Mahakama yatupilia mbali mapingamizi ya utetezi, maelezo ya Mohamed Lingw'enya yapokelewa na Mahakama. Kesi kuu kuendelea Des. 15, 2021

[Mshana Jr]

 

[Pulchra Animo]

Kwanza, nitajibu hoja zako kwa kuanzia na hii ya katiba iliyopo ya 1977.

Haki ndani ya katiba ya sasa haziwezi kusimamiwa ni hoja mfu potofu inayotumiwa na watu wasioweza kutazama mambo kwa upana wake.Ni hoja primitive na silaha rahisi kwa 'ignorant'

Katiba ya sasa ni sawa na mgonjwa aliyepo ''ICU'' kwamba mgonjwa hajiwezi wala kujitambua bado unamatumaini anaweza kwenda uani, kujiwekea Oxygen na hata kukusaidia wewe ulikwenda kumsalimu.

Nyerere alisema '' katiba inampa madaraka ya kuwa Dikteta''. Kwa bahati nzuri uadilifu na maadili ya viongozi waliomfuata yaliitetetea katiba. Miaka 5 iliyopita tumethibitisha alichosema Nyerere ni kweli. Katiba haikuweza kujitetea nani angeweza kuitumia kujitetea

Katiba Mpya si suluhisho la matatizo lakini ni hatua muhimu sana. Hakuna katiba iliyokamili duniani lakini zipo zilizo na hali nzuri. Kenya ya leo ni tofauti na sisi kwa haki na uwajibikaji

Kenya CJ anagombea hateuliwi na hafungwi na mtu. Yupo huru kutetea masilahi ya Umma

Majaji wana muda ili kuondoa conflict of interest. Kwamba hawategemewi kuwa katika bodi au taasisi nyingine na hilo linawaweka huru. Fuatilia yanayotokea Kenya

Katiba mpya si kwa ajili ya uchaguzi au tume, bali kurekebisha mifumo dhaifu iliyotakiwa kujisimamia na kusimamia umma zikiwemo taasisi kama Bunge na Mahakama

Vyombo kama DPP, DCI Takukuru ni vya umma kwa ajili ya Umma

Unakumbuka CAG na T 1.5? Kaondolewa na hakuna kilichotokea.
Takukuru ipo Ofisi ya Rais kisheria kabisa. Hadi leo ni malumbano ya T 1.5

Unakumbuka kesi ya Wakurugenzi kuwa wasimamizi wa chaguzi?

Mahakama ikaamua wasimamizi wanaapishwa na hivyo wanatenda haki. Think about that!

kwamba Mahakama ya Tanzania inaamini Mtanzania akila kiapo huyo ni muadilifu kabisa!!!
Hakuna Waziri au katibu mkuu au Mkurugenzi anayefanya ''uhalifu'', wameapa!

Bungeni kuna watu 19 wanalipwa pesa za umma. Ni kupitia mamlaka ya katiba, ipo sheria ya viongozi kutoshtakiwa kwa makosa akiwemo Rais, Waziri mkuu na Spika.
Katika mazingira haya nini unategemea katiba ya 1977 inaweza kufanya tofauti?

Hoja ni nyingi muhimu ni kuelewa katiba mpya inalenga kupunguza uozo iliyopo si kwamba ni mbovu bali ipo taabani.

Kinachoendelea mahakamani ni jambo la heri la kuwafumbua macho Watanzania.
Kuna mengi hawakujua lakini leo wanayaona na hili la kesi ya Mbowe ni jema

Kudhani ni kesi ya Mbowe ni kujidanganya! Yanayoendelea yatamkuta yoyote yule.


JokaKuu Alinda

Kuna watu hamuwezi kuelewa vitu before the fact. Na hili la katiba mtakuja kuliekewa baada ya kupata katiba mpya na kuona matatizo yetu bado yako palepale. Katiba hutafisiriwa na kupindishwa kukidhi matakwa ya walioshika hatamu.

