Africa needs fresh voices to isolate rogue leaders | JamiiForums | The Home of Great Thinkers

Dismiss Notice
You are browsing this site as a guest. It takes 2 minutes to CREATE AN ACCOUNT and less than 1 minute to LOGIN

Africa needs fresh voices to isolate rogue leaders

Discussion in 'Habari na Hoja mchanganyiko' started by ByaseL, Jun 19, 2009.

  1. B

    ByaseL JF-Expert Member

    Jun 19, 2009
    Joined: Nov 22, 2007
    Messages: 2,223
    Likes Received: 22
    Trophy Points: 135
    Jerry Okungu

    LAST week I was equally miffed by the so-called African envoys at the United Nations Human Rights Council that purported to have spoken on behalf of the continent regarding Prof Alston’s Report on Kenya.

    Now that a new voice is emerging in Africa, where leaders are beginning to dare the devil and in the words of President Jacob Zuma, “name and shame rogue leaders in the continent”, Africa should indeed be prepared for a new dawn in the manner we manage this continent.

    Wasn’t it embarrassing enough that the African Group at the United Nations Human Rights Council could taken a stand and condemn a UN Special Rapporteur for merely reporting that there were human rights abuses in Kenya? After watching news clips on that unfortunate story, many Kenyans were taken aback and asked where these so-called African Commissioners at the Council were when Kenyans were being slaughtered and gunned down by militias and the State Police.

    Where were the African envoys when that harmless and unarmed 15-year-old boy in Kisumu was being pursued by a mad policeman with an AK47 in the backstreets of Kisumu? Where were these Africans when Robert Mugabe was hunting down MDC supporters like wild game across the savannas of Zimbabwe’s farmlands? Whose interests do they serve at Geneva?

    Do they even know the meaning of human rights if this kind of statement is all they can make after so many years of human rights abuses in Africa? In equal measure, I tend to buy a number of arguments presented by Amr Roshdy of Egypt regarding the language that Alston used in his report and the manner in which he released it to the media before giving the accused government a hearing.

    However, the contention that Alston relied heavily on our local Kenyan National Human Rights Commission to produce the report cannot stand any common sense argument in any forum. Yes, Philip Alston should never have rushed to the media to release his findings before discussing it with relevant government officials. Thereafter, he should have had an audience with the President and the Prime Minister to hear their reaction before heading to Geneva with the report.

    However, in holding a press conference before consulting with Kenya government authorities, Alston was in the good company of human rights activists including the government’s own National Human Rights Commission. What he did was not different from the numerous press conferences that Transparency International and foreign missions based in Nairobi have been doing with impunity in the last few years.

    I see nothing wrong with Alston using Kenya’s NHRC report to compile his report. After all, if Alston found the local report credible enough to form the basis of his findings, this should be seen as a credit to our local institutions rather than reason to blame the outsider. It confirmed that these extra-judicial killings the KNHRC had been talking about for the last three years have had some grain of truth.

    The danger posed here is that the African Group, led by Egypt, is determined to derail democracy and human rights gains we have achieved in the last few years. Egypt in particular is not a very good example of democratic and human rights records. That is the reason political parties and the media are terrorised from time to time by state agents under the pretext of dealing with Islamic extremist groups.

    For the African Group at the UNHRC to have attacked the Alston Report the way they did, they destroyed their own case. They should have looked at the substance of the report rather than who wrote it.

    Their outbursts showed that the countries they represent at the UNHRC are no different from Kenya, Zimbabwe or any other repressive regime on the continent. The accusations against Kenya starkly reminded them of their situations in their countries; hence attempts to gag the likes of Alston or any other Rapporteur after him.

    If the African Group continues to advocate for human rights abuses at the world’s highest forum, then these atrocities that we witness on our borders will never end for many years to come especially now that we know the AU will never punish one of its own for these crimes against humanity on this continent.

    Hence we need fresh voices of Zuma, Kagame and like-minded heads of state to break ranks with rogue dictators bent on taking us back to the dark ages.
  2. Exaud J. Makyao

    Exaud J. Makyao JF-Expert Member

    Jun 19, 2009
    Joined: Nov 30, 2008
    Messages: 1,523
    Likes Received: 6
    Trophy Points: 0
    Are ZUMA and KAGAME, a good example?
  3. WomanOfSubstance

    WomanOfSubstance JF-Expert Member

    Jun 19, 2009
    Joined: May 30, 2008
    Messages: 5,465
    Likes Received: 72
    Trophy Points: 0
    Thanks EJM,
    I was about to ask where does Zuma get the moral authority and legitimacy to even dare utter such strong words!
    It must have been Dutch Courage!
  4. Yona F. Maro

