Kawambwa anaharibu ubora wa Elimu Tanzania

[SoNotorious]

Hivi elimu ya Tanzania ni kwa mujibu wa maelekezo ya wizara au ni kwa mujibu wa sera ya elimu ?

 

[nsimba]

Kinachofanya ufaulu kuwa juu private VS PUBLIC schools ni

1. Wanachukuwa watoto waliofaulu azidi

2. Miundo mbinu na walimu wakutosha

Hakuna hoja ya kuchuja watahiniwa azide kwa ufaulu wao. Mitihani wa K.2 ukishapima wanaofaulu wanapaswa kuendelea kuelimishwe hadi mitihani wa K4, na ndio sera yetu ya elimu ilivyoelekeza.

Hivyo, wanaotakiwa kuhakikisha kuwa wanafunzi wanasomeshwa vema na kumaliza. Mzazi akichagua kusomesha private hukubali kulipia mamilioni ya fedha Ikiwa ni Ada na mengineyo. Tania ya wamiliki kuweka viwango vya juu kimkakati shuleni ili wanafunzi wasome azide siyo Mbaya. Ubaya viwango hivyo visitumiwe kuwa kigezo cha kufukuza wanafunzi shuleni. Hili linasumbua mzazi kuanzia kutafuta shule mpya mwanafunzi Akiwa K.3 au cha 4. Waziri Yukon sahihi na hili halikubaliki.

 

[Kimweri]

ndio maana wanachukua creme students wanaoelewa kwa haraka ili kwenda na muda. Kumbuka kunawanafunzi wanahitaji nguvu za ziada kufundishwa individualy kitu ambacho private hawataki coz wanaona watapoteza muda!

Kwa hiyo wewe unaona kuchukua wanafunzi wanaoelewa haraka halafu kuendelea kuwachuja ndio njia ya kuongeza viwango vya Elimu Tanzania?

Unaona sahihi average students kunyimwa haki ya kupata elimu?

 

[Kimweri]

hakuna mzazi anayelazimishwa kupelka mtoto wake hizo shule za private ni wazazi wao ndio wanawapeleka hasa baada ya kuona kuwa shule za serikali au mnazoziita za kata hazifanyi vizuri.....

kingine ni kwamba hata kawambwa aseme nini hili tammo lake kwa shule za seminari za kikatoriki amechemka wale watasimamia msimao wao labda hizi private zingine hizi....

Kawambwa akiwajibu hakuna shule inayolazimishwa ku-operate Tanzania hao wamiliki wa shule watajisikia vipi? kwenye biashara kuna kitu kinaitw aku-abuse monopoly. Ndio maana Ulaya kuna anti-trust, ndio maana AT&T marekani ilivunjwa vipande.

Kianchotokea sasa ni Private schools kuwa na monopoly ya Elimu. wameshaua shule za serikali, hivyo wanajua wazazi hawana choice.

sijaui kama una ushahidi unaoonyesha kwa wanafunzi wa private wengi wao ndio wanaofanya vibaya kwa kiwango cha kishindwa kuandika hata barua ya kazi....hili siwezi kulizungumzia maana sina ushahidi nalo... na pi mwl kufundisha shule zaidi ya moja kuna sababu nyingi ikiwa ni pamoja na malipo duni wanayoyapata huko serikalini nk..hili ni tatizo la kimfumo..

You must have very short memory, kwani hapo juu umeandika shule za kata hazifanyi vizuri, kwahiyo hao wanaofanya vizuri shule za private ndio wanaokwenda form 6, right?then wanaokwenda chuo ni wengi zaidi kutoka hizo shule za private.Kwa sababu umeandika affirmative kuwa shule za kata hazifanyi vizuri. Tuchukue kuwa shule za kata anafaulu mwanafunzi mmoja, na private wanafaulu wanafunzi 100.Which means majority of students in universities are private schools products.
Here is where Kimweri comes in, if these private school students were so much better, and were taught very well, why the hell are they perceived as inadequate?why are older students from the said government schools perceived to have had better quality?
nitakupa mfano mmoja mdogo sana. kwa waliosoma Japani watanielewa.