Trust me, kwa nafasi ya Rais, hakuna substitute ya uadilifu. Mkipata president ambaye sio muadilifu, hata kama katiba yenu ingekuwa nzuri kiasi gani lazima mtalia. Tambua kwamba presidents wanaochaguliwa kwa kura ya moja kwa moja ya mwananchi are way too powerful na wana kila resource ya kufanya manipulation na kuweza kuiteka ile mihimili mingine. Kumbuka, mihimili yote mitatu ni political. Presidents wana kawaida ya kujitengenezea makundi imara ya allies kwenye mihimili miwili ya mahakama na bunge. Angalia, kwa mfano, Trump alivyoivuruga Marekani. Kimsingi, Trump alikuwa above the law. As you may know, alikuwa impeached mara mbili, lakini kila mara U.S. Senate ilishindwa kumtia hatiani, kwa sababu alikuwa na allies wa kutosha. Aliyeiokoa Marekani isitumbukie kwenye full dictatorship ni Mike Pence, ambaye alikataa kufuata utashi wa Trump, wa kukataa kuzipokea electoral votes za key swing states. Kama VP angekuwa Rudy Giuliani, with Trump, Marekani ilikuwa imeingia mkenge usio wa kawaida.

 

[Fundi Mchundo]

You’re right, hiyo sio kazi ya diplomatic missions. Ni interference ya wazi kwenye internal affairs za host country!

Seriously? Kuhudhuria tangu lini kumekuwa interference? Kwani mnaogopa wataona nini?

Amandla...

 

[Pulchra Animo]

Seriously? Kuhudhuria tangu lini kumekuwa interference? Kwani mnaogopa wataona nini?

Amandla...

Kabisa! Hiyo ni diplomatic pressure, kwasababu sio customary kwa diplomats kuhudhuria kesi za raia wa host country. Mahakama zetu zina maelfu ya kesi zingine za jinai ambazo ziko kwenye mchakato wa kusikilizwa, lakini hakuna diplomat anayehangaika kuzifuatilia.

 

[LGF]

Kuna watu hamuwezi kuelewa vitu before the fact. Na hili la katiba mtakuja kuliekewa baada ya kupata katiba mpya na kuona matatizo yetu bado yako palepale. Katiba hutafisiriwa na kupindishwa kukidhi matakwa ya walioshika hatamu.

Trust me, hakuna substitute ya uadilifu. Mkipata president ambaye sio muadilifu, hata kama katiba yenu ingekuwa nzuri kiasi gani lazima mtalia. Tambua kwamba presidents wanaochaguliwa kwa kura ya moja kwa moja ya mwananchi are way too powerful na wana kila resource ya kufanya manipulation na kuweza kuiteka ile mihimili mingine. Kumbuka, mihimili yote mitatu ni political. Presidents wana kawaida ya kujitengenezea makundi imara ya allies kwenye mihimili miwili ya mahakama na bunge. Angalia, kwa mfano, Trump alivyoivuruga Marekani. Kimsingi, Trump alikuwa above the law. As you may know, alikuwa impeached mara mbili, lakini kila mara U.S. Senate ilishindwa kumtia hatiani, kwa sababu alikuwa na allies wa kutosha. Aliyeiokoa Marekani isitumbukie kwenye full dictatorship ni Mike Pence, ambaye alikataa kufuata utashi wa Trump, wa kukataa kuzipokea electoral votes za key swing states. Kama VP angekuwa Rudy Giuliani, with Trump, Marekani ilikuwa imeingia mkenge usio wa kawaida.

My friend, you are nuts! Unashabikia Katiba ya Kenya kuwa CJ anaomba kazi kama tunavyoomba ukarani ? You do not know what you are talking about and are clueless about who it is you are tslking about. Ni nani anayemfanya interview katika Wakenya milioni 43? Maybe 5 or 6, sasa hujui hawo interviewers ni kina nani.

Kenya kuna Ukabila wa kutupwa, more ingrained kuliko uccm wetu au uchadema wetu, allegiance kwa makabila is total. It is very fortunate that they are small and equal - dholuo 1.3m hata ukihesabu na kina Heche wana mke huku na huku; Gikuyu wakiwemo Wameru na Wamasai huko huitwa Maasai) 1.5m ; Abaluhya 2m (kina mudavadi, wako wengi hadi Yuganda); kalenjin (na pokot, suk na kipsigis, bonde la ufa) ni 1.7m; Mijikenda (pwani, wagiriama, wadigo hadi Chumbageni, na shifta wa garissa), jumla ni 1m. Akamba (kina Kilonzo Musyoka, wakiwemo Wapare wetu) jumla ni laki 9 tu.

Ili upate 50%+1 uwe Rais, lazima uwe na kabila 7. Ndiyo maana BBI ya Raila ina figurehead President mmoja na Vice-Presidents 2. Exceutive head ni PM, naye ana Vice Premiers 4. Jumla 7 so that kila "kabila tawala" lina mtu wake ale "jikoni". Serkali ni "Counties", Majimbo, kama wanayotaka CHADEMA, kila Jimbo na Mangi wake huitwa Governor.

