How a deported 'EPA mogul' enjoys Dar's life | JamiiForums | The Home of Great Thinkers

Dismiss Notice
You are browsing this site as a guest. It takes 2 minutes to CREATE AN ACCOUNT and less than 1 minute to LOGIN

How a deported 'EPA mogul' enjoys Dar's life

Discussion in 'Jukwaa la Siasa' started by BAK, May 17, 2009.

  1. BAK

    BAK JF-Expert Member

    May 17, 2009
    Joined: Feb 11, 2007
    Messages: 70,882
    Likes Received: 83,364
    Trophy Points: 280
    How a deported `EPA mogul` enjoys Dar`s life

    By The guardian on sunday Team

    17th May 2009​

    His dodgy deals cost the government $100million in 1994, but he is today walking and living freely in Dar es Salaam despite the Parliamentary recommendations that he should be arrested and prosecuted immediately.

    The man who in 1994 set up and then stole from the debt buy-back programme that is now known as the External Payment Arrears (EPA) account has been living in the country for the last five years despite being declared a prohibited immigrant.

    Vidyadhar G. Chavda, an Indian citizen, first came to Tanzania in 1978 without a penny to his name, according to his own words quoted in a 1994 parliamentary report, but after years of working here as an architect he moved into the finance services industry and orchestrated a number of very lucrative, very shoddy deals.

    Chavda approached the government with his idea for the creation of the Debt Conversion Programme (DCP) - which sought to reduce the country's outstanding debts by selling them off to third parties at discounted prices - the deal that cost the country Sh50bn/- ($100m at that time prevailing exchange rate) in taxpayer money from the programme.

    "I came to this country without a single penny, a beggar…but I came with a brain worth millions of dollars supported by education and exposure," Chavda said after the news of his multibillion-shilling scandal broke in 1994.

    "The DCP funds were brought totally by my idea and efforts," he said at the time. "What I have done is beyond the sphere of understanding Parliament…it is a purely financial issue which nobody is capable of grasping."

    To repair the economic damage caused by his sleazy deals, the Central Bank of Tanzania (BoT) was forced to print billions of shillings in 1994.

    After his scandal was thoroughly investigated by the Parliamentary Committee chaired by Edward Oyombe Ayila, Chavda was finally deported in 1996, though he was not charged with any wrongdoing.

    Despite being deported, Chavda had already caused a strong political rift within the ruling party, and then-minister for home affairs Augustine Mrema resigned because he disagreed with the way the scandal was handled.

    In its recommendations, the Parliamentary Committee advised Chavda's immediate arrest and prosecution for fraud, violation of the Foreign Exchange Act of 1992 and giving false statements contrary to section 122, 309 and 346 of the country's penal code.

    The Committee further recommended that legal action be taken against all traders and lawyers who conspired with Chavda for economic sabotage, and it urged the concerned authorities to cancel the business licenses for those who collaborated with him, including Subhash Patel.

    Surprisingly only one recommendation was implemented - to revoke Chavda's residence permit and deport him - essentially letting him and his partner off the hook.

    He is now back in Tanzania where he has been living in the Masaki suburb of Dar es Salaam for the last five years, according to reliable details obtained by The Guardian on Sunday this week.

    How he played the game
    Having managed to shake the Parliamentary Committee that was formed to investigate him, Chavda carefully planned his comeback in 1997 just three years after he was deported.

    On March 18, 1997, Chavda, acting through his lawyers Mkono & Company, asked the High Court of Tanzania to issue a Witness Summons to allow him to testify on August 5 of that year in a pending civil case brought by his wife against him, Civil Case No 130 of 1993.

    His wife, an Indian citizen who had continued living in Tanzania legally after Chavda was deported, was suing him over a family financial dispute.

    On April 1, 1997, the High Court wrote to the Director of Immigration seeking clarification on the legal position of Chavda's status once he arrived in the country to testify.

    As such, the Director of Immigration informed Mkono & Company on September 25, 1997, that Chavda had been given a visa for 30 days to allow him to enter the country only to testify in court.

    Later findings from the court show, however, that during that 30-day period, the civil case was not scheduled for a hearing and Chavda's claims that he needed to appear in court lacked grounds. His visa expired and he left the country, but with the intention to come back yet again.

