs and Forestry becomes the Department of Water and Environmental Affairs.
A new Department of Economic Development has been established to focus on economic policymaking. The implementation functions will remain with the Department of Trade and Industry.
A new department of Tourism has been created.
Agriculture becomes Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry.
The Department of Provincial and Local Government becomes Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.
A new Ministry has been created for Women, Youth, Children and People with Disability, to emphasise the need for equity and access to development opportunities for the vulnerable groups in our society.
The Cabinet that will fulfill our objectives is composed as follows:
The Deputy President of the Republic of South Africa will be Mr Kgalema Petros Motlanthe.
The rest of Cabinet in alphabetical order is as follows:
1.
Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Tina Joemat-Pettersson
Deputy Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Dr Pieter Mulder
2.
Minister of Arts and Culture
Lulu Xingwana
Deputy Minister of Arts and Culture
Paul Mashatile
3.
Minister of Basic Education
Angie Motshekga
Deputy Minister of Basic Education
Enver Surty
4.
Minister of Communications
Siphiwe Nyanda
Deputy Minister of Communications
Dina Pule
5.
Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs
Sicelo Shiceka
Deputy Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs
Yunus Carrim
6.
Minister of Correctional Services
Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula
Deputy Minister of Correctional Services
Hlengiwe Mkhize
7.
Minister of Defence and Military Veterans
Lindiwe Sisulu
Deputy Minister of Defence and Military Veterans
Thabang Makwetla
8.
Minister of Economic Development
Ebrahim Patel
Deputy Minister of Economic Development
Gwen Mahlangu-Nkabinde
9.
Minister of Energy
Dipuo Peters
10.
Minister of Finance
Pravin Gordhan
Deputy Minister of Finance
Nhlanhla Nene
11.
Minister of Health
Dr Aaron Motsoaledi
Deputy Minister of Health
Dr Molefi Sefularo
12.
Minister of Higher Education and Training
Dr Blade Nzimande
13.
Minister of Home Affairs
Dr Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma
Deputy Minister of Home Affairs
Malusi Gigaba
14.
Minister of Human Settlements
Tokyo Sexwale
Deputy Minister of Human Settlements
Zou Kota
15.
Minister of International Relations and Cooperation
Maite Nkoana-Mashabane
Deputy Minister of International Relations and Cooperation (1)
Ebrahim Ismail Ebrahim
Deputy Minister of International Relations and Cooperation (2)
Sue van der Merwe
16.
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development
Jeff Radebe
Deputy Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development
Andries Nel
17.
Minister of Labour
Membathisi Mdladlana
18.
Minister of Mining
Susan Shabangu
19.
Minister of Police
Nathi Mthethwa
Deputy Minister of Police
Fikile Mbalula
20.
Minister of Public Enterprises
Barbara Hogan
Deputy Minister of Public Enterprises
Enoch Godongwana
21.
Minister for the Public Service and Administration
Richard Baloyi
Deputy Minister for the Public Service and Administration
Roy Padayachie
22.
Minister of Public Works
Geoff Doidge
Deputy Minister of Public Works
Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu
23.
Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform
Gugile Nkwinti
Deputy Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform
Dr Joe Phaahla
24.
Minister of Science and Technology
Naledi Pandor
Deputy Minister of Science and Technology
Derek Hanekom
25.
Minister of Social Development
Edna Molewa
Deputy Minister of Social Development
Bathabile Dlamini
26.
Minister of Sport and Recreation
Makhenkesi Stofile
Deputy Minister of Sport and Recreation
Gert Oosthuizen
27.
Minister of State Security
Siyabonga Cwele
28.
Minister in The Presidency (1)
National Planning Commission
Trevor Manuel
29.
Minister in The Presidency (2)
Performance Monitoring and Evaluation as well as Administration in the Presidency
Collins Chabane
30.
Minister of Tourism
Marthinus van Schalkwyk
Deputy Minister of Tourism
Thozile Xasa
31.
Minister of Trade and Industry
Rob Davies
Deputy Minister of Trade and Industry (1)
Thandi Tobias
Deputy Minister of Trade and Industry (2)
Maria Ntuli
32.