So, hiyo Application Form yako eti ya kuwaomba uwe Jaji ni daganyatoto tu, wachana nay What matters ni kabila lako, kama huna huna!

Kwa uzoefu wangu (I've seen a fair bit of the world), Tanzania has got the best Constitution in the world. It has the most representative Parliament in the world. We have one of the, if not the, most independent Judiciary(s) in the world, certainly better than the US where each President appoints his own kind each time there is a vacancy (i.e., mmoja akifa, they die in the office, hawastaafu). Ours is better than the German one that gassed 6m Jews (that equals 2 and a half Israels of today) and 3m Russians - whatever they say NOW. It is better than the Australian one that butchered the Aborigines or the Canadian one which murdered the Eskimos. In Africa it is better than that of Chad and Benin snd Tunisia or Congo or Djibouti that you don't even now.

Who gets the credit? ZFZMWCCM, of course.

 

[mangikule]

Kweli mawakili wa Gaidi Mbowe na wenzake ni bure kabisa. Wanafanya court battle kwa kutegemea huruma ya akina Mmawia na tindo

Kweli mawakili wa Gaidi Mbowe na wenzake ni bure kabisa. Wanafanya court battle kwa kutegemea huruma ya akina Mmawia na tindo! Nafikiri ni wakati wa kuanzisha ashtag

#KIBATALA SIO ADVOCATE!!!!

! Nafikiri ni wakati wa kuanzisha ashtag

#KIBATALA SIO ADVOCATE!!!!

 

[Pulchra Animo]

My friend, you are nuts! Unashabikia Katiba ya Kenya kuwa CJ anaomba kazi kama tunavyoomba ukarani ? You do not know what you are talking about and are clueless about who it is you are tslking about. Ni nani anayemfanya interview katika Wakenya milioni 43? Maybe 5 or 6, sasa hujui hawo interviewers ni kina nani.

Kenya kuna Ukabila wa kutupwa, more ingrained kuliko uccm wetu au uchadema wetu, allegiance kwa makabila is total. It is very fortunate that they are small and equal - dholuo 1.3m hata ukihesabu na kina Heche wana mke huku na huku; Gikuyu wakiwemo Wameru na Wamasai huko huitwa Maasai) 1.5m ; Abaluhya 2m (kina mudavadi, wako wengi hadi Yuganda); kalenjin (na pokot, suk na kipsigis, bonde la ufa) ni 1.7m; Mijikenda (pwani, wagiriama, wadigo hadi Chumbageni, na shifta wa garissa), jumla ni 1m. Akamba (kina Kilonzo Musyoka, wakiwemo Wapare wetu) jumla ni laki 9 tu.

Ili upate 50%+1 uwe Rais, lazima uwe na kabila 7. Ndiyo maana BBI ya Raila ina figurehead President mmoja na Vice-Presidents 2. Exceutive head ni PM, naye ana Vice Premiers 4. Jumla 7 so that kila "kabila tawala" lina mtu wake ale "jikoni". Serkali ni "Counties", Majimbo, kama wanayotaka CHADEMA, kila Jimbo na Mangi wake huitwa Governor.

So, hiyo Application Form yako eti ya kuwaomba uwe Jaji ni daganyatoto tu, wachana nay What matters ni kabila lako, kama huna huna!

Kwa uzoefu wangu (I've seen a fair bit of the world), Tanzania has got the best Constitution in the world. It has the most representative Parliament in the world. We have one of the, if not the, most independent Judiciary(s) in the world, certainly better than the US where each President appoints his own kind each time there is a vacancy (i.e., mmoja akifa, they die in the office, hawastaafu). Ours is better than the German one that gassed 6m Jews (that equals 2 and a half Israels of today) and 3m Russians - whatever they say NOW. It is better than the Australian one that butchered the Aborigines or the Canadian one which murdered the Eskimos. In Africa it is better than that of Chad and Benin snd Tunisia or Congo or Djibouti that you don't even now.

Who gets the credit? ZFZMWCCM, of course.

Nilichoandika mimi na ulichoandika wewe vina uhusiano gani, mzee mzima?

 

[gigabyte]

My friend, you are nuts! Unashabikia Katiba ya Kenya kuwa CJ anaomba kazi kama tunavyoomba ukarani ? You do not know what you are talking about and are clueless about who it is you are tslking about. Ni nani anayemfanya interview katika Wakenya milioni 43? Maybe 5 or 6, sasa hujui hawo interviewers ni kina nani.

