Kiongozi gani wa kumlinganisha na hayati Mwl Nyerere katika kuishi maisha simple? | JamiiForums | The Home of Great Thinkers

Dismiss Notice
You are browsing this site as a guest. It takes 2 minutes to CREATE AN ACCOUNT and less than 1 minute to LOGIN

Kiongozi gani wa kumlinganisha na hayati Mwl Nyerere katika kuishi maisha simple?

Discussion in 'Jukwaa la Siasa' started by Zak Malang, Oct 10, 2011.

  1. Zak Malang

    Zak Malang JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Dec 30, 2008
    Messages: 5,410
    Likes Received: 18
    Trophy Points: 0
    Wanajamvi, nimeipata makala hii iliyotoka katika Gazeti la The African la Jumamosi iliyopita. makala ambayo inahoji uadilifu na hali ya kutopenda anasa uko wapi siku hizi ndani ya viongozi wetu wakuu?

    Ni makala iliyotulia kwani inaeleza jinsi Hayati baba wa Taifa hakuweza kulinganishwa na viongozi wengi katika bara hili la Afrika kwa kuonyesha mfano wa kuishi maisha simple.

    Na ndiyo maana aliweka miiko mikali ya viongozi ingawa baada tu ya kuachia madaraka 1985 waliomrithi walitupilia mbali miiko hiyo na kuleta sera za kilafi -- za 'survival of the fittest' sera ambazo madhara yake sasa tuinayabaini hapa nchini kwa uchungu mkubwa:


    Who among the leaders can emulate his life style?


    It never ceases to amaze me – I mean why the Almighty God should elect to be so sparing with His production of good people for leaders of this continent, those with lustrous qualities, instead of scores of scoundrels and bandits whose main pre-occupation after attaining power is to enrich themselves, their families, allies and friends.

    The Kiswahili saying "Penye miti hukosa wajenzi" (literary translation: a place with abundance of trees is usually devoid of builders) is undeniably fitting here. After endowing the continent with a host of natural resources, He handed it to the Mafiosi to lead it. For, why should He deliver only a handful of radiant leaders – about one in every 25 countries and after every after 50 years or so?

    Mwalimu Julius Kambarage Nyerere was one such endowment. He was lionised by the liberal left of the world for his impassioned advocacy of his style of African socialism, but mauled by his critics as a pompous autocrat, whose idealism failed to deliver prosperity to his people.

    To his credit, Nyerere stepped down peacefully and voluntarily, long before it became fashionable – though painfully – for Africa's self-appointed life presidents to subject themselves to the verdict of their peoples in multi-party elections.

    Granted that he had many failings, but he is at least remembered for having provided a moral leadership to Tanzania, and indeed Africa, since the time the continent was taking its first shaky steps after independence.

    As we commemorate twelve years of his departure this coming Friday and (two months hence) 50 years from the night he proudly stood at the National Stadium to take the salute as the Union Jack was being lowered and the new Tanganyika flag of green black and gold raised, let's take a moment to reflect what Mwalimu meant for Tanzania.

    Let's be honest of ourselves – there is something missing within us – a huge leadership vacuum. He must be stirring in his grave to know the type of the leadership we have around: its moral fibre and standing in tatters, good governance and accountability cast to the four winds and the destination of the nation's trajectory unknown.

    I personally foresaw the signs for this for the country about two decades ago when I first visited Mwalimu's Msasani residence in 1992. It was the time I was working as reporter-cum-editorial assistant with The Family Mirror, a fortnightly hothead in English that rarely remained on newsstands for more than a couple of hours after landing.

    The paper was among the first to hit the streets – three years previously following the Government's liberalisation of the media.

    I was among reporters who attended a press conference Mwalimu called to speak his mind about the (in)famous ‘Tanganyika Debate' tabled in Bunge by legislators who had formed G55 bloc.