    Yona F. Maro R I P

    Jun 19, 2009
    Joined: Nov 2, 2006
    Messages: 4,237
    Likes Received: 33
    Trophy Points: 0
    My dear fellow countrymen,

    This is the first of what I hope will be a series of regular letters to the 40 million Good People of this Great Nation. Being my first letter, I would like to deal with an issue of utmost concern to all, something that touches every life in the nation. Corruption is a menace that is posing a great challenge to our development, a torn in the flesh of our national conscience compromising the rule of law and becoming an undesirable way of life and governance that is undermining our democratic values. I would spend much energy and time addressing what I think should be lasting solutions to this somewhat incurable disease that is more dangerous than the notorious Swine flu.

    Many have talked passionately and elaborately about this problem with only a few suggesting the ways out. Lamentation will not effect any change unless we get to the root cause, cure it and remove all the signs and symptoms. I would be using this space to do exactly that. We have to come together to end this problem even though we did not create it but we have all contributed to project it to the current level.

    Very often, when we talk about corruption, we all tend to look at the other side, it something others do. Someone else is corrupt. It's what the politicians do, it's what the bosses do and all the state and local government houses; and the parliaments. Yes they do but if they are the only corrupt beings, then only an insignificant fraction of our society is corrupt. We are all quick to judge as corrupt, the TRA and all organizations that have T stuck in them such as TPA , TANESCO, TEMESA, TAESA, TANAPA, TANROADS, TBC, …. Yes! You are right. They are all corrupt but corruption is not limited to them. If corruption is only limited to what we see in Lowassa , Mkapa, Rostam , Mengi , and Dowans , I would be the first to thrown stone at them in the open. No! It is far beyond this.

    So what is corruption? Nice question! Who is corrupt? Still a good question!! How did we get there? A better question!!! And how do we get out of this mess? Wow! You've just ask the best question!!!! My letter will deal with all these questions.

    According to Oxford English dictionary, corruption is dishonest or illegal behaviour or the willingness to act dishonestly in return for money or personal gain. If I have to expand this and bring it home, then corruption is a dysfunctional system or institution in which government officials, political officials and private employers or employees seek illegitimate personal gains through actions such as bribery, extortion, nepotism, graft, embezzlement and abuse of corporate power by managers against the shareholders or consumers. Corruption usually facilitate organized crime and criminal activities such as money laundering, fraud, drug trafficking and all other forms of trafficking.

    A government is susceptible to political corruption where access to politics is organized with limited transparency, limited competition and directed towards promoting narrow interests featuring stuffs like kleptocracy – rule by thieves inflating contracts and electoral process manipulation and rigging.

    Who is corrupt?

    This is a practical question that I would like to answer practically. In answering this question, I would like to ask you a few personal questions based on your past experiences. You'll need to do some personal appraisal. If you answer YES to any of the questions, it can not be said that your are totally immune to corruption. If you answer is NO to all the question, I may have to bring a lie-detector to run the test on you by myself and if you still get a perfect NO, be sure that I'd recommend you to Transparency International (TI) in Berlin, Germany for a special anti-corruption award.

    · Have you ever embezzled i.e. wrongfully taken, stolen or misappropriated a fund or office entrusted in your care. This include sending an official employee e.g. your official driver on a private errand? YES/NO

    · Have you ever favoured or received favour from relatives, friends and associates in employment, judgement, award of contract or admission? YES/NO

    · Have you ever made an illegitimate gain in employing someone or given a contract to a person other than the most competent candidate? YES/NO

    · Have you ever been ‘settled', taken a graft or a kickback i.e. a share of misappropriated funds from overpriced purchases or allocated from an organization involved in inflated contract? YES/NO

    · Have you ever rigged an election or accepted an elected office through a fraudulent election? YES/NO

    · Have you ever inflated the price of an item purchased in your official capacity or inflated the price of a contract?

    · Have you ever used your official power illegitimately as means to an end, to punish or promote a person or to trump-up charges against enemies? YES/NO

    If your answer is outright NO, congratulation! You have not contributed to corruption in the country but wait! Before you start uncorking the Champagne or giving testimony in your local church of your incorruptibility, let me ask you the last question.

    · Have you ever given any form of bribe to any one or taken one. YES/NO

    The answer to this may require a real soul-searching. Think of the popular Tshs 20000 at the checkpoint substituting vehicle documents, 30000 at the airport for easy passage, 300000 to the Immigration officer for quick passport, Tshs 20000 at Namanga and Tanga border to make the Custom men blind, 1000000 to have a reduced tariff or duty, 3000000 to the Bunge Committee, Tshs 60000000 to NEC to change the will of the people, Tshs 400000000 to the Presidency for the Mineral block……………. Wow! Everything has a price.

