Are you saying that representatives and personal determination were enough factors to win this election? Do you believe that the electoral results announced by NEC were genuine and accurate?every election is about somebody, thats why even ACT-Wazalendo received a tally of 98,546 votes. The issue is with UKAWA supported who made and declare this election is war against CCM. Little do they know that CCM is not their problem but their representatives and personal determination (refer to Arusha Declaration);
Are you saying that representatives and personal determination were enough factors to win this election? Do you believe that the electoral results announced by NEC were genuine and accurate?
Trying peacefully through a ballot box to take out CCM amounts to a war? Is there anybody in this forum who think this statement makes sense?
Why do you want us to refer to a dead and failed declaration? A declaration whose founder declared that it was a big mistake!!
What about when that willingness and determination is strangled by the government? Personally I was not looking for a government that screw things up. Don't be supercilious, everyone who supported change knew that the government cannot do everything for them.i strongly believe, you need to have faith in the person who represents and when that person is doing their job "representing" you, you also have to be willing and have determination to succeed. You cant send someone to Chamwino or Magogoni St. and just sit at home waiting for miracles.
We have democracy, if you want to take CCM out of power you have to go through the ballot box. War wont resolve anything, if at all it will cause even more uncertainty to those who wants to use it as a means to oust CCM.
the entire declaration IS NOT a failure, some of its elements were not feasible, but majority was good stuff. The reason you want out is because of the those elements which are good but CCM didn't keep/follow.
What about when that willingness and determination is strangled by the government? Personally I was not looking for a government that screw things up. Don't be supercilious, everyone who supported change knew that the government cannot do everything for them.
Nobody said a war is one of the options on the table for the opposition to root out CCM. That's your concept, there is a big difference betwen peaceful protests and wars. We have a failed democracy in this country.
I admit no one knows everything. I have read the Arusha Declaration, there were good principle for leaders to follow, CCM broke some of those elements by not speaking against things like racketeering to name few. In last election racketeering was mentioned as the main reason the public have lost faith in CCM.People want CCM out not because they didn't follow some elements inside some declaration, that could be just a tip of the iceberg, I guess you need more schooling around that area.
In accounting for votes there is a concept called 'Materiality concept'. Now, information is material if its omission or misstatement could influence legitimacy, reliability and completeness of the election results which subsequently affects the emotions of the voters. Ignoring materiality concept in vote tallying process is equal to ignoring the voice of the voters.....when you write gov screwed things up, did you expect 100% trouble free election or .. ? I have never seen a trouble free elections, i have read history books about previous elections, any election has some shortcomings, lets just say if you have over 500 voters anywhere taking part in any type of election there will be some issues.
The purpose of an election is to provide a choice to people on who most of them think should lead them.....The winner is the candidate with majority votes, our constitution does not have provisions for a leader of the government to be elected from the party with majority seats.....My point is that, regardless of the election results in parliamentary levels, the presidential election results does not always coincide with the parliamentary....meaning that a party with less parliamentary seats can win a presidential election and form a government....and the purpose of doing an election is to get a winner who can lead gov, we cant have two or three winners, there will be no point of doing elections. The winner is the party elected by MAJORITY, some opposition parties tend to think that winning party is the one elected by few people
Corruption is not a problem which you can solve expediently by adopting a piece of declaration....you might be providing a wrong prescription to a patient and falsely hoping your sick friend will get well....when you are pursuing a wrong path in these critical areas, that exacerbates rather than mitigating the situation at hand....you can't just cut the branches and sit back and relax, you've got to get the roots of the causes...we are far from there....I admit no one knows everything. I have read the Arusha Declaration, there were good principle for leaders to follow, CCM broke some of those elements by not speaking against things like racketeering to name few. In last election racketeering was mentioned as the main reason the public have lost faith in CCM.
Now, if the question is why CDM put Lowassa on the frontline despite being axed by CCM? Remember that Lowassa was vetted thoroughly by CDM before they accepted him.....however that shift was subject to a litany of debates and that is now a non-issue. The election has now taken place, by all accounts wasn't free and fair and the fifth President has started his job...But we know that after the results have been announced by NEC there is no any legal avenue to forward claim(s) if any through a court process...that's how our justice system works and that is clearly stipulated in the constitution....as a party we decided to rescind Lowassa's party nomination because of racketeering allegations, this was done solely to try to win the public.