    Having identified a loophole in the system that could be exploited, Chavda planned a comeback in January 2002 centred on another ‘necessary' appearance in court.

    Chavda again had his lawyers - this time from the firm Gomba & Tadayo - write to the High Court requesting a Witness Summons to testify in Civil Case No 74 of 1996, a separate civil case filed by the National Bank of Commerce against him for an alleged 800m/- in outstanding loan repayments.

    He was again allowed to enter the country after being given Entry Visa No 0000695 dated March 4, 2002. Chavda should have left within 28 days of the visa's issuance, but he had stayed almost a year until the Director of Immigration caught on and ordered him to leave the country immediately.

    According to details in our possession, Chavda then filed Miscellaneous Civil Case No 60 of 2003 asking the court to force the immigration department to grant him a visa so that he could testify in the two civil cases facing him.

    On March 11, 2004, the High Court issued its ruling in Chavda's favour, ordering the Director of Immigration to issue a two-year visa to the deportee.

    One senior immigration official in Dar es Salaam told The Guardian on Sunday this week that the decision to grant Chavda the visa was both illogical and indefensible.

    "The law is very clear; he should be outside the country and is only allowed to come once needed or summoned by the court," said the official, who asked for anonymity on the grounds that he is not the department's official spokesperson.

    "A hearing can't take two years, it is just one or a few weeks as long as the pending cases are civil cases."

    Chavda's two-year visa expired in April 2006, but again neither of the two cases had been heard, and not even preliminary hearings had been held for either of them.

    Following of the expiry of his visa, the office of the Attorney General wrote a letter on May 6, 2006, directing the Director of Immigration to act accordingly.

    "Since the ruling date was March 11, 2004 then the time for stay in Tanzania has elapsed, and given the fact that Chavda didn't appeal against the decision, now act according to the law on this issue," reads part of the letter signed by D.L Chidowu on behalf of the AG.

    Despite the AG's letter, the immigration department has still not taken any action against Chavda.

    In a May 25, 2007, letter to Professor Abdullah Safari of Safari Law Chambers - Chavda's newest lawyer - the AG's office wrote that it seemed the ministry of home affairs had flipped its position on the matter and was complicit in allowing Chavda to remain in the country.

    "The issue of Chavda has taxed much this office. We as advocates of the government and chief legal advisers did our best to defend the position of the government in court to declare Chavda a prohibited immigrant…however it is now clear that the parent ministry [home affairs] has changed its previous position," reads part of the letter signed by P. J Ngwembe on behalf of the AG.

    When asked on Friday why Chavda was still being allowed to remain in Tanzania, Minister for Home Affairs Lawrence Masha was deliberately vague.

    "It's the government that has decided that he should stay in the country because he is still needed," Masha told The Guardian on Sunday.

    The minister would not elaborate on why Chavda was ‘needed' in the country when he was no longer involved in any currently pending civil cases.

    The minister's response is a curious departure from what his boss, Prime Minister Mizengo Pinda, told Parliament on April 30 this year, in response to a question asked by Kigoma North MP Zitto Kabwe.

    The Prime Minister said he wasn't aware whether Chavda was still in the country, but he promised to thoroughly investigate on which grounds the Asian tycoon was allowed to stay in Tanzania if he were.

    The senior immigration official said this ‘confusion' among top-ranking government officials speaks to the deliberate obfuscation and questionable protection surrounding Chavda and his status in the country.

    "This is a man who was supposed to be arrested and charged with criminal offences but surprisingly he is today a free man enjoying the protection of some government officials and a group of Asian traders," the senior immigration official said.

  2. Kapinga

    Kapinga JF-Expert Member

    May 17, 2009
    Joined: Nov 20, 2007
    Messages: 728
    Likes Received: 3
    Trophy Points: 0
    interesting how these scams are always a yr before elections!! Nice to know about mrema's stance back in the day...someone please give us details of the issues mrema fought during his time as a ccm member and seems time is slowly deleting him....
  3. S

    S.M.P2503 JF-Expert Member

    May 17, 2009
    Joined: Nov 25, 2008
    Messages: 463
    Likes Received: 21
    Trophy Points: 35
    Wajinga ndo tunaoliwa...