Embassy of Japan in Tanzania - Study in Japan

1. [h=4]Undergraduate Students[/h]*Unfortunately no Tanzanian student has passed the screening for several years.

That is from Japanese Embassy, kwa waliowahi fanya mitihani yao pale embassy miaka ile na waliosoma japani watakubaliana nami kuwa wanafunzi wanaomaliza sasa hivi kutoka hizo privates mlizojazwa illusion kuwa zina kiwango bora cha elimu kuliko government schools ni bomu.
What i see private schools doing is taking best Tanzanian students and waste their future by obsessing on results rather than education.
Do you think it's a coincidence that, Tanzania's best high school students continuously fail to pass that screening for the better part of last decade after Private schools have become no one choice for parents?
Yani nyie mnauziwa mbuzi kwenye gunia halafu mnakenua meno hovyo.hizo shule ziko hapo kufanya biashara, and they will make sure they spend as little as possible to make as much profits as possible. And what better way to spend little than making sure the students you have are already smart enough?and those that you are unsure of, you just threaten them with exams, and if they fail you kick them out?

wastani wa 30% ni mdogo sana...na kama ndio wastani wa serikali basi shule binafsi wasilazimishwe kufata wastani wa serikali....
mzazi kumpeleka mtoto wake shule hata kabla ya matokeo kutoka ni kwa sababu pengine shule husika ina ubora wa hali ya juu na hivyo wazazi wengi kupenda kuwapelka watoto wao hapo so ili kuwahi nafasi basi wanawahi lakini pia hawalazimishwi kufanya hivyo ....mzazi anaweza kusubiri tu matokeo ya serikali na kumpeleka mtoto wake huko....

I never said 30% average was much, what i would have expected to see from private schools, is lobbying with the ministry of education to increase that average.
Hakuna shule Tanzania yenye ubora wa hali ya juu kulinganisha na government schools tulizosoma kina kimweri enzi hizo. Labda kama unamaanisha soseji na chipsi kwenye lunch, na study tours zisizokwisha.
Nimeshaeleza kwa nini wazazi wanalazimika kufanya hivyo, THEY HAVE BEEN GAMED into submission. Mzazi hana choice, na hiyo ndio cost ya monopoly.
Hivi unafiki kila mtanzania anaona raha kulipia DSTV kutazama mpira mara moja kwa wiki?wengi hufanya hivyo kwa kuwa hakuna choice nyengine, Hiyo ndiyo hasara ya monopoly practices.Usiseme shule nyingi, i know that,what i mean is private schools have gamed parents into focusing on shule gani imeongoza kitaifa.so, elimu imebaki kuwa hivyo.

 

[Kimweri]

wewe unatoa mfano wa muhimbili,muhimbili ni hospitali ya serikali,labda ungetolea mfano hospitali ya AMI hapo tungeenda sawa,hizi ni shule za private,hivyo mzazi halazimishwi kupeleka mwanae,cha muhimu hapa ni kuboresha shule za serikali,kuzipa vitendea kazi na walimu.

Hapana, Mfano wa muhimbili fananisha na TMJ au Tumaini, AMI ni kama IST,exclusive.

Utajisikiaje siku ukienda Tumaini ukaambiwa bima yako ya afya haifanyi kazi kwa kuwa huna pesa?na ili utibiwe hapo lazima uwe na Allianz insurance card or IMG card?

Kama shule za private zinajiona ziko exclusive na hazina haja ya kufuata taratibu za wizara ya elimu si vibaya wakajitoa Necta wakaanzisha accreditation body yao, na wakajitungia mitihani yao, then they will see how that will fly. Heck they can even adopt IB.

 

[nyamwenga]

Viwango vya ufaulu shule zote n vimoja tu sasa iweje wao wapandishe Mara 50,70,80 .Ina maana awataki kuwap heshima watu wanao watawala mpaka wakiuke sheria? Futa leseni zao Mr Kawambwa

kwani lengo hasa la wewe na kawambwa ni nini? Maana sioni logic ktk hoja zenu?