    After registering our names at the main gate we walked along the worn out tarred drive towards the single-storeyed building standing in the distance. I noticed that the lawns on either side of the drive were screaming for a mower, but above all, the whole place looked desolate and had an eerie atmosphere.

    Well, after all residences for presidents are not places for hectic activity, let alone this one whose occupant was in seventh year of retirement. But uncut grass? Unmanicured lawns? But wait for it.

    As we approached the single-storeyed structure I was struck by its modest appearance. A first I thought it was the servants/administration block and that the real residence was behind it. But that was Mwalimu's Msasani residence built under mortgage from a housing loan.

    It could have been any building in Magomeni or Mwananyamala areas that one comes across and hardly needing a second glance.

    The light green walls were surely in need of paint, some of the windows had their mosquito netting torn, and louvres were broken or missing in some places. As we entered the hall, the dusty terrazzo floor greeted us and I thought, is this really the residence of one of Africa's greatest sons? I'm not finished yet.

    We were ushered into a veranda overlooking the garden and the Indian Ocean in the distance. From the photographs I used to see in the Daily News and Uhuru this is the place where Mwalimu, as President, used to meet and chat with world leaders and other dignitaries.

    His famous rocking chair was at one corner with its back to the sea, and a couple of deep sofas with wide wooden armrests – for the visiting dignitaries – on either side of it. Was Mwalimu suffering from thalassophobia? – the morbid fear of the sea? Else I could not reason why he hated sitting while facing the sea.

    The condition of these pieces of furniture showed that they had seen better days. The leather seat of the rocking chair needed replacement while its woodwork, and that of the sofas would have done with another coat of polish. Well was it probably because he was no longer the Head of State? That fewer and fewer world dignitaries were visiting his residence?

    After we were seated, with some us missing the chairs, Mwalimu came down from the stairs in company of his long time secretary, Joan Wickens, an English lady, then in her twilight years, and another male aide.

    We stood up, all of us shook his hand – it was my first time ever to do so – and waved us to sit down. As the press conference progressed, most of the time my mind was elsewhere – trying to figure out how could this truly famous man – a giant of the African independence struggle, a man who retained his worldwide moral authority even after his vision of rural socialism faltered – live in such undemanding surroundings?

    Besides, his way of living must have been like that during his entire presidency and it explains a lot on why he towered over many other African leaders (if not the entire world) when it comes to questions of morality and unostentatious personal habits. How can a human being elect to be so repugnant to lavish living? For it was there all the time, at the snap of his fingers.

    As I was half listening to Mwalimu's tirades at the G55 for wanting to "break the Union" saying they could only do so over his dead body, anger was building inside me, directed to Government leaders, those he had handed the leadership reins seven years earlier.

    Why did they allow him to live in the neglected surroundings? I very much doubt that he preferred it that way himself, because I couldn't picture him chasing away a group of workmen sent for repairs or men delivering new furniture.

    The next day, the front page leads of many newspapers were on the issue of the condition of Mwalimu's Msasani house and not on what he said about the G55 debate. That must have surprised him as well.

    A few weeks later, on assignment from my editor (Anthony Ngaiza), I revisited Mwalimu's residence for a response from Mama Wickens to our query on whether or not Mwalimu had any objections to the decision by the Dar es Salaam City authorities – then under the mayorship of Kitwana Kondo – to rename the historical Pugu Road – Mwalimu Julius K. Nyerere Road.

    She said yes, Mwalimu objected, at least not when he was still alive. However, the City Fathers simply removed the "Mwalimu Julius K." from the street name plates. Sure, he was not the only Nyerere born into this world.

    During that brief visit I also saw workmen doing renovations to the House, painting it over, replacing louvres etc etc. So they heard the screams from the newspapers!

    But that was perhaps the first and last time the renovations were made to the residence till his death on October 14 1999. Many mourners who went to the residence recounted poignant tales on the pathetic condition of the residence. As people gathered, workmen were busy painting walls, replacing curtains and fixing broken water pipes.