    Hivi ku-testify mpaka mtu aje au arudi bongo? Angeweza ku-testify kwa video link na pia kuwa cross- examined kwa njia hiyo hiyo...

    Inavyoonekana serikali yetu pia mahakama zimejaa hiviyo tupu hata huyo judge aliyetoa ruling kwa home affairs kwamba wampe visa ya miaka miwili...

    Tangu lini serikali yetu ikatoa visa ya miaka miwili na je ilikuwa tourist, special au business visa...

    Jambo hili linaitia aibu sana serikali...

    Mrema, amka na umchangamkie tena Chavda na Masha Jiuzulu maana inaoneka hujui huyo mtu anahitajika kivipi... na kabla hajamuondoa inabidi afunguliwe mashitaka kama haya ya kuingizia serikali hasara ya hizo $100m, akipatikana na hatia apewe maximum adhabu na akisha itumika afukuzwe kama mbwa... Kwisha!!!

    Ni hayo wakuu
  4. s

    skasuku Senior Member

    May 17, 2009
    Joined: Apr 19, 2008
    Messages: 113
    Likes Received: 2
    Trophy Points: 35
    Only in Tanzania....
  5. P

    Prince William Member

    May 18, 2009
    Joined: May 6, 2009
    Messages: 19
    Likes Received: 3
    Trophy Points: 0
    Masha ajibu Maswali haya;-

    1: Wakati anafukuzwa serikali haikujua kama anahitajika?
    2: Je wanajua kama huyu ni mtuhumiwa wa uhalifu anayepaswa kukamatwa na kushtakiwa?
    3: Kama serikali ilijua anahitajika nchini, kwa nini uhamiaji kupitia ofisi ya AG walifaili pingamizi zaidi ya kumi kupinga asiruhusiwe kukaa nchini?
    4:Kwa nini AG aseme 'it seemed the parent ministry has changed its stand? Why have they changed?
    5: Katika kesi za madai ni lazima mtuhumiwa atoe ushahidi physically? Hawezi kufaili kupitia kwa lawyers wake?
    6: Mali zake ziko wapi?

    Ukweli hapa ni kwamba Bwana Mdogo Masha ni Mwanasheria, anatakiwa atusaidie katika hili maana hasara ya huyu Muasia kwa taifa kwa kipindi hicho ilikuwa ni dola 100millioni. Sawa na hela ambazo zimepotea katika EPA kwa exchange rate ya sasa.
  6. A

    Alpha JF-Expert Member

    May 18, 2009
    Joined: Aug 30, 2007
    Messages: 614
    Likes Received: 12
    Trophy Points: 35
    So can someone tell me why my comment was deleted?

  7. B

    ByaseL JF-Expert Member

    May 18, 2009
    Joined: Nov 22, 2007
    Messages: 2,223
    Likes Received: 22
    Trophy Points: 135
    "Wajinga ndio waliwao" anasema mwandishi Karugendo! Hawa jamaa ( mafisadi mapapa) walianza kutafuna nchi tangu zamani. In fact baadhi yao wanasema hapo zamani walipokuwa wao wenyewe (wahindi) kabla ya "waswahili" hawajaingia kwenye mchezo huu kama " DCP na EPA" walikuwa hawana shida. Walitafuna nchi wakati sisi tumelala fofofo! Tataizo limekuja baada ya waswahili kuonja pesa hii haramu na kuanza starehe za ajabu na kununua magari kama vile Vogue na kuzileta kwa Charter Cargo Flights mpaka DAR!! Waswahili hawajui pesa ndio maana wengi wao walipozipata wakawa malimbukeni. Huo Marehemu Berya wa BOT anayetajwa kenye kesii ya EPA sasa hivi alikuwa Meneja wa DCP miaka ya 1990 na alipata misuko suko wakati wa uchunguzi wa Ayombe Ayila.

