BoT Scandal: Tulikotoka, Tulipo, Tunakoelekea - JamiiForums |The Home of Great Thinkers

BoT Scandal: Tulikotoka, Tulipo, Tunakoelekea · 29th January 2007, 03:11 PM

	Quote:
	Echoes of 1990s debt-swap in new scandal at Tanzania central bank By JOSEPH MWAMUNYANGE The scope of the probe into the looting of billions of dollars from the Bank Tanzania that was recently announced by Finance Minister Zakia Megji may be expanded to include the abuses of the controversial Debt Conversion Programme of the 1990s. In that programme — which involved investors buying the country’s foreign currency debt at a discount and accepting payment in local currency that was then supposed to be invested in projects in priority areas — it is suspected that unscrupulous businessmen incorporated fake companies to access the facility and beat the guidelines that were set by the Central Bank. Last month, Mrs Meghji told The EastAfrican that the government would float an international tender for auditors of repute to investigate the curRent fraud at the central bank involving the management of the Commercial Debt Account. In another inquiry, carried out in September last year, a reputable international audit firm wrote to the BoT governor questioning the over $120 million that was paid to several companies in Tanzania under the Commercial Debt Programme. One company was paid about $40 million. The claims and payments were made between May 2005 and March 2006. The audit firm advised the BoT governor to hire a forensic expert to assist in investigations into the alleged forgery. Instead, the BoT disputed the report and terminated the services of the audit firm. For two weeks, efforts to get the names of directors or shareholders of the companies from the Business Registration and Licensing Authority (BRELA) proved fruitless because the files couldn’t be traced. A source from the Treasury told The EastAfrican, “If the auditors expected to be engaged by the government do not move in fast enough, there is a possibility that they will find some important documents missing.” The 1990s scam involving the Debt Conversion Programme (DCP, 1990-94) had dramatic repercussions. Augustine Mrema, (then minister for Labour and Youth) was fired for “spilling the beans” in parliament over the DCP money, while a Treasury Permanent Secretary also lost his job “in the public interest” over the scandal. Mr Mrema was sacked by the then president Ali Hassan Mwinyi for what was described as “collective responsibility” following his revelations in parliament that he was blocked from investigating the DCP funds. The DCP was created by Tanzania to sell government debt at a discounted rate. One objective was to encourage investments in priority areas chosen by the government. They included agriculture, tourism, industry, commerce and transportation and would have involved local and foreign investors creating jobs. The other reason was for the government to reduce its local and foreign debt stocks, which had reached alarming proportions. In summary, the DCP enabled an investor to purchase foreign debts at a discounted rate. The Bank of Tanzania would then make available to the investor local currency to the full amount of the debt redeemed. But some of the funds were repatriated abroad instead of being invested. The Debt Conversion Programme (DCP) was established in 1990 but only became operational in January 1991; by 1993, the government had halted the whole programme after discovering that it was “distorting the economy” instead of bringing about economic development, as the government had expected. In the two and half years that the programme was operational, some 82 companies were given permits to buy debt. The government paid the firms Tsh50.877 billion in local currency, equivalent to 18.02 per cent of the government’s recurrent budget for 1992/93. “The government was forced to print money worth Tsh 48 billion to cover the deficit. A simple analysis showed that 15 companies were given Tsh 1 billion each, while 13 others were allocated between Tsh500 million and Tsh1 billion each; and 54 companies got Tsh500 million,” said the 1994 Parliamentary Report. A quick analysis showed that 45 per cent of the money was paid to just 4 companies. These were Deco Arts (Tsh3.054 billion), Hotel Sea Cliff (Tsh1.786 billion), M.M. Motors (Tsh1.619 billion) and M.M. Garage (Tsh522.128 million), totalling some Tsh6.982 billion. All four were associated with one businessman. 