 

[nyamwenga]

Kwa hiyo wewe unaona kuchukua wanafunzi wanaoelewa haraka halafu kuendelea kuwachuja ndio njia ya kuongeza viwango vya Elimu Tanzania?

Unaona sahihi average students kunyimwa haki ya kupata elimu?

unajua hata mwanafalsafa wa zamani plato aliwagawa wanafunzi kwa makundi kulingana na uwezo wao darasani hata walimu wanalijua hilo. Unajua ingelikuwa gs ndo zinafanya hicho kinachofanywa na ps mi nadhani mngekuwa mnahoja za kuongea!

Ukipenda boga penda na ua lake ndichokinachofanyika ps, wewe ukiamua kumpeleka mwanao ps kubali na taratibu zao na kama huwezi basi nenda shule za kawambwa!

Ni aibu kwa taifa lenye mpango wa kuinua elimu halafu inataka alama za ufaulu zishushwe hili halikubaliki kabisa. Serikali inapaswa kujiuliza kwnn ps zinafanya vizuri ktk mitihani ya taifa ukilinganisha na gs na sio kuja na hoja mufilisi eti gs zishushe wastani wa alama zao.

Labda km tu unataka kujipima uwezo wako wa kubishana kwa hoja lakn ukweli unaujua kuwa hii hoja ya kawambwa haina tija kabisa kwa elimu yetu ya tz.

 

[Kimweri]

unajua hata mwanafalsafa wa zamani plato aliwagawa wanafunzi kwa makundi kulingana na uwezo wao darasani hata walimu wanalijua hilo. Unajua ingelikuwa gs ndo zinafanya hicho kinachofanywa na ps mi nadhani mngekuwa mnahoja za kuongea!

Ukipenda boga penda na ua lake ndichokinachofanyika ps, wewe ukiamua kumpeleka mwanao ps kubali na taratibu zao na kama huwezi basi nenda shule za kawambwa!

Ni aibu kwa taifa lenye mpango wa kuinua elimu halafu inataka alama za ufaulu zishushwe hili halikubaliki kabisa. Serikali inapaswa kujiuliza kwnn ps zinafanya vizuri ktk mitihani ya taifa ukilinganisha na gs na sio kuja na hoja mufilisi eti gs zishushe wastani wa alama zao.

Labda km tu unataka kujipima uwezo wako wa kubishana kwa hoja lakn ukweli unaujua kuwa hii hoja ya kawambwa haina tija kabisa kwa elimu yetu ya tz.

I would agree if these schools did the same as plato.

Put students according to their level of understanding teach them. mwalimu hakimbii jukumu la kufundisha.

Hoja ya kawambwa iko sahihi, mimi sio mnafki kuping akila kinachosemwa na CCM just for the sake of it.Private schools wakae na MOE wapandishe viwango vya ufaulu vifikie wanvyoona wao vinafaa. Then from then on hakuna biashara ya kila shule kuwa na kiwango chake.

sioni privcate schools zikiongeza kiwango cha elimu tanzania, zaidi ya kuharibu watoto wetu.


Embassy of Japan in Tanzania - Study in Japan

1. Undergraduate Students
   
   *Unfortunately no Tanzanian student has passed the screening for several years.

Pingana na wajapani hao hapo.

Wewe ndio unabisha bila sababu za msingi kwa kuamini illusion ya kuwa kiwango cha elimu kinaongezeka kwa kuwa watoto wako wameenda private na wamfaulu necta kwenda kidato cha sita na baadae chuo kikuu.

Kumbe cha maana walichosoma ni vitabu vya nyambri nyangwine na past papers.

I repeat, Private schools are destroying education in Tanzania by removing a healthy balance that must exist.

 

[mgt software]

Wewe unaongea nini,darasa linakuwa na watoto 45,then 40 wanafanya vizuri,5 wanafeli halafu unasema mwalimu kasababisha,ulitaka nwalimu amfanyie mtihani???hapo ni dhahiri kuwa either mtoto mwenyewe ni mzembe au IQ yake ni zao la mama mbumbumbu,(according to genetics)

Hapo ndipo umeonyesha udhaifu kabisa watoto 45 wanashinda watano 40 zero hapo ni kosa la mwalimu pamoja na vitendea kazi, sio IQ, haiwezekani wamama na mababa wakapeleka watoto 45 watano ndio wajanja au IQ zao za juu wao peke yao hapo kuna ukosefu dhana mdomo kumwelewesha mwanafunzi.