Minister of Transport
Sbusiso Joel Ndebele
Deputy Minister of Transport
Jeremy Cronin
33.
Minister of Water and Environmental Affairs
Buyelwa Sonjica
Deputy Minister of Water and Environmental Affairs
Rejoice Mabhudafhasi
34.
Minister of Women, Youth, Children and People with Disabilities
Noluthando Mayende-Sibiya
We stated clearly during the campaign that we want an efficient, caring and effective administration, which will be accessible and responsive to the needs of the people.
We reiterate that we will not tolerate laziness and incompetence, and that we will emphasise excellence and achievement from the Cabinet and the public service.
With these objectives in mind, I am confident that the new structure of government will enable the state machinery to speed up service delivery.
Civil servants will not lose their jobs as a result of these changes. This is a matter of principle in terms of the countrys labour relations dispensation.
I however want to stress to our public servants that the era of hard work has begun. Public servants who do their work diligently and efficiently have nothing to worry about.
I wish the new team all the best with their responsibilities.
We request the South African public and all key sectors of our society to support them in their national service.
Let me also take this opportunity to wish all South African mothers well on Mothers Day today.
Mothers are the backbones of our families, communities and our nation.
We truly appreciate their role in our society, in both the public sphere and within families.
I thank you.
Of course, kama ilivyotegemewa kajenga Ghorofa badala ya Kibanda. Most ministry can be turned into agencies or boards capable of generating adequate income to run themselves without depending on the treasury.
Afirca countries can afford less than the Ministry proposed here. This is too much of a burden not only to the taxpayers but even to the overall leader. Unless of course is a superman capable of coordinating efficiently and effectively 34 ministries. As in Tanzania the chaos just starts here. Too many ministries. The analysis below shows that it is possible for South Africa too to be run by only 14 ministries with the rest being turned into agencies, commissions or boards capable of avoiding red-tape and bureaucracy as well as making money for the people.
The rest of Cabinet in alphabetical order is as follows:
1.
Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Okay!
2.
Minister of Arts and Culture
NO.
Should become a National Agency of Arts, Language and culture and be able to run on its own!
3.
Minister of Basic Education
Okay.
For strategic reasons.
4.
Minister of Communications
Okay. But.....
Should go together with Science and Technology.
5.
Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs
Okay.
For strategic and black empowerment reasons.
6.
Minister of Correctional Services
Can go together with Ministry of Home Affairs.
7.
Minister of Defence and Military Veterans
Okay.
8.
Minister of Economic Development
Repetition and overlaps
9.
Minister of Energy
No.
Should be National Energy Agency capable of developing itself into something capable of self-sustainance.
10.
Minister of Finance
Okay!
11.
Minister of Health
Add Food and Nutrition.
12.
Minister of Higher Education and [Training] HRM.
Okay. But why training and not Human Resource Management and Devleopment?
13.
Minister of Home Affairs
See above. Joined to Correctional Affairs.
14.
Minister of Human Settlements
+ Environment ! here it is where it belongs? It is man who harms the environment not other resources.
15.
Minister of International Relations and Cooperation
Okay.
16.
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development
Shuould be Justice and Constitutional development Commission head enjoying similar perks like Minister. But capable of self-sustainance through various levvies and charges.
17.
Minister of Labour
After HRM linked to Higher education for planning purposes this should be SOUTH AFRICA LABOUR EXCHANGE .... most work being done online with exception of rural areas to be assisted by Rural development ministry.
18.
Minister of Mining
This Should be South African Mining Agency and should be capable of footing its own bill.
19.
Minister of Police
This will be a department in the Home Affairs.
20.
Minister of Public Enterprises
This should be Commission of Public Enterprises and should be maintained by the clients.
21.
Minister for the Public Service and Administration
This should be a Commission of Public Service and Administration---coming up with various training, research and consultancy programmes to the point of making it run on its own income.
22.
Minister of Public Works
Okay. Very strategic. But assist it to create more employment in the rural areas.
23.
Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform
Okay. Strategic.
24.