    Mengi akisema hawa ni mafisadi anajua anasema nini ndio maana aliwaalika kwenda mahakani haraka sana. Tatizo la binadamu hasa waafrika ni kwamba kimaumbile ni "doubting Thamases". Hatuamini mkapa tuone kwa macho au tuguse. Hatupendi kuamini kwa kunusa maana hata mwalimu JK Nyerere alisema rushwa 'inanuka". Tumekaa mno kwenye harufu ya rushwa mpaka tumekuwa "immune". Hatusikii tena! Kama tume ya Bunge ilibainisha wizi katika DCP na serikali ikampiga PI huyo Chavda kwa nini mpaka leo yuko hapa? By the way, Kuna mahali Jeetu Patel alisikika akisema kwamba yeye kama JP hajawahi kupanga kuibia serikali bali ni watu wakubwa (toka Serikalini) wanamjia na kumwambia "JP kuna pesa hapa fanya ABC tupate pesa!" Anafanya na pesa inachukuliwa kilaini. Wajinga ndio waliwao na kwa mtido huu nchi italiwa sana!! Tusikubali ujinga huu hata kama ni kupiga kelele za "wezi hao" na kuzomeapamoja na kikiadhibu chama tawala kwa "consiracy of silence and conavincy" kwenye UFISADI.
  8. Chapakazi

    Chapakazi JF-Expert Member

    May 18, 2009
    Joined: Apr 19, 2009
    Messages: 2,881
    Likes Received: 8
    Trophy Points: 135
    Duh...hii ni hatari! Totally unbelievable. Wananchi wanapiga kelele na EPA kumbe mkuu wao katulia Masaki anakula upepo taratibu....hahaha. Yani hii ni AIBU kwa serikali na mahakama zetu.
    Kama mtu anahitajika kuja kwenye kesi, kwa nini hiyo kesi haiendi haraka. Huyu Hakimu/Judge inabidi jina lake litoke, maana hapo lazima kala. Pili, Mkono pamoja na Gomba nao lazima wajibu maswali kadhaa na ikiwezekana washtakiwe na kufutiliwa mbali leseni. Huwezi kuwaibia wananchi chini ya mwavuli wa sheria. Hiyo sasa ni unavuka mpaka.

    Scandal kama hii nchi nyingine ingekuwa imeshaangusha serikali, na ma-judge kadhaa wamesha-resign. Na hao wa Uhamiaji, mbona wanapiga kelele kimya kimya. Kwa nini hii ishu hawakuipigia tarumbeta kwenye vyombo vya habari? Yani kuna maswali mengi sana yanayohitaji majibu. Nashangaa hata upinzani hawajazungumzia hili kabisa. Nao wanakula huko au vipi?

    My proposal, kuanzishwe kipindi kama kile cha kitimoto, (mfano wa hardtalk ya BBC) na kila wiki kiwe kinaongelea ishu kama hizi. Tunahitaji mwangaza ndani ya giza nene la serikalini.

    Alafu Mrema ni vipi? Mbona moto wake sasa umeisha? Kama zamani alikuwa na msimamo mkali hivyo, vipi leo hii? Au na yeye ameshawekwa mfukoni...hehehe.

    Kweli unapopambana na CCM, sio unapambana na chama, bali ni ORGANISATION ya WIZI. Itakumaliza vibaya na kwa mbinu yeyote.

    Last time niliwauliza Upinzani wataweza kubadilisha nchi? Sasa mnaona uozo uliopo ndani ya nchi? Ni ngumu sema itabidi twende hivyo hivyo.
  9. Msanii

    Msanii JF-Expert Member

    May 18, 2009
    Joined: Jul 4, 2007
    Messages: 6,427
    Likes Received: 370
    Trophy Points: 180
    Nini Chavda?
    kuna yule mama mmarekani aitwaye sister Jean wa dogodogo centre ambaye alipewa PI ya saa 90 na mrema enzi zile. Ila sasa yupo karibu sana na mafirst ladies wakimsaidia kukusanya hela za dogodogo projects.
    Hii nchi bwana inapendeza kweli. na tumekuwa wakiwa tangu alipotutoka BABA
  10. Kapinga

    Kapinga JF-Expert Member

    May 18, 2009
    Joined: Nov 20, 2007
    Messages: 728
    Likes Received: 3
    Trophy Points: 0
    Watanzania tulidhani tupo juu ya wananigeria na wakenya kwenye ku loot the central banks..nadhani sasa tupo kapu...moja...tukubali hali halisi..nyerere was the only guy holding the tanzanian imagine of poor humble people...