There is no doubt that things have changed from 1977 to today...there is more technological development...we have to make sure we have more controls in place because as we think about changing public servants attitude towards corruption, we need to be mindful that unless we address all the stakeholders in this issue we might be chasing a ghost....so, in addition to the traditional techniques you pointed out, we have to employ new and proven techniques.We have a long way to go but this is a good sign and I hope we continue to uphold Arusha Declaration values inside CCM and gov at large.
There are two kinds of non-trouble free elections, man-made and natural. When thousands of illegal votes are transferred to polling stations by CCM, that's man made. When figures in polling stations vs those at NEC differ, that is man-made. When opposition's IT experts are arrested for tallying votes, that is man-made. When votes are rigged by NEC to favour certain candidates, that is man-made. When a heavy rainfall affects the voting process, that's natural. When a candidate with majority support is strangled, that's man made.when you write gov screwed things up, did you expect 100% trouble free election or .. ? I have never seen a trouble free elections, i have read history books about previous elections, any election has some shortcomings, lets just say if you have over 500 voters anywhere taking part in any type of election there will be some issues......and the purpose of doing an election is to get a winner who can lead gov, we cant have two or three winners, there will be no point of doing elections. The winner is the party elected by MAJORITY, some opposition parties tend to think that winning party is the one elected by few people
Peaceful protests are not welcomed by policcm when that kind of protest is threatening their interests. Policcm will always create reasons to deny license for such protest. There issue is no longer whether it is peaceful or violent.well we live in democracy, peaceful protests are welcomed, but your earlier quote didnt indicate that, or pointed that was the case hence my response.
CCM is too corrupt and Lowassa leaving the party doesn't change that fact. Nobody needs hope for a good sign, people need to see actions.I admit no one knows everything. I have read the Arusha Declaration, there were good principle for leaders to follow, CCM broke some of those elements by not speaking against things like racketeering to name few. In last election racketeering was mentioned as the main reason the public have lost faith in CCM.
as a party we decided to rescind Lowassa's party nomination because of racketeering allegations, this was done solely to try to win the public.
We have a long way to go but this is a good sign and I hope we continue to uphold Arusha Declaration values inside CCM and gov at large.
This election is about choosing a different path for our country, We, as the citizens of this country we love, have a choice to make about the path we are going to pursue as a country. There are two candidates on the ?spotlight? with two different paths for our country.
....................................................................................................................................
Attacking Lowassa is trying to make Tanzanians believe that this election is not about a new path for our country?..What the critics fail to understand is that this election is not about Lowassa, it is about us (the citizens)
People with objective minds are so rare in this country...Tanzanians are used to poverty, they have been led to believe that God is the one to blame for their impoverishment.....and that government has nothing to do with their welfare.....
are you implying there were some sort of missing information somewhere?In accounting for votes there is a concept called 'Materiality concept'. Now, information is material if its omission or misstatement could influence legitimacy, reliability and completeness of the election results which subsequently affects the emotions of the voters. Ignoring materiality concept in vote tallying process is equal to ignoring the voice of the voters.....
yes, i agree with you, i think there was a missing word from my statement, i should have written MAJORITY of VOTERS and not Parliamentary seats. Thanks for pointing.The purpose of an election is to provide a choice to people on who most of them think should lead them.....The winner is the candidate with majority votes, our constitution does not have provisions for a leader of the government to be elected from the party with majority seats.....My point is that, regardless of the election results in parliamentary levels, the presidential election results does not always coincide with the parliamentary....meaning that a party with less parliamentary seats can win a presidential election and form a government....
there are many ways of tackling corruption in government, and they spoilers are actually very few people but they cause endless damage to the rest of people in the country. We have to be honest with ourselves and admit first that this is problem is here to stay, all the government can do is to try and limit to what extension of its damage. Some of the reasons for continuity of corruption is development, as a country develop there will be an increase for corruption to thrive especially in sensitive sectors like health, taxation, trade etc.Corruption is not a problem which you can solve expediently by adopting a piece of declaration....you might be providing a wrong prescription to a patient and falsely hoping your sick friend will get well....when you are pursuing a wrong path in these critical areas, that exacerbates rather than mitigating the situation at hand....you can't just cut the branches and sit back and relax, you've got to get the roots of the causes...we are far from there....