Minister of Science and Technology
See above. Already attached elsewhere but can establish NATIONAL AGENCY OF INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY (ICT)
25.
Minister of Social Development
Redundant expecially with Women, Children.....and so on already aboard.
26.
Minister of Sport and Recreation
Let it be NATIONAL AGENCY OF SPORTS AND RECREATION DEVELOPMENT and capable of running on its own by promoting individuals, teams/groups so they generate income locally and abroad.
27.
Minister of State Security
Is there no South African CIA what is this for ?
28.
Minister in The Presidency (1)
National Planning Commission
Okay. Strategic.
29.
Minister in The Presidency (2)
Performance Monitoring and Evaluation as well as Administration in the Presidency
NOT a ministry but a section within the National Planning Commission. You plan, show the way, control and then monitor and get feedback,
30.
Minister of Tourism
Why not South African National Tourism Board?
31.
Minister of Trade and Industry
Okay.
32.
Minister of Transport
NO. Instead National Transport Agency.
33.
Minister of Water and Environmental Affairs
Change. Take environment elsewhere. See above. Then create a Ministry of Water, water resources utilisation and irrigation farming.
34.
Minister of Women, Youth, Children and People with Disabilities
Okay.
Statement by President Jacob Zuma on the appointment of the new Cabinet
This is Zuma's statement on the formation of his new cab. My critique is below:
10 May 2009
Members of the media,
Good afternoon and thank you for joining us.
We have since the launch of the ANC Manifesto indicated the type of new administration we envisaged in terms of size, shape and political focus.
We wanted a structure that would enable us to achieve visible and tangible socio-economic development within the next five years.
It should be a structure which would enable us to effectively implement our policies.
The structure of Cabinet and national departments has therefore been re-organised to achieve better alignment between the structure, our electoral mandate as per our election Manifesto, and the developmental challenges that need to receive immediate attention from government.
In summary, some of the changes in the structure of government are the following:
Following extensive research on international models on how governments in other parts of the world plan and monitor performance, we have decided to establish a National Planning Commission which will be based in the Presidency.
The NPC will be responsible for strategic planning for the country to ensure one National Plan to which all spheres of government would adhere.
This would enable us to take a more comprehensive view of socio-economic development in the country.
We have also created a monitoring and evaluation competency in the Presidency, to monitor and evaluate the performance of government in all three spheres.
There will therefore be two Ministers in the Presidency, one responsible for the NPC and the other for Monitoring and Evaluation as well as administration in the Presidency.
Other changes are the following:
The Department of Minerals and Energy will be split into two separate departments of Mining and of Energy, each with a Minister.
The Department of Education will be split into separate Ministries, one for Basic Education and the other for Higher Education and Training.
The Department of Housing will be called the Department of Human Settlements to take on a more holistic focus.
There will be a new department of Rural Development and Land Affairs, which are part of our key priorities for the next five years.
The Department of Water affairs and Forestry becomes the Department of Water and Environmental Affairs.
A new Department of Economic Development has been established to focus on economic policymaking. The implementation functions will remain with the Department of Trade and Industry.
A new department of Tourism has been created.
Agriculture becomes Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry.
The Department of Provincial and Local Government becomes Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.
A new Ministry has been created for Women, Youth, Children and People with Disability, to emphasise the need for equity and access to development opportunities for the vulnerable groups in our society.
The Cabinet that will fulfill our objectives is composed as follows:
The Deputy President of the Republic of South Africa will be Mr Kgalema Petros Motlanthe.
The rest of Cabinet in alphabetical order is as follows:
1.
Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Tina Joemat-Pettersson
Deputy Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Dr Pieter Mulder
2.
Minister of Arts and Culture
Lulu Xingwana
Deputy Minister of Arts and Culture
Paul Mashatile
3.
Minister of Basic Education
Angie Motshekga
Deputy Minister of Basic Education
Enver Surty
4.
Minister of Communications
Siphiwe Nyanda
Deputy Minister of Communications
Dina Pule
5.
Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs
Sicelo Shiceka
Deputy Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs
Yunus Carrim
6.