Kenya kuna Ukabila wa kutupwa, more ingrained kuliko uccm wetu au uchadema wetu, allegiance kwa makabila is total. It is very fortunate that they are small and equal - dholuo 1.3m hata ukihesabu na kina Heche wana mke huku na huku; Gikuyu wakiwemo Wameru na Wamasai huko huitwa Maasai) 1.5m ; Abaluhya 2m (kina mudavadi, wako wengi hadi Yuganda); kalenjin (na pokot, suk na kipsigis, bonde la ufa) ni 1.7m; Mijikenda (pwani, wagiriama, wadigo hadi Chumbageni, na shifta wa garissa), jumla ni 1m. Akamba (kina Kilonzo Musyoka, wakiwemo Wapare wetu) jumla ni laki 9 tu.

Ili upate 50%+1 uwe Rais, lazima uwe na kabila 7. Ndiyo maana BBI ya Raila ina figurehead President mmoja na Vice-Presidents 2. Exceutive head ni PM, naye ana Vice Premiers 4. Jumla 7 so that kila "kabila tawala" lina mtu wake ale "jikoni". Serkali ni "Counties", Majimbo, kama wanayotaka CHADEMA, kila Jimbo na Mangi wake huitwa Governor.

So, hiyo Application Form yako eti ya kuwaomba uwe Jaji ni daganyatoto tu, wachana nay What matters ni kabila lako, kama huna huna!

Kwa uzoefu wangu (I've seen a fair bit of the world), Tanzania has got the best Constitution in the world. It has the most representative Parliament in the world. We have one of the, if not the, most independent Judiciary(s) in the world, certainly better than the US where each President appoints his own kind each time there is a vacancy (i.e., mmoja akifa, they die in the office, hawastaafu). Ours is better than the German one that gassed 6m Jews (that equals 2 and a half Israels of today) and 3m Russians - whatever they say NOW. It is better than the Australian one that butchered the Aborigines or the Canadian one which murdered the Eskimos. In Africa it is better than that of Chad and Benin snd Tunisia or Congo or Djibouti that you don't even now.

Who gets the credit? ZFZMWCCM, of course.

Ukabila ni tatizo la kijamii na haliondolewi kupitia katiba.Katiba ya nchi inashughulika na mienendo na shughuli za nchi kiserikali kwa maana ya siasa na wajibu.sasa sijui ukabila wa kenya unahusikaje na katiba yao.

 

[Fundi Mchundo]

Kabisa! Hiyo ni diplomatic pressure, kwasababu sio customary kwa diplomats kuhudhuria kesi za raia wa host country. Mahakama zetu zina maelfu ya kesi zingine za jinai ambazo ziko kwenye mchakato wa kusikilizwa, lakini hakuna diplomat anayehangaika kuzifuatilia.

Pressure kwa nani? Serikali au Mahakama? Mahakama si iko huru? Jaji ndio muamuzi wa mwisho katika kesi na suala la nani anamsikiliza halipaswi kumstua. Hivi kweli unalinganisha kesi za wizi wa kuku na kesi ya Mwenyekiti wa chama kikubwa cha upinzani!
Hii ni opportunity ya Mahakama kuonyesha kuwa iko juu ya siasa. Kwa mawazo yangu Mahakama ilitakiwa kuirusha live au kuistream kwenye social media kuwahakikishia watanzania kuwa haki inatendeka. Mabalozi nao na dunia nzima wangeweza kuangalia ili kukata mzizi wa fitna.

Amandla...

 

[mgen]

My friend, you are nuts! Unashabikia Katiba ya Kenya kuwa CJ anaomba kazi kama tunavyoomba ukarani ? You do not know what you are talking about and are clueless about who it is you are tslking about. Ni nani anayemfanya interview katika Wakenya milioni 43? Maybe 5 or 6, sasa hujui hawo interviewers ni kina nani.

Kenya kuna Ukabila wa kutupwa, more ingrained kuliko uccm wetu au uchadema wetu, allegiance kwa makabila is total. It is very fortunate that they are small and equal - dholuo 1.3m hata ukihesabu na kina Heche wana mke huku na huku; Gikuyu wakiwemo Wameru na Wamasai huko huitwa Maasai) 1.5m ; Abaluhya 2m (kina mudavadi, wako wengi hadi Yuganda); kalenjin (na pokot, suk na kipsigis, bonde la ufa) ni 1.7m; Mijikenda (pwani, wagiriama, wadigo hadi Chumbageni, na shifta wa garissa), jumla ni 1m. Akamba (kina Kilonzo Musyoka, wakiwemo Wapare wetu) jumla ni laki 9 tu.

