Thanks to Barrick Gold operations: 70 Billions lost in bad mining contracts, Tanzania suffers | JamiiForums | The Home of Great Thinkers

Dismiss Notice
You are browsing this site as a guest. It takes 2 minutes to CREATE AN ACCOUNT and less than 1 minute to LOGIN

Thanks to Barrick Gold operations: 70 Billions lost in bad mining contracts, Tanzania suffers

Discussion in 'Biashara, Uchumi na Ujasiriamali' started by nngu007, Jan 16, 2012.

  1. nngu007

    nngu007 JF-Expert Member

    Jan 16, 2012
    Joined: Aug 2, 2010
    Messages: 15,871
    Likes Received: 56
    Trophy Points: 145
    70 Billions lost in bad mining contracts, Tanzania suffers

    By Tanzania Corruption Tracker System

    The signing of lopsided mining contracts by highly placed government officials is reported to be causing Tanzania financial loss of 50m US dollars (70bn Tanzanian shillings) per annum.

    Since the signing of such contracts ten years ago, Tanzania could be said to have lost 500m US dollars (700bn Tanzanian shillings), quite a staggering sum which could have changed, considerably, the country's economy had such contracts been designed in a way that would have been beneficial to the country.

    The foregoing figure was pointed out by officials of the opposition Chama cha Demokrasia na Maendeleo (Chadema) during their campaign rallies in the run up to the Busanda constituency by-election scheduled for Sunday, May 24th 2009.

    Although the financial figure Tanzania is alleged to have been losing since it first allowed in investors in the mining sector is staggering. Chadema officials' allegation on the massive financial loss was quoted by a privately owned local television station, ITV during its 8pm news bulletin aired on Monday, May 18th 2009.

    The figures are also collaborated by an independent study on Gold Mining in Tanzania commissioned by religious organizations in Tanzania in 2008. According to the report titled: Golden Opportunity; How Tanzania is failing to Benefit from Gold Mining, published by Tanzania's religious organizations, Tanzania Episcopal Conference (TEC), The National Muslim Council (BAKWATA) and the Christian Council of Tanzania (CCT), the combined lost income to Tanzania arising from low royality rate, unpaid corporation tax and alleged tax evasion is at least USD400million over the past seven years.

    'This is a very conservative estimate, in that it does not cover all the gold mining companies or all figures for the past seven years (which are not publicly available). Neither does it cover the financial costs of other tax incentives such as VAT exemption, which are extremely difficult to estimate. These extra revenues could of course provide a huge boost to tackling poverty in Tanzania' the report reads in part.

    The environmental impact of dubious Mining Activities in Tanzania.

    Combined with the allegations of corruption and dubious mining. contracts are the environmental aftermath from the mining operations in Tanzania.

    The environmental impact from Mining operations is not only threatening the social livelihoods of communities living around the mining operations but its negative ramifications to development may be very difficult to determine. One example of such devastating set back to development includes the Toxic spill and environmental disaster which was reported in May 2009 at the Canadian Barrick Gold's North Mara Mine.

    According to well informed sources, chemically contaminated water from the mine's storage pond overflew into the nearby Tigithe River and thereby threatening human, livestock and plants. The overflowing of the water from the pond is said to have been caused by heavy rains that fell in the area and vandalism of the plastic sheeting of the water ponds.

    The local residents from the area however dispute this and attribute the toxic spill to sheer 'negligence' on the part of the Gold Mining Company and government's failure to put large scale Mining Companies under close scrutiny. The Mining Contracts signed under dubious circumstances, involving corrupt government officials, contain claw back provisions that have tacitly compelled the Government to keep a 'hands off' stance from the Mining Companies and thus allowed them to reap the mining resources with minimal interference and less regard for the economic and environmental impacts accruing from mining activities in the Country.