    As I said, only a few leaders in the continent could be compared to him – not even Nelson Mandela. Perhaps the few exceptions include Gen Murtala Mohamed of Nigeria (ruled 1975-76) and Capt Thomas Sankara of Burkina Fasso (1983-87).

    The former liked so much to know how his subjects were living by travelling in an unmarked car in the streets of Lagos. He used to arrive at post offices unannounced and join those in the queue, throwing those he finds into great astonishment after he's recognised. However such style of living brought his death – he was killed in an abortive coup attempt when his car was ambushed in traffic in

    Capt Sankara was the world's poorest president. He was so incorruptible that after his death, a major anti-corruption panel initiated in 1987 by his successor revealed Sankara to have had a salary of only USD 450 a month and his most valuable possessions to be a car, four bikes, three guitars, a fridge and a broken freezer.

    Sankara refused to use the air conditioning in his office on the grounds that such luxury was not available to anyone but a handful of Burkinabes.
    And when asked why he had let it be known that he did not want his portrait hung in public places, as is the norm for other African leaders Sankara said "there are seven million Thomas Sankaras" – i.e. his country's entire population.
    Nyerere was among only a handful of African presidents to voluntarily leave office. He must have seen the futility of his socialist policies and must have sensed the coming clamour for democracy that later swept the continent following the collapse of communist regimes in Eastern Europe and Russia.

    But as he was stepping down, Nyerere declared that although socialism had failed in Tanzania, he would remain a socialist because, he said, he believed socialism to be the best policy for poor countries like Tanzania. His successor decided otherwise, he committed the country to capitalism and the free market, but with debatable benefits to the country – especially the majority poor.

    And that is exactly what Tanzanians are experiencing today. They are already speaking – in low tones – that it was better during his time – even though many would contest that assertion as well.

    But at least there weren't blatant acts of selling our natural resources to foreigners for a song, through dubious contracts signed during weekends in hotel rooms in those foreign lands.

    Mwalimu must have foreseen all that, hence his refusal, during his reign, to have our minerals opened up for exploitation until Tanzanians acquire the expertise to mine them themselves. He must have seen that minerals have brought some African countries to their knees – DRC, Angola, and Sierra Leone.

    During his time with the South Commission he once told a reporter at a press conference: "Small nations are like indecently dressed women. They tempt the evil-minded." Tanzania is undoubtedly a good example.


  2. Zak Malang

    Zak Malang JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Dec 30, 2008
    Messages: 5,410
    Likes Received: 18
    Trophy Points: 0
    Makala imetulia na asemayo Mzee Sued ni ukweli kabisa. Siku hizi wakubwa wakiugua kidogo tu -- hukimbilia nje kwa matibabu. Niliambiwa kuwa hayati Mwalimu alipinga sana kupelekwa London kutibiwa - ila walimlazimisha tu.

    Hivi kweli JKN alijilimbikiza mali
    ? Mwenye taarifa sahihi atujuze.
  3. Gang Chomba

    Gang Chomba JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Feb 29, 2008
    Messages: 8,790
    Likes Received: 810
    Trophy Points: 280
    nyerere anasubiri kwa Kamanda Edward wa ukweli yaani Sokoine.
  4. MkimbizwaMbio

    MkimbizwaMbio JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Nov 16, 2010
    Messages: 872
    Likes Received: 6
    Trophy Points: 0
    Labda RIZ1 akiwa raisi huko mbeleni. lakini kwa hawa waliopo sioni.
  5. B

    Boramaisha JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Apr 29, 2009
    Messages: 820
    Likes Received: 2
    Trophy Points: 0
    Kuna mtu aliyekuwa karibu na JKN aliniambia kwamba huyu Mzee tangu aingie madarakani mwaka 1961 alikuwa hashiki pesa yoyote ile. Fedha zote za mshahara wake kama Rais na marupurupu mengine km per diem wakati akisafiri ndani na nje zilikuwa zikishikwa na kushughulikiwa na wasaidizi wake.