I wont speak for CHADEMA, but it is my honest opinion that, they went against their principles but accepting someone there were pointing as a master racketeer, they failed or diagreed on vetting process thats why Dr Slaa left the party, remember?Now, if the question is why CDM put Lowassa on the frontline despite being axed by CCM? Remember that Lowassa was vetted thoroughly by CDM before they accepted him.....however that shift was subject to a litany of debates and that is now a non-issue. The election has now taken place, by all accounts wasn't free and fair and the fifth President has started his job...But we know that after the results have been announced by NEC there is no any legal avenue to forward claim(s) if any through a court process...that's how our justice system works and that is clearly stipulated in the constitution....
well former President Mkapa started war against corruption, we now have agencies like PCCB who are now incharge, looking, investigate and prosecuting corrupt leaders. CCM have started their own war against corrupt leader within CCM. It is hope that normal citizens will stand up against corruption on streets. Everyone need to be involved in this war.There is no doubt that things have changed from 1977 to today...there is more technological development...we have to make sure we have more controls in place because as we think about changing public servants attitude towards corruption, we need to be mindful that unless we address all the stakeholders in this issue we might be chasing a ghost....so, in addition to the traditional techniques you pointed out, we have to employ new and proven techniques.
I understand some of the things you have mentioned but those are recurring stories from oppositions, we have heard same stories since 1995 about CCM rigging elections. What some of the opposition followers fail to understand is, we live in democracy, there will never be trouble free elections, but that should be a reason to discount that a big part of election process was transparent enough for international community to accept. Our aim will always to hit that 100% free and fair elections but as human being we have shortcomings. If i ask you how many counterfeit votes were caught, what figure will you give me?There are two kinds of non-trouble free elections, man-made and natural. When thousands of illegal votes are transferred to polling stations by CCM, that's man made. When figures in polling stations vs those at NEC differ, that is man-made. When opposition's IT experts are arrested for tallying votes, that is man-made. When votes are rigged by NEC to favour certain candidates, that is man-made. When a heavy rainfall affects the voting process, that's natural. When a candidate with majority support is strangled, that's man made.
peaceful rallies are welcome, the police are incharge and if they sense they wont be able to contain the rallies or if for any reason they think they cant give such permits then they will be expected to refuse permission hold these rallies. There is no point for police to act brave and allow political rallying knowing that they will turn violent. I trust police have enough intelligence prior to these kind of activities.Peaceful protests are not welcomed by policcm when that kind of protest is threatening their interests. Policcm will always create reasons to deny license for such protest. There issue is no longer whether it is peaceful or violent.
CCM is too corrupt and Lowassa leaving the party doesn't change that fact. Nobody needs hope for a good sign, people need to see actions.
The point I was trying to make was that when eligible voters are done voting, they've got to trust that their votes will be counted at least most of the time. The problem we have is that, over the course of several years that vital trust is gone because there have been material omissions and misstatements in the electoral results including this year's, making it difficult for people to trust that NEC's results are genuine and not made up. Opposition parties have raised material concerns about misinformation and violation on the side of NEC, but there is no question in anybody's mind including yours that we don't have an independent NEC.....are you implying there were some sort of missing information somewhere?
I appreciate that.....yes, i agree with you, i think there was a missing word from my statement, i should have written MAJORITY of VOTERS and not Parliamentary seats. Thanks for pointing
Let me deal with your specifics:there are many ways of tackling corruption in government, and they spoilers are actually very few people but they cause endless damage to the rest of people in the country. We have to be honest with ourselves and admit first that this is problem is here to stay, all the government can do is to try and limit to what extension of its damage. Some of the reasons for continuity of corruption is development, as a country develop there will be an increase for corruption to thrive especially in sensitive sectors like health, taxation, trade etc.
So, i agree with you that, adaption declaration elements wont solve the problem but we cant discount the even small impact it will have in fight against corruption
In a democracy people agree to disagree, and they work through a process to reach a compromise. Now, you can't get 100% of what you want and I was disheartened that people like Dr. Slaa failed to wrap their brains around that simple concept.....I wont speak for CHADEMA, but it is my honest opinion that, they went against their principles but accepting someone there were pointing as a master racketeer, they failed or diagreed on vetting process thats why Dr Slaa left the party, remember?