    A Dar es Salaam based investigative English daily, THISDAY quotes the Tarime District Councillor, Mr Agostino 'Neto' Sasi as saying that trees along the river bank are now dying and at least three children and one elderly man have experienced skin problems after coming into contact with the water. "The river has overflowed into the surrounding fields and caused crops such as millet, maize and sorghum also to dry up. At least five cows have died from drinking water from the river."

    The Matongo Ward Councillor, Machage B. Machage said cattle, fish and plants were dying as a result of the chemically contaminated water. He said efforts to seek government assistance by scientifically testing the water had not borne fruits as the latter insisted, after testing the water, that the liquid was safe.

    He however, said that when they asked those who had carried out the tests from the government to drink the water they had claimed to be safe both for human and livestock consumption, they refused!

    Machage said they had asked for government's assistance in testing the water because they did not accept Barrick Gold's continued claim that the water was safe.

    On Monday, Mr Sasi who is a retired Tanzania Peoples Defence Forces soldier told a radio journalist that his belief that the water in their area was contaminated lay in the fact that it had no living things such as fish. He said during his tenure in the army, they had been educated to drink water in the forest if they found it to be containing living things such as fish and other living organisms.

    "Water that is still and does not contain any living organisms is not fit for human consumption", he said in apparent response to a question on what made him think that the water was contaminated when he could not provide scientific evidence.

    What has inflicted people, livestock, fish and plants in Mr Sasi's area is tragic and the environmental degradation it has caused and continues to in its wake will not only take a long time to repair but would also cost the nation heavily.

    Unfortunately this is not the first time that people from the area are complaining about the contamination of water from their area.

    Residents from the area have from time to time raised the red flag, but no one, least of all the government which was in the first place involved in the signing of the contract has shown any interest!

    [​IMG]This is a water hole that was built by Barrick Gold near their North Mara Gold mine on behalf of the local communities. The edge of the mine pit can be seen in the upper left-hand corner. But the water appears milky and dirty and the plants around the water hole are dying.

    The mine's General Manager, Kevin Moxham, has argued that the ongoing violent conflicts with locals is to blame; "we spend a lot of time and resources to deal with crime incidents instead of funding development projects. This also reduces the cake that could have gone into improving the livelihood of the North Mara community, Tarime district and Mara region in general." (Photo By Allan Lissner, 2008)

    Government's detachment from mining problems

    What is however, worrying is that the very government that is dogged with reports of signing dubious contracts and circumstantial evidence of corruption implicating high ranking officials in the Ministry f Minerals and Energy has recently reported to have allowed foreign investors to embark on more dangerous mining, uranium!

    The million dollar question is that if the government cannot ensure that investors take precautionary measures against pollution in the course of their gold mining activities, how is the government going to protect the environment where more dangerous minerals such as uranium is involved?

    We all remember what happened at the Chernobly in Ukraine in 1986 when nuclear power plant had leaks. Although the leaks were finally blocked, but the damage to the environment had already been done. To date, hundreds of children are being born close to the area with various kind of deformity as a result of the leak of the nuclear waste.

    The question that the Tanzanian government ought to ask itself is if the then highly developed Soviet government could not stop the nuclear leak then, how is underdeveloped Tanzania going to succeed when it cannot even handle chemical waste from gold mining as evidenced by the North Mara Mine? Does the government really need to go into mining dangerous minerals such as uranium at this stage without any mechanisms for blocking crevices of corruption in the mining sector?

    [​IMG]The Mwita family lives in Nyamongo next to Barrick's North Mara gold mine.