 

[mgt software]

Wewe unaongea nini,darasa linakuwa na watoto 45,then 40 wanafanya vizuri,5 wanafeli halafu unasema mwalimu kasababisha,ulitaka nwalimu amfanyie mtihani???hapo ni dhahiri kuwa either mtoto mwenyewe ni mzembe au IQ yake ni zao la mama mbumbumbu,(according to genetics)

Hapo ndipo umeonyesha udhaifu kabisa watoto 45 wanashinda watano 40 zero hapo ni kosa la mwalimu pamoja na vitendea kazi, sio IQ, haiwezekani wamama na mababa wakapeleka watoto 45 watano ndio wajanja au IQ zao za juu wao peke yao hapo kuna ukosefu dhana mdomo kumwelewesha mwanafunzi.

 

[Shenkalwa]

mtoa mada haufaham trend ya elimu tanzania.kama hauhusiki na maswala ya elimu bora usilete mada hizo.acha wanaohusika na maswala ya elimu ndo walete mada hizo.ningekuwa mimi ningediliti thread yangu.

Mimi naona wewe ndiye una matatizo zaidi. Kitu gani hukuelewa hapo. Njoo na hoja katika mada yenyewe. Wewe elimu ya nchi hii haikuhusu????

 

[annanathaniel]

Sasa kwa Mkoa wa Pwani nani anafaa kuwa waziri? Yule mhuni mliwa tigo wa Kisarawe?

Astakafullah nani huyo tena jamani!!

 

[eddy]

Kwa mtazamo huu kuna siku mtaambiwa mnalazimishwa kupeleka wagonjwa wenu Muhimbili, si muwapeleke India na marekani wakafanyiwe checkup?

You are not getting the big picture. Private schools are systematically destroying government schools by artificially gaming with results because they can. When they can't do this anymore and they are forced to work with students they have within the boundaries that are similar to government schools, the bubble will burst. The distribution of students will go back to normal, where you have best performing students,average performing and ones that will perform poorly. Key to these schools is to make sure this number gets smaller by innovating in teaching, not discarding students they can't teach to be best performers.

mkuu unaweza andika kiswahili wengine ruga ilitupika kando kidogo

 

[mgt software]

Wana JF,

Pokea pongezi kubwa kutoka kwa wadau wa Elimu Tanzania, hapo nyuma wenye shule binafsi walikuwa wanaiba sana mitihani , wengi walifungiwa na wengine fufelishwa vibaya sana, kama mnakumbuka mwaka juzi watu walifeli sana hivyo serikali kupitia mawazo ya Mbunge wa kuteuliwa Mh. Mbatia iliyafanyia kazi na kurekebisha sehemu mbalimbali.

Shule hizi za binafsi nyingi zinakuwa zinafundisha mitiani ambayo wanaipata mapema kwa watu wasiokuwa waaminifu, na pia kujua walimu mhimu ambao huwa wanawapendekeza kwenda kutunga mitiani.

Mbinu nyingine ni kuwakaririsha madara, au kuwafukuza ambao hawafikia viwango, njia hii ilikuwa ya kibiashara zaidi kwa kuwa walengwa ni matajiri tu, ambao kila mwaka wanapandishiwa ada lakini hulipa tu bila kufuatilia kama ni kweli mtoto ana uwezo au anakalili tu.

Kama shule hizi zinafundisha kwa usahihi zaidi mbona wakijiunga na chuo kikuu wakakutana na waliomaliza na kupata Div. II au ambao wana Div. III lakini wanalipiwa na wazazi , mbona huwa wanaishia kuwa wakawaida sana au wengine wanafeli kabisa. Dr. Kawambwa kaza uzi kama hawafuati masharti maanzishe Idara zao wakimaliza wakasomee nje , wakirudi Tanzania tutawapokea tu, ilimradi tuwapime kwanza kama wana uwezo.