Ili upate 50%+1 uwe Rais, lazima uwe na kabila 7. Ndiyo maana BBI ya Raila ina figurehead President mmoja na Vice-Presidents 2. Exceutive head ni PM, naye ana Vice Premiers 4. Jumla 7 so that kila "kabila tawala" lina mtu wake ale "jikoni". Serkali ni "Counties", Majimbo, kama wanayotaka CHADEMA, kila Jimbo na Mangi wake huitwa Governor.

So, hiyo Application Form yako eti ya kuwaomba uwe Jaji ni daganyatoto tu, wachana nay What matters ni kabila lako, kama huna huna!

Kwa uzoefu wangu (I've seen a fair bit of the world), Tanzania has got the best Constitution in the world. It has the most representative Parliament in the world. We have one of the, if not the, most independent Judiciary(s) in the world, certainly better than the US where each President appoints his own kind each time there is a vacancy (i.e., mmoja akifa, they die in the office, hawastaafu). Ours is better than the German one that gassed 6m Jews (that equals 2 and a half Israels of today) and 3m Russians - whatever they say NOW. It is better than the Australian one that butchered the Aborigines or the Canadian one which murdered the Eskimos. In Africa it is better than that of Chad and Benin snd Tunisia or Congo or Djibouti that you don't even now.

Who gets the credit? ZFZMWCCM, of course.

Huwezi Ukafuta Utaifa, Ukabila, na Lugha!
Ndio sababu hata nyani wa India ni Muhindi na nyani wa Afrika ni Mwafrika!

 

[Pulchra Animo]

Pressure kwa nani? Serikali au Mahakama? Mahakama si iko huru? Jaji ndio muamuzi wa mwisho katika kesi na suala la nani anamsikiliza halipaswi kumstua. Hivi kweli unalinganisha kesi za wizi wa kuku na kesi ya Mwenyekiti wa chama kikubwa cha upinzani!
Hii ni opportunity ya Mahakama kuonyesha kuwa iko juu ya siasa. Kwa mawazo yangu Mahakama ilitakiwa kuirusha live au kuistream kwenye social media kuwahakikishia watanzania kuwa haki inatendeka. Mabalozi nao na dunia nzima wangeweza kuangalia ili kukata mzizi wa fitna.

Amandla...

Pressure kwa JMT, ambaye ndiye mlalamikaji. Mbowe hajashitakiwa katika capacity yake ya mwenyekiti wa CDM. Ni kesi ya jinai kama kesi zingine za jinai. Kesi ya Mbowe sio high profile case ya kwanza kusikilizwa na mahakama zetu. Raia wote wa Tanzania wanayo haki ya kupata equal treatment mbele ya sheria; hatupaswi kuwa na first-class citizens wala second-class citizens. Kama hatufanyi streaming kwa kesi zingine, hakuna sababu ya kufanya streaming kwa kesi hii moja tu!

 

[zandrano]

Pressure kwa JMT, ambaye ndiye mlalamikaji. Mbowe hajashitakiwa katika capacity yake ya mwenyekiti wa CDM. Ni kesi ya jinai kama kesi zingine za jinai. Kesi ya Mbowe sio high profile case ya kwanza kusikilizwa na mahakama zetu. Raia wote wa Tanzania wanayo haki ya kupata equal treatment mbele ya sheria; hatupaswi kuwa na first-class citizens wala second-class citizens. Kama hatufanyi streaming kwa kesi zingine, hakuna sababu ya kufanya streaming kwa kesi hii moja tu!

ahsante sana Mkuu kwa kueleza kwa ufasaha.
naamini wafuasi wa Mbowe watakuwa wamekuelewa.

umeongelea suala la "Rule of Law" ktk lugha nyepesi na rahisi zaidi.

 

[Mtoto wa Shule]

Yaani mnadhani tuna imani na hizi mahakama, hivyo mnaamini tuna ujinga huo kuwa mawakili wa utetezi wanashindwa huko mahakamani. Ni kama box la kura hivi sasa, unaona kabisa wapiga kura hawajafika hata 100, kisha matokeo yakitoka unasikia CCM wamepata kura 500. Tulishaamka muda mrefu, upuuzi uliopo kwenye taasisi nyingi za umma, upo mahakamani pia. Hizo ndio dalili za mwisho za chama kupoteza uhalali wa utawala.