    The waste rock on the edge of the mining pit can be seen just behind their huts here. Ongoing conflict between the mine and local communities have created a climate of fear for those who live nearby. Since the mine opened in 2002, the Mwita family say that they live in a state of constant anxiety because they have been repeatedly harassed and intimidated by the mine's private security forces and by government police. There have been several deadly confrontations in the area and every time there are problems at the mine, the Mwita family say their compound is the first place the police come looking. During police operations the family scatters in fear to hide in the bush, "like fugitives," for weeks at a time waiting for the situation to calm down. They used to farm and raise livestock, "but now there are no pastures because the mine has almost taken the whole land ... we have no sources of income and we are living only through God's wishes. ... We had never experienced poverty before the mine came here." They say they would like to be relocated, but the application process has been complicated, and they feel the amount of compensation they have been offered is "candy." (Photo by Allan Lissner-, 2008)

    What the present crop of leadership ought to realize is that the Father of the Nation, Mwalimu Julius Nyerere knew the existence of uranium and other minerals immediately the country won its independence. This is because the location of various minerals as we know it today was well documented by Germans during their short spell in the country before the First and Second World Wars.

    But because Mwalimu was then well informed about the politics of minerals through reading and by his close friend, Algerian leader, Mr Ben Bella, he decided that it was better to put all the country's efforts in agriculture while the government trained locals abroad in mining technology.

    It was at this time in the late 1960s that the government came up with what came to be known as the 20 Year Industrialization Programme under which many young Tanzanians were sent to the Eastern European countries where they were trained in metallurgy, production engineering just to mention a few.

    Mwalimu's decision would later be proved right when Nigeria abandoned agriculture after discovering oil, a development that would turn the country into a net food importer instead of an exporter. To date, the western African nation has failed to make good use of its abundant oil resource for its economic development!

    Thus oil would later become a curse to Nigeria just as the abundance of minerals in Sierra Leone (diamond) and the Democratic Republic of Congo have and continue to become a curse to these countries. The DRC continues to be embroiled in endless wars mainly caused by its rich mineral resources which have become a curse rather than a blessing! Where there is corruption and misgovernance, there will be always turmoil and organized chaos.

    By Tanzania Corruption Tracker System
  2. Roulette

    Roulette JF-Expert Member

    Jan 16, 2012
    Joined: Dec 15, 2010
    Messages: 5,618
    Likes Received: 16
    Trophy Points: 0
    Kwanini wasifanye Contract review kama zilivo fanyika nchi zingine?
    Ten years ago gold price ilikua 300 us$, leo iko 1650 us$, more than 500% increase.
    Alafu international best practices zimebadilika pia. The Government has all the ammunition needed to engage in this battle now.

    TIMING JF-Expert Member

    Jan 16, 2012
    Joined: Apr 12, 2008
    Messages: 21,837
    Likes Received: 125
    Trophy Points: 160
    RR everything is done intentionally, kuna watu wako bize kukusanya pesa ya kampeni
  4. Roulette

    Roulette JF-Expert Member

    Jan 16, 2012
    Joined: Dec 15, 2010
    Messages: 5,618
    Likes Received: 16
    Trophy Points: 0
    Sijakataa Mkuu, ila si Bunge lipo? kwa nini walio wachagua wasiwaombi kuweka discussion ya hizo review on the agenda for the next session? Government iulizwe kuhusu hizo contract. Naamini ilikua ni bonge la dili wakati ule ila sasa baada ya 2 major economic crisis Gold imerudi kua the privileged way of treasury kwa nchi nyingi.
    Just thinking: Ukiangalia duniani wengi wanaproduce gold at 500-800/Oz na hata 1000/oz coz bado kuna faida ya 600/Oz minimum. In Tanzania companies zinaproduce sometimes at as low as 350/Oz. So hata tukifanya review hakuna atakae laumu sababu we have passed the cap of attracting investors, we need a sustainable way of mining now. Either by increased taxation or by demanding more CSR (aligned in the National Development plans).
  5. ubun2

    ubun2 Senior Member

    Jan 16, 2012
    Joined: Jun 23, 2011
    Messages: 145
    Likes Received: 1
    Trophy Points: 0
    These mining contracts, and all those other "contracts" that have cost Tanzania go through the AG's office. Even though the nation losses in Billions, few Tanzanian officials pocket the money themselves. How does this system benefit the people of Tanzania?
    The loss people of Tanzania suffer is courtesy of few Tanzanian officials & their friends. The whole system is CORRUPT, nation being looted for almost 30 years!! System is for the corrupt, by the corrupt, to serve the corrupt!!
  6. nngu007