In regards to election, I dont agree with you when you say, these elections were "BY ALL ACCOUNTS" free and fair, remember there were 8 candidates, not everyone party will agree that by all account elections were not free and fair, I think pockets of people especially UKAWA followers will agree with your statement that election were not free and fair, AGAIN refer to my previous statements in democracy we are looking at the majority of people accepted election were free and fair and that will stand
well former President Mkapa started war against corruption, we now have agencies like PCCB who are now incharge, looking, investigate and prosecuting corrupt leaders. CCM have started their own war against corrupt leader within CCM. It is hope that normal citizens will stand up against corruption on streets. Everyone need to be involved in this war
Lowassa openly said he had 10M votes while he was given 6M which should have been Magufuli's and that Magufuli was added 2M votes which he were never his, that is more than recurring stories from 1995, that is more than a few troubles in election. That is called outright stealing.I understand some of the things you have mentioned but those are recurring stories from oppositions, we have heard same stories since 1995 about CCM rigging elections. What some of the opposition followers fail to understand is, we live in democracy, there will never be trouble free elections, but that should be a reason to discount that a big part of election process was transparent enough for international community to accept. Our aim will always to hit that 100% free and fair elections but as human being we have shortcomings. If i ask you how many counterfeit votes were caught, what figure will you give me?
What I said is that you cannot expect peaceful rallies everyday, there is no country that has peaceful rallies everytime there is a protest. You cannot steal people's democratic rights and just get away with it through denying people the right to demonstrate, the freedom of assembly. Police intelligence stories are always used against the opposition, I think you should know better.peaceful rallies are welcome, the police are incharge and if they sense they wont be able to contain the rallies or if for any reason they think they cant give such permits then they will be expected to refuse permission hold these rallies. There is no point for police to act brave and allow political rallying knowing that they will turn violent. I trust police have enough intelligence prior to these kind of activities.
CCM is the factory producing corrupt people, so, it is either they shut off production or shift production to clean people. Kingunge told everybody that CCM didn't nominate Magufuli, that people who gathered in that hall were presented with 5 then 3 pocket names from the Chairman and his team. CCM is the same pig with different lipstick.Any political party has bad guys, even in opposition there are number of corrupt guys too. I have faith in President Magufuli I believe is a man we need for times like these hence why CCM nominated him for presidency.
I agree with you NEC is not independent and that is government that is something to do with constitution, the good thing is, we have started making step towards changing/reform our constitution.The point I was trying to make was that when eligible voters are done voting, they've got to trust that their votes will be counted at least most of the time. The problem we have is that, over the course of several years that vital trust is gone because there have been material omissions and misstatements in the electoral results including this year's, making it difficult for people to trust that NEC's results are genuine and not made up. Opposition parties have raised material concerns about misinformation and violation on the side of NEC, but there is no question in anybody's mind including yours that we don't have an independent NEC.....
well, bodies like NEC need to be protected and given enough powers to look after these issue, it will be sad to see NEC being interfered with police, courts, etc. And the fact that you want NEC to be more independent, that means only one thing, MORE POWER to NEC.The last point I wanna make on this is that, I don't find any sense of blocking issues regarding justice in election process not to be settled in a justice system. That always gives NEC extensive powers to disregard the voice of the voters with impunity. Changing these obsolete laws is the first step towards promoting growth in democracy, I know that is not in CCM's interest but as long as it is in the interest of URT, there must be changes around those areas.
i disagree with your first point, as i mentioned earlier, corrupt leader in FACT and FIGURES are very few, the damage however is very big. In CCM for example, CCM has 8.4 million members but the number of people who have been alleged to be involved in corruption they are not more 20. so its a small percentage of people who spoil for everyone in the party. In society at large as well, it is well known that, still its a small number of people but they have huge impact.So, i agree with you that, adaption declaration elements wont solve the problem but we cant discount the even small impact it will have in fight against corruption
Let me deal with your specifics:
First, public servants involved in corruption are so many and they tend to override the system. It has evolved to becoming a way of life in the interactions between the people and the government. If someone could cut that number in half, there could be more progress....