8888888888888888888888888888888888888888 by Joseph Mwamunyange The Tanzania Government Has Decided To Contract International Forensic Auditors To Investigate The Mysterious Disappearance Of Millions Of Dollars From The Bank Of Tanzania (bot), The Country’s Central Bank. The Saga Started In December When Finance Minister Zakia Meghji, In A Surprise Move, Put A Notice In The Daily News Announcing That, “the Government Had Been Informed Of Alleged Impropriety In The Management Of External Commercial Debt Accounts At The Bot.” The Minister Described The Allegations As “serious” And Announced That The Government Had Directed The Office Of The Controller And Auditor General To Conduct A Special Audit And To Report To The Government Urgently. Curiously, Mrs Meghji’s Statement Did Not Disclose Who Reported The Matter To The Government Or How It Came To Know Of The Missing Millions. But It Is Suspected That The Information The Government Is Acting On Came From A Report By A Mission Of The International Monetary Fund (imf) That Conducted An Audit On The Bot Last Year — Which Explains Why The Government Has Wasted No Time In Bringing In Investigators. Whichever Way One Looks At It, The Development Is Significant Because It Is The First Time The Country Will Be Conducting A Thorough And Independent Investigation In The Sensitive Area Of The Commercial External Debt Account — The Same Account That Has Proved To Be So Prone To Abuse By Corrupt Regimes In Developing Countries. For Instance, The So-called Anglo Leasing Scam That Has Dogged The Regime Of President Mwai Kibaki In Kenya For The Past Two Years Basically Involves Abuse Of The Country’s Commercial Debt Account By Well-connected Government Contractors And Cronies Of The Regime. The Case Must Also Ring A Bell With Indonesia Where, In 2002, The Governor Of The Central Bank, My Syahrill Jabril, Was Indicted After He Being Accused Of Having Surreptitiously Channelled Millions Of Dollars To Foreign Commercial Banks By Disguising The Money As Payments For Servicing The External Commercial Debt Account. When The Payments Were Audited, It Turned Out That Part Of The Money Was Paid In Commissions To Companies Linked To Key Leaders Of The Of The Ruling Golkar Party. The Suspicion Was That The Money Was Used To Finance President B.j Habibie’s Election Campaign. In An Exclusive Interview With The Eastafrican, Tanzania’s Controller And Auditor General, Ludovick Utouh, Revealed That His Office Had Already Prepared The Terms Of Reference For The Investigations And That These Had Been Submitted To The Imf. The Special Audit Is Expected To Start Within The Next Six Months. Mr Utouh Said That The Investigation Would Establish The Actual Amount Of Money Missing From The Central Bank And If There Was Any Impropriety. Insiders Estimate The Amounts Involved Run Into Millions Of Dollars And That Some Of The Firms Used In The Fraud Were Off-the-shelf Companies Registered In A Very Short Period Of Time Specifically To Facilitate The Channelling Of Monies. Speaking To The Eastafrican, Mrs Meghji Said The Government Was Keen To Determine Whether There Was Any The Truth In The Allegations, Adding That The Findings By The Reputable External Auditors And Investigators Would Be Made Public Because The Government Wanted To Be Transparent On This Issue As Well As On Other Sensitive Matters. It Remains To Be Seen How Quickly The International Investigators Will Move And How Much Co-operation Will Be Given To Them By Government Officials. In 2001, The Government Of Former President Daniel Arap Moi Of Kenya Gave In To Pressure From The Imf To Appoint International Investigators To Audit The Country’s External Debt Account At The Central Bank Of Kenya. The French Finance House Lazard Brothers, Who Were Engaged To Conduct The Inquiry, However Failed Make Any Progress Because Some Ministers Refused To Provide The Auditors The Original Documents And Contracts For Which Payments Were Being Released From The External Debt Accounts. Since Most Of The Contracts Belonged To Suppliers Of Security Equipment And Services, The Government Argued That Secrecy Laws Prohibited The Handing Over Of Such Documents To Foreign Consultants. For President Jakaya Kiwete, The Investigations Are Thus A Litmus Test Of His Commitment To Transparent Government. Kikwete’s Government Came To Power Promising To Give More Powers To The Prevention Of Corruption Bureau (pcb) To Go After The Big Fish. 8888888888888888888888888888888888888888 In Line With This “new Vigour,” A Former Tanzanian Envoy To Italy, Prof Costa Mahalu And Two Others Last Week Become The First Envoys In Tanzanian History To Be Brought To The Court To Answer Charges Of Misappropriation Of Funds Whilst Serving Tanzania Abroad. Another Prominent Businessman Is Likely To Be Taken To Court By The Corruption Watchdog When Investigations Into His Activities Are Completed. On His Recent Visit To The United Kingdom, President Kikwete Said That Tanzania Government Would Like The Ongoing Investigations By The Uk’s Serious Fraud Office Into The Purchase Of The Bae Watchman Radar System To Go On An Interrupted, Promising That His Government Would Not Interfere. The Controversial Multibillion Military Radar System, Which Tanzania Purchased From The Uk-based British Aerospace Engineering At $40 Million Was Of The Same Kind That Three Other Countries Bought At 45 Per Cent Less Cost.

