IIAG's REPORT: Tanzania ni nchi ya KUMI BORA katika Uongozi Afrika 2012

[MsemajiUkweli]

Ukweli husemwa:

Mkuu, report yenyewe ndiyo hiyo, halafu kumbuka Rais ni taasisi, Rais Jakaya Kiwete anaweza akawa hewani lakini kwa vile ni taasisi, uendeshaji wa nchi inakuwa uko active. Halafu tuondoe hii taswira ya kisiasa ya kuwa Rais anasafiri bila sababu yeyote. Hii ni dhana tu ya kisiasa inayojengwa katika jamii kuonyesha kama vile hafanyi kazi za nchi bali za kibinafsi.

[/B];4832365]Uongozi bora au uongozi zero? Hivi tuna uongozi gani Tanzania? Rais ambaye kila kukicha yuko hewani. Call me vuvuzela but I think we are headed to arnachy.

 

[MsemajiUkweli]

Ukweli husemwa:

KIKWETE AMEFOJI DATA ILI ASHINDE ZAWADI YA MO. IBRAHIM

data hizi inaelekea zimetolewa na serikali yenyewe kwa nia niliyoitaja hapo juu kwani they do not reflect reality.

offcourse data hizi ni za kupikwa, ukweli wa Takwimu wanazo watanzania wenyewe ingawaje

unazungumzia human right ndani ya Tanzania hii nenda kawaulize familia za watu wanauwawa kila siku na polisi bila
hata ya kuwepo kesi achana na takwimu feki.

AMEFOJI DATA!!. Kweli?.

Mkuu, hizi data ziko wazi na zimepatikana kutokana na makusanyo ya data katika taasisi 23 za kitaifa na kimataifa. Hizi unazosema ni kama vile porojo.

Ni kweli kuna uvunjifu wa haki za binadamu hapa na pale ndiyo maana nchi haikupewa 100% mark. Ukweli ni ukweli tu na unasimama.

 

[Azipa]

Ukweli husemwa:


Halafu tuondoe hii taswira ya kisiasa ya kuwa Rais anasafiri bila sababu yeyote. Hii ni dhana tu ya kisiasa inayojengwa katika jamii kuonyesha kama vile hafanyi kazi za nchi bali za kibinafsi.

Mkuu, hili suala la rais kiguu na njia siyo hapa Tanzania tu tunalalamika hata Malawi nao wanamlalamikia JB

Halafu JB na JK wana sifa kuu moja, wote ni ombaomba

 

[Azipa]

Ukweli husemwa:



AMEFOJI DATA!!. Kweli?.

Mkuu, hizi data ziko wazi na zimepatikana kutokana na makusanyo ya data katika taasisi 23 za kitaifa na kimataifa..

Salim yupo jikoni kwanini ashindwe kutubeba kwenye ripoti kama hizo.

Ni rahisi tu, mabaya yote anayafagilia chini ya carpet, anaweka mazuri tu mezani ili yakaguliwe. Au kuna mtu anajua huu utafiti unaendeshwaje?

Weka hapa majina ya hizo taasisi. Mbona unazijua wewe tu?

 

[Ngongoseke]

Ukitaka kuijua tz lazima utoke nje ndio utajua uzuri na ubaya wetu, tatizo letu tumekuwa watu wa ajabu kila kitu tunajipima na nchi za magharibi au USA,lakini hatujipimi na waafrica wenzetu,ukitaka kujijua wewe umeendelea kiasi gani basi usimtazame aliembele yako mwangalie alie nyuma yako ndio utajua wewe umeendelea kiasi gani.

 

[MTENDAHAKI]

Ukweli husemwa:


Kwa miaka sita mfululizo, Mo Ibrahim foundation imekuwa ikifanya fahirisi katika nchi zote za Afrika katika maswala ya utawala ambapo mwaka huu imefanya utafiti katika nchi 52 za Afrika.

Kila mwaka imekuwa ikichapisha matokeo ya uchanganuzi wake uliojikita katika maeneo ya Amani na Utawala wa Sheria, Haki za Binadamu, Maendeleo ya Kisiasa na Kiuchumi kwa kushirikiana na mawakala 23 kutoka Afrika na Ulimwenguni kote.


Kwa mara ya kwanza, Tanzania imekuwa ni miongoni mwa nchi kumi bora afrika.


Angalizo:
1) Kwa chapisho hili, Nini matokeo ya madai yaliyowasilishwa na kituo cha Sheria na Haki za Binadamu (LHRC) katika Mahakama ya Uhalifu ya Kimataifa (ICC) na katika Tume ya Afrika ya Haki za Binadamu kutaka kuishitaki serikali kwa ukiukwaji wa haki za binadamu.