I am yet to see a society or community were there is no corruption, the problem is here because corruption is interpreted in different terms in different societies. A small favour can be regarded as corruption even in Holy community. So, i believe the best we could do is to set examples yes, but a corrupt free society is not attainable.Second, we can't say the problem is here to stay when we are not taking concrete actions to prevent and combat it. We have to set an example, people need to see that it amounts to crime and long jail terms. When we only limit the damage, then suddenly people realizes you know what? may be corruption is not that bad after all..makes it much more difficult to deal with it if people somehow think the government is only concerned with damage limitation..
Corruption is corruption, what I was referring to what the 'scale' of corruption. Even there is a gov tender worth 100 mil the bribe could be the same percentage as 1 mil tender, but the scale is different, you have large scale corruption on 100 mil deal compare to 1 mil albeit it is still corruption. And penalties reflects these scale at the moment.Third, the theory that corruption is directly proportional to development is wrong. According to you, corruption is down during recession and high during recovery. In Tanzania corruption is high in all sectors regardless of the economic situation......
it's true Mwalimu is no longer with us, but I know few people in government who have the same values and spirit of Mwalimu. At present, inside CCM we have some of the AD elements for our members to follow and keep, In government civil servants also have values they need to abide by and some of these values they have to use to conduct business in government were drawn from AD 1977. In short AD elements were not figured out from out of space, these were simple to follow value for any society to strive well, these were humanity values.Lastly, investing time to revive elements of a declaration you keep on mentioning is going to have little or no effect on corruption levels in this country..we don't have the likes of Mwl. Nyerere today in our government to enforce it....
Well, I believe Dr. Slaa followed his instinct, I think he saw an outcome which many inside his old party either refused to accept or were just blinded by the events during election campaign. I understand how he thought it was pointless to fight a loosing war, and for him to step aside was what any person with integrity will do.In a democracy people agree to disagree, and they work through a process to reach a compromise. Now, you can't get 100% of what you want and I was disheartened that people like Dr. Slaa failed to wrap their brains around that simple concept.....
I have heard of several incidents but I can assure you that those events were expected, no one plans or anticipate irregularities but they have to be expected. Whats important is that, those incidents were fewer compare to the majority of election process. Again, in democracy you look for majority, local and international observers testified that the elections were "LARGELY" free and fair. It is the balance, we have largely free and fair elections then the vote counts. (if elections were rendered largely NOT free and fair then that would amount to a problem).When I say election wasn't free and fair I didn't just say that without any proof, I witnessed myself a range of violations that rendered our election not credible...But you don't have to take my word for it, you can go through the reports of independent observers both local and international and get a glimpse....
ok, you point there, EL is problem in position to be heard compare to others but remember in democracy is all about head count, if 7 out 8 people say they were satisfied with elections they win an argument.By the way, you mentioned 8 candidates...I think you forgot that according to NEC, Magufuli and Lowassa garnered 98.43% of the votes while the rest (six) had 1.535% only..you can now understand which party can actually stand out and talk about credibility of this election....
The government is not serious about preventing and combating corruption..I have a series of PCCB and non-PCCB cases to prove that...when you have a system the breed and nurture these people and just go after the petty corruption cases to try to keep up the appearance, you can see how far we are from rooting the problem.....
well, anyone can claim they had 10M votes, have you seen evidence that he had 10M votes? It will be very naive to accuse of anyone of stealing votes if you dont have hard evidence that EL garnered 10M votes. I don't have any reason to believe his claim. Why do you believe him?Lowassa openly said he had 10M votes while he was given 6M which should have been Magufuli's and that Magufuli was added 2M votes which he were never his, that is more than recurring stories from 1995, that is more than a few troubles in election. That is called outright stealing.