    Really, corruption can be graded. Some are more harmful than the others but every bit of it is detrimental to our system. We are where we are today as a result of all the forms of corruption at all level and we are all have to take responsibility and flush it out of our national life.

    How did we get this low?

    No nation is perfect. No country is 100% protected from corruption. In all great nations, corruption is not visible and acceptable. It goes on underground and perpetrated by only an infinitesimal fraction of the society and who are brought to book whenever they are caught. Tanzania was like this until the mid ‘60 when we had our first shot at electoral corruption.

    Ever since the mid ‘60s, corruption has been dwelling with us and all successive governments made the fight against corruption a core point of their policies. We never really had a large scale corruption until the regime of Benjamin Mkapa , A News Maker turned president. The government was viewed as very corrupt and incompetent by virtually all sectors of Tanzanian society. Are News Makers incompetent to put their Making experiences and skills to ruling a nation?

    So how do we get out of this mess called corruption?

    Whatever has a beginning must definitely have an end. Life always present us with choices. We have two choices in ending this endemic vice that has apparently caused us to live a discounted life with an ever diminishing standard of living. It has eroded our national pride and sense of belongingness leaving us with nothing other than a collapsed system with brain drain and unemployment as main features and now threatening to completely mortgage our future.

    Much sooner than later, we will be left with a violent change is we fail to make a peaceful change now! Dodoma should know that those who make peaceful changes impossible, make violent changes inevitable.

    Most Tanzanians hope and pray to live in a country that will be free from corruption and many of us believe that a cause worth living for is worth dying for. We will be left with no alternative than this bloody revolution if we fail to act on a peaceful resolution.

    The peace resolution will require a collective effort by all and sundry to be spearheaded by the government. Needless to say that with this depth of corruption, no single person or organisation has the moral ability and capability to fight it because when you do a background check, you will find out that those empowered by law to fight corruption are more deeply involved in corruption than those they want to check. The government has to provide an enabling environment by making zero tolerant policies (that must be strictly adhered to) against corruption and by leading through example that will flow down the ladder.

    President Kikwete must show that he is serious about fighting this corruption and if he succeeds in just only this, posterity will place him on the right side of history.

    Everyone has to give up all corrupt practices or be brought to book and whenever we see something, we have to say something as demanded by TAKUKURU.

    Tanzania also need to get back all the stolen money and looted treasures especially considering the present economic situation. We thereby need to set up a recovery commission using the South African model of Truth and Reconciliatory Commission (TRC) in order to get the loots back so that we can have a fresh start.

    TRC was a court-like body assembled in South Africa after the abolition of apartheid. Anyone who felt that he or she was a victim of its violence was invited to come forward and be heard. Perpetrators of violence could also give testimony and request amnesty from prosecution. Despite some flaws, it is generally thought to have been successful. It was seen by many as a crucial component of the transition to full and free democracy in South Africa.

    A recovery commission will enable people to come out voluntary and return back their loots in exchange for amnesty and only those who refuse to cooperate will be brought to justice.

    If we fail to act now, the good people of this great nation are becoming impatient and the forceful change is imminent. A word is enough for the wise and the fact remains that "The future will have no pity for those men who have the exceptional privilege of speaking the word of truth to their own oppressors but who have taken attitude of passivity, mute indifference and sometimes of cold complicity". Frantz Fannon

    God Bless Tanzania !

    Tanzania Go Better!

    Yours Sincerely,
  5. WomanOfSubstance

    WomanOfSubstance JF-Expert Member

    Jun 19, 2009
    Joined: May 30, 2008
    Messages: 5,465
    Likes Received: 72
    Trophy Points: 0
    Unajua tumeshajiweka kwenye weekend mood.Kusoma kitu kirefu hivyo Mkuu mhhhhh.
    Can you paraphrase?
  6. Yona F. Maro

    Yona F. Maro R I P

    Jun 19, 2009
    Joined: Nov 2, 2006
    Messages: 4,237
    Likes Received: 33
    Trophy Points: 0
    hata kwenye mikataba yenye maslahi ya nchi huwa mnasema hivyo halafu mnaingiza nchi katika hasara kubwa kwahiyo sishangai usiposoma wewe mwenzako atasoma , au mjukuu wako atakuja kusoma huko mbeleni si lazima wewe usome
  7. WomanOfSubstance

    WomanOfSubstance JF-Expert Member

    Jun 19, 2009
    Joined: May 30, 2008
    Messages: 5,465
    Likes Received: 72
    Trophy Points: 0
    Asante Mkuu!