 

[eddy]

Ndio shida ya wizara ya elimu kuongozwa na mtu asiye na nasaba na elimu,yeye kaipata kwa bahati mbaya unategemea nini, angependa shule zote zitoe matokeo kama za kata ili seirkali isiendelee kuumbuka, wenye shule binafsi komaa,msikubali kubeba kila kokoro kama ilivyotokea mwake ulee mtoto wa mkubwa iliamiliwa lzima asome FEZA secondary, MWISHO WA SIKU ilikuwa "azungushe", division 4 ya kutafuta kwa torch.

Ukweli ni fedheha kuambiwa mwanao hawezi kufaulu kwa kuwa ni mjinga na hafundishiki, ni fedheha kutumia fedha nyingi kumsomesha mtoto na mwisho wake anafeli, lakini ni fedheha zaidi mtoto kufeli darasani peke yake, tatizo hapa sio kawambwa tatizo ni muuliza swali, tuambieni kwanza huyo mbunge aliyeleta hiyo hoja anaelimu gani ndio tuendelee kujadili, zipo shule ada yake hadi milioni 15 kwa mwaka, sasa kama toto pumbafu si ni bora nilipeleke kinondoni muslim ada laki mbili.

kuna mama mmoja alizaa watoto wawili na baba tofauti, mtoto mmoja alikuwa kipanga darasani, mama aliuza nyumba yake na kumpeleka mtoto kusoma canada, kwa sasa yule mtoto ni meneja katika benki kubwa na alishamnunulia mamayake nyumba nyingine na magari. huyu wa pili mzazi alifanya kila namna ikashindikana ilishalifungulia shamba la kuku na bata mzinga.

kumbuka shule hizi huchukua watoto kutoka familia zenye uwezo, ukae na litoto lipumbavu hakianani litawatia mimba hadi walimu na shule nidhamu itavurugika na shule itakufa. hebu fikiria unaletewa litoto kama Le Mutuz shule itakuwepo kweli?

 

[Job K]

Hapo ndipo umeonyesha udhaifu kabisa watoto 45 wanashinda watano 40 zero hapo ni kosa la mwalimu pamoja na vitendea kazi, sio IQ, haiwezekani wamama na mababa wakapeleka watoto 45 watano ndio wajanja au IQ zao za juu wao peke yao hapo kuna ukosefu dhana mdomo kumwelewesha mwanafunzi.

Naona hujamwelewa!

 

[MPadmire]

Shule za Serikali zimepoteza sifa, umaarufu na ubora....

Shule za serikali zimekuwa sio kitovu cha kutoa wataalamu tena

Shule za Serikali sio kimbilio tena la kupata elimu bora

Heshima ya shule za serikali iko wapi jamani?

 

[nyamwenga]

I would agree if these schools did the same as plato.

Put students according to their level of understanding teach them. mwalimu hakimbii jukumu la kufundisha.

Hoja ya kawambwa iko sahihi, mimi sio mnafki kuping akila kinachosemwa na CCM just for the sake of it.Private schools wakae na MOE wapandishe viwango vya ufaulu vifikie wanvyoona wao vinafaa. Then from then on hakuna biashara ya kila shule kuwa na kiwango chake.

sioni privcate schools zikiongeza kiwango cha elimu tanzania, zaidi ya kuharibu watoto wetu.


Embassy of Japan in Tanzania - Study in Japan

1. Undergraduate Students
   
   *Unfortunately no Tanzanian student has passed the screening for several years.

Pingana na wajapani hao hapo.

Wewe ndio unabisha bila sababu za msingi kwa kuamini illusion ya kuwa kiwango cha elimu kinaongezeka kwa kuwa watoto wako wameenda private na wamfaulu necta kwenda kidato cha sita na baadae chuo kikuu.

Kumbe cha maana walichosoma ni vitabu vya nyambri nyangwine na past papers.

I repeat, Private schools are destroying education in Tanzania by removing a healthy balance that must exist.

mkuu km unapinga alama za ufaulu kuwa juu ktk shule za private then unataka ps wakae na MOE ili kuangalia uwezekano wa kupandisha alama, sasa hapa unachobisha ni nini?