I dont think police will forever refuse opposite their right to protest but "sometime" they will refuse permission to do so, and they will do with explanations. Do you remember how many times opposition rallied between 2010 and 2015? over 10, 20, 30? perhaps?What I said is that you cannot expect peaceful rallies everyday, there is no country that has peaceful rallies everytime there is a protest. You cannot steal people's democratic rights and just get away with it through denying people the right to demonstrate, the freedom of assembly. Police intelligence stories are always used against the opposition, I think you should know better.
haha no CCM is a political party and in any successful political party it is expected to have crooks and shady figures, but to say its a factory manufacturing corrupt people, no, its what opposition try to believe. There is a alot of exaggeration going on in opposition parties, so its important to sieve what is a fact from rumour.CCM is the factory producing corrupt people, so, it is either they shut off production or shift production to clean people. Kingunge told everybody that CCM didn't nominate Magufuli, that people who gathered in that hall were presented with 5 then 3 pocket names from the Chairman and his team. CCM is the same pig with different lipstick.
All these cannot explain why we have material omissions and misstatements in the NEC's results both at parliamentary and presidential levels...why NEC announced numbers that doesn't add up, why they have totals exceeding 100% and so forth...I agree with you NEC is not independent and that is government that is something to do with constitution, the good thing is, we have started making step towards changing/reform our constitution.
I think also, the issue of lack of trust on voters side, NEC moved to reassure people that elections will be transparent, I did somewhere that, NEC did 5 things which were crucial and important to raise trust.
First, THEY PRINTED OUT NAMES OF ALL registered voters. this list was put outside all voting centres, 7 days PRIOR to voting. that was first bold and clear move.
SECONDLY, all parties had representatives when the voting was in progress.
THIRD, all parties representatives and international observers were PRESENT during vote counting process.
FOURTH. total number of VOTES and allocations were DISPLAYED outside voting centre, for people to see who they voted for.
FIFTH, after the finish of announcing all vote count, International Observers and Party representatives were ONCE AGAIN to go into a special room and VERIFY all results before signing off winner's certificate (this was done at NEC HQs in Dar)
More powers to make independent rather than conditional decisions...and that's good for the voters and it is definitely good ingredient for democratic growth....the only sense the status quo is making is that we have a wing of CCM conducting an election for us....well, bodies like NEC need to be protected and given enough powers to look after these issue, it will be sad to see NEC being interfered with police, courts, etc. And the fact that you want NEC to be more independent, that means only one thing, MORE POWER to NEC
I'm surprised you are talking of 20! We have thousands of corrupt people in the government, get your facts straight..., I'm not just talking about those big scandals...the government is losing billions if not trillions in a lot more places, in every sector, every Ministry, Department and Local government agency.....i disagree with your first point, as i mentioned earlier, corrupt leader in FACT and FIGURES are very few, the damage however is very big. In CCM for example, CCM has 8.4 million members but the number of people who have been alleged to be involved in corruption they are not more 20. so its a small percentage of people who spoil for everyone in the party. In society at large as well, it is well known that, still its a small number of people but they have huge impact
We need to see action and not just comfortable inaction. There are far too many risks and loses for doing little or nothing.....I am yet to see a society or community were there is no corruption, the problem is here because corruption is interpreted in different terms in different societies. A small favour can be regarded as corruption even in Holy community. So, i believe the best we could do is to set examples yes, but a corrupt free society is not attainable
The point was that all corruptions, small scale and large scale are independent to an economic development....which is not true....Corruption is corruption, what I was referring to what the 'scale' of corruption. Even there is a gov tender worth 100 mil the bribe could be the same percentage as 1 mil tender, but the scale is different, you have large scale corruption on 100 mil deal compare to 1 mil albeit it is still corruption. And penalties reflects these scale at the moment
Name me a few of the few people with the values and spirit of Mwalimu....it's true Mwalimu is no longer with us, but I know few people in government who have the same values and spirit of Mwalimu. At present, inside CCM we have some of the AD elements for our members to follow and keep, In government civil servants also have values they need to abide by and some of these values they have to use to conduct business in government were drawn from AD 1977. In short AD elements were not figured out from out of space, these were simple to follow value for any society to strive well, these were humanity values
I don't have anything new to say about Dr. Slaa except that he is off the politics and that was his choice...Well, I believe Dr. Slaa followed his instinct, I think he saw an outcome which many inside his old party either refused to accept or were just blinded by the events during election campaign. I understand how he thought it was pointless to fight a loosing war, and for him to step aside was what any person with integrity will do
The oppositions did point out material concerns that have been ignored. What do you think local observers like LHRC will say about this election?I have heard of several incidents but I can assure you that those events were expected, no one plans or anticipate irregularities but they have to be expected. Whats important is that, those incidents were fewer compare to the majority of election process. Again, in democracy you look for majority, local and international observers testified that the elections were "LARGELY" free and fair. It is the balance, we have largely free and fair elections then the vote counts. (if elections were rendered largely NOT free and fair then that would amount to a problem)
Even if all of them disagree with NEC's results is there any legal avenue to settle their claim(s)?ok, you point there, EL is problem in position to be heard compare to others but remember in democracy is all about head count, if 7 out 8 people say they were satisfied with elections they win an argument
That's a great conclusion....an answer to PCCB will be constitution reform, as it stands the President appoints PCCB chair and the board, you can see that is a problem It will be hard to go after someone who appointed you to the job. PCCB has to be independent like NEC to avoid impartiality, this can only be done through constitution reform.