Bongo Kila Mahali Kuna Wizi Au Rushwa Ari Mpya Nguvu Mpya - Kulikoni?

Kamua madude hapa

Lunyungu · #2 (**permalink**) 29th January 2007, 03:35 PM

Muulizeni Mtoa Ukweli wakati anatoa ujinga kila mahala . Huyu JK katulia wau warudishe pesa walizompa ili afanyie kampeni .Yote haya ni longo longo hatutajua Ukweli .

Halisi · #3 (**permalink**) 29th January 2007, 04:41 PM

Naamini hii story inaweza kutoa mwanga wa nini alichosema Lunyungu

Govt posts huge tax exemptions and …

MPs are not amused
. Exemptions equal EU budget support
. They are also equal to our budget deficit

SAYUNI KIMARO
Dar es Salaam

	Quote:
	THE government has reportedly doled out a staggering 480bn/- in tax exemptions within the past six months – and Parliament isn’t amused, THISDAY can report. The exemptions are said to cover the six months ending December, 2006, according to sources within the Parliamentary Committee for Finance and Economic Affairs. The sources intimate that the legislators are now demanding a detailed report on the exemptions after the Ministry of Finance presented its report to the committee on Thursday – which they reject as inadequate. The document submitted to the committee revealed that between July and December last year, the Tanzania Revenue Authority exempted taxes totalling 475,244.9m/- on the Mainland and 7,892.7m/- in Zanzibar – where the Isles investment promotion agency (ZIPA) got the bulk of the exemptions at 20.8 per cent, surpassed only by government institutions which got 44.2 per cent. “We demanded explanations because the amount involved was big enough to cover our budget deficit, and cut our dependence on donors. That’s why we called for more explanation from the government,” a committee member said. The parliamentarian said the cash dished out through exemptions is equal to what the country got from the European Development Fund as budget support last year -- 500bn/-. According to the Treasury report, the beneficiaries of the exemptions, which included customs and domestic taxes in the Mainland were: Tanzania Investment Centre (88.26bn/- or 18.6 per cent); private companies and individuals (73.3bn/- or 15 per cent); donor funded projects (21.35bn/- or 4.5 per cent); and government institutions (13.92bn/- or 2.9 per cent). Others were religious institutions and NGOs (11.4bn/ or 2.4 per cent), parastatal companies (9.54bn/- or 2 per cent); and regional cooperation agreements (2.31bn/- or 0.5 per cent). In Zanzibar, other exemptions also went to private companies (1.55bn/- or 19.6 per cent); parastatals (1bn/- or 12.7 per cent); religious institutions and NGOs (211m/- or 2.7 per cent). On domestic taxation, there was a “special” tax waver of 217bn/- or 45.8 per cent – which went to duty-free shops (1,57bn/- or 0.3 per cent) and a category code-named “zero rated” exemptions which amounted to 35bn/- or 7.5 per cent, the Treasury report shows. Over the same period, actual collections from the Tanzania Revenue Authority amounted to 559,237.7m/-, but the tax exemption set through Customs department tally at 220,118.4m/-, or 39 per cent of the collections. In the meantime, internal revenue collections on the Mainland amounted to 305,220.9m/-. But here, the exemptions surpassed collections by 84 per cent, or 255,126.6m/- in real figures. Actual collections in the Isles over the same period stood at 9,615.0m/-, but here, too, much of the money (82% ) went to cover tax exemptions, which stood at 7,892.7m/-. In 2006/7 Zanzibar collected 14,514.5m/- in revenues compared to the estimated amount of 13,344m/-, a nine-per cent improvement over its own estimates. Actual collections stood at 3,896.4m/- (internal revenues) equivalent to 102 per cent. In Customs taxes the estimated collection was 11,547.8m/- but actual collections were 6,766.4m/-, equivalent to 59 per cent. In 2006/7 the government planned to accumulate 5,078.5m/- and the actual collections were 4,899.6m/- equivalent to 97 per cent of projected internal revenues. The Customs had set a target of an amount of 8,265.5m/-, and collected 9,614m/-, equivalent to 116 per cent. The Mainland had set targets of 172,497.2m/- in internal revenues but actual collections came to 177, 261.3m/- or 103 per cent. There was also a target of 362,116.7m/- for the “big” tax payers, but actual collections fell 3% shy of projections: 364,748.0m/- was collected. There was a similar shortfall of collections against projections for the Customs Department.