Minister of Correctional Services
Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula
Deputy Minister of Correctional Services
Hlengiwe Mkhize
7.
Minister of Defence and Military Veterans
Lindiwe Sisulu
Deputy Minister of Defence and Military Veterans
Thabang Makwetla
8.
Minister of Economic Development
Ebrahim Patel
Deputy Minister of Economic Development
Gwen Mahlangu-Nkabinde
9.
Minister of Energy
Dipuo Peters
10.
Minister of Finance
Pravin Gordhan
Deputy Minister of Finance
Nhlanhla Nene
11.
Minister of Health
Dr Aaron Motsoaledi
Deputy Minister of Health
Dr Molefi Sefularo
12.
Minister of Higher Education and Training
Dr Blade Nzimande
13.
Minister of Home Affairs
Dr Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma
Deputy Minister of Home Affairs
Malusi Gigaba
14.
Minister of Human Settlements
Tokyo Sexwale
Deputy Minister of Human Settlements
Zou Kota
15.
Minister of International Relations and Cooperation
Maite Nkoana-Mashabane
Deputy Minister of International Relations and Cooperation (1)
Ebrahim Ismail Ebrahim
Deputy Minister of International Relations and Cooperation (2)
Sue van der Merwe
16.
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development
Jeff Radebe
Deputy Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development
Andries Nel
17.
Minister of Labour
Membathisi Mdladlana
18.
Minister of Mining
Susan Shabangu
19.
Minister of Police
Nathi Mthethwa
Deputy Minister of Police
Fikile Mbalula
20.
Minister of Public Enterprises
Barbara Hogan
Deputy Minister of Public Enterprises
Enoch Godongwana
21.
Minister for the Public Service and Administration
Richard Baloyi
Deputy Minister for the Public Service and Administration
Roy Padayachie
22.
Minister of Public Works
Geoff Doidge
Deputy Minister of Public Works
Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu
23.
Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform
Gugile Nkwinti
Deputy Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform
Dr Joe Phaahla
24.
Minister of Science and Technology
Naledi Pandor
Deputy Minister of Science and Technology
Derek Hanekom
25.
Minister of Social Development
Edna Molewa
Deputy Minister of Social Development
Bathabile Dlamini
26.
Minister of Sport and Recreation
Makhenkesi Stofile
Deputy Minister of Sport and Recreation
Gert Oosthuizen
27.
Minister of State Security
Siyabonga Cwele
28.
Minister in The Presidency (1)
National Planning Commission
Trevor Manuel
29.
Minister in The Presidency (2)
Performance Monitoring and Evaluation as well as Administration in the Presidency
Collins Chabane
30.
Minister of Tourism
Marthinus van Schalkwyk
Deputy Minister of Tourism
Thozile Xasa
31.
Minister of Trade and Industry
Rob Davies
Deputy Minister of Trade and Industry (1)
Thandi Tobias
Deputy Minister of Trade and Industry (2)
Maria Ntuli
32.
Minister of Transport
Sbusiso Joel Ndebele
Deputy Minister of Transport
Jeremy Cronin
33.
Minister of Water and Environmental Affairs
Buyelwa Sonjica
Deputy Minister of Water and Environmental Affairs
Rejoice Mabhudafhasi
34.
Minister of Women, Youth, Children and People with Disabilities
Noluthando Mayende-Sibiya
We stated clearly during the campaign that we want an efficient, caring and effective administration, which will be accessible and responsive to the needs of the people.
We reiterate that we will not tolerate laziness and incompetence, and that we will emphasise excellence and achievement from the Cabinet and the public service.
With these objectives in mind, I am confident that the new structure of government will enable the state machinery to speed up service delivery.
Civil servants will not lose their jobs as a result of these changes. This is a matter of principle in terms of the countrys labour relations dispensation.
I however want to stress to our public servants that the era of hard work has begun. Public servants who do their work diligently and efficiently have nothing to worry about.
I wish the new team all the best with their responsibilities.
We request the South African public and all key sectors of our society to support them in their national service.
Let me also take this opportunity to wish all South African mothers well on Mothers Day today.