well, anyone can claim they had 10M votes, have you seen evidence that he had 10M votes? It will be very naive to accuse of anyone of stealing votes if you dont have hard evidence that EL garnered 10M votes. I don't have any reason to believe his claim. Why do you believe him?
I dont think police will forever refuse opposite their right to protest but "sometime" they will refuse permission to do so, and they will do with explanations. Do you remember how many times opposition rallied between 2010 and 2015? over 10, 20, 30? perhaps?
Magufuli and Kinana both admitted that CCM has many corrupt people, I don't understand why you, a nobody in CCM want to refute that.haha no CCM is a political party and in any successful political party it is expected to have crooks and shady figures, but to say its a factory manufacturing corrupt people, no, its what opposition try to believe. There is a alot of exaggeration going on in opposition parties, so its important to sieve what is a fact from rumour.
JPM was nominated by CCM central committee and general meeting to run for presidency, Kingunge didnt have his man nominated that is why he was not happy but the rest of CCM family accepted JPM's nomination. Sometimes you have to override some of the proceedings to ensure better outcome and I believe is what happened. What mattered the most in the end is we had a RIGHT MAN.
All these cannot explain why we have material omissions and misstatements in the NEC's results both at parliamentary and presidential levels...why NEC announced numbers that doesn't add up, why they have totals exceeding 100% and so forth...
All those steps cannot give answers to raids and confiscation of materials of CDM's IT experts dealing with the tallying process...and/or subsequent similar activity to the independent observers such as the LHRC officials...
All these cannot shed some light on why ZEC's Chairman stopped announcing the results in Zanzibar contrary to the provisions of various sections of the Electoral Acts...
Independent observers were not allowed access to critical rooms during the tallying process...I encouraged you to go through EU observer's report to understand what I'm talking about....
More powers to make independent rather than conditional decisions...and that's good for the voters and it is definitely good ingredient for democratic growth....the only sense the status quo is making is that we have a wing of CCM conducting an election for us....
When NEC is sure it has done justice to every candidate, it shouldn't fear or think it is an interference to clear stuffs with disgruntled candidates through a court process....Many democratic countries have such provisions....
Even if we take your number and say we have 2,000 corrupt figure it is still far small figure compare to millions of government workers across the country. it is still a small amount compare to genuine good people who work daily to make good contribution to the country.I'm surprised you are talking of 20! We have thousands of corrupt people in the government, get your facts straight..., I'm not just talking about those big scandals...the government is losing billions if not trillions in a lot more places, in every sector, every Ministry, Department and Local government agency.....
We need to see action and not just comfortable inaction. There are far too many risks and loses for doing little or nothing.....
The point was that all corruptions, small scale and large scale are independent to an economic development....which is not true....
some people like Pres. Ali Mwinyi, Warioba, Wassira, Msekwa, Msuya etc these people have never been linked to any misappropriation of gov offices or public funds etc.Name me a few of the few people with the values and spirit of Mwalimu....
oll kollekt.I don't have anything new to say about Dr. Slaa except that he is off the politics and that was his choice...
The oppositions did point out material concerns that have been ignored. What do you think local observers like LHRC will say about this election?
Even if all of them disagree with NEC's results is there any legal avenue to settle their claim(s)?