Kinachoendelea mahakamani kwasasa kwa sisi wasoma alama za nyakati, tunajua nini kitaenda kutokea kwenye utawala huu wa CCM.

Nakubali Hanna imani na Mahakama ya Tanzania. Nakumbuka baada ya Uchaguzi Mkuu, baadhi ya wafuasi na wapenzi wenu walienda kufungua kesi The Hague mnapopaamini. Hivi hizo kesi ziliishia wapi? Ahahahahahahahah!!!

 

[Tindo]

Nakubali Hanna imani na Mahakama ya Tanzania. Nakumbuka baada ya Uchaguzi Mkuu, baadhi ya wafuasi na wapenzi wenu walienda kufungua kesi The Hague mnapopaamini. Hivi hizo kesi ziliishia wapi? Ahahahahahahahah!!!

Yap hatuna imani na hizo mahakama za Makada wa CCM, zile kesi za the Hague ziliishia ilipoishia Tanzania ya viwanda.

 

[Bome-e]

Aisee!

 

[Yesu Anakuja]

You’re right, hiyo sio kazi ya diplomatic missions. Ni interference ya wazi kwenye internal affairs za host country!

tena interference kwa mahakama, interference kwenye uhuru wa mahakama/rule of law, wakati siku zote huwa wanahubiri respect of the rule of law, ila wao wanavunja, wanaingilia mahakama. hapo ndio utaona unafiki wa wazungu.

 

[Yesu Anakuja]

..Ujerumani wametupa fedha kuboresha mifumo yetu ya sheria. Pia wamekuwa wafadhili wakubwa wa kitivo cha sheria Udsm. Kwa hiyo lazima wafuatilie kinachoendelea.

mifumo ipi ya sheria? majengo ya mahakama yanafadhiliwa na world bank. taja hiyo mifumo ya sheria iliyoboreshwa na wajerumani? kwanza hao walitutawala halafu wanataka kuleta ujinga ningekuwa rais wangenitambua.

 

[JokaKuu]

mifumo ipi ya sheria? majengo ya mahakama yanafadhiliwa na world bank. taja hiyo mifumo ya sheria iliyoboreshwa na wajerumani? kwanza hao walitutawala halafu wanataka kuleta ujinga ningekuwa rais wangenitambua.

..kuna mapitio ya sheria yanafanyika sasa hivi yanafadhiliwa na Ujerumani.

..wakoloni weusi wa Tanu na Ccm wametawala kwa muda mrefu kuliko Wajerumani.

 

[Nguruvi3]

Kuna watu hamuwezi kuelewa vitu before the fact. Na hili la katiba mtakuja kuliekewa baada ya kupata katiba mpya na kuona matatizo yetu bado yako palepale. Katiba hutafisiriwa na kupindishwa kukidhi matakwa ya walioshika hatamu.

Trust me, kwa nafasi ya Rais, hakuna substitute ya uadilifu. Mkipata president ambaye sio muadilifu, hata kama katiba yenu ingekuwa nzuri kiasi gani lazima mtalia. Tambua kwamba presidents wanaochaguliwa kwa kura ya moja kwa moja ya mwananchi are way too powerful na wana kila resource ya kufanya manipulation na kuweza kuiteka ile mihimili mingine. Kumbuka, mihimili yote mitatu ni political. Presidents wana kawaida ya kujitengenezea makundi imara ya allies kwenye mihimili miwili ya mahakama na bunge. Angalia, kwa mfano, Trump alivyoivuruga Marekani. Kimsingi, Trump alikuwa above the law. As you may know, alikuwa impeached mara mbili, lakini kila mara U.S. Senate ilishindwa kumtia hatiani, kwa sababu alikuwa na allies wa kutosha. Aliyeiokoa Marekani isitumbukie kwenye full dictatorship ni Mike Pence, ambaye alikataa kufuata utashi wa Trump, wa kukataa kuzipokea electoral votes za key swing states. Kama VP angekuwa Rudy Giuliani, with Trump, Marekani ilikuwa imeingia mkenge usio wa kawaida.