Mothers are the backbones of our families, communities and our nation.
We truly appreciate their role in our society, in both the public sphere and within families.
I thank you.
Of course, kama ilivyotegemewa kajenga Ghorofa badala ya Kibanda. Most ministry can be turned into agencies or boards capable of generating adequate income to run themselves without depending on the treasury.
Afirca countries can afford less than the Ministry proposed here. This is too much of a burden not only to the taxpayers but even to the overall leader. Unless of course is a superman capable of coordinating efficiently and effectively 34 ministries. As in Tanzania the chaos just starts here. Too many ministries. The analysis below shows that it is possible for South Africa too to be run by only 14 ministries with the rest being turned into agencies, commissions or boards capable of avoiding red-tape and bureaucracy as well as making money for the people.
The rest of Cabinet in alphabetical order is as follows:
1.
Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Okay!
2.
Minister of Arts and Culture
NO.
Should become a National Agency of Arts, Language and culture and be able to run on its own!
3.
Minister of Basic Education
Okay.
For strategic reasons.
4.
Minister of Communications
Okay. But.....
Should go together with Science and Technology.
5.
Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs
Okay.
For strategic and black empowerment reasons.
6.
Minister of Correctional Services
Can go together with Ministry of Home Affairs.
7.
Minister of Defence and Military Veterans
Okay.
8.
Minister of Economic Development
Repetition and overlaps
9.
Minister of Energy
No.
Should be National Energy Agency capable of developing itself into something capable of self-sustainance.
10.
Minister of Finance
Okay!
11.
Minister of Health
Add Food and Nutrition.
12.
Minister of Higher Education and [Training] HRM.
Okay. But why training and not Human Resource Management and Devleopment?
13.
Minister of Home Affairs
See above. Joined to Correctional Affairs.
14.
Minister of Human Settlements
+ Environment ! here it is where it belongs? It is man who harms the environment not other resources.
15.
Minister of International Relations and Cooperation
Okay.
16.
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development
Shuould be Justice and Constitutional development Commission head enjoying similar perks like Minister. But capable of self-sustainance through various levvies and charges.
17.
Minister of Labour
After HRM linked to Higher education for planning purposes this should be SOUTH AFRICA LABOUR EXCHANGE .... most work being done online with exception of rural areas to be assisted by Rural development ministry.
18.
Minister of Mining
This Should be South African Mining Agency and should be capable of footing its own bill.
19.
Minister of Police
This will be a department in the Home Affairs.
20.
Minister of Public Enterprises
This should be Commission of Public Enterprises and should be maintained by the clients.
21.
Minister for the Public Service and Administration
This should be a Commission of Public Service and Administration---coming up with various training, research and consultancy programmes to the point of making it run on its own income.
22.
Minister of Public Works
Okay. Very strategic. But assist it to create more employment in the rural areas.
23.
Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform
Okay. Strategic.
24.
Minister of Science and Technology
See above. Already attached elsewhere but can establish NATIONAL AGENCY OF INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY (ICT)
25.
Minister of Social Development
Redundant expecially with Women, Children.....and so on already aboard.
26.
Minister of Sport and Recreation
Let it be NATIONAL AGENCY OF SPORTS AND RECREATION DEVELOPMENT and capable of running on its own by promoting individuals, teams/groups so they generate income locally and abroad.
27.
Minister of State Security
Is there no South African CIA what is this for ?
28.
Minister in The Presidency (1)
National Planning Commission
Okay. Strategic.
29.
Minister in The Presidency (2)
Performance Monitoring and Evaluation as well as Administration in the Presidency
NOT a ministry but a section within the National Planning Commission. You plan, show the way, control and then monitor and get feedback,
30.
Minister of Tourism
Why not South African National Tourism Board?
31.
Minister of Trade and Industry
Okay.
32.
Minister of Transport
NO. Instead National Transport Agency.
33.
Minister of Water and Environmental Affairs
Change. Take environment elsewhere. See above. Then create a Ministry of Water, water resources utilisation and irrigation farming.
34.
Minister of Women, Youth, Children and People with Disabilities
Okay.