Hii tweet ya World Bank Tanzania unaweza fikiri kuwa ni fake

Behaviourist said:
Mada yangu haihusiani na kwamba GDP ni kipimo cha maendeleo ya nchi au la,mada yangu inahusiana na serekali ya Tanzania kudanganya katika utoaji wa data za GDPs.Wao kila mwaka hukomaa na ukuaji wa asilimia 7 kitu ambacho ni uongo.
Click to expand...
Ni kweli hilo ndilo lilikuwa lengo lako.
====
Mkuu, unaona ni sawa kuendelea kutumia kipimo cha GDP mbali na mapungufu yote haya yaliyoonyeshwa !?
Mkuu, kwa nini uone shida, umma wa JF, Tanzania na ulimwengu kujuzwa habari za ubovu wa kipimo cha GDP!?
 
Wyatt Mathewson said:
Kila kipimo kina weakness zake

Kuja hapa na kushambulia kipimo sababu kina weakness wakati vyote vina weakness tunashindwa kuelewa motive yako hasa kama ni sincere.

Ni fact tu,ingekua imepata kutoka 5.8% ikaenda 10% mkuu usingeongea huu unafiki hapa...ungesifia Magufuli mpaka mdomo uchanike

Shida ni unafiki
Click to expand...
Mbona unamshambulia mwenzako!? Ha hahaaa
====
Tuache kujifunga kwenye mizania ya kisiasa. Tuwe objective, palipo na shida tuseme na parekebishwe. Kujadili mada muhimu huku unawaza upinzani wako kwa mtoa hoja, kutasababisha ukose objectivity kwenye uandaaji na utoaji wa maoni yako.
 
TUJITEGEMEE said:
Ni kweli hilo ndilo lilikuwa lengo lako.
====
Mkuu, unaona ni sawa kuendelea kutumia kipimo cha GDP mbali na mapungufu yote haya yaliyoonyeshwa !?
Mkuu, kwa nini uone shida, umma wa JF, Tanzania na ulimwengu kujuzwa habari za ubovu wa kipimo cha GDP!?
Click to expand...
Hakujawahi kuwa na conclusion kuwa kitumike kipimo kipi!
 
Ibrahim_ said:
Ndio maana ikasemwa kuwa GDP is not a reliable index to measure economic developments, it rather shows the growth in material things regardless of who finally benefits. Kuna nadharia nyingi za ukuaji wa uchumi na zote zina strength na weakness zake.

Ndio maana umoja wa mataifa uliibua njia mbadala kama vile poverty index kwa kuwa vina akisi mabadiliko ya kiuchumi ya mtu mmoja mmoja.

Hivyo Kwa maoni yangu aliyesema GDP sio reliable indicator yuko sahihi kabisa. Tuelewe kitu kimoja, GDP inatumika na Wb na IMF sana sana Lkn mashirika mengi ya UN hutumia index zingine hasa poverty index (gin coefficient kama mtakumbuka) .

Kwa kawaida inawezekana GDP kushuka wakati maisha ya watu yanaimarika zaidi na inawezekana maisha kuwa magumu ilihali GDP Inapanda, which is a case in our Country. Pia, GDP inahesabu malipo kwa kampuni za nje kama za wachina, yepi merkezi, waarabu wa Stigler gorge n.k kama sehemu ya mapato kwa wananchi. Ilihali zile fedha hupelekwa kwenye Nchi zao.

Na kama mjadala huu juu ya GDP mtaungizia siasa, then hautakuwa na hitimisho la maana. Kwa maana ya kuwa GDP ni standard ya WB na IMF. Na taasisi hizi zimeziagiza Nchi zote kutumia standard ya index hiyo.

Mwisho :Kwenye hili lazima wachangiaji tukubali kutokukubaliana. Lakini ukweli utabaki kuwa GDP does not define National economic performances or prosperity if one insist on using it be it a leader or a common person then should consider himself or herself outdated. And there are more than one method to measure economic performance or prosperity of the country. Let's do the homework to learn which one are the other method and which one is the best. Whatever conclusion you come up with in this matter know that it is subjective to your intellect, knowledge, and preferences.

Samahani kwa kuchangia lugha.
Click to expand...