Sina uhakika kama unaelewa hoja. Kwanza, hakuna katiba 100% duniani zipo zinazokidhi mahitaji 80-90%

Katiba iliyotengenezwa kwa umakini inaziba mianya ya hovyo na kutoa mwelekeo
Katiba haitarajiwi ku solve kila tatizo bali ni msingi wa mifumo (systems) za nchi

Mfano:
-India imewahi kukaa miezi 3 bila Waziri mkuu na nchi ilikuwa salama
-Uingereza ambayo haina katiba iliyoandikwa ilikaa wiki 3 bila Waziri mkuu , salama salimini
-Germany majuzi wamekaa wiki 3 kutafuta muafaka wa nani aongoze baada ya kutopatikana mshindi wa moja kwa moja. Ndivyo ilivyo kwa Israel n.k.

Nchi hizo hazikufanikiwa kwa kubahatisha, ni mifumo ya nchi imara na taasisi zake

Kwa nchi yetu ni tofauti.
Rais anamuondoa CAG kinyume cha sheria kwasababu hakuna chombo kitakachomhoji
Spika ''anawajibika'' kwa Rais kwasababu Rais ambaye ni mwenyekiti wa chama anaweza kumuondoa kwa kupitia ''caucus' au kamati za chama.
CJ anateuliwa na Rais na tumeona kituko cha CJ kuwekwa probation na mhimili wa serikali
NEC inateuliwa na Rais na ndiye anatangaza matokeo ya 'mechi' ya Rais na watu wengine
Msajili wa vyama anateuliwa na kuondolewa na Rais ambaye ni mwenyekiti wa chama
DPP, DCI na Takukuru wanateuliwa na Rais na Takukuru ipo chini ya ofisi ya Rais
Waziri mkuu na VP wote ni wateuliwa wa Rais
Vyombo vyote vya ulinzi na usalama vipo chini yake
Orodha inaendelea hadi kwa maDC na Wakurugenzi wa Halmshauri

Katika hao hakuna 'checks and balances'' . Sauti ya Mwananchi kama mwenye nchi ipo wapi?
Rais ana 'absolute power'

Kautokana na absolute power Rais anaweza ku manipulate pillars na institution za nchi.
Mfano, kuteua majaji na kisha kuweza kuwateua tena baada ya kustaafu kwa kazi nyingine kuna ''compromise'' utendaji wa mahakama na utoaji haki.

Kuhusu US, kuna kitu husemi. Kwamba, Trump amekuwa impeached twice. Matokeo ya impeachment hayahusiani na process. Clinton alitenda kosa lakini halikumuondoa madarakani
Usichanganye kati ya ''process na results''

Pence kukataa ilikuwa kuhofia sheria. Hata leo wanaokataa wito wa kamati za Bunge wanashtakiwa, asikudanganye mtu Trump hakutaka kuondoka lakini mifumo ilikuwa tayari kumbeba akakimbia.

Hebu angalia Biden anavyosumbuka na Senate na House katika kupata pesa au kupitisha miswada
Hata national debt inajadliwa, vipi sisi tunajua nini kuhusu national debt zaidi ya kuona namba?

Kesi ya Mbowe ni muhimu na yenye heri sana, afadhali imetokea. Watu wasioelewa wanaelewa sasa na kila siku matundu yanaonekana. Mhimili wa sheria unapotiliwa shaka haki itapatikana wapi? Kama hakuna haki upendo na amani vinatokeaje?

 

[Pulchra Animo]

Sina uhakika kama unaelewa hoja. Kwanza, hakuna katiba 100% duniani zipo zinazokidhi mahitaji 80-90%

Katiba iliyotengenezwa kwa umakini inaziba mianya ya hovyo na kutoa mwelekeo
Katiba haitarajiwi ku solve kila tatizo bali ni msingi wa mifumo (systems) za nchi

Mfano:
-India imewahi kukaa miezi 3 bila Waziri mkuu na nchi ilikuwa salama
-Uingereza ambayo haina katiba iliyoandikwa ilikaa wiki 3 bila Waziri mkuu , salama salimini
-Germany majuzi wamekaa wiki 3 kutafuta muafaka wa nani aongoze baada ya kutopatikana mshindi wa moja kwa moja. Ndivyo ilivyo kwa Israel n.k.