    Kwa mfano mshahara wake ulikuwa ukipelekwa benki, kama ni kutoa pesa benki kwa matumizi yake na ya familia Katibu Myeka (Private Secretary) wake ndiye aliyekuwa anaandika cheque na kwa maelewano maalum na benki aliruhusiwa kuweka sahihi kwenye cheque kwa niaba ya Rais JKN. Vivyo hivyo kwa fedha zinginetaslimu kama hizo per diems walikuwa wakichukua wasaidizi wake kwa niaba yake. Akihitaji kununua chochote kile iwe ni nguo ama kiatu aliwaambia wasaidizi wakamnunulie!

    Akitaka kumpa mwanawe fedha ya matumizi ama akitaka kumpa mtu yoyote msaada wa fedha utaratibu ni huo huo fedha anatoa Private Secretary wake kuwapa wahusika! Hata sadaka ya kwenda kutoa kanisani Rais JKN alikuwa anawekewa kwenye Biblia na kwenda kutoa kanisani. Kwa kifupi ni kwamba alikuwa hashiki fedha yoyote!!!! Hata alipostaafu wasaidizi wake waliendelea kumshikia fedha zake. Huyo ndiye Julius Kambarage Nyerere.

    Fedha kwake hazikuwa msingi wa maendeleo hata kidogo! Kwake Juhudi, Maarifa na Uadilifu ndiyo vilikuwa vitu vya msingi katika kuleta maendeleo si yake yeye bali ya Taifa zima.
  6. Zak Malang

    Zak Malang JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Dec 30, 2008
    Messages: 5,410
    Likes Received: 18
    Trophy Points: 0
    Habari nyingine nilizopata kwa mtu mmoja wa ukoo wa Mwalimu aliyewahi kuishi katika nyumba yake ya Msasani ni kwamba alikuwa hana makuu kabisa.

    Aliniambia kuwa kuna siku maji huwa hayapandi juu katika floor ambako ndiko alikuwa akilala. Asubuhu akigundua maji hakuna basi husimama juu kwenye stairs (ngazi) na humwita huyo jamaa yake, ambaye hupanda hizo stairs na JKN akimuambia; "hawa Waswahili (akimaananisha wafanyakaz wa ndani) vipi leo, naona bado hawajafika, Naomba uniletee maji ya kuoga.

    Huyo jamaa humpokea ndoo (zile za kizamani za aluminium) na kuteremka nayo na kumkingia maji kwenye mabomba ya chini na kupanda nayo stairs, huku JKN, akiwa katika dressing gown lake humpokea ndoo hapo juu ya stairs na kwenda nayo bafuni kwake.

    Huyu huyu jamaa pia alinieleza kuwa JKN alikuwa anapenda sana kusoma vitabu na na pia kujaza crossword puzzle, tena zile ngumu (cryptic puzzles). Akirudi safari hasa kutoka nchi za Ulaya huja na maboksi na maboksi ya vitabu na magazeti yenye hizi crosswords, hata kama ni magazeti ya zamani.
  7. Zak Malang

    Zak Malang JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Dec 30, 2008
    Messages: 5,410
    Likes Received: 18
    Trophy Points: 0

    Yes, Sokoine alikuwa kiongozi mwenza wa JKN katika kuishi simple life style. Ndiyo maana alimpenda sana. Viongozi wetu wa siku hizi na walafi kweli kweli.
  8. H

    HAKI bin AMANI Senior Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Sep 5, 2011
    Messages: 156
    Likes Received: 0
    Trophy Points: 0
    Alikuwa na nyumba ya kizamani ya kuishi Butiama ambayo hata hivyo ilijaa vitabu badala ya fenicha. Walipotaka kumjengea nyumba ya kifahari alikataa kwamba yeye siyo tembo wa kujengewa nyumba kubwa ya kuishi. Hata hivyo ililazimu Jeshi wamjengee nyumba ambayo haikuwa ya kifahari bali kama museum kwa sababu wakati wa ujenzi hakutaka kitu chochote kiharibiwe kama vile miamba mikubwa iliyokuwa sehemu hiyo.
  9. PAMBA1