2) Kwa chapisho hili, Nini maana ya malalamiko mbalimbali yanayotolewa na baadhi ya Wanaharakati, Wanasiasa na Wananchi kuwa Serikali ya Awamu ya Nne imeshindwa kukidhi matakwa ya wananchi katika utawala bora.




Tanzania's recent performance in the Ibrahim Index of African Governance

Rank (../52)	Category / Sub-Category	Score (../100)	Change
		2006	2007	2008	2009	2010	2011	06-11
10th	Overall	58.4	58.1	58.3	58.4	59.1	58.8	0.4
16th	Safety & Rule of Law	63.5	61.9	63.0	60.7	60.0	62.3	-1.2
19th	Rule of Law	56.5	57.2	56.3	55.3	55.3	55.3	-1.3
20th	Accountability	50.1	47.8	49.6	48.6	47.4	46.6	-3.6
10th	Personal Safety	52.5	52.5	56.3	48.8	47.5	57.5	5.0
13th	National Security	95.0	90.0	90.0	90.0	90.0	90.0	-5.0
9th	Participation & Human Rights	63.4	64.0	56.9	59.6	61.6	62.3	-1.1
15th	Participation	66.3	67.4	54.1	61.4	60.1	62.3	-4.0
18th	Rights	46.6	49.5	46.4	47.8	52.6	52.6	6.0
6th	Gender	77.3	75.0	70.2	69.5	71.9	71.9	-5.4
14th	Sustainable Economic Opportunity	52.4	53.1	57.3	56.7	57.2	54.2	1.8
20th	Public Management	62.6	62.5	64.2	60.6	59.1	57.5	-5.1
23rd	Business Environment	58.9	59.5	60.8	63.9	63.3	56.4	-2.5
22nd	Infrastructure	23.1	23.5	30.9	28.5	32.4	32.8	9.7
7th	Rural Sector	65.1	67.0	73.2	74.1	74.1	70.1	4.9
23rd	Human Development	54.3	53.3	56.1	56.7	57.4	56.4	2.1
27th	Welfare	51.0	51.4	51.8	52.2	52.1	49.2	-1.9
32nd	Education	42.2	44.2	46.0	47.2	46.5	46.5	4.3
17th	Health	69.7	64.3	70.4	70.5	73.5	73.5	3.8

Tanzania: Sub Category Ranks


Data hizi zimepatikana kutoka Mo Ibrahim Foundation.

Ukiwa mtafiti hata hupati taabu kuhusu hii ripoti,"Mean is always affected by extreme values"!angalia rule of law ni ya ngapi,accountability etc vina negative incriment! !vipengele vilivyoubeba wastani ni Gender 6th ,Ruala sector 7th!bado haki za binadamu haziheshimiwi nchi hii!

 

[MsemajiUkweli]

Ukweli husemwa:

Mkuu,
Kwangu mimi kuomba omba siyo kosa, kosa ni pale huo msaada unapotumika isivyo kwa manufaa ya wananchi waliomlipia nauli kwenda kuomba omba.

Ningekuelewa kama kelele zote zingekuwa niza matumizi mabaya ya misaada.

Mkuu, hili suala la rais kiguu na njia siyo hapa Tanzania tu tunalalamika hata Malawi nao wanamlalamikia JB

Halafu JB na JK wana sifa kuu moja, wote ni ombaomba

 

[MsemajiUkweli]

Ukweli husemwa:

Weka hapa majina ya hizo taasisi. Mbona unazijua wewe tu?

Mkuu, anaweza kupata msaada hapa kupitia hii tovuti,
Mo Ibrahim Foundation | Home.