Mkuu ukitaka kupima peformance ya kiuchumi ya nchi huwezi kuepuka kutumia GDP

kuna concept ndogo

Economic growth (Ukuaji wa kiuchumi) ambayo hapa tunaangalia vitu vinavyoweza pimwa in quantity au kifupi kifedha kama kiwango cha uwekezaji, import and export, miundombinu etc. Hapa GDP haiepukiki haswa katika kupima economical peformance ya nchi

Economic Development (maendeleo ya kiuchumi) hapa tunaangalia quantity pamoja na quality (vitu visivyopimika kifedha) mfano literacy rate, life expectancy, mortality rate


Naona contradiction kubwa mnataka ipime na Economical development wakati kuna vipimo vingine mnavyoweza kutumia kama ulichokitaja au Human development Index. Pia GDP si kitu kimoja, kuna njia nyingi za kuipata GDP based na mahitaji yako ya Data hivyo si lazma ihusishe uwekezaji wa foreigners

lastly GDP ni kweli huwa haitumiki sana kupima well off ya watu kutokana na Economic structure ya nchi nyingi kutofautiana mfano sekta zinazoendesha ukuaji na impact yake kwa watu, Income distribution katika nchi na vigezo vingine zaidi lakini HII HAIONDOI UMUHIMU WAKE KAMA KIPIMO CHA PEFORMANCE YA UCHUMI WA NCHI
 
Behaviourist said:
Mada yangu haihusiani na kwamba GDP ni kipimo cha maendeleo ya nchi au la,mada yangu inahusiana na serekali ya Tanzania kudanganya katika utoaji wa data za GDPs.Wao kila mwaka hukomaa na ukuaji wa asilimia 7 kitu ambacho ni uongo.
Click to expand...


Hoja kubwa hapo ni ama tuziamini takwimu za serikali inayotujengea miundombinu mujarabu na miradi mikumbwa ya maendeleo inayoonekana wazi, ama tuwaamini mabepari na mabeberu ambao wametuibia rasilimali zetu deile na pia wametuletea mtanduko wa korona na kutuuzia chanjo yake!???
 
Jasmoni Tegga said:
Hoja kubwa hapo ni ama tuziamini takwimu za serikali inayotujengea miundombinu mujarabu na miradi mikumbwa ya maendeleo inayoonekana wazi, ama tuwaamini mabepari na mabeberu ambao wametuibia rasilimali zetu deile na pia wametuletea mtanduko wa korona na kutuuzia chanjo yake!???
Click to expand...
Kwa maoni yangu ni busara sana kuwaamini wale wanaotoa hela za kututengenezea hiyo miradi yetu mikubwa ya maendeleo.Mtoa hela ndiye Mungu wetu wa pili.
 
Ukielewa sababu kwa nini Iran ilisita sana kuruhusu wataalamu washirika wa hasimu wao mkubwa US kufanya uchunguzi wa mauaji ya ajali ya ndege nchini mwao last year, utagundua kwa nini normally takwimu za mabeberu zinaiweka Tanzania shimoni.
 
Behaviourist said:
Kwa maoni yangu ni busara sana kuwaamini wale wanaotoa hela za kututengenezea hiyo miradi yetu mikubwa ya maendeleo.Mtoa hela ndiye Mungu wetu wa pili.
Click to expand...


Wewe ni mbovu kumkichwa, hiyo inajulikana tu mbona. Hivi ukikopa fedha benki, ni mali yako ama ya benki!???
 
TUJITEGEMEE said:
If critically look into my argument about GDP, you will find out that I bringing out a constructive criticism/provocation, which our Tanzanian economic experts are supposed to work on it. They have to come up with a reliable index, which will actually reflect our prosperity in these modern days of artificial intelligence and the company. Remember, I am not the economist by professiona.
Click to expand...
Did you hear the opinions of two of them (Dr Blandina Kilama, REPOA and Prof. Ngowi, Mzumbe University) during the launch yesterday? If in most cases, they were not answering the questions, I do not think whether they have the capacity to come up with the alternative measure.
 
Waseme wanataka kipimo gani tukitumie badala ya kuelezea mapungufu ya GDP na kubaki hewani bila conclusion.
 
Kamakabuzi said:
Unavimudu? Fahari ya macho, kuona si kuchukua!
Click to expand...
Ujue kitu unaweza ukakimudu ila bado usiwe na access nacho, nenda Saudi Arabia uone kama utapata hivyo vitu kirahisi hata kama unavimudu, kule pombe na wanawake ni kama madawa ya kulevya, we acha tu, bongo sihami.
 
TUJITEGEMEE said:
GDP is the parameter/index, which carries the lumpsum of several variables! In other words it is not a reliable factor to gauge the prosperity of the country.
Click to expand...
Wangesema imepanda toka 5.8% - 6.9% ungeandika haya haya?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Discussions

Back
Top Bottom
Forums
New posts
Post thread
Back