    PAMBA1 Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Sep 13, 2011
    Messages: 51
    Likes Received: 0
    Trophy Points: 13
    yupo ambaye si kiongozi ila ni mwana CCM mufu dr Rwaitama nimzalendo sana huyu mtu.
  10. T

    Topical JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Dec 3, 2010
    Messages: 5,176
    Likes Received: 11
    Trophy Points: 0
    Nyerere ni BIG time failure

    Nyerere ujamaa wake umefail miserably...

    Uchumi umedorora hadi watu wanavaa ngozi karne hii...wanafulia mizizi karne hii..

    Anyway wale wanaompenda na kumtukuza tunawafahamu wanataka kumpa st. nyerere..let them go ahead..

    Lakini ilikuwa makosa makubwa kuacha nchi miaka 24 kwa mwendawaxxxx
  11. Zak Malang

    Zak Malang JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Dec 30, 2008
    Messages: 5,410
    Likes Received: 18
    Trophy Points: 0

    Mbona unazowea sana kukurupuka kwa kwenda nje ya mada? Mada inasema kiongozi mkuu wa nchi aliyeishi smple life, ambaye hakuwa na tamaa za kujilimbikizia mali.

    Mada haikuzungumzia sera zake -- na hata hivyo mwandishi amegusia kwamba ujamaa aliyotuletea ulishindikana.

    Tafadhali uwe unastick kwenye mada!
  12. Zak Malang

    Zak Malang JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Dec 30, 2008
    Messages: 5,410
    Likes Received: 18
    Trophy Points: 0
    Laiti ingekuwapo, wakati wake, ile Tuzo ya Mo Ibrahim, JKN angeliipata bila wasiwasi wowote. Kuna wakati kamati ya Tuzo hiyo ilitaka kumtunuku JKN tuzo hiyo posthumously, na hii bado imo katoka malengo ya Kamati.
  13. T

    Topical JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Dec 3, 2010
    Messages: 5,176
    Likes Received: 11
    Trophy Points: 0
    Simple life so what? mkuu

    Aliamini katika umaskini akaishi kimaskini..

    Akasababisha kila mwananchi awe maskini ..kwakuwa aliamini ndio njia ya kwenda huko kuzimuxxxx

    Akaleta sera za umaskini, ubaguzi, uchoyo, unyang'anyi na chuki kwa wenye kufanya kazi kwa bidii wakapata pesa halali

    Akaua enteprises na enterprenuar skills za watu..kwa miaka 24...

    It was a big mistake kuwa na rais wa aina hii tena kwa muda mrefu sana unnecessarilly..
  14. Kibukuasili

    Kibukuasili JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: May 15, 2010
    Messages: 858
    Likes Received: 9
    Trophy Points: 35
    Sasa watanzania ndio tunaishi maisha ya nyerere, viongozi wanaishi maisha yao!
  15. trachomatis

    trachomatis JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Jun 7, 2011
    Messages: 3,653
    Likes Received: 93
    Trophy Points: 145
    Topical unayoongea ni kweli.. Hoja yao naamini umeielewa ila huikubali. Labda nikuulize,katika viongozi wa kiafrika walioongoza nchi zao baada ya uhuru yupi umemuona ni kiongozi wa maana zaidi ya huyo JKN?
  16. BAK

    BAK JF-Expert Member

    Oct 10, 2011
    Joined: Feb 11, 2007
    Messages: 70,759
    Likes Received: 82,836
    Trophy Points: 280
    Mkuu CP, hawa waliokuja baada ya Mwalimu mimi huniwia vigumu sana kuwaita Viongozi, maana sioni chochote wanachoongoza zaidi ya ufisadi wa hali ya juu ambao unaifilisi nchi.