Do you have any evidence that Magufuli received 8M votes and Lowassa 6M??, don't tell me you heard or got that from NECCM!
the question was pointed at you, you were meant to answer it, not me. do you remember how many times UKAWA rallied between 2010 and 2015? when you get the number, sit down and think again, because oppositions tend to be blinded with their belief that the government is biased against them, they even go as far as point they have NEVER been allowed to rally.You don't think because you don't know. There is a lot you don't know about POLICCM.
I never refuse that allegation, read all my posts, I have always openly admitted that in CCM there are crooks. One of them was E Lowassa, your presidential candidate.Magufuli and Kinana both admitted that CCM has many corrupt people, I don't understand why you, a nobody in CCM want to refute that.
well, what i meant by that statement is, if it is necessarly, we will ensure we override our own proceedings and get rid of popular but corrupt candidates like E Lowassa in order to nominate upright and non corrupt candidates like JPM."override some of the proceedings to ensure better outcome" is equal to "override some of the proceedings to ensure we have a candidate that serves our interests". That is the RIGHT MAN.
Take a look at the following highlights:I think you were looking at either ITV or UKAWA numbers, can you produce evidence here? Note: show me NEC official printed form with percentages exceeding 100%
my list was directed at transparency.
Police raided those office for a different reason, as it stands only NEC are allowed to count votes, thats what our Election ACT states, anyone else doing the counting is reliable for arrest, fine and imprisonment. Opposition tend to use these incidents to point to their grieving but the law is there to be kept, If you dont keep the law then you will be arrested. Its only through constitution reform thats when they will be allowed to do their own counting
I understand well your 'majority' concept....Now, if you insist that Tanzania is a typical democratic state, then (a)why is/are the claims(s) or allegation(s) of the candidates dissatisfied with presidential results not heard in the court of law?...(b)Does it mean NEC is so perfect in handling presidential elections?....following on your answers in (a) and (b), (c) why are disputes in electoral results at lower levels such as parliamentary allowed to be settled through a justice system?i have drawn my own conclusions, from reports i have read, i need to make an emphasis that, in democratic states, the simple rule is majority, when majority of people say elections were largely free and fair, that is all matters, obviously we acknowledge there were few incidents but that is to be expected
If CCM's chairman is appointing NEC's chairman, secretary and other top officials....CCM as a party is participating in the election...I will argue that CCM is deciding the elections for the voters...I also, disagree that CCM decided the elections, we had observers from all the world, if there were any major breaches or irregulaties like one party deciding entire election outcome then they would have mentioned it. All was reported were few incidents
What is your basis of assuming 2000 corrupt persons in the government of Tanzania?Even if we take your number and say we have 2,000 corrupt figure it is still far small figure compare to millions of government workers across the country. it is still a small amount compare to genuine good people who work daily to make good contribution to the country
According to you, If anybody says that corruption levels in Malaysia during the 1990's were higher than corruption levels in the same country in 2015, considering the fact that Malaysian economy has grown between 1990 and 2015, that person is lying?again, i said the scale of corruption is directly proportional to economic development, the bribes taken in 1990s arent the same as bribes taken in 2010s, agree?
According to your statement, (1)you think that the prosecutor will jump into every corruption case without considering the weight of his/her evidence?...regardless of your answer in (1)..(2)Don't you think it is necessary to recruit smart advocates who can win a lot of graft cases and help us get back our lost revenues?...regardless of your answers in (1) and (2)....(3) Should we not pursue corruption cases because there are cost involved?Also, like many ordinary citizens, they dont understand how difficult is to prosecute people who are accused of bribe and corruption, It costs more to run these cases on average than the amount which was actually bribed or taken/received. So as easy as it may sound to someone to point at bribe allegation, in reality to prosecute someone is not something as straight forward, and if gov doesnt get it right they might end up losing more money through fine because of damages
Can Magufuli sign new employment contracts with these people to work in his administration?some people like Pres. Ali Mwinyi, Warioba, Wassira, Msekwa, Msuya etc these people have never been linked to any misappropriation of gov offices or public funds etc
majority of local observers said the elections were largely free and fair. LHRC were biased from start with their press statements which clearly showed they were siding with UKAWA supporters, if you remember their offices were raided because there were illegal counting taking place. For those reason, I dont think they will have anything positive to say.