Au kitangulizi hiki,

The 2012 Ibrahim Index of African Governance (IIAG) | Methodology


Introduction
The Ibrahim Index of African Governance (IIAG) is a composite index, constructed by combining underlyingvariables in a standardised way to provide a statistical measure of governance performance in Africancountries. The IIAG was created in recognition of the need for a quantifiable tool to accurately measure andmonitor African governance performance – and its progress over time and across countries – and as a meansof supporting the development of effective and responsive solutions to complex public policychallenges. Policies need to be evaluated by their results, which can only be done if accompanied by rigorousdata. The broad aim of the IIAG is to better inform and sustain the governance debate by providinggovernments, citizens and stakeholders with a practical measurement instrument which is transparent anduser-friendly, and to encourage data-driven narratives on governance issues in Africa.
The IIAG was launched in 2007 and has evolved to be the most comprehensive quantitative assessment ofAfrican governance available. The 2012 IIAG is the sixth iteration and builds on the work of the previous fiveyears (the first two of which the IIAG was housed at the Kennedy School of Government at HarvardUniversity1). The IIAG is conceptually driven by the Mo Ibrahim Foundation Board and the IIAG AdvisoryCouncil2. A sub-set of the Advisory Council sits on a Technical Committee which, along with the IIAG ResearchTeam, is responsible for the methodological and statistical robustness of the IIAG. As a progressive andconsultative project the input and critique of stakeholders is encouraged and appreciated.
The IIAG is structured in such a way that the composite IIAG score is the aggregate of four overarchingcategories which are themselves made up of 14 underlying sub-categories. These sub-categories arecalculated from the scores of 88 indicators (made up of 123 constituent variables) taken from 23 third-partydata providers. These independent data providers include multilateral development banks, think tanks,business risk rating agencies and UN agencies.
Defining Governance
Governance, as defined by the Foundation, is considered from the viewpoint of the citizen. The definition isintentionally broad so as to capture all of the political, social and economic goods and services that any citizenhas the right to expect from his or her state, and that any state has the responsibility to deliver to itscitizens. The IIAG is unique in that it assesses governance by measuring outputs and outcomes. Thisdefinition of governance does not focus on de jure measurements, but rather aims to capture attainments orresults, reflecting the actual status of governance performance in a given context – be it national, regional orcontinental.
1 The 2007 and 2008 versions of the IIAG were compiled under the direction of Professor Robert Rotberg andDr Rachel Gisselquist.
2 A full list of the Mo Ibrahim Foundation Board and IIAG Advisory Council can be found at:

 

[Azipa]

Ukweli husemwa:

Mkuu,
Kwangu mimi kuomba omba siyo kosa, kosa ni pale huo msaada unapotumika isivyo kwa manufaa ya wananchi waliomlipia nauli kwenda kuomba omba.

Ningekuelewa kama kelele zote zingekuwa niza matumizi mabaya ya misaada.

Mimi naona udhaifu wa JK umesababishwa na hii ombaomba hasa kwenye foreign policy.

Kunawakati gazeti la Sunday Times lilishawahiandika Tanzania imesitisha uhusiano na Israel, basi Membe akaitwa ubalozi wa Marekani kuhojiwa kwanini? Membe akajibalaguza huku na kule hadi kufikia kusema hilo gazeti limenunuliwa alisema hilo linawezekana kwasababu Tanzania ilipokea wajumbe kutoka Palestina muda si mrefu

Ukiombaomba unakuwa hauna uhuru wa kufanya maamuzi

 

[MsemajiUkweli]

Ukweli husemwa:

Mimi naona udhaifu wa JK umesababishwa na hii ombaomba hasa kwenye foreign policy.
Ukiombaomba unakuwa hauna uhuru wa kufanya maamuzi

Mkuu,

Ninakubaliana na kauli yako lakini vile vile sikubaliani pale unaposema omba omba inafanya kukosa uhuru wa kufanya maamuzi. Mbona Mwalimu Nyerere alikuwa omba omba zaidi ya Rais Kikwete lakini Mwalimu alikuwa na msimamo usioteteleka katika maamuzi kuhusu foreign policy.

Ni kweli, uwanja wa siasa za kimataifa kipindi cha Mwalimu ni tofauti na wa sasa, lakini vilevile msimamo wa kiongozi wa nchi unachangia kwa kiwango kikubwa katika maamuzi kuhusu siasa za nje.

Watoa misaada kila mara huwa wanapenda kutikisa kiberiti kuona kama njiti zimejaa, lakini wakigundua kama kuna mapungufu, basi hapo ndipo wanapojipenyeza na policy zao

 

[Joste]

Unajua maana ya urais kweli. Linganisha mambo kwa ukweli. Kuwa hewani maana yake nini

 

[Margwe]

Kuzuri ni kule usikofika, huu ni msemo mzuri kwa wote mnaolaumu. Mnajua wazi kuwa waafrika wengi toka nchi nyingine za Afrika hukimbilia Bongo na wanaota wapate urai hapa wakati wenyewe tunapalaumu.

Ukitaka kuona uzuri wa Bongo Tembelea nchi nyingine za Afrika uone jinsi ubabe ulivyo baina ya watawala na watawaliwa, baina ya chama tawala na vyama pinzani, sijakwambia juu ya makabila na kadhalika.