Game Theory · #4 (**permalink**) 29th January 2007, 04:45 PM

sasa hii kali na sijui kama tapona mtu

Game Theory · #5 (**permalink**) 29th January 2007, 04:46 PM

ILI WANANCHI WANAHALI MBAYA

Lunyungu · #6 (**permalink**) 29th January 2007, 04:49 PM

Hapa kuna so many issues zinakuja kufunikwa, kuna Mahalu , kuna Rada , na miswada ya ajabu Bungeni , kuna Bunge na Kamati ya Mengi , kaeni macho wananchi . Kumbukeni wengi wa nafasi hizi akiwemo commissioner nk ni watu Mtandao na waliiwezesha CCM kutumia na kuwa hapo ilipo. JK hataki kuumaliza umaarufu kirahisi atazua jambo jipya ili kufunika jingine .Kama huamini kaa uone. Nielezeni Richmond na sasa sijui kuna watu gani . Unafiki mtupu kwamba the guy is real . Usalama wa Taifa sasa kazi ni kubuni matukio kuzima matukio.

Sina imani na Uchunguzi huo.

Dua · #7 (**permalink**) 29th January 2007, 04:53 PM

DrWHO

Kuna wizi pale wa hali ya juu, hawa jamaa wanaotukopesha wameshituka kwani hata wao hawawezi kuwa na pesa kiasi hicho na kutoka nchi masikini ambayo tunaambiwa kila siku. Pesa wakubwa wanavyokula wenyewe inabidi waanze kuwaonea huruma wadanganyika. SUBIRI NAONA WAZIRI AMELIVALIA NJUGA.

PESA WANAYOINGIZA HATA WALE WANAOFANYA KAZI SQUARE MILE PAMOJA NA BONUS ZAO HAWAFUI DAFU

Mtanzania · #8 (**permalink**) 29th January 2007, 05:10 PM

Waungwana,

Suala la exemptions lina tofauti kidogo na hilo suala la bank kuu. Kiwango kilichotajwa kinatisha ingawaje mimi mwenyewe nimewahi kufaidika na hizo
exemptions. Lengo lake ni kupunguza gharama za wawekezaji, kwa mfano mimi
nimefaidika kwa kununua vifaa vya ujenzi bila VAT.

Tatizo ni pale ambapo hizo exemptions zinatumiwa vibaya na wajanja. Watu wanasema wanajenga hiyo miradi wakati hakuna na vifaa vinapotea.

Ila nijuavyo mimi sasa TRA wako macho sana na kila mara wanakuja kukagua
kuona kama hivyo vifaa vinatumika ipasavyo.

Idea yenyewe ni nzuri ila kama inatumia vibaya basi inapoteza maana nzima.

Nimeona nijisalimishe kwani katika hizo huenda kuna pesa ambayo mimi nime save ha haaa!!!

Kama exemptions zinatumika vizuri mategemeo ni kwamba hiyo miradi ikianza basi italipa kodi hata zaidi. Ukweli huenda ni tofauti na sisi wananchi ndio tunalipa hizo kodi huku wajanja hata hizo kodi wanaendelea kukwepa.

Mzee Mwanakijiji · #9 (**permalink**) 29th January 2007, 05:19 PM

Kuna tatizo mahali fulani, nalo linahusu fedha..!! Aidha Watanzania (kama serikali) hatujui kusimamia fedha, au tunajua kutumia fedha kwa vitu visivyo vya lazima. Kwenye suala la mikataba kila siku najiuliza hivi kweli tunao watu waliosomea sheria? Kwenye haya masuala ya fedha, najiuliza hivi tunao watu waliosomea Uhasibu!?

Game Theory · #10 (**permalink**) 29th January 2007, 05:31 PM

hivi how hard is it kupata kazi pale benki kuu?

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Echoes of 1990s debt-swap in new scandal at Tanzania central bank	Bubu Ataka Kusema	Habari/Hoja mchanganyiko	0	19th February 2007 03:29 PM

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)