    nngu007 JF-Expert Member

    Jan 16, 2012
    Joined: Aug 2, 2010
    Messages: 15,871
    Likes Received: 56
    Trophy Points: 145
    JK Nyerere was damn bright... alipuchukua nchi aliambiwa kuwa tuna madini hayo hadi Uranium... Yeye akaamua mpango wa kusomesha watanzania nje kwa Masuala ya Madini sababu aliona mabaya ya madini yanayowafanya wanigeria
  7. kichwili

    kichwili Member

    Jan 16, 2012
    Joined: Dec 14, 2008
    Messages: 19
    Likes Received: 0
    Trophy Points: 0
    kweli wajinga ndio waliwao! Angalau hao viongozi wanaosign hiyo mikataba batili wangejinufaisha kiukweli, sio kupokea vijisenti halafu mzungu anafaidi kinoma, yaani hakuna akili kabsaa, cha kushangaza zaidi bado mnawapa kura. Unajijua mwenyewe ingawa bado hujapata pilau au shati la ccm, ulipiga kura ccm, wewe hauna haki ya kulalamika lolote. This goes back to the days of slavery, inasemekana kwamba mzungu wa kwanza alikuwa hana nia ya kununua mtumwa alipopiga nanga, bali waswazi walileta mali wakapiga bei mzungu akachangamkia. Tangu enzi zile exchange rate imekuwa one way ikiwa mzungu anafaidika, mswazi anazorota kwa hiyo lawama ipo pande zote. Made in china kitu gani? Produced in afrika/south america lakini producer hapati kitu, hii ndiyo "international trade", upuuzi mtupu if you ask me. Chakusikitisha ni kwamba hali ilivyo daima haitabadilika mpaka yesu atakaporudi, so prepare for the long ride, ccm daima! Hii ramani imeshachorwa kwa wino, kwahiyo taka usitake tafuta nafasi yako katika huu mfumo ama sivyo utapigwa chini. Wapi umeona mtu mweusi na akili zake hajashughulikiwa? From lumumba, malcolm x, steve biko, wote kwisha kazi, marehemu nyerere alionya kuhusu "neo colonialism" lakini wapi. Mpe mswazi suti mbili tatu dili iko tight, ushawini amekupa funguo kila kitu.
  8. shanature

    shanature JF-Expert Member

    Jan 16, 2012
    Joined: Nov 15, 2010
    Messages: 718
    Likes Received: 27
    Trophy Points: 45
    Picture 001.jpg fanya kama ni mtu umempa shamba lako alime alau ulinganishe apatacho na wewe akulipacho,,,,,toka dola milion taku mwekezaji ana pata mpaka dola elfu 80 mtanzania ndio analipwa hio ni kihalali,,kabisaaa kama ni wewe ungekubali hilo dili,,tafakari chukua hatua tz
  9. Engager

    Engager JF-Expert Member

    Jan 17, 2012
    Joined: Jan 12, 2011
    Messages: 329
    Likes Received: 10
    Trophy Points: 35
    :lol:...........TANZANIA NCHI YA AJABU SANA..........:lol:
  10. Habdavi

    Habdavi JF-Expert Member

    Jan 18, 2012
    Joined: Mar 5, 2011
    Messages: 393
    Likes Received: 25
    Trophy Points: 45
    angalia wenzetu wakenya wana mgodi mmoja tu na umeanza operation novemba mwaka jana lakini kampuni inalipa royalty ya 5% ambayo katika mgawanyo 15% inapewa halmashauri ya wilaya husika yenye mgodi na 85% inakwenda serikalini. Na juu ya yote kampuni inalipa kodi. Hapa kwetu ni wizi mtupu, tukija kushtuka tumeachiwa mashimo tu na huku wezi wachache wakijilia vyao walivyopata kwa wizi.