Angalia Uganda na uulize Bisigye yuko wapi, kosa lake ni kuwa mpinzani. Mngekuwa nchi nyingine leo akina Mh SLAA na Prof LIPUMBA wapo kizuizini.

Nyie acheni, maana unamtukana Rais peupe bado unapumua, unaweza kwenda kuishi kokote TZ na ukajisikia nyumbani. Uliza habari za wakikuyu na makabila mengine Hapa jirani Kenya.

Msifieni kijana kajitahidi.

Hapo kwenye red sidhani saaannnnna. Itakuwa hujafanya utafiti vizuri.

 

[tutaweza]

Hah hah hah! Takwimu nyingine bana, yaani Zambia haipo!?
Hizo takwimu ni zile za kwenye makaratasi (sekondary data), yaani hupikika kirahisi tena ukichukulia Tanzania tulivyokuwa na wataalamu wa mapishi!
Wangefanya survey ya wananchi moja kwa moja na tungejua ukweli halisi. Hata watoto wadogo kwa sasa wanajua nchi inaendeshwa kisanii.
Ila hizo takwimu zinawasaidia jamaa kuomba misaada kutoka kwa wahisani ili kujazilia mapungufu ya bajeti (Si wamekosa ubunifu wa kutumia rasilimali zetu katika bajeti ya kujitegemea!)

 

[Domy]

Mkuu, hili suala la rais kiguu na njia siyo hapa Tanzania tu tunalalamika hata Malawi nao wanamlalamikia JB

Halafu JB na JK wana sifa kuu moja, wote ni ombaomba

Wote ni omba omba lakini mbongo amezidi halafu ni mtoto wa kiume,bora yule mwanamke ataonekana anatumia kauli mbiu 'mwanamke akiwezeshwa anaweza' sasa huyu matonya wetu huyu kama si kututia aibu ni nini ndio maana akaambiwa atumie 0713.

 

[raymg]

Hata kwa wajinga hua kuna wakwanza hadi wa mwisho.....so sishangai TZ kuwa ya 10

 

[Okmnaya]

Tanzania imekuwa ya 10 kwa mara ya kwanza hili halina ubishi. Lakini ukilinganisha scores za 2006 na zile 2011 utaona kuwa kuna ukuaji hasi kwenye maeneo mengi. Tafsiri ni kwamba Tanzania ilipata marks nyingi mwaka 2006 kuliko ilivyopata mwaka 2011. Hali ni hiyo hiyo ukilinganisha performance ya 2010 na 2011 unapata mwelekeo huo huo. Kifupi ni kwamba taarifa ya Mo Ibrahimu Foundation inaonyesha kuzorota kwa hali ya utawala bora kwa nchi za Kiafrika. Kilichotokea mwaka huu ni kuwa hata katika darasa la wanafunzi wenye uwezo mdogo sana yupo atakayekuwa wa kwanza na mwingine wa mwisho. Hatupaswi kujivunia kwa kuwa namba 10 kwani kwa ujumla tulikuwa bora zaidi mwaka 2006 kuliko tulivyo sasa.

 

[Okmnaya]

Kwamba Tz imekuwa ya 10 haina maana kuwa hali ya Utawala bora nchini imeimarika. Kiukweli ni kuwa Hali ya sasa (ukiangalia mwenendo wa takwimu ni mbaya katika maeneo mengi kuliko ilivyokuwa 2006. Tafsiri ya taarifa hii ni kwamba hali ya Utawala Bora Afrika (ikiwemo Tz) inazorota. Kwa kuwa kwenye kila kipimo lazima awepo wa kwanza na wamwisho, TZ imekuwa ya 10 japo alama ilizopata ni za chini. Hata kwenye darasa la failures lazima atakuwepo wa kwanza na mwingine wa mwisho.

 

[cr9]

Tanzania kuwa ya kumi katika listi haimaanishi inatawalia vizuri kwa kufuata misingi ya haki za binadamu na maendeleo na usalama kwa watu wake. Ranking hii imetokana na nchi ambazo tumeshindanishwa nazo nani hajui nchi za afrika zilivyo.

Ukichukua wanafunzi vilaza tupu ukawaweka darasa moja lazima kutakuwa na kilaza wa vilaza wote na kipanga ndani ya vilaza. The same kwa vipanga.

Tukitaka ukweli tuiasess tanzania yenyewe peke yake kwa vigezo vilivyoaninshwa alafu tuseme chagua kati 1-5 yani 5 imefanya vizuri na 1 haijafanya vizuri ndiyo utagundua hakuna kitu ni utumbo mtupu