Mimi najua tatizo la elimu ya tanzania sio wala sio alama za ufaulu, yaani hata km watasema alama ziwe asilimia 100 mimi sioni tatizo kwani kupanda na kushuka kwa elimu ya tz tatizo sio alama yaani elimu yetu inamatatizo makubwa sn.

Hoja ya kawambwa ni dhaifu wala hupaswi kuishupalia hadi misuli ikusimame suala la kufeli chuo kikuu hata wa gvnt school wanafeli tena sn tu!

Siioni hoja yako ilipo maana naona unazunguka palepale, hebu nambie kivipi hoja ya kawambwa itaboresha elimu?

 

[nyamwenga]

Ukweli ni fedheha kuambiwa mwanao hawezi kufaulu kwa kuwa ni mjinga na hafundishiki, ni fedheha kutumia fedha nyingi kumsomesha mtoto na mwisho wake anafeli, lakini ni fedheha zaidi mtoto kufeli darasani peke yake, tatizo hapa sio kawambwa tatizo ni muuliza swali, tuambieni kwanza huyo mbunge aliyeleta hiyo hoja anaelimu gani ndio tuendelee kujadili, zipo shule ada yake hadi milioni 15 kwa mwaka, sasa kama toto pumbafu si ni bora nilipeleke kinondoni muslim ada laki mbili.

kuna mama mmoja alizaa watoto wawili na baba tofauti, mtoto mmoja alikuwa kipanga darasani, mama aliuza nyumba yake na kumpeleka mtoto kusoma canada, kwa sasa yule mtoto ni meneja katika benki kubwa na alishamnunulia mamayake nyumba nyingine na magari. huyu wa pili mzazi alifanya kila namna ikashindikana ilishalifungulia shamba la kuku na bata mzinga.

kumbuka shule hizi huchukua watoto kutoka familia zenye uwezo, ukae na litoto lipumbavu hakianani litawatia mimba hadi walimu na shule nidhamu itavurugika na shule itakufa. hebu fikiria unaletewa litoto kama Le Mutuz shule itakuwepo kweli?

hahaa mkuu umenichekesha sn hapo kwa LE MUTUZ.

 

[thegreen]

mtoa mada haufaham trend ya elimu tanzania.kama hauhusiki na maswala ya elimu bora usilete mada hizo.acha wanaohusika na maswala ya elimu ndo walete mada hizo.ningekuwa mimi ningediliti thread yangu.

mkuu minaona kama mwenye uzi kafanya kitu chema, na hajakurupuka kabisa. ni mengiyametokea kwenye sekta ya elimu ambayo kiukweli tukiendelea kuyafumbia macho naona ni dhambi na huko mbeleni historia itatuukumu kwa nini tulikaa kimya. unakumbuka matokea ya kidato cha nne ya mwaka 2012 ambayo yalitoka mwanzoni mwa mwaka 2013 wanafunzi wengi walifeli wengine walichora ma zombie kwa zile booklet na wengine walitungia verse. serikali mwaka huo huo chini ya wizara ya elimu wakafanya mabadiliko ya madaraja yakawa loose kidogo sio kama ya wale wenzao wa mwaka 2012,2011,2010. sikuona kamakuna ulazima wa wahusika wanaoshikilia wa hao kufanya hayo mabadiliko kwani yangeachwa tu ili wenzao waliowaacha shule wakazane. kipindi mimi nasoma wastani wa shule ilikuwa ni 55, mkifaulu au mkifeli shule ilikuwa hailegezi wala kufanya mabadiliko ya madaraja hivyo tulisoma sana. unakumbuka mwaka flani nyuma kuna waziri aliyatoa masomo ya biashara na sijui kuna mwingine alikuja na kuunganisha fizikia na kemia? ila sasa nashukuru physics na chemistry yanajitegemea na bookeeping na commerce yamerudi kwa syllabus. sasa mkuu inaonekana ww unafahamu more kuliko sisi, plz tujuze trend ya elimu ikoje nami atleast nijue.