Nchi hizo hazikufanikiwa kwa kubahatisha, ni mifumo ya nchi imara na taasisi zake

Kwa nchi yetu ni tofauti.
Rais anamuondoa CAG kinyume cha sheria kwasababu hakuna chombo kitakachomhoji
Spika ''anawajibika'' kwa Rais kwasababu Rais ambaye ni mwenyekiti wa chama anaweza kumuondoa kwa kupitia ''caucus' au kamati za chama.
CJ anateuliwa na Rais na tumeona kituko cha CJ kuwekwa probation na mhimili wa serikali
NEC inateuliwa na Rais na ndiye anatangaza matokeo ya 'mechi' ya Rais na watu wengine
Msajili wa vyama anateuliwa na kuondolewa na Rais ambaye ni mwenyekiti wa chama
DPP, DCI na Takukuru wanateuliwa na Rais na Takukuru ipo chini ya ofisi ya Rais
Waziri mkuu na VP wote ni wateuliwa wa Rais
Vyombo vyote vya ulinzi na usalama vipo chini yake
Orodha inaendelea hadi kwa maDC na Wakurugenzi wa Halmshauri

Katika hao hakuna 'checks and balances'' . Sauti ya Mwananchi kama mwenye nchi ipo wapi?
Rais ana 'absolute power'

Kautokana na absolute power Rais anaweza ku manipulate pillars na institution za nchi.
Mfano, kuteua majaji na kisha kuweza kuwateua tena baada ya kustaafu kwa kazi nyingine kuna ''compromise'' utendaji wa mahakama na utoaji haki.

Kuhusu US, kuna kitu husemi. Kwamba, Trump amekuwa impeached twice. Matokeo ya impeachment hayahusiani na process. Clinton alitenda kosa lakini halikumuondoa madarakani
Usichanganye kati ya ''process na results''

Pence kukataa ilikuwa kuhofia sheria. Hata leo wanaokataa wito wa kamati za Bunge wanashtakiwa, asikudanganye mtu Trump hakutaka kuondoka lakini mifumo ilikuwa tayari kumbeba akakimbia.

Hebu angalia Biden anavyosumbuka na Senate na House katika kupata pesa au kupitisha miswada
Hata national debt inajadliwa, vipi sisi tunajua nini kuhusu national debt zaidi ya kuona namba?

Kesi ya Mbowe ni muhimu na yenye heri sana, afadhali imetokea. Watu wasioelewa wanaelewa sasa na kila siku matundu yanaonekana. Mhimili wa sheria unapotiliwa shaka haki itapatikana wapi? Kama hakuna haki upendo na amani vinatokeaje?

Nadhani unaishi kwenye dunia ya kufikirika. Strength ya katiba (na hata ya sheria) bila watawala waadilifu doesn’t exist. Kama Mike Pence angekosa huo uadilifu, Marekani ilikuwa imegota. Hakuna Ibara ya US Constitution inayoilazimisha US Senate kuthibitisha electoral votes za state yoyote. Kama VP (ambaye ndiye president of the US Senate) na US Senate yake wangeamua kuzikataa electoral votes za swing states, Marekani ilikuwa haina ujanja wowote zaidi ya kuwa kwenye impasse ambayo ingempa Trump excuse ya kutangaza state of emergency. Department of Justice (ambayo kimsingi ndiyo ina dhamana ya kulinda rule of law) ni toothless linapokutana na president mhuni kama Trump. Uliona jinsi alivyomtumbua then AG Jeff Sessions kwasababu tu alijiengua katika kusimamia uchunguzi wa interference ya Russia katika US General Election ya 2016. Uliona pia alivyomtumbua then FBI Director James Comey. Where were the US Constitution and Laws when this occurred?

Asikudanganye mtu, ni nchi chache sana ambazo zina judges na CAG ambao sio wateule wa Rais au Prime Minister. Kuwa mteule wa Rais au Prime Minister sio tatizo, provided the appointing authority ni muadilifu. Mahakama nayo ni political institution yenye vulnerabilities zote za political institutions. A rogue president can easily engineer the removal of a strong CJ (hata kama huyo CJ sio mteule wa Rais). Rais anazo resources za kila aina kuwezesha hili kufanyika.

Narudia tena, kwa nafasi ya Rais, hakuna substitute ya uadilifu! Ni sawa tu na jinsi crimes zingine zinavyoendelea kuwepo hata baada ya nchi kuwa na sheria zinazotoa adhabu kali, including the death penalty. Kwa mtu muadilifu, ukimuambia “having an affair with a schoolchild is illegal” inatosha kabisa. Kwa yule ambaye sio muadilifu, hata ukimuambia “the penalty for having an affair with a schoolchild is 30 years of prison time” haitoshi; bado atafanya tu!